CONTENTS Third Series Volume 68 2011 JANUARY Eprror’s Nore. By Christopher Grasso GEOGRAPHIES OF POWER: MappinG INDIAN BORDERS IN THI “BORDERLANDS” OF THE EaRLy SOUTHWEST. By Juliana Barr......... 5 Two interactive maps anda teaching supplement are available online THE “TRAGICALL HISTORIE’: CANNIBALISM AND ABUNDANCE IN COLONIAL JAMESTOWN. By Rachel B. Herrmann New Worip Tempests: ENVIRONMENT, SCARCITY, AND THE COMING OF THE PEQuoT War. By Katherine A. Grandjean................ 75 An appendix is available online JOHN CARROLL AND THE ORIGINS OF AN AMERICAN CATHOLIC CHURCH, 7a} -iars: By Camere O Donnell... 20... ccc ccc ice ciacntine 101 Sources and Interpretations “A Stave” Writes THOMAS JEFFERSON. By Thomas N. Baker Trae Nee 127 Reviews of Books KAMINSKI ET AL., eds., Zhe Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution, volumes 19-23, Ratification of the Constitution by the States. New York. By Pauline Maier....... iid anbawaess 155 BREEN, American Insurgents, American Patriots: The Revolution of the PU TP ONES 5, POI a ish s ads was esedccnse’ 160 CALVERT, Quaker Constitutionalism and the Political Thought of John Dickinson; and CaALHooNn, Political Moderation in America’s First Two Centuries. By Ellen Holmes Pearson.................000005 164 MaNDELL, Tribe, Race, History: Native Americans in Southern New England, 1780-1880; and Rosen, American Indians and State Law: Sovereignty, Race, and Citizenship, 1790-1880. By Mark Rifkin ..... 168 “Children and Childhood,” a review essay of Mintz, Huck’s Raft: A History of American Childhood; Marten, ed., Children and Youth in a New Nation; and HERNDON and Murray, eds., Children Bound to Labor: The Pauper Apprentice System in Early America. By Mary Niall Mitchell CONTENTS Third Series Volume 68 2011 JANUARY Eprror’s Nore. By Christopher Grasso GEOGRAPHIES OF POWER: MappinG INDIAN BORDERS IN THI “BORDERLANDS” OF THE EaRLy SOUTHWEST. By Juliana Barr......... 5 Two interactive maps anda teaching supplement are available online THE “TRAGICALL HISTORIE’: CANNIBALISM AND ABUNDANCE IN COLONIAL JAMESTOWN. By Rachel B. Herrmann New Worip Tempests: ENVIRONMENT, SCARCITY, AND THE COMING OF THE PEQuoT War. By Katherine A. Grandjean................ 75 An appendix is available online JOHN CARROLL AND THE ORIGINS OF AN AMERICAN CATHOLIC CHURCH, 7a} -iars: By Camere O Donnell... 20... ccc ccc ice ciacntine 101 Sources and Interpretations “A Stave” Writes THOMAS JEFFERSON. By Thomas N. Baker Trae Nee 127 Reviews of Books KAMINSKI ET AL., eds., Zhe Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution, volumes 19-23, Ratification of the Constitution by the States. New York. By Pauline Maier....... iid anbawaess 155 BREEN, American Insurgents, American Patriots: The Revolution of the PU TP ONES 5, POI a ish s ads was esedccnse’ 160 CALVERT, Quaker Constitutionalism and the Political Thought of John Dickinson; and CaALHooNn, Political Moderation in America’s First Two Centuries. By Ellen Holmes Pearson.................000005 164 MaNDELL, Tribe, Race, History: Native Americans in Southern New England, 1780-1880; and Rosen, American Indians and State Law: Sovereignty, Race, and Citizenship, 1790-1880. By Mark Rifkin ..... 168 “Children and Childhood,” a review essay of Mintz, Huck’s Raft: A History of American Childhood; Marten, ed., Children and Youth in a New Nation; and HERNDON and Murray, eds., Children Bound to Labor: The Pauper Apprentice System in Early America. By Mary Niall Mitchell CONTENTS 7557 APRII Forum: Ethnogenesis MappiING ETHNOGENESIS IN THE EarLty MODERN ATLANTIC. By James Sidbury and Jorge Cafiizares-Esguetta ........00e0csesevssvess: 181 THE Quiet VIOLENCE OF ETHNOGENESIS. By James H. Sweet ....... 