Sunday 8 June 2008 Dr Maurice M. Mizrahi Congregation Adat Reyim Tikkun Lel Shavuot discussion The Ten Commandments in the Midrash 'Aseret ha-Dibrot, Exodus 20 1 God is One -- The Shema Midrash - Deuteronomy Rabbah 2:31-36 31. HEAR, O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE (Deut. 6:4). Halachah: If a Jew recites the Shema' and does not enunciate clearly its letters, has he fulfilled his duty? The Sages have learned thus: If one recited [the Shema'] but did not clearly enunciate [its letters], R. Jose says: He has done his duty; R. Judah says: He has not done his duty. And what constitutes a clear enunciation of the letters? Our Rabbis taught us: [In reciting the words] 'bekol levavekem' ('with all your heart', Deut. 11:13), one should make a clear pause between the one lamed and the other lamed; in 'va'avadtem meherah' ('and you perish quickly', Deut. 11:17), one should make a clear pause between the one mem and the other mem. R. Judah further said in the name of Rav: And if one was reciting the Shema' while walking [he should] stop, in order to accept the Kingdom of Heaven standing. And what part [of the Shema'] is termed 'the Kingdom of Heaven'? [The words], 'The Lord our God, the Lord is One.' Whence did Israel merit to recite the Shema'? R. Phinehas b. Hama said: Israel merited to recite the Shema' at the Revelation on Sinai. How [is this to be inferred]? You find that it was with this word [Shema'] that God first began [to speak] at Sinai. He said to them: 'Hear, O Israel, I am the Lord Your God,' [Deut. 5:1] and they all answered and exclaimed: 'The Lord our God, the Lord is One.' And Moses said, 'Blessed be the name of His glorious kingdom for ever and ever.' The Rabbis say: God said to Israel: 'My children, all that I have created I have created in pairs; heaven and earth are a pair; sun and moon are a pair; Adam and Eve are a pair; this world and the world to come are a pair; but My Glory is One and unique in the world.' Whence this? From what we have read in our context, HEAR O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE. 32. Another explanation: HEAR, O ISRAEL. This bears out what Scripture says, 'Whom have I in heaven but You? And beside You I desire none upon earth (Ps. 73:25). Rav said: There are two firmaments, the heaven and the heavens of heavens. R. Eleazar said: There are seven firmaments: Heaven (shamayim), the Heavens of Heavens (sheme shamayim), Firmament (raki'ah), Sky (shehakim), Habitation (ma'on), Residence (zebul), Thick Cloud ('arafel); and God opened them all unto Israel in order to show them that there is no God but He. The Assembly of Israel said before God: 'Master of the Universe, whom have I in heaven but Your glory? As in heaven I have none but You, so too upon earth I desire no other; as I have not associated another God with You in heaven, so upon earth, too, I have not associated with You any other God; but daily I enter the synagogues and testify concerning You that there is no other God but You, and I exclaim, HEAR, O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE.' 33. Another explanation: HEAR O ISRAEL. This bears out what Scripture says, 'My son, fear the Lord and the king,' etc. (Prov. 24:21). What is the force of 'And the king'? Abraham who feared Me -- did I not proclaim him as king in the world, as it is said, 'At the vale of Shaveh--the same is the king's vale' (Gen. 14:17); Joseph who feared Me, of whom it is written, 'For I fear God' (Gen. 42:18) -- did I not proclaim him as king in the world, as it is written, 'And Joseph was the governor over the land' (Gen. 42:6)? [He who fears the Lord need fear none else, and is thus as a king.] Another interpretation: 'My son, fear the Lord and the king,' and rule over your inclination. Once R. Simeon b. Eleazar came to a city in the South and entering a synagogue he asked the teacher 2 [scribe], 'As you live, is there here any wine for sale?' The latter replied: 'Master, this is a city of Samaritans and they do not prepare the wine with [the strict levitical] purity as my fathers were wont to do.' He [R. Simeon] then said: 'If you have any wine to spare give it to me and I will buy it from you.' The teacher replied: 'If you can master your desires you should not taste of it'; whereupon R. Simeon b. Eleazar exclaimed: 'As for me, I can master my desires.' Hence the force of 'and king', that is to say, Rule over thine inclination. [Be 'king' over your desires'.] Another explanation: 'My son, fear the Lord and the king.' What is the force of, 'And the king'? [It means], but [fear] not Molech, as [Scripture] in another context says, 'And you shall not give any of your seed to set them apart to Molech’ (Lev. 18:21). Another explanation: What is the force of, 'And the king'? Make [God] King over you. And meddle not with them that are given to change (Prov. loc. cit.): Do not meddle with those who declare that there is a second god. R. Judah b. Simon said: [Scripture says], 'And it shall come to pass, that in