S339 B [He NaTORAL AUSEUN CER H >, . The Reading Naturalist No. 54 SS ; Z { SS Published by the Reading and District Natural History Society 2002 Price to Non Members £2.50 THE READING NATURALIST No 54 for the year 2001 The Journal of the Reading and District Natural History Society President Mr Rod d’Ayala Honorary General Secretary Mrs Catherine Butcher, 42 Long Lane, Tilehurst, Reading, RG31 6YJ Honorary Editor Dr Malcolm Storey, 43 Berry's Road, Upper Bucklebury, Reading, RG7 6QL Editorial Sub-committee The Editor, Dr Alan Brickstock, Mrs Janet Welsh, Mr Hugh H. Carter Miss June M. V. Housden, Mr David G. Notton Honorary Recorders Botany: Mrs Janet Welsh, 56 Grove Road, Sonning Common, Reading, RG4 9RL Fungi: Dr Alan Brickstock, 25 Cockney Hill, Tilehurst, Reading, RG30 4HF Entomology: Mr David G. Notton, Museum of Reading, Blagrave Street, Reading, RG1 10H Invertebrates other than insects: Mr Hugh H. Carter Vertebrates: Mr Hugh H. Carter, 10 Northbrook Road, Caversham Park Village, Reading RG4 6PW CONTENTS Obituaries 1 Members’ Observations 2 Excursions Meryl Beek 3 Wednesday Afternoon Walks Alan Brickstock 5 Meetings (2000-2001) Catherine Butcher 6 The Fishlock Prize 4 Membership Norman Hall 8 Presidential address: Why Some Plants are Rare Rod d’Ayala 8 The Woodland of Maiden Erlegh Park A. M. Mannion & S. Peck 15 Some Thoughts on Foot and Mouth, Agriculture and the Future of the Countryside Rod d’Ayala 17 A new Leaf-mining Fly — Phytomvyza hellebori Malcolm Storey 19 The Bowen collection of Lichens at Reading Museum David G. Notton 20 A new Toadstool — Leccinum cyaneobasileucum Malcolm Storey 21 Recorder’s Report for Botany 2001 Janet Welsh 22 Recorder's Report for Mycology 2001 Alan Brickstock 23 Recorder’s Report for Entomology 2001 David G. Notton 29 Recorder's Report for Invertebrates other than insects 2001 Hugh H. Carter 32 Recorder's Report for Vertebrates 2001 Hugh H. Carter 32 The Weather at Reading during 2001 Ken Spiers 34 EDITORIAL The most significant event in the countryside this year was the outbreak of the particularly infectious “O” form of Foot and Mouth (“F & M”). 2,030 cases resulted in the slaughter of 3,915,000 animals (DEFRA: 21 Oct 01), restrictions on stock movements and the countryside being closed to the public for several months during the first half of the year. The total cost is estimated at £2.4 — 4.1 billion, including £2 - 3 billion to the tourist industry compared to £800 million — 2.4 billion to agriculture (Countryside Agency report). Farmers were paid £1.1 billion compensation (DEFRA: 21 Oct 01). For comparison, the National Health Service costs over £50 billion per year. The effects on nature conservation include serious over- or under-grazing of pasture generally, including reserves. Fields containing stock when the restrictions came in were reduced to bare ground. Many livestock farmers must be now considering their options. Rod d’Ayala’s article reflects on both the immediate effects and the implications for the future of the countryside. For the Society, the outbreak meant the cancellation of several field meetings. It also largely prevented members from undertaking fieldwork other than in their own gardens, along roadsides and in public parks. This has reduced both the number of excursions to report on and of records passed to the Recorders. Copyright © 2002 Reading & District Natural History Society. Photographs illustrating “Why Some Plants are Rare” (pages 8-14): Copyright © Rod d’Ayala Lichen photograph (page 20): Copyright © 2001 Museum of Reading All other photographs: Copyright © 2002 Malcolm Storey OBITUARIES Humphry Bowen 1929-2001 Humphry Bowen died on August 9th, aged 72. Although an environmental chemist in his academic career, he was also a naturalist with a wide range of interests, but above all a deep love of plants. He worked in conjunction with many organisations — he was a council member of the BSBI and of the local wildlife trust, BBOWT, and was botanical recorder for both Dorset and Berkshire. As a lecturer at the University of Reading, he biased his research towards environmental issues affecting plants, such as sulphur dioxide pollution, oil spillages and toxic elements in the environment. He led many outings for the Reading Naturalists as well as overseas tours, particularly to Greece and Turkey. His ability to identify almost anything that was living was legendary, including taxonomically difficult groups such as lichens. Most