Report on CJK Joint survey on Fora/Consortia July. 2008. Contents I. Introduction --------------------------------------------------- 3 II. Analysis on Fora/Consortia -------------------------------------- 4 1. List of Fora/Consortia Surveyed in 2007 ------------------------ 4 2. Analysis of Fora/Consortia Surveyed ------------------------ 6 2-1. Reclassification of Objective Field 2-2. Analysis by objective field 2-3. Analysis by purpose of activities 2-4. Analysis by number of participating members 2-5. Analysis by activities Domain III. Appendix: Details of Fora ------------------------------------- 16 1. Survey on ICT Fora in the world(Global & Regional) 2. Survey on ICT Fora in Korea 3. Survey on ICT Fora in China 4. List of ICT Fora in Japan(Descriptions not included) Telecommunications Technology Association 2 ⅠⅠⅠⅠ. Introduction 1. Background Joint survey on Fora/Consortia 1-1. GSC Meeting - TTC proposed a collaboration in fora survey among CJK members in 2005(GSC10) → Agreed (April.06) - TTC presented the first report of survey at GSC12 (first report) 1-2. CJK Standardization Meeting - TTA assigned as the convener of Ad-hoc Group on Fora, and responsible to report at CJK8 (The convener of AHGF is rotated among CJK Members [TTC('07) → TTA('08) → CCSA('09) → Agreed (CJK7,'07.4)] - TTA has surveyed and analyzed 190 fora - TTA submits the second report of fora survey at GSC13 2. Schedule and Working Method Joint survey on Fora/Consortia Date Activities Role July 2007 ~ Survey on fora of ICT in the world excluding fora of China, TTA January 2008 Japan and Korea Circulation of topics for analyzing fora, Ad-hoc Fora February 2008 Adjustment/Implementation of CJK member opinions Member March 2008 Analysis and Interim presentation at CJK8 TTA April 2008 Request China and Japan for their fora survey TTA Gather, analyze and update reports submitted by CCSA and Ad-hoc Fora May-Jun 2008 TTC [Full text report not available for Japan (TTC)] Member July 2008 Submission of the final report at GSC13 TTA 3 ⅡⅡⅡⅡ. Analysis of Fora/Consortia Activity 1. List of Fora/Consortia Surveyed in 2007 1-1. There are about 190 ICT fora in the world - Fora were classified into 4 regions depending on the location of the secretariat total of for a Region Name of Fora (Percentage) 3GPP, AUTOSAR, DMP, DRM, DVB, ECMA, EDIFICE, EMF, 23 ERTICO, Femto Forum, GS1, GSM Association, HGI, IDF, IFR, MeT, Europe Region (12%) MOST, OMTP, PLC, TV Anytime Forum, UMTS, World DMB Forum, WWRF 1394TA, 3GPP2, AIM, ATSC, Bio API, Bluetooth SIG, BSF, CABLELABS, CDG, CELF, DCMI, DLNA, DMTF, DSLF, ENUM, EPCglobal, Ethernet Alliance, FCIA, FLO, FSAN, HANA, HAVi, HomePNA, ICANN, IDPF, IEEE RAS, IEEE802, IETF, IMS Forum, IMS Global, IMTC, IPv6 Forum, IrDA, ISMA, ISOC, Khronos Group, North America 88 LAP, LINUX Foundation, LIPS Forum, LONMARK, MEF, MFA, MIPI, Region (46%) MoCA, MPEGIF, MPF, MSF, NFC Forum, OAGi, OASIS, OGC, OGF, OIF, OMA, OMG, OSGi, Parlay, PCCA, PCISIG, PCMCIA, PCSC, PICMG, Quest, Road to 100G Alliance, Rosettanet, SAF, SAL-C, SCA, SCOPE Alliance, SCTE, SDR, SIP, SNIA, TMForum, TOG, UPnP, USBIF, Voice XML, VSF, VSIA, W3C, Web 3D, WfMC, WIFI, WiMAX, WiMedia, WS-I, ZigBee AICF, DVD Forum, ASIA PKI Forum, TDIA, IGRS, ITopHome, SCDMA, CFA, MMTA, AVSA, TAF, WAPI Industry Alliance, China Bluetooth Technical Industry Alliance, china RFID Industry Alliance, Future