The Project Gutenberg EBook of The Coming Ice Age, by C. A. M. Taber This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you'll have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this ebook. Title: The Coming Ice Age Author: C. A. M. Taber Release Date: August 29, 2019 [EBook #60195] Language: English Character set encoding: UTF-8 *** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE COMING ICE AGE *** Produced by Tim Lindell, Charlie Howard, and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images generously made available by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.) Map 1 No. 1. THIS MAP SHOWS THE SPREAD OF GLACIERS AND ICEBERGS, AND THE EXTENSION OF SOUTHERN LANDS DURING ICE AGE AND ALSO THE DIRECTION OF WINDS AND OCEAN CURRENTS. Map 2 No. 2. THIS MAP SHOWS THE SPREAD OF GLACIERS AND ICEBERGS AND THE DIRECTION OF WINDS AND CURRENTS AT THIS DATE. THE COMING ICE AGE. BY C. A. M. TABER. BOSTON: Geo. H. Ellis, 141 Franklin Street. 1896. COPYRIGHT, 1896. BY C. A. M. TABER. GEO. H. ELLIS, PRINTER, 141 FRANKLIN STREET, BOSTON. PREFACE. The explanations given in the following pages, in which I have sought to show the manner in which an ice age is being brought about, is an extension of a treatise on “The Cause of Warm and Frigid Periods,” which I published in a small edition in 1894. And, from the small number of copies circulated, only a few came to the hands of persons particularly interested in such matter. Yet there were instances of its having proved of special interest to persons celebrated for their geological attainments, and also to instructors in physical geography. Besides, it received considerate notice in some of the leading reviews. Being thus somewhat encouraged, and thinking that the subject was too important to be neglected, I have given it further study during the last year, and meanwhile have obtained additional information from recent discoveries which has served to corroborate my views. Hence I have been able to be more explicit in my explanations in the present volume than in my earlier writings. Still, while acting as a pioneer in the matter, it will be seen that I have only attempted to expose the main outlines, as my age and failing health will not permit me to enter into the voluminous details necessary for a full explanation. In order to show why my attention has been turned to the great climatic changes which have taken place during past ages, and now threaten the future, I will repeat the introduction of my earlier publication, wherein I wrote that “the reason why I have undertaken to explain the causes which have brought about the warm and cold epochs is because of my being unable to harmonize the several theories that have been published with the general mode of action which nature pursues to-day. Having in the early part of my life been employed for a score of years in the whaling service, during which time my sea voyages were passed in cruising over the North and South Atlantic, and over the Indian Ocean, from latitudes north of the equator to the southern shores of Kerguelen Land, and along the seas of Southern Australia, I also, in my searching, cruised over the Pacific Ocean from the icy seas south of Cape Horn to the northern latitudes of Alaska, and, from New Zealand in the Western Pacific to the numerous islands in the tropical zone. And it may be said that among the chief things to be learned on such voyages was the direction of the prevailing winds and surface currents of the sea. Thus the impressions then received were in mind when, in after years, I had my attention drawn to the several theories advanced for explaining the causes which produced the warm and frigid epochs. But, so far as my marine experience goes, such theories have not harmonized with nature’s mode of operating at this age of the world. Therefore, I have conceived views which, to my mind, are more agreeable to the simple operations of nature of which I have long been witness. Consequently, I have written several short essays on climatic changes since 1880, and also letters relating to the same subject, which have been published in Science and Scientific American. But the space allowed for the introduction of such matter was necessarily too limited for so wide an explanation as the subject required. The views then advanced I have again repeated, with the addition of several facts pertaining to physical geography, which, so far as I know, have never before been published.” 3 4 Wakefield, Mass., U.S.A. June, 1896. CONTENTS. CHAPTER I. PAGE CAUSE OF COLD AND MILD PERIODS, 9–36 Traces of ancient glaciers in temperate zones, 9; prevailing winds the main cause of the circulation of the ocean waters between the tropical and temperate zones, 10; general direction of prevailing winds, and how, in connection with continents, they circulate the surface waters of the sea, 11; high and low sea-levels; separation of antarctic lands from South America, 12; Captain Larsen’s discoveries in antarctic regions, 13; how low lands south of Cape Horn were submerged, 13; how the winds move more surface water southward than northward, 14; Dr. Croll’s views on winds and ocean currents, 16; under-currents of the ocean, and how caused, 16; Gulf Stream currents, 17; antarctic under-currents, 18; why the winds were able to force more of the ocean waters southward than northward at the close of the Tertiary age, 19; Mr. Alfred R. Wallace’s views on Tertiary seas, 20; how the Cape Horn channel affects the ocean currents, 21; cause of the increase of cold in southern latitudes, 22; how the Cape Horn channel is closed during ice age, and its effect on ocean currents and temperature of southern latitudes, 24; the melting of glaciers from southern lands, 27; a salt sea requisite for circulation during ice age, 28; direction of surface currents in southern seas, 29; Humboldt current, 30; Agulhas current, 32; temperature of arctic ice, 34; movement of southern icebergs, 35; glaciers south of Cape Horn, 36. CHAPTER II. HOW ICE PERIODS IN THE NORTHERN HEMISPHERE ARE BROUGHT ABOUT, 37–54 Northern seas during Tertiary age, 37; Gulf Stream during Tertiary times, 38; the origin