• CTSA PROCEEDINGS 54 (1999): 181-99 • SECRETARY'S REPORT THE FIFTY-FOURTH ANNUAL CONVENTION The Catholic Theological Society of America held its fifty-fourth annual convention 10-13 June, 1999, at the Hyatt Regency Miami, Miami, FL. The theme of the convention was "Development of Doctrine." Registration took place from 1:00 to 5:00 p.m. and from 6:30 to 7:30 p.m. on June 10. A special preconvention session, "The Nature and Authority of Doctrine: A Search for Common Ground," was held from 1:30 to 3:00 p.m. and the continuing group, the Women's Seminar in Constructive Theology, held its session from 3:15 to 6:15 p.m. At the opening session, the Most Reverend John C. Favalora, Archbishop of Miami, welcomed the convention participants to Miami. Reverend Monsignor Franklyn M. Casale, President of St. Thomas University, offered the opening prayer. The first plenary address followed. The evening concluded with a reception. CTSA gratefully acknowledges Barry University, Blessed Edmund Rice School for Pastoral Ministry, St. Leo's College, St. Thomas University, and St. Vincent de Paul Regional Seminary for subsidizing this event. Since there were no resolutions submitted for consideration by the conven- tion, the Hearing of the Resolutions Committee on Friday afternoon, June 11, was cancelled. The business meeting took place in the late afternoon on Friday. The President's reception for new members followed the business meeting. The convention's eucharistic liturgy was celebrated in the late afternoon of Saturday, June 12, at Gesu Church. CTSA President Robert Schreiter served as presider and homilist. The convention banquet followed the liturgy. Toward the end of the meal, President Schreiter read the citation for the John Courtney Murray Award and presented the plaque and medal to Ladislas Orsy, S J. Morning prayer was held from 8:30 to 8:45 a.m. on Friday, Saturday and Sunday. On various days throughout the convention there were special receptions, breakfasts, or other meetings, for such groups as the Women's Seminar, the Karl Rahner Society, the Theological Studies Board of Editorial Consultants, Herder and Herder Theological Advisory Board and the conveners of continuing and developing groups. A faculty grants seminar sponsored by the Association of Theological Schools was held following the convention on Sunday afternoon, June 13. 182 CTSA Proceedings 54 / 1999 CONVENTION PROGRAM Thursday, June 10 1:30-3:00 Special Session Topic: "The Nature and Authority of Doctrine: A Search for Common Ground" (I) Moderator: Robert P. Imbelli, Boston College Presenters: Avery Dulles, Fordham University "Catholic Doctrine: Between Revelation and Theology" Richard A. McCormick, University of Notre Dame "Moral Doctrine: Stability and Development" 3:15-6:15 Women's Seminar in Constructive Theology. Continuing Group 1 Topic: "Reconsidering Sacramentality: A Conversation with M. Catherine Hilkert and Susan A. Ross" Conveners: Susan M. St. Ville, University of Notre Dame Susan M. Simonaitis, Fordham University Moderator: Mary T. Stimming, Dominican University Presenters: M. Catherine Hilkert, University of Notre Dame Susan A. Ross, Loyola University of Chicago 6:15-7:15 Reception: Women's Seminar in Constructive Theology 7:30-9:30 Opening and First Plenary Session Moderator: Robert J. Schreiter, Catholic Theological Union, CTSA President Welcome: Most Rev. John C. Favalora, Archbishop of Miami Opening Prayer: Rev. Monsignor Franklyn M. Casale, President, St. Thomas University, Miami Address: John E. Thiel, Fairfield University "Perspectives on Tradition" Respondent: Barbara Hilkert Andolsen, Monmouth University 9:30 Reception 'Regarding Group Sessions: Members are welcome to attend any group session. Those designated "Continuing" have program spaces assured on an ongoing basis, reviewed when the convention structure is reviewed. "Developing" groups are in the process of discerning appropriateness for becoming Continuing, and are assured a place on the program, with annual review, for three years. A "Research" group also has program space for up to three years if it determines this to be useful. Groups designated "Select" are selected by the Program Committee from members' proposals