Forum, TD-SCDMA(China), NGMCF, KWISF, Spectrum Engineering Forum, Korea UWB Forum, WPAN Forum, USN Forum, MRF, u-city Forum, Next Generation Broadcasting Forum, MPEG Forum, KDCF, IPTV Forum Korea, BcN Forum, IPv6 Forum Korea, VoIP Forum, URI Forum, FoN Forum, Korea Ethernet Forum, Intelligent Robotics Forum, Next Generation PC Forum, Home 77 Asia Region Network Forum, GFK, LBS Forum, Telematics/CVB Forum, IT infra (41%) service Forum, SoC Forum, DRM Forum, DCF, M3D Forum, Metadata crosswork Forum, SW technology Forum, Web Korea Forum, IABF, MW 2.0 Forum, Modeling Forum Korea, u-payment Forum, Integrity Forum on Electronic Commerce, Korea Bio-metric Forum(Korea), Business Grid, Consortium for Millimeter wave Practical Application, ECHONET, ECOM, ICTFSS, ITS Forum, JAISA/BSC Committee, JEPPO, JICSAP, Marlin, MBA, MCPC, PHSMoU, PoF, PUCC, SPIA, T-Engine, UOPF, VLCC, IIC, UNF,DOPG, mITF, (Japan) 2 etc Open IPTV Forum, VOIPSA (1%) Total number of 190 Fora 4 - More than 46% of fora surveyed are located in the North American region - Most Fora in Asian region consist of 50 or less members and are established / activated since 2000 1-2. New/Re-named Fora - The following table consists of newly launched or re-named (Including merged, deleted) Fora in 2007 Name of Fora Month / year Technical field Femto Forum July/2007 Convergence Infrastructure Newly Launched Open IPTV Forum March/2007 Convergence Infrastructure Forum Road to 100G Alliance January/2007 Convergence Infrastructure Renamed Linux Foundation Forum (Open Source Development Lab January/2007 Information Technology (merge, delete) + Free Standard Group) - 3 Fora were newly founded, 1 forum changed the name due to a merger between OSDL and FSG. - Missions of newly Launched Fora ● Femto Forum: Promoting femtocell standard & deployment (**Femtocells are low-power wireless access points that operate in licensed spectrum to connect standard mobile devices to a mobile operator's network using residential DSL or cable broadband connections) ● Open IPTV Forum: Producing end-to-end specifications for IPTV technologies ● Road to 100G Alliance: Development of a new era of next generation networking Platforms 5 2. Analysis of Fora/Consortia Surveyed 2-1. Reclassification of Objective Field - Reclassification based on TTC's original "classification by objective Field" reflecting the opinion of CJK Ad-hoc Member - Naming change ● 3 Classification name change: Telecommunication, Information Technology, Service → Convergence Infrastructure, Information Technology, Convergence Service ● 1 Field name change: Software → u-Infra Software - Category Change ● Infrastructure, Subscriber, LAN, Internet → Broad Convergence Network ● Home-networking, Intelligent Transport System, PC → u-Computing ● Multimedia → Digital Broadcasting, Contents - Addition of 3 Fields ● RFID/USN (Radio Frequency Identification/Ubiquitous Sensor Network), Security Intelligent Robotics 6 2-2. Analysis by Objective field Following table shows the results of classifying and summarizing forum activities on an objective field basis. For those Fora that span multiple objective fields, only their first objective field (the highest priority in their objective fields) were used for comparison. category Field total Name of fora DSLF, EMF, ENUM, Ethernet Alliance, FCIA, FSAN, ICANN, IEEE802, IETF, IMTC,IPv6, ISOC