of a cold period in the northern hemisphere, 38; remarks on Gulf Stream and arctic currents, 39; circulation of arctic waters, 40; arctic channels during ice age, 41; how the weight of glaciers in the northern hemisphere attracts the waters of the southern seas during ice age, 42; Professor Prestwich on the submergence of European lands, 43; the great Atlantic tide rips the head-waters of the Gulf Stream, 44; high sea-level of Atlantic calm region, 45; tropical Atlantic currents, 46; Sargasso Sea, 48; arctic and Gulf Stream currents, 49; Pacific Ocean currents, 50; slow growth of an ice period, 52; reduction of Cape Horn channel, 53; permanence of antarctic glaciers elevated above the snow-line during mild periods, 54. CHAPTER III. SPREAD OF GLACIERS DURING COLD EPOCHS, 54–61 Spread of glaciers in tropical zone, 54; Professor Agassiz on the origin of Galapagos Islands, 55; the bowlders of Hood’s Island and rookery of Albatross, 56; alpine flora of Galapagos and tropical America, 57; Mr. J. Crawford on ancient glaciers in Nicaragua, 58; Cuba and Republic of Colombia during ice age, 58; destruction of animal life during glacial age, 59; temperature of North Atlantic and Mediterranean Sea during ice age, 60; temperature of ocean during warm epochs, 61; generative age ascribed to warm eras; Professor Wright on pre- glacial man, 61. CHAPTER IV. THE GLACIERS OF THE TEMPERATE ZONE, 62–75 Professor Hitchcock on the early history of North America, 62; glacial deposits of Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard, 63; Professor James Geikie on the glacial deposits of Northern Italy, 64; California coast ranges the work of Sierra glaciers, 65; ancient glaciers on the Pacific slope north of California, 67; Professor Geikie’s views on the ancient glaciers in the Salt Lake region, 68; Colorado Cañon, 69; the conglomerate deposits in the Appalachian district, 69; remarks on the glacial boundaries in United States during ice age, 70; sands of Florida, 71; ancient ice-sheets of the plains west of the Mississippi River, 73; the driftless region of Wisconsin, 74; tropical waters of North Atlantic chilled during ice age, 75; the drifted snow of British America and Siberia during ice age, 75. 5 6 7 CHAPTER V. REMARKS ON THEORIES ADVANCED FOR EXPLAINING ICE PERIODS, 76–93 Professor Geikie on supposed causes of the glacial period, 76; change in the relative level of the land and sea during glacial and post-glacial times, 77; submergence of northern lands at close of ice age, 78; the main cause of the movement of water from the northern seas at the close of glacial age, 79; why the earth-movement hypothesis should be rejected, 79; glaciers of Europe and Alaska, 80; North Pacific currents, 81; why the Pacific waters are growing cool, 82; the lowering temperature of the northern seas, 83; the increase of cold in Europe and Asia, 84; falling temperature of the Andean region, 85; General Drayson’s astronomical discoveries for explaining the cause of ice periods, 87; why the Gulf Stream was always confined to the North Atlantic, 89; the improbability of the Indian Ocean currents entering the arctic seas, 90; why the increase of glaciers must continue while the Cape Horn channel maintains its present capacity, 91; comments on the coming ice age, 92; tropical zone the abode of man during ice age, 93; preservation of the tropical ocean fauna through the glacial period, 93. CHAPTER I. CAUSE OF COLD AND MILD PERIODS. It is now generally conceded by those who have given the subject much attention that the greater portion of North America above the latitude of 39° north to the shores of the Arctic Ocean has been furrowed and scoured by the action of ice. Vast traces of ancient glaciers are also found in Europe; for it is reported that ice-sheets have left unmistakable marks of having overrun the greater part of the lands lying between the arctic seas and the latitude of the Pyrenees. In Asia evidences of glacial action have been noticed from Northern Siberia to the mountains of Syria. The great glaciers of Himalaya have in times past attained gigantic proportions. In Northern China huge bowlders are found scattered over the valleys, and a long distance from the mountains. The southern hemisphere, in proportion to the extent of its land surface, shows ample traces of former ice action. From the latitude of 38° south to the southern extremity of the western continent there is said to be the clearest evidence of former glacial action in numerous bowlders scattered over the land. On the shores of the South Pacific, from the Island of Chiloe to Cape Horn, the coast is fringed with deep fiords, which appear to be channelled out by ice, like the fiords of Norway and Greenland. And at this date the mountains of that southern region are covered with snow, and the glaciers which flow down the valleys are said to reach the tide-water as far north as the latitude of 47° south. The glaciers of New Zealand, now of Alpine proportions, during the ice age descended to the sea, and channelled the deep fiords on its south-western coast; and certain traces of glacial action have been observed in Southern Australia, and also in the province of Natal, South Africa. Kerguelen Land is pierced with deep, narrow fiords, which have the appearance of having been the work of ancient glaciers. The lands south of the antarctic circle are to-day supposed to be covered by an ice-sheet, of which the great ice barrier surrounding that region furnishes ample proof. While impressed with the above reports of the work of ancient glaciers, in connection with my own observations along the shores of the several oceans, I have been led to seek for the physical causes which brought about the great climatic changes of past geological ages. And, while having the subject under consideration, I have had my attention directed to the manner in which the great prevailing winds in connection with continental lands are able to move the heated surface waters of the tropical oceans into the colder zones, and also transfer the cold waters of the higher latitudes into the tropical zones. And it is through this grand movement of the ocean waters