209 THE INDIANS’ O_p Wor tp. By Claudio Saunt ..................... 215 Lost IN TRANSITIONS: SUFFERING, SURVIVAL, AND BELONGING IN rHE Earty MODERN ATLANTIC Wor p. By Pekka Hamiilainen..... 219 Comp ications. By Laurent Dubois 22 WEIRD SCIENCE: IDENTITY IN THE ATLANTIC Wor-p. By Christopher FIOuSONE jo htodeer dl )et ae 227 ‘TOWARD CONNECTEDNESS AND Pace. By Karen B. Graubart ........ 233 A PLea For A New ATLAantic History. By Patrick Griffin ........... 236 ON THE GENESIS OF DESTRUCTION, AND OTHER MIssING SUBJECTS. By James Sidbury and Jorge Cafiizares-Esguerra...............4. 240 ATLANTIC SLAVERY, ATLANTIC FREEDOM: GEORGE WASHINGTON, SLAVERY, AND TRANSATLANTIC ABOLITIONIST NETWORKS. By a PPC Tere Ere ee rr err. 247 An interactive diagram and a historiographical note are available online Sources and Interpretations POWER AND CONFESSION: ON THE CREDIBILITY OF THE EARLIEST REPORTS OF THE DENMARK VESEY SLAVE Conspiracy. By James COTE EI a5 so sv a was tials.a cda ipicla wcan bn bank bee RS 287 Reviews of Books SNYDER, Slavery in Indian Country: The Changing Face of Captivity in Early America. By Michael Guasco ... . 0... 00s ccscdetesces 305 Wuirte, Encountering Revolution: Haiti and the Making of the Early Republic.B y Ronald Angelo Johnson .............ce.c0e 0ee.n s 311 ZABIN, Dangerous Economies: Status and Commerce in Imperial New Vai. Dy Call Rene TW. a iss anes casicwncauicustaennysa’ 315 BEILer, /mmigrant and Entrepreneur: The Atlantic World of Caspar Wistar, 1650-1750. By Cathy Matson CORNECTHORS 8 C8 Fe AW aOR, ICU 5 A SPARE ee JULY Forum: Transformations of Virginia: Tobacco, Slavery, and Empire INTRODUCTION. By James Horn 327 758 WILLIAM AND MARY QUARTERLY THE PHASES OF CONVERSION: A NEw CHRONOLOGY FOR THE RISE OF SLAVERY IN Ear y VirGIniA. By John C. Coombs............... 332 THE VISIBLE Fist: THE CHESAPEAKE TOBACCO TRADE IN WAR AND THE PurpPOSE OF EMPIRE, 1690-1715. By Douglas Bradburn........ 361 A supplemental table is available online BooM-AND-Bust CycCLes IN CHESAPEAKE History. By Lorena S. Te ee eT reer eer re OP er Ean OP Py ee me 387 REIMAGINING THE Po.iticaL ECONomy OF Ear_y VirGIniA. By Paul pr NN 6 A kV Sigc h hore eR Slt Pau isa sins 393 Tosacco Roap: New Views OF THE EARLY CHESAPEAKE. By Peter A. GOREN 5-5. Bia es OER ae ee ates Ee ORE AS co TATE EN 398 SLAVERY, TRADE, WAR, AND THE Purposes OF Empire. By April Lee REE Ry Py are EO Te Sey Be EU eae 405 HiIsTORICIZING SUPPLY AND DEMAND IN EARLY AMERICAN ECONOMIC History: THE IMPORTANCE OF TRANSATLANTIC Potitics. By NN ee I circa SA aes een lie MERE Maas Se poe 409 COUNSEL, SLAVERY, AND THE POLITICS OF EMPIRE: REDISCOVERING THE DYNAMISM OF VIRGINIA’S SEVENTEENTH-CENTURY COUNCIL OF Suara. By Alemender B. PIM... i hhietccdieseeiinisss 414 PROVINCIALS ABROAD; Or, A FUNNY THING HAPPENED ON THE WAY TO THE ATLANTIC SEMINAR: MorRE COLLABORATIVE REFLECTIONS ON CHESAPEAKE History. By Douglas Bradburn and John C. ee TRE ne Serr wen tre rt ee eee 420 SPAIN AND THE FOUNDING OF JAMESTOWN. By William S. Goldman. .... 427 An interactive map is available online THe “Bap Business” OF OBEAH: POWER, AUTHORITY, AND THE Pouitics OF SLAVE CULTURE IN THE BriTIsH CaRIBBEAN. By Randy i OE Ce Rey ee Le ee eS ere ra ee eee 451 Reviews ofB ooks “Liberties of Empire,” a review essay of ZAHEDIEH, The Capital and the Colonies: London and the Atlantic Economy, 1660-1700; FLAVELL, When London Was Capital ofA merica; and JasanorF, Liberty's Exiles: American Loyalists in the Revolutionary World. By Jane Kamensky.... 