all the land, says the Lord, two parts therein shall be cut off and die' (Zech. 13:8); the mouths that declare that there are two Powers shall be cut off and die. And who will survive in the future? But the third shall be left therein. This refers to Israel who are termed 'thirds', [threefolds] for they are divided into three groups, Priests, Levites, and Israelites; and are descended from the three Patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Another explanation: Because they praise God with the threefold expression of holiness, 'Holy, holy, holy' (Isa. 6:3). R. Aha said: God was angry with Solomon when he uttered the above verse. He said to him: 'Why do you express a thing that concerns the sanctification of My Name by an obscure allusion' [in the words] 'And meddle not with them that are given to change' (shonim)? Thereupon immediately Solomon expressed it more clearly [in the words], 'There is one that is alone, and he has not a second; yea, he has neither son nor brother' (Eccl. 4:8); 'He has neither son nor brother,' but HEAR, O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD. THE LORD IS ONE. 34. R. Isaac opened [his discourse] with the text 'The Lord is my portion, says my soul; therefore will I hope in Him’ (Lam. 3:24). R. Isaac said: This may be compared to a king who entered a province with his generals, rulers, and governors. Some of the citizens of the province chose a general as their Patron, others a ruler and others a governor. One of them who was cleverer than the rest said, 'I will choose the king.' Why? All others are liable to be changed, but the king is never changed. Likewise, when God came down on Sinai, there also came down with Him many companies of angels, Michael and his company, Gabriel and his company. Some of the nations of the world chose for themselves [as their Patron] Michael, others Gabriel, but Israel chose for themselves God, exclaiming, 'The Lord is my portion, says my soul'; this is the force of, HEAR. O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE. 35. Another explanation: HEAR O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE. Whence did Israel merit to recite the Shema'? When Jacob was about to die he called together all the tribes and he said to them: '[I am anxious] lest you bow down to another God after I have departed this world.' Whence this? For so it is written, 'Assemble yourselves, and hear, you sons of Jacob' (Gen. 49:2). What is the force of, 'And hearken unto Israel your father' (ib.). Jacob said to them: 'The God of Israel, He is your Father.' They replied: HEAR. O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE. And he added softly, 'Blessed be the name of His glorious kingdom for ever and ever.' R. Levi said: And what do Israel imply when they now say, [HEAR. O ISRAEL]? HEAR our father ISRAEL, [Jacob] what you have commanded us we still adhere to; THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE 36. Another explanation: HEAR O ISRAEL. 3 The Rabbis say: When Moses ascended to heaven he heard the ministering angels saying to God, 'Blessed be the name of His glorious kingdom for ever and ever.' This [declaration] Moses brought down to Israel. And why do not Israel make this declaration publicly [i.e. aloud]? R. Assi replied: This can be compared to a man who stole jewelry from the royal palace which he gave to his wife, telling her, 'Do not wear these in public, but only in the house.' But on the Day of Atonement when Israel are as pure as the ministering angels they do recite publicly, 'Blessed be the name of His glorious kingdom for ever and ever.' 4 Honoring Father and Mother Midrash - Deuteronomy Rabbah 1:15 15. YOU HAVE COMPASSED THIS MOUNTAIN LONG ENOUGH (Deut. 2:3). Halachah: What is the reward of a Jew who zealously observes the duty of honoring father and mother? The Rabbis have learnt thus [Peah 1:1]: These are the things for which a man enjoys the fruits in this world while the principal remains for the World to Come: the honoring of father and mother, etc. [Mishnah 1.The following are the things for which no definite quantity is prescribed: the corners [of the field, left unreaped], first-fruits, [the offerings brought] on appearing [before the Lord at the three pilgrim festivals], the practice of lovingkindness, and the study of the Torah. These are the things for which a man enjoys the fruits in this world while the principal remains for him in the world to come: the honoring of father and mother, the practice of charity, and the making of peace between a man and his friend; but the study of the Torah is equal to them all.] Dama b. Nethina . R. Abbahu said: R. Eliezer the Great was asked by his disciples: 'Can you give an example of [real] honoring of parents?' He replied: 'Go and see what Dama b. Nethina of Askelon did. His mother was mentally afflicted and she used to slap him in the presence of his colleagues, and all that he would say was, "Mother, it is enough!"' Our Rabbis say: Once the Sages came to him to