that we are enabled to account for the difference in the temperature of places now lying in the same parallels of latitude. The natural methods for conveying tropical heat into the higher latitudes, and also for excluding it therefrom, are so simple and efficient that on due consideration we are able to conceive how epochs possessing mild climates have been succeeded by periods of frigidity. It has been admitted by several writers on climatic changes that, should the tropical surface waters of the ocean be moved into the high latitudes in large volume, thus adding their warmth to the heat imparted by the sun, such combined heat would cause a mild climate. And it has been estimated that the amount of equatorial heat moved into the temperate and polar regions of the northern hemisphere by the Gulf Stream alone is equal to one-fourth of all the heat received from the sun by the North Atlantic from the tropic of Cancer to the arctic circle. Still, it appears to me, while viewing the subject from a marine standpoint, that the explainers of climatic changes have never 9 10 11 fully comprehended the manner in which the surface waters of the ocean are moved from the tropics into the high latitudes, and returned from the high latitudes to the tropics. Consequently, they have neglected necessary and efficient natural agents in their explanatory theories, and with much learning and ingenuity have laboriously sought to show how great changes of climate could be brought about through other causes. But when we notice the simple methods employed by nature to-day for transferring the heat of the tropics into the higher latitudes, and also the manner of excluding such heat therefrom, they appear to afford an explanation for the great changes of climate which have taken place during past ages; for it appears that the natural manner of proceeding by which heat is moved from the torrid zone into the high latitudes sufficient to cause a mild climate is through the ocean currents which are constantly set in motion by the great prevailing winds of the globe. These winds, as is well known, blow mostly from the east toward the west in the tropics, and from the west toward the east in the high latitudes. This counter-movement of the winds, in connection with a continent extending both northward and southward from the equator over many degrees of latitude, such as obtains on the western continent, is abundantly able to create extensive depressions and elevations on the ocean’s surface, and thus cause vast streams of water to move by gravity from the high sea-levels to the low sea- levels; and in this way the tropical waters have been moved during past ages, and to a considerable extent are now moved far into the northern and southern seas. This transfer of the ocean waters is the main cause of a temperate climate being enjoyed by countries situated in the high latitudes at this age. But, in order that the tropical currents should be able to flow into the high latitudes, in quantities sufficient to cause all lands and seas situated in such latitudes to enjoy a mild climate, it would be necessary that the land should extend unbroken, or nearly so, from the arctic to the antarctic circles. Thus, with a continent of such vast extent, the westerly winds would blow the surface waters of the ocean away from the eastern shores in the high latitudes, and so cause extensive low sea-levels; while the easterly winds of the torrid zone would heap the surface waters of the ocean against the eastern tropical shores of the continent. Consequently, the warm waters of the tropical high sea-level would be moved by gravity to the low sea-levels of the high latitudes, even to the arctic and antarctic regions, and thus afford them a mild climate. In this way we account for the mild climate enjoyed on lands and seas within the high latitudes during the warm epochs anterior to the glacial periods. As the western continent is the only land that extends unbroken from the equator to the cold latitudes of both hemispheres, thus affording an opportunity for the prevailing winds to move the tropical waters into the high latitudes, I will call attention to that portion of the continent which extends far southward into the southern ocean, where the winds and ocean currents have the greatest range and power to affect the climate on different parts of the globe. Here we see South America separated from the antarctic continent by a wide channel of deep water, where the westerly winds blow with great force. The space now covered by this interesting channel, owing to its being situated in the high southern latitudes, must have been occupied by a channel of comparatively small capacity, or else an isthmus of low land uniting the southern portion of South America with the antarctic continent during the warm epochs when the beds of the ancient seas of the northern hemisphere contained a considerable portion of the water now swelling the southern ocean. Therefore, the obstructions which separated the Pacific Ocean from the South Atlantic furnished opportunity for the westerly winds to force the surface waters of the sea away from the leeward side of such obstructions, causing a vast low sea-level, sufficient to attract the tropical waters heaped against Brazil by the trade winds into the southern seas in adequate quantity to cause a mild climate throughout the antarctic regions through long periods of time. Recent discoveries have proved that these high southern latitudes have been subject to great changes of climate. According to the reports from the Dundee whalers, while searching for seal in the icy seas that surround the South Shetlands, they met with the Norwegian ship “Jason,” Captain Larsen, who had traced the eastern shore of Graham Land to 68° south latitude, noting two active volcanoes. The same mariner brought from Seymour Island fossil shells and coniferous wood of the Tertiary epoch. These furnish sufficient evidence to show that a warmer climate once prevailed there. At the commencement of the glacial age the obstructions which separated the South Pacific from the South Atlantic had become deeply submerged by the