for a given year. Those designated "Invited" appear on the program in a given year at the invitation of the President-elect. Secretary's Report 183 Friday Morning, 12 June 9:00-10:30 Group Meetings 1. "Strangers in a Strange Land: Christian Responses to Migrants and Refugees." Invited group. Moderator: William C. Spohn, Santa Clara University Presenters: Richard J. Ryscavage, Jesuit Refugee Service/USA Thomas Chobolla, Secretariat for Pastoral and Community Services, Archdiocese of Los Angeles William R. O'Neill, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley 2. "The Lutheran-Catholic Joint Declaration on Justification by Faith: An Instance of Development of Doctrine." Select group. Moderator: Jeffrey J. Gros, Secretariat for Ecumenical and Interreligious Affairs, National Conference of Catholic Bishops Presenters: Margaret O'Gara, University of St. Michael's College Michael Root, Trinity Lutheran Seminary 3. Communication Theology. Continuing group. "Ecclesial Reception, Communication, and the Development of Doctrine" Convener: Bernard R. Bonnot, Unda-USA and the Odyssey Channel Moderator: Mary McCormick, St. Mary Seminary, Cleveland Presenter: Richard R. Gaillardetz, University of St. Thomas, Houston "Ecclesial Reception in the Development of Doctrine" Respondents: Francis Forde Plude, Notre Dame College, Cleveland "Interactive Communication Technologies and Reception" Paul A. Soukup, Santa Clara University "Walter Ong's Insights and the Process of Reception" 4. Medieval Theology. Continuing group. "Development of the Doctrine of Salvation in the Middle Ages" Convener: Michael Gorman, St. Francis Xavier University, Antigonish, Nova Scotia Presenters: Joan M. Nuth, John Carroll University "Development of Doctrine in Julian of Norwich's Showings" Matthew Levering, Boston College "Aquinas and the Medieval Debate about Christ's Saving Work" 5. Moral Theology. Continuing group. "The Development of Moral Doctrine" Conveners: Brian F. Linnane, College of the Holy Cross Maura A. Ryan, University of Notre Dame Presenter: Jean Porter, University of Notre Dame "From General Principle to Concrete Norm: The Case of Contraception (Again)" Respondents: Michael P. Moreland, Boston College Cristina L. H. Traina, Northwestern University 184 CTSA Proceedings 54 / 1999 6. The Thought of John Henry Newman. Developing group. "Newman on Development: Testing Newman's Tests" Convener: Edward Jeremy Miller, Gwynedd-Mercy College Presenters: Thomas R. Potvin, Dominican School of Theology, Ottawa "Preservation of Type: What Is Christianity's Type or Idea?" Robert L. Kinast, Center for Theological Reflection, Tampa "Practical Theology: A Test Case for Newman's Tests" Edward Enright, Villanova University "Newman's Tests of Development: Some 19th-century Protestant Critics" 7. Practical Theology. Continuing group. "Practical Theology and Theological Education" Convener: Michael P. Horan, Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles Moderator: Mark F. Fischer, St. John's Seminary, Camarillo, CA Presenter: Thomas H. Groóme, Boston College "The Pedagogical Challenges Posed by Practical/Pastoral Theology" Respondents: Mark L. Poorman, University of Notre Dame Gaile M. Pohlhous, Villanova University 8. Karl Rahner Society. Continuing group. "Rahner and the Development of Doctrine" Convener: Melvin E. Michalski, St. Francis Seminary Moderator: Ann R. Riggs, Marquette University Presenters: Mary E. Hines, Emmanuel College "A Rereading of Rahner's Work on Doctrine in the Light of Today's Questions" Paul G. Crowley, Santa Clara University "Newman, Rahner, and the Problem of Ecclesial Pluralism" Richard Lennan, Catholic Institute of Sydney "Rahner's Theology of the Priesthood and the Development of Doctrine" 9. Theology and the Natural Sciences. Continuing group. "The Significance of Scientific Cosmology for Christology" Convener: William R. Stoeger, Vatican Observatory Research Group, University of Arizona Presenter: Zachary J. Hayes, Catholic Theological Union "Cosmic Christology" Respondent: David S. Toolan, America 10. Hans Urs von Balthasar Society. Continuing group. "The Church in America and the New Path to Solidarity" Convener: Peter J. Casarella, Catholic University