481 ““Nought from nought leaves nought’: Figuring Venture Smith,” a review essay of Stewart, ed., Venture Smith and the Business of Slavery and Freedom. By Peter P. Hinks... 02.62cee c2ise0 een es 490 Preston, The Texture of Contact: European and Indian Settler Communities on the Frontiers of Iroquoia, 1667-1783. By Jon Parmenter CONTENTS 759 Woopwarb, Prospero’s America: John Winthrop, Jr., Alchemy, and the Creation of New England Culture, 1606-1676. By Richard Godbeer. . . . 503 Kern, The Jeffersons at Shadwell. By Barbara B. Oberg............... 506 COMPILOEA TID OI IS. sis. bo.c ies 3: andes tt Cee 510 OCTOBER GROUNDED Histories: LAND AND LANDSCAPE IN EARLY AMERICA. By UU FEMI, 6 8 ois Cediksiensciacdadendenssseaeneeel Forum: Patriot Royalism PaTRIOT ROYALISM: [HE SruART MONARCHY IN AMERICAN POLITICAL Trower, 1769-75. By Eric Netbon:. ...6 .00556 <a ce decnaeeaevaas THE PROBLEM OF SOVEREIGNTY. By Gordon S. Wood ............... WHIGS AGAINST WHIGS AGAINST WuiIGs: THE IMPERIAL DEBATES OF 1765-76 RECONSIDERED. By Pauline Maier .................006- THE PLurat PreroGatIveE. By Daniel J. Hulsebosch ................ TAKING THEM SERIOUSLY: PATRIOTS, PREROGATIVE, AND THE ENGLISH SEVENTEENTH CENTUuRY. By Eric Nelson...............2000000- Forum: Economics and American Independence FREE TRADE, SOVEREIGNTY, AND SLAVERY: TOWARD AN ECONOMIC INTERPRETATION OF AMERICAN INDEPENDENCE. By Staughton Lynd anil Saal, WeE ES os 5 ih as Reed ee WAR AND THE IMPERATIVE OF UNION. By Robert G. Parkinson Oe ee errr amr ee rer BEYOND THE “Economic.” By Barbara Clark Smith................. MEN Out oF TIME: CONFRONTING History AND Mytu. By Michael A We DVOHED 3665 ow ite La ae ns wakes oa eee ee REFLECTIONS ON ECONOMIC. INTERPRETATION, SLAVERY, THE PEOPLE Out oF Doors, AND Top Down versus Borrom Up. By Staughton Lynd and David Waldstreicher Research Note LIGHTING THE FUSE OF REVOLUTION IN VIRGINIA, May 1765: REREADING THE “JOURNAL OF A FRENCH TRAVELLER IN THE COLONIES.” By se eee errr rr errr err rere Reviews ofB ooks Critical Forum: Brown, Foul Bodies: Cleanliness in Early America CLEANLINESS AND CuLtTuRE. By Jan Ellen Lewis .............2200005. Bopigs, GEOGRAPHIES, AND THE ENVIRONMENT. By Ann M. Little 760 WILLIAM AND MARY QUARTERLY Bopigs IN EUROPEAN AND AMERICAN HistTorioGraPHy. By Kathryn Norberg THE Historica Bopy, OuR HUMANITY, AND THE COST OF Mobernity. By Kathleen M. Brown CLEANLINESS AND CULTURE: FURTHER THOUGHTS. By Jan Ellen Lewis... WHERE THE Boys Were. By Ann M. Little CLEANLINESS AND RiGuts. By Kathryn Norberg Critical Forum: TOMLuINS, Freedom Bound: Law, Labor, and Civic Identity in Colonizing English America, 1580-1865 CLEAR, Hop, BuILp: PATRIARCHY AND SOVEREIGNTY IN THE COLONIZATION OF EARLY ENGLISH AMERICA. By Julia Adams 701 Law, LABOR, AND Civic IDENTITIES IN THE BRITISH AND SPANISH Empires. By Tamar Herzog and Richard J. Ross ..............44- 707 INDIGENOUS SOVEREIGNTY UNDER AND AFTER SPANISH Rute. By Paul LEGAL PLURALISM AND Native SOVEREIGNTY. By Richard White LecaL Hisrory, INSIDE AND Out. By Stuart Banner ; FREEDOM BOUND: A Response TO Reapers. By Christopher Tomlins. . . . Knott, Sensibility and the American Revolution. By Edward Countryman Brooke, Columbia Rising: Civil Life on the Upper Hudson from the Revolution to the Age of Jackson. By Paul A. Gilje Carney and Rosomorr, /n the Shadow of Slavery: Africa’s Botanical Legacy in the Atlantic World; and HAWTHORNE, From Africa to Brazil: Culture, Identity, and an Atlantic Slave Trade, 1600-1330. By Joseph C. Miller Kiepp, Revolutionary Conceptions: Women, Fertility, and Family Limitation in America, 1760-1820. By Sarah Hand Meacham Correction