sea, which may have been caused by a tendency of the ocean’s waters to move southward or by a comparative small movement in the earth’s crust. But, on account of the stability of the crust of the earth during times so late as the glacial epochs, the submergence of this southern region was probably owing to the movement of the ocean’s waters from the northern hemisphere into the southern hemisphere, which appears to have been brought about mostly through the agency of the great prevailing winds; for it seems to have happened that the prevailing winds on account of the disposition of the lands and seas were able to move more of the ocean waters southward than they moved northward during the age preceding the glacial periods. The waters thus slowly and gradually forced into the high southern latitudes must have deprived the northern hemisphere of their heaviness, and added their weight to the southern hemisphere. Therefore, the waters moved southward could not all be returned to the seas of the northern hemisphere by gravity, for the reason that the earth’s centre of attraction would change in accordance with the weight of water moved from the northern hemisphere into the southern. It will thus be seen that, while the northern seas were drained or became shallow, the augmented southern oceans deeply submerged the region south of Cape Horn, thus widely separating the western continent from the antarctic lands. Although the south-east trade winds on the eastern sides of the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans extend further northward than the north-east trade winds extend southward, owing to the heated tropical shores north of the equator being more extensive than such lands south of the equator, still, on account of the general weakness of the south-east trade winds at the equator, and also because of the obstructing northern lands, they have during remote times, and at this age, been largely prevented from impelling the surface waters of the sea into the northern latitudes in opposition to the brisk north-east trades. Furthermore, on account of the widening of the oceans as 12 13 14 they extend southward, the surface currents setting in the latter direction have more broad and easy passages than the great currents setting northward. Moreover, the great currents setting southward on the western sides of the oceans south of the equator are also much assisted during the southern summer months by the strong north-east monsoons which prevail along the east coast of equatorial Africa and the east coast of South America as far as the latitude of 30° south. The South African current is impelled northward by the trade winds down the south-western coast of Africa; but it is debarred from entering the northern latitudes by the Guinea currents, and so turned away into the south equatorial current which flows into the Brazilian stream. The Gulf Stream is much obstructed in its northern movement by the narrow Florida channel and the opposing arctic currents, and also by the trend of the North American coast eastward; while its return current on the eastern side of the Atlantic has a much less obstructed passage in its southern movement, and, while on its way past the Azores and Madeira Islands, is largely assisted by the prevailing winds. The Brazil current, with the impelling force of a strong north-east monsoon during the summer season, has no obstruction whatever in its southern passage until it meets with an offshoot from the great drift current of the southern ocean. And the same favorable conditions are obtained by the great currents setting southward on the western sides of the South Pacific while on their way to the low sea-levels east of Southern Australia and New Zealand. That portion of the equatorial stream of the Pacific which continues west across the Indian Ocean finds no open passage to the northern seas. Consequently, it turns south along the east coast of Africa into the southern seas. Therefore, this current, in connection with the great currents setting southward east of Australia, offsets the great Humboldt current setting north along the coast of Peru. In the North Pacific the Japanese current setting northward is obstructed by the narrowing of the ocean; while its return current on the American side has a constantly widening ocean on its passage southward, and also favorable winds to impel the surface waters toward the equator. Still, with all the facilities above mentioned for the movement of the ocean waters into the southern latitudes, it is probable that since the shallow seas of the northern hemisphere were drained, or much diminished, the prevailing winds have not possessed sufficient force to further augment the southern seas, because of the superior weight of the land in the northern hemisphere compared with the lands south of the equator. It will appear to those who attribute the rotation of the earth as being the main cause of ocean currents that I am too much given over to the wind theory. But I have reason to believe, as Dr. Croll has asserted, that “the winds are the principal cause of the ocean currents, and are not due to the trade winds alone, but to the general impulse of the prevailing winds of the globe.” Dr. Croll also declares that “all of the principal currents of the globe are moving in the exact direction which they ought to move, assuming the winds to be the sole impelling cause.” Those who think that the rotation of the earth is the real cause of the movement of the great surface currents of the sea should explain in some reasonable way why the Agulhas current turns west into the Atlantic from the Mozambique stream, and why the Guinea current turns to the east from the main tropical current of the North Atlantic; for it seems that these two great currents move in direct opposition to the rotation theory, while at the same time many things go to show that they receive their motion from the winds. This view of the question will receive further attention in succeeding pages. It is the opinion of some writers that a difference of temperature and density between the waters of the polar latitudes and the torrid zone is the