of America Moderator: Alejandro García-Rivera, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley Presenter: Peter J. Casarella, Catholic University of America "Ecclesia in America: Path to Solidarity" Respondent: Lorenzo Albacete, St. Joseph's Seminary, Dunwoodie Secretary's Report 185 11:00-12:30 Second Plenary Session Moderator: Mary Ann Donovan, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley, CTSA Past President Address: Francine Cardman, Weston Jesuit School of Theology "The Praxis of Ecclesiology: Learning from the Donatist Controversy" Respondent: George P. Schner, Regis College, Toronto School of Theology Friday Afternoon, 11 June 2:30-4:15 Group Sessions 1. "The Nature and Authority of Doctrine: A Search for Common Ground" (II). Special session. Moderator: Robert P. Imbelli, Boston College Dialogue with: Avery Dulles, Fordham University, and Richard A. McCormick, University of Notre Dame 2. Catholic Social Teaching. Continuing group. "Social Sin: A Contested Concept in Catholic Social Teaching" Convener: William P. George, Dominican University Moderator: Thomas J. Poundstone, St. Mary's College of California, Moraga Presenters: Rosemarie E. Gorman, Fairfield University "Segundo: Structural Sin and Original Sin" Margaret R. Pfeil, University of Notre Dame "Correlating the Social Dimensions of Sin and Reconciliation" 3. Yves Congar: Ecumenical Colloqium. Developing group. "Congar on Authentic Expressions of the Faith" Convener: Mark E. Ginter, St. Meinrad School of Theology Moderator: Catherine E. Clifford, University of St. Michael's College Presenter: Susan M. Brown, King's College, London, Ontario "Congar and the Development of Doctrine: A Catholic Perspective" Respondents: Stanley S. Harakas, Archbishop Iakovos Professor of Orthodox Theology, Emeritus, Holy Cross Greek Orthodox School of Theology "An Orthodox Response" Frank Macchia, Southeastern College of the Assemblies of God "A Pentecostal Response" 4. "Doctrine in the City: Teaching Theology in an Urban Context." Invited group. Convener: Thomas F. Ryan, St. Thomas University, Miami Moderator: Mary Carter Waren, St. Thomas University, Miami Presenters: Thomas F. Ryan, St. Thomas University, Miami "The Promise of Miami's Cultural Tapestry: Theological and Pedagogical Reflections" Kay A. Read and Dennis P. McCann, DePaul University 186 CTSA Proceedings 54 / 1999 "The DePaul-Birmingham (UK) Project: An International Perspective on Theology and Religious Studies in the City" Michael P. Horan, Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles "Pedagogical Strategies for the City" 5. Christology. Continuing group. "Christologies of the Second Vatican Council" Convener: Michael E. O'Keeffe, St. Xavier University, Chicago Presenter: Robert A. Krieg, University of Notre Dame "Christological Aspects of the Second Vatican Council" 6. Sacramental and Liturgical Theology. Continuing group. "The Communion Rite as Ecclesial Act" Convener: Bruce T. Morrill, Boston College Moderator: Gary A. Macy, University of San Diego Presenters: Jill Raitt, University of Missouri at Columbia "Sacramental Transformation and Eucharistic Communion: Pursuing Augustine's Insight in History" Thomas J. Scirghi, Fordham University "A New Attitude of Mind: Intercommunion and the Domestic Church" 7. "The Bible and the Bodies of Women: Development of Doctrine, Definitive Teaching, and the Case of Loisy." Select group. Convener: Ellen M. Leonard, University of St. Michael's College Moderator: Susan M. St. Ville, University of Notre Dame Presenters: Ellen M. Leonard, University of St. Michael's College Mary Rose D'Angelo, University of Notre Dame 8. Spirituality. Continuing group. "Religious Experience and the Development of Spiritual Teaching: Thérèse of Lisieux and Dorothy Day" Convener: Joan M. Nuth, John Carroll University Moderator: Stephen T. Krupa, John Carroll University Presenters: Mary E. Frohlich, Catholic Theological Union "Desolation and Doctrine in Thérèse of Lisieux and in Postmodern Culture" Leon Hooper, Woodstock Theological Center "Dorothy Day's Interpretation of Thérèse of Lisieux" 9. Theological Anthropology. Continuing group. "Incarnation and Human Embodiment as Ground for Theological