Askelon, where he lived, to buy from him a precious stone [to replace one] lost from the vestments of the [high] priest, and they fixed the price with him at a thousand golden pieces. He entered the house and found his father asleep with his leg stretched out on the chest wherein the stone was lying. He would not trouble him, and he came out empty-handed. As he did not produce the stone the Sages thought that he wanted a higher price, and they therefore raised their offer to ten thousand golden pieces. When his father awoke from his sleep Dama entered and brought out the stone. The Sages wished to give him ten thousand golden pieces, but he exclaimed: 'Heaven forfend! I will not make a profit out of honoring my parents; I will only take from you the first price, one thousand golden pieces, which I had fixed with you.' And what reward did the Holy One, blessed be He, give him? Our Rabbis report that in the very same year his cow gave birth to a red heifer, which he sold for more than ten thousand golden pieces. See from this how great is the merit of honoring father and mother. Esau. R. Simeon b. Gamaliel said: No son has ever honored his parents as I have done, and yet I find that Esau honored his father even more than I. How? R. Simeon b. Gamaliel said: I usually waited on my father dressed in soiled clothes, but when I went out into the street I discarded these clothes and put on instead handsome clothes. Not so Esau; the clothes in which he was dressed when attending on his father were his best. The proof for this is this. When he went out hunting in order to bring venison to his father that he might bless him, what did Rebekah, who loved Jacob, do? She gave him dainties and said to him, 'Go to your father and receive the blessings before your brother receives them.' Whereupon Jacob said to her, 'Mother, do you not know that Esau my brother is a hairy man, and I am a smooth man’ (Gen. 27:11): Perhaps my father will discover that I am not Esau and I will be put to shame before him.' Whence this? Because it is said, 'Perhaps my father will feel me,' etc. (Gen. 27:12). She replied to him: 'My son, your father's eyes are dim; I will dress you with the fine clothes which your brother wears when he attends on your father, and when you come to him and he takes hold of your hand he will think that you are Esau and he will bless you.' And whence this? Because it is said, 'And Rebekah took the choicest garments of Esau,' etc. (Gen. 27:15), that is to say those which he was wont to wear when attending on his father, as it is said, 'And put them upon Jacob her younger son' (Gen. 27:15). 5 Hence when Jacob came to him, what did Isaac say? 'The voice is the voice of Jacob, but the hands are the hands of Esau' (Gen. 27:22). [He recognized that the garments were the best.] Isaac blessed him and he went out. Then Esau arrived and entered into the presence of his father. Isaac asked him, 'Who are you, addressing me in such a loud voice?' He replied: 'I am your son, your firstborn, Esau' (Gen. 27:32). As soon as he heard his voice he knew that he was Esau. He said to him: 'My son, your brother came with guile, and has taken away your blessing' (Gen. 27:35). Thereupon Esau began to cry and to complain: 'Come and see what this quiet man of whom it is written, 'And Jacob was a quiet man, dwelling in tents' (Gen. 25:27), has done to me. Not enough that he mocked me for selling him my birthright, Behold, now he hath taken away my blessing' (Gen. 27:36). Hence you learn that Esau was most scrupulous in honoring his parents. 6 Murder, adultery and idolatry Midrash - Exodus Rabbah 16:2 2. DRAW OUT, AND TAKE YOU LAMBS (Ex. 12:21). It is written: 'In sitting still and rest shall you be saved’ (Isa. 30:15). We have learned [Pes. 25]: Everything may be used for healing, save idolatry, immorality, and murder. MURDER. For example: If one should say to a man: 'Kill this man and you will be healed', he should not listen to him, for it says: 'He who sheds man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed' (Gen. 9:6). Since he who sheds blood has his own blood shed, how can the sufferer be healed by the shedding of blood? ADULTERY. What is an example of being healed through immorality? If a man is told to act immorally that he may be healed, he should not listen to such advice, for a man is strictly forbidden to act immorally. You will find the section concerning the nazirite and the unfaithful woman side by side. [Num. 5:11-31] The nazirite vows not to drink wine; whereupon God says to him: You have made a vow not to drink wine in order to be removed from sin; then do not say: "I will eat grapes and no sin will befall me." Since, however, you have made a vow against wine, I will teach you not to sin before Me.' He told Moses, therefore, to teach Israel the laws of the nazirite, as it says: 'When either man or woman shall clearly utter a vow... he shall abstain from wine and strong drink' (Num. 6:2-3), 'he shall eat nothing that is made of the grape-vine’ (Num. 6:4), and when he does this, he will be like an angel [free from sin]. All the days that he consecrates himself to the Lord, he shall be holy, as it says: 'And, behold, a watcher and a holy one' [referring to an angel](Dan. 4:10). Again, a woman too is called 'vine', for it says: 'Your wife shall be as a fruitful vine’ (Ps. 128:3). God said: Do not say: I know I must not intimately associate with a woman, but I will take hold of her, or embrace her or kiss her and still not be led into sin. For just as the nazirite who vowed abstention from wine must abstain from grapes, whether dried or in a liquid state, also from anything soaked with grapes or that comes out of the vine, so also must you abstain from the slightest touch of any woman who is not your wife. This is what Solomon cautioned: 'Can a man take fire in his bosom, and his clothes not be burned?... so he that goes in to his neighbor's wife; whoever touches her shall not go unpunished' (Prov. 6:27,29). Hence did God place the section of the nazirite next to that of the unfaithful wife, because of their similarity to one another. He who touches another's wife brings death upon himself, as it says: 'Yea, a mighty host are all her slain’ (Prov. 7:26), and also 'Her feet go down to death; her steps take hold on the nether-world’ (Prov. 5:5). Since it [immorality] has all these characteristics, how can it give new life to the sick? It is for this reason that one must not seek healing thereby. IDOLATRY. What is the example for idolatry? If an ailing person in Israel is told to go to a certain idol and he will be healed, he must on no account obey; for so we are told: 'He who sacrifices to the gods, except to the Lord only, shall be utterly destroyed' (Ex. 22:19). Since he who worships other gods is destroyed, it is much better for him to die of his illness in this world than bring destruction upon himself [in both worlds]. Not only is idolatry itself forbidden, but this prohibition extends to all things connected with idolatry. For instance: If a man is told to take of the incense offered up to idols or something from the sacred grove and make of it a charm whereby he may be healed, he should not comply; for it says: 'And none of the devoted thing shall cleave to your hand' (Deut. 13:18) -- this refers to idolatry. It also says: 'And you shall not bring an abomination into your house, and be accursed like unto it' (Deut. 7:26). Why is this? Because there is no reality in them and they are of no avail whatsoever, as it says: 'Do not be afraid of them, for they cannot do evil, neither is it in them to do good' (Jer. 10:5). 7 -You will find that this is what Jeremiah said to his generation: 'Behold, I will arraign the idols in judgment, and will declare their works and that of God, so that all may know the difference between God and the idols.' Four times on one page will you find that Jeremiah exposed the shame of idolatry and revealed the praise of God, as it says: 'Thus says the Lord: Do not lean the way of the nations,... for the customs of the peoples are vanity' (Jer. 10:2,3); 'They deck it with silver and with gold... they are like a pillar in a garden of cucumbers, and do not speak’ (Jer. 10:4,5). -Now that you have heard the shame of the idols, come and hear the praises of God, as it says: 'There is none like You, O Lord;... Who would not fear You, O King of the nations?' (Jer. 10:6,7). -Now that you have heard the praises of God, hear once again the shame of idolatry, for it says: 'But they are altogether brutish and foolish:... silver beaten into plates which is brought from Tarshish' (Jer. 10:8,9). -Now that you have heard the shame of the idols, come and I will tell you once again the praise of God, for it says: 'But the Lord God is the true God' (Jer. 10:10). -Now that you have heard the praise of God, come and hear once again the shame of the idols; for it says: 'Thus shall you say to them: 'The gods that have not made the heavens and the earth, these shall perish from the earth, and from under the heavens’ (Jer. 10:11). -After having heard the shame of the idols, come and hear once again to the praise of God; for it says, 'He who has made the earth by His power... at the sound of His giving a multitude of waters in the heavens' (Jer. 10:12-13). -Now that you have heard the praise of God, come and hear once again the shame of the idols, for it says, 'Every man is proved to be brutish... They are vanity, a work of delusion’ (Jer. 10:14-15). -Now come and listen once again to the praises of God after this exposition of the shame of the idols, for it says, 'Not like these is the portion of Jacob; for He is the former of all things' (Jer. 10:16). God, therefore, said: Since it [idolatry] is like a mute stone, [Hab. 2:19] and mere make-believe, and others have to guard it from being stolen, how can it possibly give new life to those who are suffering?' It is for this reason that one must not seek a cure from anything that belongs to it. You will find that when Israel were in Egypt, they served idols, which they were reluctant to abandon, for it says: 'They did not every man cast away the detestable things of their eyes' (Ezek. 20:8). God then said to Moses: As long as Israel worship Egyptian gods, they will not be redeemed; go and tell them to abandon their evil ways and to reject idolatry. This is what is meant by: DRAW OUT AND TAKE YOU LAMBS, that is to say: Draw away your hands from idolatry and take for yourselves lambs, thereby slaying the gods of Egypt and preparing the Passover; only through this will the Lord pass over you. This is the meaning of 'In sitting still and rest shall you be saved'. [Through repentance and rejection of idols will you be saved.] 