principal cause of the movement of the surface waters of the ocean from the equatorial latitudes toward the polar seas, and so returned in under-currents; and this is a favorable factor for assisting the winds on some parts of the sea, especially in aiding the Brazil current in moving the surface waters from the high sea-levels abreast Brazil, and the equatorial calm belt of the Atlantic into the southern ocean, and also for favoring the surface currents setting southward on the western sides of the South Pacific and Indian Oceans. Yet, whatever gravitating force it may possess for assisting the above-named currents, it would also act against the impelling force of the trade winds, while they were drifting the surface waters northward toward the equator on the eastern sides of the several oceans, and also to retard the returning surface currents, while being drifted by the winds southward on the eastern sides of the North Atlantic and North Pacific. Therefore, while it would seem to favor the winds in their work on the one hand, it would act as an opposing agent on other parts of the ocean. Still, the difference of temperature between the tropical and antarctic seas probably does act in opposition to the wide and brisk trade winds on the eastern sides of the great oceans south of the equator, and so prevents their impelling the surface waters northward to a great extent; and this seems to be one great cause of there being less surface water moved northward than southward over the greatest oceans of the globe. The theory that the difference of density caused by the difference of temperature between the polar seas and the equatorial oceans made under-currents to flow from the polar latitudes, and meet in the equatorial seas, can only be carried on in the Atlantic Ocean, and in a comparatively less perfect way in the Pacific Ocean, and not at all in the Indian Ocean. The North Atlantic being open to the Arctic Ocean, a portion of the Gulf Stream waters that enter it from the north-west of Europe do sink and return southward in under-currents; and the cold waters which pass down the east and west coast of Greenland also sink under the Gulf Stream while on their southern movement. The meeting of these arctic currents with the cold under-currents from the antarctic seas in the tropical zone is probably one cause of their cold waters rising near the surface of the sea in the torrid latitudes of the Atlantic; and the same conditions probably obtain in a somewhat less degree in the Pacific Ocean. Yet it appears that the cold waters of the Antarctic occupy the largest space in the tropical zone, even in the North Atlantic. Dr. Carpenter, in his lectures on Ocean Currents, speaks of meeting with antarctic water so far north as the latitudes of the West India 15 16 17 18 Islands; and he also says that all of the Pacific Ocean at its depths is supplied from the Antarctic Ocean, as are the cold under-waters of the tropical Indian Ocean, which extend over twenty degrees north of the equator. Thus, from what we can learn of the antarctic under-currents, they seem to show that they are not wholly attracted northward on account of the difference of temperature between the antarctic and the tropical oceans, but partly because of more surface water being moved southward by the prevailing winds than they are able to move northward. And it appears that, if through the winds, combined with the difference of temperature between the antarctic seas and the equatorial waters, and also because of the oceans widening toward the south, more surface water is being carried southward than northward, the waters of the under-currents so caused must rise toward the surface in the latitudes from which they were first removed. Having called attention to the fact that the prevailing winds are not able at this date to augment the southern ocean waters from the scanty northern seas, because of the preponderance of northern lands, still there is reason to believe that even now, owing to the form of continents and oceans, and the attraction of the tropical surface waters into the Antarctic Ocean because of the difference of density between the warm and cold seas, the prevailing winds of this age are able to force more of the surface waters of the sea southward than they force northward; but, owing to the superior weight of the land in the northern hemisphere, the surplus surface water forced into the southern seas is returned by gravity after being cooled by the antarctic ice, and so adding to the deep under-currents which flow with a sluggish movement over the bottom of the sea into the tropical and northern temperate latitudes. And in this way the northern oceans are maintained at their present sea-level. The cold under-currents are probably assisted in their northern movement by whatever difference there may be in the density of the antarctic waters over the bottom waters of the equatorial seas. But, as such currents extend into the northern tropical latitudes of the northern hemisphere, it seems that the winds are the main cause of the under-currents which carry so much antarctic cold into the northern tropical seas, because the winds have forced an undue proportion of ocean surface water southward, to be attracted northward in under-currents by the preponderating northern lands. Yet, notwithstanding the superior weight of land in the northern hemisphere, it appears that there have been periods when there was somewhat more water in the oceans of the southern hemisphere than now; for it is reported that a portion of the low lands of Australia show traces of having been submerged during late geological times. This may have happened through an increased weight in the antarctic glaciers, which have in past ages, and probably may in future epochs, cause more of the ocean waters to be attracted southward than now obtains. But it is probable that an increase of southern ice would be largely counterbalanced by the accumulation of ice on northern lands. Yet it appears certain that since the Tertiary epoch the waters of vast shallow seas have been moved from the northern hemisphere into the southern. The dry beds of the