MEF, MFA, MSF, OIF, Parlay, Quest , Road to 100G Alliance, SCOPE Alliance, SIP, SNIA, TMForum, VOIPSA, VSF,(E,N) BcN 38 Forum, IPv6 Forum Korea, VoIP Forum, URI Forum, FoN BcN (20%) Forum, Korea Ethernet Forum, Telecommunication Terminal Testing & Approval Forum, WLAN Authentication and Privacy Infrastructure Industry Alliance, China Bluetooth Technical Industry Alliance, MBA, VLCC, PUCC, POF(A) Convergence ATSC, BSF, CABLELABS, DRM, DVB, FLO, ISMA, Open IPTV Infrastructure 16 Forum, SCTE, TV Anytime Forum, World DMB Forum(E,N), Broadcasting (8%) Next Generation Broadcasting Forum, MPEG Forum, KDCF, IPTV Forum Korea, AVSA 3GPP, 3GPP2, Bluetooth SIG, CDG, Femto Forum, GSMA, IMS Forum, IrDA, MIPI Forum, NFC Forum, OMA, OMTP, SDR, UMTS, WIFI, WiMAX Forum, WiMedia Alliance, WWRF, ZigBee Mobile 32 Alliance(E,N), NGMC Forum, KWISF, Spectrum Engineering Forum, Communication (17%) Korea UWB Forum, WPAN Forum, TDS-CDMA, Future Forum, TDIA, SCDMA, MMTA, Millimeter Wave Practical Application, MPCP, mITF, CELF, LINUX Foundation, LIPS Forum, OMG, SAF, TOG, Voice 16 XML , W3C, Web 3D, WS-I (E,N), SW technology Forum, Web u-Infra SW (8%) Korea Forum, IABF, Mobile Web 2.0 Forum, Modeling Forum Korea, CFA(A) Information DCMI, DMP, DVD, IDF, IDPF, IMS Global, Khronos, Technology 13 Digital Contents MPEGIF(E,N), DRM Forum, DCF, M3D Forum, Metadata (7%) crosswork Forum, Marlin(A) 5 Bio API Consortium, PKI Forum, Korea Bio-metric Forum, Security (3%) ICTFSS, JAISA/BSC, AIM, EPC global, GS1, SAL-C(E,N), USN Forum, MRF 10 RFID/USN Forum, u-city Forum, China RFID Industry Alliance, ECOM, (5%) T-Engine 1394TA, AUTOSAR, DLNA, ECMA, ERTICO, Global Platform, HANA, HAVi, HGI, HomePNA, LONMARK, MoCA, MOST, OGC, OGF, OSGi, PCCA PCISIG, PCMCIA, PICMG, PLC, UPnP, USBIF(E,N), NGPC Forum, Home 41 u-Computing Network Forum, GFK, LBS Forum, Telematics/CVB Forum, Convergence (22%) IT infra service Forum, SoC Forum, IGRS, Home Network Service Standards Industry Alliance, Internet ITS Consortium, PHS MoU, ECHONET, Business Grid, DOPG, UNF, UOPF, ITS Forum, SPIA AICF, DMTF, EDIFICE, LAP, MeT, MPF, OAGi, OASIS, 16 EC PCSC, Rosettanet, SCA, WfMC, u-payment FORUM, ECIF, (8%) JICSAP, JEPPO 3 Robotics IEEE RAS, IFR, Intelligent Robotics Forum (2%) Total of fora 190 7 - The percentage of fora which are in conjunction with Convergence Infrastructure takes up to about 45% of total fora. Specially, BcN and Mobile Communication field takes up 37% of total of Convergence Infrastructure category - Objective field and location of Fora Secretariat Number of Fora category Field total North Europe ASIA etc America 38 BcN 1 23 13 1 (20%) Convergence 16 Broadcasting 4 6 5 1 Infrastructure (8%) Mobile 32 6 13 13 - Communication (17%) 16 u-Infra SW - 10 6 - (8%) Information 13 Digital Contents 2 5 6 - Technology (7%) 5 Security - 1 4 - (3%) 10 RFID/USN 1 3 6 - (5%) 41 u-Computing 6 17 18 - Convergence (21%) Service 16 EC 2 9 5 - (8%) 3 Robotics 1 1 1 - (2%) 190 Total of fora 23 88 77 2 (100%) 8 - The following points can be concluded from the table ● Overwhelming 46% of Fora are in North America, and 41% are in ASIA. Europe with 12% comes next. ● The specialized fields are as follows: North America - focuses on general Convergence Infrastructure related to Broad Convergence Network field. Europe focuses on general Convergence Infrastructure related to mobile Communication and Asia