8 Shabbat Midrash - Exodus Rabbah 25:11-12 11. SEE THAT THE LORD HAS GIVEN YOU SHABBAT (Ex. 16:29). Why does it say SEE, when 'know' would have been better? This, however, is what God said to them: 'When the heathen come and say to you: "Why do you keep Shabbat on this day?" then tell them: "See, the manna does not descend on Shabbat." Why does it say, THE LORD HAS GIVEN *YOU*? - TO YOU has He given it, but not to the heathen. It is in virtue of this that the Sages stated [Sanh. 56b] that if some of the heathen observed Shabbat, then not only do they not receive any reward, [but they are even considered to be transgressing]; for it says, 'And day and night shall not cease' (Gen. 8:22), and also 'It is a sign between Me and the children of Israel forever' (Ex. 31:17). [Veshamru] Ex. 31:16. Therefore the people of Israel shall keep Shabbat, to observe Shabbat throughout their generations, for an everlasting covenant. 17. It is a sign between me and the people of Israel forever; for in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, and on the seventh day he rested, and was refreshed. It is just as if a king and queen were sitting on their thrones and somebody passed between them; he would be deemed to have offended. [Likewise, if a heathen comes between God and Israel, it would be improper.] 12. R. Levi said: If Israel kept Shabbat properly even for one day, the son of David would come. [In Shabbat 118b, R. Simeon bar Yohai puts the number at two Shabbatot.] Why? Because it is equivalent to all the commandments; for so it says, 'For He is our God, and we are the people of His pasture, and the flock of His hand. To-day, if you would but listen to His voice!' (Ps. 95:7) -R. Johanan said: The Holy One, blessed be He, told Israel: 'Though I have set a definite term for the millennium which will come at the appointed time, whether Israel returns to Me in penitence or not, still, if they repent even for one day, I will bring it before its appointed time.' Hence, 'To-day, [redemption comes] if you would but listen to His voice'; and just as we find that the son of David will come as a reward for the observance of all commandments [one day], so also will he come for the observance of one Shabbat, because Shabbat is equivalent to all commandments. R. Eleazar b. Abina said: In the Torah, the Prophets, and the Writings we find it stated that Shabbat is equivalent to all commandments. -In the Torah, because when Moses forgot to tell them the command of Shabbat, God said to him: 'How long you refuse to keep My commandments and My laws?' (Ex. 16:28), [His sin was only forgetting the instruction of Shabbat, and yet was tantamount to his neglect of all the commands.] and immediately after this it says, 'See that the Lord has given you Shabbat' (ib. 29) -In the Prophets, for it says, 'But the house of Israel rebelled against Me in the wilderness; they walked not in My statutes' (Ezek. 20:13), and immediately afterwards it says, 'And My sabbaths they greatly profaned' (ib.). -In the Writings, because it says, 'You came down also upon Mount Sinai, and spoke with them from heaven' (Neh. 9:13), and immediately afterwards it says, 'And made known to them Your holy sabbath.' [Shabbat is the only command that is specified.] God said: 'If you virtuously observe Shabbat, I will regard you as observing all the commands of the Law, but if you profane it, I will regard it as if you had profaned all the commands'; for so it says, 'That keeps Shabbat from profaning it, and keeps his hand from doing any evil' (Isa. 55:2). [Thus, to refrain from desecrating Shabbat is equivalent to refraining from all evil.] When man keeps Shabbat, whatever he decrees God fulfils, for 9 it says, 'If you turn away your foot because of Shabbat' (Isa. 63:13), and immediately after this it says, 'Then shall you delight yourself in the Lord' (Isa. 63:14), which has the same meaning as the verse, 'So shall you delight yourself in the Lord; and He shall give you the petitions of your heart' (Ps. 37:4). Moreover, whatever benefit you derive in this world, is but the fruit thereof, but the principal will remain for you in the World to Come, because it says, 'And I will feed you with the heritage of Jacob your father; for the mouth of the Lord has spoken it' (Isa. 58:14). 10