ancient northern seas encourage this opinion, while the comparatively small area of southern lands serves to support such views. Still, during the ages prior to the glacial periods, while the low lands of the northern hemisphere were covered by the sea, the wide shoal channels which submerged the lower portion of North America afforded convenient passages for the surface waters of the ocean in their northern movement, and so prevented the oceans of the southern hemisphere from gaining undue preponderance. Hence long geological ages passed away before the winds were able to force more of the ocean waters southward than they could move northward, and thus augment the southern ocean from the waters of the northern seas. But the slow growth of such immense marine deposits in the shallow seas as are found in the Florida Peninsula and other portions of that region was at length sufficient to greatly obstruct the passage of the Gulf currents in their northern movement, and thus cause conditions which enabled the winds to force more of the ocean waters southward than they could move northward after the close of the Tertiary epoch. Mr. Alfred R. Wallace says in “Island Life” that the seas in the northern hemisphere during the Tertiary period covered a much larger area than now, and extended across Central Europe and portions of Western Asia, and the Arctic Ocean was enlarged. As it is not likely that any portion of the waters of the sea have been absorbed by the earth during the late epochs in the world’s history, therefore the ocean waters have not diminished except during cold periods, when the water evaporated from the sea was converted into ice, and, eventually, again returned to the sea. Thus it necessarily follows that, when the seas of the northern hemisphere contained a much larger portion of the waters of the globe than at this age, the seas of the southern hemisphere must have contained proportionally less. Consequently, during such times a portion of the shoal seas of the high southern latitudes must have been dry land. Therefore, this must have been the condition of the shallow sea basins in the region of Cape Horn. Mr. Wallace also says that “many peculiarities in the distribution of plants and some groups of animals in the southern hemisphere render it almost certain that there has sometimes been a greater extension of antarctic lands during Tertiary times.” And he also asserts that the great ocean basins have not changed, and that the form of continents has been permanent. It will thus be seen that it was through the movement of the ocean’s waters southward that the low lands south of Cape Horn were covered with water previous to the frigid periods, and so caused the wide separation between the western continent and the antarctic lands. The Cape Horn channel thus enlarged, the continuous mildness of the high southern latitudes which possessed the earlier ages came to an end, and gave place to alternate epochs of frigid and mild weather. For it appears that it is owing to the creation or enlargement of the Cape Horn channel that it is possible for frigid periods to be brought about, for the reason that its enlarged space of water prevents the westerly winds from maintaining a great low sea-level in the higher latitudes of the southern ocean; for, whenever the capacity of the Cape Horn channel is enlarged, the westerly winds, instead of maintaining a low sea-level on the South Atlantic, employ their force in impelling the surface water of the southern seas around the globe. And this work the strong westerly winds of the high southern latitudes have always accomplished whenever the Cape Horn channel was widely open, and this is what the winds are doing at this date. 19 20 21 Therefore, such waters of the torrid zone as are moved southward from their high sea-level, caused by the trade winds abreast the Brazilian coast, are largely turned away from the high southern latitudes. It is true, even with an enlarged Cape Horn channel, they can always flow along the South American coast to an inferior low sea-level, caused by the westerly winds blowing the surface waters of the sea away from the coast of Argentine and Patagonia; but on gaining that region they meet the cold ice-bearing currents which turn away east of Cape Horn from the great southern drift current to gain the same low sea-level which attracts the Brazil water. Consequently, the ice-bearing currents from the south, which branch off from the great southern drift current, are able to largely turn away the warm Brazil current from the higher southern latitudes; and, furthermore, the great southern drift current which passes through the Cape Horn channel, and so onward around the globe, also partly turns away the Mozambique current as well as the East Australian current, and so largely prevents their waters from warming the southern seas. Therefore, it is evident that, whenever the Cape Horn channel obtains sufficient capacity to give an independent circulation to the southern ocean, the conditions are favorable for the increase of cold in the southern latitudes. For it is because of the large exclusion of the tropical waters from the southern seas that ice-sheets have been able to form in early periods and in later epochs on the antarctic lands, and store away the annual frosts for thousands of years, and at the same time furnish icebergs sufficient to chill the waters of the southern temperate oceans, and consequently make cold such of the surface waters of the sea as are forced into the southern latitudes by the winds in surface currents, and so returned to warmer seas in cold under-currents, and thus with such frigid combinations bring about cold periods. Thus it appears, as I have previously shown, that it is owing partly to there being more of the surface waters of the sea forced southward by the prevailing winds than they impel northward that the cold under-currents are maintained; but it also requires an independent circulation of the southern ocean, such as I have pointed out, to cool its surface waters before they can sink and form cold under-currents. And there is reason to believe that such cold