Anthropology" Convener: Susan Windley, University of St. Thomas, St. Paul Moderator: Ted Ulrich, Catholic University of America Presenters: Diane Schneider, St. Mary's University, Winona "The God of Illness and Wholeness" Michael Stoeber, Catholic University of America "Suffering and Spiritual Development" Secretary's Report 187 10. Hispanic/Latino Theology. Continuing group. "Possible Contributions of Afro-Cuban Religion to Catholic Theology of Grace: An Interreligious Dialogue" Convener: Roberto S. Goizueta, Loyola University, Chicago Presenter: William Ramos, Florida International University Lukumi Religion: Possibilities for Dialogue" Respondent: Orlando O. Espin, University of San Diego 4:45-6:15 Business Meeting 6:15-7:15 President's Reception for New Members 8:30-10:00 Special Session. In Honor of the 10th Anniversary of the Deaths of the University of Central America Martyrs. Sponsored by the North American Contextual Theology. Continuing Group. "The Love That Produces Hope: The Thought of Ignacio Ellacuría" Convener: William R. O'Neill, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley Moderator: Kevin F. Burke, Weston Jesuit School of Theology Presenters: Maria Pilar Aquino, University of San Diego Gustavo Gutiérrez, Bartolomé de las Casas Institute (Gutiérrez' paper read by James B. Nickoloff, College of the Holy Cross) Roger D. Haight, Weston Jesuit School of Theology Robert A. Lassalle-Klein, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley Saturday Morning, 12 June 7:15-8:45 Breakfast Meeting: Karl Rahner Society Convener: Melvin E. Michalski, St. Francis Seminary Presenter: George Dennis O'Brien, President Emeritus, University of Rochester "Sex before God" 9:00-10:30 Third Plenary Session Moderator: Margaret A. Farley, Yale University Divinity School, President-Elect, CTSA Address: John T. Noonan, U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit "Experience and the Development of Doctrine" Response: M. Cathleen Kaveny, University of Notre Dame Law School 188 CTSA Proceedings 54 / 1999 11:00-12:30 Group Sessions 1. Renaissance/Modern Theology. Continuing group. "Doctrinal Development and the Tübingen School" Convener: Robert A. Krieg, University of Notre Dame Moderator: John E. Thiel, Fairfield University Presenters: Michael J. Himes, Boston College "J.S. Drey and J.A. Möhler on Doctrinal Development Grant Kaplan, Boston College "Historical Revelation and Living Tradition in J.E. Kuhn" William E. McConville, Siena College "F. A. Staudenmaier on Dogmatic Development" Respondent: Donald J. Dietrich, Boston College 2. "The Faith/Morals Distinction and the Development of Moral Doctrine." Select group. Convener: Michael J. Baxter, University of Notre Dame Presenters: John R. Berkman, Catholic University of America "The Faith/Morals Distinction and the History of Catholic Moral Theology" Joseph E. Capizzi, Catholic University of America "'Faith and Morals' in Modern Theology, Vatican II to Present" Respondents: James T. Bretzke, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley Paul J. Wojda, University of St. Thomas, St. Paul 3. Early Christian Theology. Continuing group. "Doctrinal Development in the Early Church" Convener: Alexis J. Doval, Saint Mary's College of California, Moraga Moderator: Dolores L. Greeley, St. Louis University Presenters: Robert J. Daly, Boston College "Development, Evolution, Devolution: Eucharistie Theology from its Origins to Berenger of Tours" Mary Ann Donovan, Jesuit School of Theology at Berkeley "Later Theology and an Early Text: Revisiting Adversus haereses III 4. Ecclesiology. Continuing group. "Protecting the Faith: Ad Tuendam Fidem" Convener: Susan K. Wood, Saint John's University, Collegeville Presenters: Michael A. Fahey, Marquette University "The Context of Ad Tuendam Fidem" Ladisias M. örsy, Georgetown University "Ad Tuendam Fidem: A Canonical Interpretation" 5. Trinitarian Theology. Continuing group. "The Immanent-Economic Distinction" Convener Nancy A. Dallavalle, Fairfield University Moderator: Anthony Keaty, St. John's Seminary, Brighton Presenters: David M. Coffey, Marquette University Secretary's Report 189 "A Critical Analysis of Catherine LaCugna's God for Us: 'Revisiting the