focuses on general Convergence Service related to u-Computing 2-3. Analysis by purpose of activities Following Table shows a classification of fora according to the purpose of activities. The purposes of activities are defined as follows: - De-facto standard: to develop de-facto standard. - Pre-standard: to contribute to standard development organizations. - Implementation specifications/interoperability: to develop implementation specifications and secure interoperability - Others: to conduct market researches, diffusing and enlightenment activities, information exchange, academic conferences, and so forth purpose of activities total Name of Fora ATSC, Bluetooth SIG, CABLELABS, DMTF, DVD Forum, Femto Forum, HANA, HomePNA, IDPF, IEEE RAS, IEEE802, IETF, Khronos Group, LIPS Forum, OASIS, OMA, OSGi, PCCA, PCISIG, PCMCIA, PICMG, PLC Forum, SCTE, TOG, TVAnytime Forum, USBIF, VSIA, W3C(E,N)KWISF, Korea UWB Forum, WPAN Forum, USN Forum, MRF Forum, URI Forum, FoN 56 de facto standard Forum, Intelligent Robotics Forum, NGPC Forum, Home (29%) Network Forum, Grid Forum Korea, LBS Forum, Telematics/CVB Forum, IT infra service Forum, System on chip Forum, Digital Contents Forum, Mobile 3D Forum, Metadata crosswork Forum, SW technology Forum, Web Korea Forum, Modeling Forum Korea, Integrity Forum on Electronic Commerce, IGRS, ITopHome, CFA, IIC, SPIA, ECHONET 9 3GPP, 3GPP2, AIM, Bio API, DCMI, DRM, DVB , ECMA, FCIA, FSAN, IMS Global, ISMA, MEF, MeT, MIPI, MSF, OGC, OMG, Parlay Group, Rosettanet, TMForum, Web 3D, World DMB Forum(E,N), Next Generation Broadcasting 37 Forum, MPEG Forum, IPTV Forum Korea, BcN Forum, IPv6 Pre-standard (19%) Forum Korea, Korea Ethernet Forum, DRM Forum, Korea Bio-metric Forum, TD-SCDMA industry Alliance, Mobile Multimedia Technology Alliance, WLAN Authentication and Privacy Infrastructure Industry Alliance, VLCC, POF, Consortium for Millimeter Wave 1394TA, BSF, CELF, DLNA, DMP, DSLF, EDIFICE, EPC global, Ethernet Alliance, FLO, HAVi, HGI, IDF, IMS Forum, IMTC, IrDA, LAP, LINUX Foundation, LONMARK, MFA, MoCA, MOST, MPF, NFC Forum, OAGi, OGF, OIF, OMTP, Implementation Open IPTV Forum, PCSC, Quest, Road to 100G Alliance, 59 specifications/interoper SAL-C, SCOPE Alliance, SDR, SIP, UMTS, UPnP, UWB (31%) ability Forum, Voice XML, WIFI, WiMAX, WiMedia, WS-I, ZigBee(E,N), u-city Forum, Korea Digital Cable Forum, Voice over IP Forum, Mobile Web 2.0 Forum, u-payment FORUM, AVSA, TAF, China RFID Industry Alliance, T-Engine, UOPF, Business Grid, MPCP, DOPG, MBA, UNF AICF, AUTOSAR, CDG, EMF, ENUM, ERTICO, Future Forum, GS1,GSM Association, ICANN,IFR, IPv6, ISOC, mITF, MPEGIF, PKI Forum, SAF, SCA, SNIA, VOIPSA, 38 VSF, WfMC, WWRF(E,N) NGMC Forum, Spectrum Others (20%) Engineering Forum, IABF, SCDMA, China Bluetooth Technical Industry Alliance, TDS-CDMA, ECOM, JEPPO, ICTFSS, JICSAP, PHSMoU, PUCC, Marlin, ITS Forum, JAISA/BSC, ITS Forum - Analysis of classification by Purpose of Activity is as follows: ● The Percentage of Implementation & Interoperability and De-facto Standard is about 31%, Pre-standard is 19%, and others is 20%. According to purpose of Activity and location of Fora, Secretariat is as follows: ● The North America has the highest of Implementation & Interoperability (19%), Europe has the same as Implementation & Interoperability as Others(4.8%), and Asia have the highest of De-facto Standard(15%) 10