under-currents are more efficient in lowering the temperature of the temperate and tropical oceans than even the icebergs which such under-currents move into the temperate seas. And, when it is considered that the cold antarctic under-currents fill the depths of the Pacific and Indian Oceans in the northern hemisphere, and also largely the tropical depths of the North Atlantic, I am led to believe that the frigid conditions of the ice age were concurrent in the northern and southern hemispheres. The main reasons for such belief I will explain in the following chapter. After the foregoing explanations, showing how frigid periods are brought about through the independent circulation of the southern ocean surface waters, it is evident that, whenever through a slow natural process the Cape Horn channel is closed, a great change is wrought in the circulation of the southern ocean. For instead of the westerly winds blowing the surface waters of the southern seas constantly around the globe, and so turning away and preventing the entrance of the tropical currents into the high southern latitudes, the strong westerly winds, whenever the Cape Horn channel is closed or greatly obstructed, would blow the surface waters away from the Atlantic side of the closed channel, and so cause a great low sea-level, sufficient to attract the ocean waters of the tropical high sea-level abreast Brazil well into the southern seas. Therefore, it is important to trace nature’s slow methods of closing the wide Cape Horn channel at the perfection of an ice age. In my previous explanations on the subject I have thought that, should the southern seas have remained at or near the same sea- level as now, through an ice period brought about in the manner I have described, ice-sheets would accumulate on the antarctic continent, and also on the southern lands of South America, sufficient to flow out into the sea and close the Cape Horn channel. But further consideration shows the impossibility of the southern seas having maintained their present sea-level during the growth of frigid epochs which have left such ample traces of glaciers having extended widely over the lands of the high latitudes of both the northern and southern hemispheres. For it appears that the larger areas of land in the northern latitudes, embracing wide continents and large islands, must, during the growth of a frigid age, have increased the spread of glaciers many times greater in extent than could be obtained on the smaller lands of the high latitudes of the southern hemisphere. For it is evident that the water evaporated from the sea and deposited in snow on the large continents and islands of the high northern latitudes during the growth of an ice period would, while thus diminishing the ocean waters, greatly increase the weight of northern lands. Therefore, the waters of the diminishing seas of the southern latitudes would be attracted into the northern oceans in opposition to the prevailing winds. Thus it appears that the Cape Horn channel would be too much reduced at the perfection of an ice age to afford an independent circulation for the southern ocean, even without being filled by glaciers to the extent I have pointed out in previous essays. Still, to whatever dimensions the Cape Horn channel might be reduced at the perfection of a frigid period, the enlarged shores bordering its diminished waters would be covered by heavy glaciers that would flow into the shrunken strait, and so close it effectually. Thus the reduction of the Cape Horn channel during the advance of an ice age seems, on close consideration, to be a simple operation of nature, which in the normal course of events must have taken place. As the closing of the Cape Horn channel has been considered by reviewers the weak and questionable point in preventing my views from gaining acceptance, it becomes necessary to be explicit concerning the manner in which the Cape Horn channel has in past ages been obstructed. According to the charts prepared by John James Wild, the middle portion of the strait is represented as being over a thousand fathoms in depth; but, as far as I know, its true soundings have never been determined. The deep portion of the mid-channel is described as being narrow when compared with its whole breadth from Cape Horn to the antarctic continent. And, when it is considered, with the growth of an ice age, how much of the ocean waters would be stored in the vast ice-sheets of the northern hemisphere, and consequently because of their weight a large portion of the diminished southern oceans would be attracted into the northern seas, it seems that the bottom of the shoaler waters of the Cape Horn channel, which now comprise so large a portion 22 23 24 25 of its breadth, would be raised above the surface of the sea. The one-hundred-fathom depth south of Cape Horn, now supposed to extend from longitude 70° west to 55° west, and southward to the latitude of 57°, would be a land supporting heavy glaciers for six hundred miles along the north side of the reduced channel during the advanced growth of a frigid age; and the same conditions would be obtained in the vicinity of the South Shetland. And when, in addition, we contemplate the great snow-fall of that region, and the consequent gathering of glaciers which would occur on the widened shores of the lessened channel, and the certainty of their flowing into the diminished strait, together with the immense icebergs of such an age grounding in the shoaled waters, it seems that the complete obstruction of the reduced channel would be accomplished. While contemplating the conditions that would obtain while the Cape Horn channel was being reduced, it will be seen that the independent circulation of the icy southern ocean would be carried on to a considerable extent even after the narrowing strait was no longer able to afford space for wide drift currents, for the reason of the strong current that would be caused on account of the high ocean-level maintained by the westerly winds on the Pacific side of the diminishing channel, and the great low sea-level that would take place on its Atlantic side. Still, as