Framework of Trinity' " Ralph G. Del Colle, Marquette University "Immanent-Economic Distinction: A Doxological Query" Elizabeth Groppe, University of Notre Dame "Responses to the Critiques of Catherine LaCugna's Analysis of the 'Immanent-Economic Trinity' Paradigm" "The Theology of Edward Schillebeeckx: Implications for Understanding the Development of Doctrine." Select group. Convener: Daniel P. Thompson, Fordham University Moderator: Mary T. Stimming, Dominican University Presenter: Daniel P. Thompson, Fordham University "Schillebeeckx and the Development of Doctrine: Historical Periods, Postmodernity and the Translation of Experience" Respondent: Elena G. Procario-Foley, Iona College "Spirituality and the Development of Doctrine." Select group. Convener: Robert C. Christie, De Vry Institute Moderator: Anne-Marie R. Kirmse, Fordham University Presenters: William V. Dych, Fordham University "The Role of Experience in Doctrinal Development in the Theology of Karl Rahner" Robert C. Christie, De Vry Institute "Holiness in John Henry Newman's Theory of Doctrinal Development" Andrew Talion, Marquette University "Rousselot and Quasi-Intention" "Development and Truth: Is 'Development' the Issue?" Select group. Convener: Paul G. Crowley, Santa Clara University Moderator: Mary E. Hines, Emmanuel College Presenters: Bradford E. Hinze, Marquette University "Ecclesial Repentance and Doctrinal Development: A Dialogical Model" Jack A. Bonsor, Santa Clara University "The Unity of Truth and the Fractured Christian Church" Stephen Schloesser, Stanford University "Development, Bisociation, Mimicry? Neo-Thomism and the Invention of Tradition" Health Care Issues in the U.S. and Canada. Research group. "The Mission of Catholic Health Care" Convener: Thomas J. Poundstone, St. Mary's College of California, Moraga Presenters: Regina Wolfe, St. John's University, Collegeville "The Mission of Catholic Health Care: Facing the Challenges" Mark C. Miller, Redemptorist Bioethics Consultancy for Western Canada "Core Values of Health Care: Stewardship, Ethics, and Mission" 190 CTSA Proceedings 54 / 1999 10. "Scholasticism: Cross-cultural and Comparative Perspectives— New Insights into the Catholic Scholastic Tradition?" Select group. Convener: Francis X. Clooney, Boston College Moderator: Paul J. Griffiths, University of Chicago Presenter: José I. Cabezón, Iliff School of Theology "Scholasticism—The Book and Its Theological Rationale" Respondents: Lois Malcolm, Luther Seminary, St. Paul Thomas P. Rausch, Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles David M. Williams, Boston College Saturday Afternoon, 12 June 2:30-4:15 Group Sessions 1. "Christian Doctrine in the Caribbean: Development?" Select group. Convener: Gerald M. Boodoo, Xavier University of Louisiana Moderator: Philip Linden, Xavier University, New Orleans Presenters: Gerald M. Boodoo, Xavier University of Louisiana "Doctrine and its Development in a Forced Theological Context" Jason Gordon, Regional Seminary of St. John Vianney, Trinidad "Cultural Collisions, Religious Freedom, and Development of Doctrine in the Caribbean" 2. Comparative Theology. Continuing group. Topic: "Theological Anthropology: Hindu/Buddhist Practice" Convener: Bradley J. Malkovsky, University of Notre Dame Moderator: Ted Ulrich, Catholic University of America Presenter: Francis X. Clooney, Boston College "In the Light of Her Face: Hindu Goddess Worship and Human Nature— What Christians Can Learn from It" Respondent: Susan M. Windley, University of St. Thomas, St. Paul 3. Development of Doctrine and the Jews. Select group. "Vatican II on the Jews: A Dramatic Example of Theological Development" Conveners: M. Christine Athans, St. Paul Seminary, St. Paul John T. Pawlikowski, Catholic Theological Union Moderator: Ronald E. Modras, St. Louis University Presenters: M. Christine Athans, St. "The Historical Context—Anti-Judaism and Anti-Semitism" John T. Pawlikowski, Catholic Theological Union "Vatican II and Beyond" Respondent: Ronald E. Modras, St. Louis University 4. "The Diocesan Synod: A Means to Develop Doctrine." Invited group. Convener: Catherine T. Nerney, Chestnut Hill College Moderator: Richard R. Gaillardetz, University of St. Thomas, Houston