previously shown, it seems that during an advanced stage of the frigid epoch, the heavy glaciers from the enlarged northern and southern shores of the shrunken channel, together with the ponderous icebergs, blocking its waters, the closing process would at last be speedy and effective. And on further consideration it might be said that a channel of much less width and depth would not have been of sufficient capacity to have caused ice periods so wide-spread as those that have left their traces on the continents and islands of the globe, for the reason that the independent circulation of the southern ocean would not have been sufficiently complete and long continued to have brought such world-wide cold periods to perfection. With the Cape Horn channel closed, as above explained, there would be, as I have asserted, a great change wrought in the circulation of the southern ocean; for instead of the westerly winds blowing its surface waters constantly around the globe, and so turning away and preventing the entrance of tropical currents into the higher latitudes, the strong prevailing westerly winds would blow the surface waters of the sea from the Atlantic side of the closed Cape Horn channel, and so cause a great low sea-level, sufficient to attract the ocean waters of the tropical high sea-level abreast Brazil well into the southern seas. The winds of the southern westerly wind-belt being stronger in that region than on any other portion of the globe, consequently they are able to do nearly as much work while drifting surface water as the belt of westerly wind of greater width on other parts of the southern seas. Thus a person who has had a long experience with the forcible westerly winds of the southern ocean can well understand their ability for disturbing the ocean waters in the latitudes of the Cape Horn channel. The drift currents of this region are moved by the winds and waves from one to four miles an hour. Therefore, with the Cape Horn channel closed, there is nothing more certain than that the westerly winds would be able to cause a vast low sea-level on the Atlantic side of the closed Cape Horn strait, and that the waters of the high tropical sea-level abreast Brazil would be attracted to its wide depression, as shown on map No. 1. The tropical waters thus attracted far southward would be cooler than the tropical waters of to-day, owing to the great amount of cold imparted to the ocean by the numerous icebergs of a frigid age. Still, they would begin the slow process of raising the temperature of the southern ocean, and would in time carry sufficient heat into the southern regions to melt the ice from all southern lands; for, in addition to the Brazil currents, the waters of the high sea-level of the tropical Indian Ocean which pass southward down the Mozambique channel would reach a much higher latitude than during periods when the Cape Horn channel was open. The ice periods of the northern and southern hemispheres being concurrent, a condition which I shall explain in another chapter, makes it obvious that during the melting of the glaciers from the antarctic continent and other southern lands the depleted Cape Horn channel could not gain sufficient capacity to give an independent circulation to the southern ocean during the melting of the southern ice- sheets, on account of the diminishing heaviness of the antarctic ice and the greater weight of the extensive glaciers and augmented seas of the northern latitudes. Consequently, it seems that the southern seas would continue in a lessened state while the glaciers were being melted from the northern hemisphere, as was the case during the melting of the ice from the southern hemisphere; and, furthermore, during such times the glaciers which overrun all the low lands and shoal waters of the Cape Horn region would, on account of their position being to the windward of the tropical currents, be the last great mass of ice to melt from the southern hemisphere. Therefore, it seems that the Cape Horn channel would continue closed or greatly obstructed while the glaciers were being melted from the lands of both hemispheres. Thus at length a mild climate would extend over the globe, and so remain until the prevailing winds slowly forced the surface waters of the sea into the southern ocean in the manner explained in previous pages, thus filling the Cape Horn channel to its present capacity, and again restoring the independent circulation of the southern ocean. While contemplating the conditions that would obtain during the melting of the ice from the antarctic lands, it will be seen that the tropical waters attracted to the great low sea-level to the leeward of the closed Cape Horn channel would eventually enter the great bight of the antarctic continent to the eastward of Graham Land, where Captain Weddell sailed to the latitude of 74° south. This deep gulf, owing to its situation, would receive the full impact of the southern movement of the tropical currents; and, as the warm waters spread over the wide sea-level, the westerly winds would convert them into a drift current, and under such conditions would be driven along the shores of the antarctic continent, past the South Indian and Pacific Oceans, and eventually, after undergoing a cooling process from the long icy passage, be forced against the Pacific side of the closed Cape Horn channel and the western Patagonian coast. While regarding the circulation of the sea during an ice age, it may be said that the ocean’s being composed of brine was the cause of its waters being able to circulate in frigid latitudes where fresh water would congeal. Consequently, this is one of the reasons why successive periods of frigidity and mildness have been brought about; for with an ocean of fresh water, repeated epochs of cold and warmth could not have occurred, because a sea composed of fresh water would have congealed while circulating in the high latitudes 26 27 28 during a frigid age. Therefore, it required a sea of brine to maintain a liquid state during the low temperature of an ice period. For, while the cold of a glacial age increased, the saltness of the sea increased also,...