of us will have used his Flora of Berkshire, published in 1968, and, just before his death, he was able to publish the Flora of Dorset, a flora which competes well with the new high standards which have been set recently in comital floras. Humphry gave many talks for the Reading Naturalists over the years, and these were always superbly illustrated and delivered with a great sense of humour. His death is a sad loss to us all, but those of us who knew him will have gained from his wealth of experience and knowledge and these live on in his books and collections. Vera Paul OBE, 1913 - 2001 Vera Paul joined the Reading and District Natural History Society in the early 1950's, becoming an Honorary Member in 1980. In her working life she was a teacher, from which she retired in 1980. Vera’s main natural history interest was botany, having learnt plants from an early age in her home area of Peppard, South Oxfordshire. She supplied records for the Naturalist for many years. Vera was a modest unassuming person with a strong will and an equally strong drive to get things done; her achievements were recognised in 1980 when she was awarded an OBE for services to conservation. She was a founder member of the Berkshire, Buckinghamshire and Oxfordshire Naturalists Trust (now BBOWT) and was the driving force behind the acquisition of the Warburg Reserve at Bix Bottom. Without her foresight and determination, the Trust would not have purchased the site, one of the best Wildlife Trusts Reserves in the country, and probably still BBOWT's best site. At the time, the purchase price (£25,000) was enormous, and she raised the money with all sorts of fund-raising schemes. Her fund-raising role, and financial support, for BBOWT over many years cannot be understated. She ran the Trust Christmas Raffle for many years and organised other major appeals. She was also responsible for the purchase of the Hartslock nature reserve at Goring. The RDNHS have had a long association with this site, one of only three current sites for the Monkey Orchid in Britain. Perhaps her main claim to (botanical) fame, was the discovery of the Ghost Orchid in 1931, in a wood near her home at Peppard. Secretly, she was very proud of this find and the botanical fame that followed her throughout her life. In the late 1950's she carried out botanical surveys in the South Oxfordshire area as part of the BSBI survey. The results of this national survey lead to the publication of the national plant atlas in 1962. In the last few years of her life, she was unable to carry out work in the field, but was always interested in any new plant finds or queries. Over the years she has backed many projects, both intellectually and financially. On a personal note, it was Vera who gave me my chance in conservation. | first worked for the Trust as a volunteer, and ended up being posted to the Warburg Reserve at Bix Bottom. At that time Vera was still very heavily involved with the running of the reserve, and she was instrumental in my being taken on as staff member at “her” reserve — first in a part time capacity and then full time. One of my first jobs was to update the botanical records for the Reserve, a detailed list of over 400 species primarily made or compiled by Vera herself since the 1960's. Vera Paul, and a few select people like her, came from a generation of naturalists who were the pioneers of modern conservation. Without people like her our corner of Berkshire, Buckinghamshire and Oxfordshire would be a poorer place. In the face of the continual and rapid changes and threats to the countryside, it would have been easier just to watch, and accept, the advances and “improvements” of the modern world. There was very little in the way of an environmental movement or the wider public comprehension of “green” issues that there is today. We should be grateful that she, and her colleagues, chose to intervene and did not allow everything to be lost. 1 MEMBERS’ OBSERVATIONS Before the talks begin, members are invited to announce their observations. Here is a selection of observations from the 00/01 winter meetings: 26 Oct 2000 Tony Rayner reported a Brimstone butterfly and a Red Admiral at The Red Cow, Cholsey, a pair of Common Darters laying, 1 Grass snake and 1 Black Redstart on a roof, several times between 19/10 and 21/10 Ken Grinstead had found Common Fly Agaric at Silchester Norman Hall had seen a Red Admiral in his garden 29 Oct 2000 Michael Keith-Lucas reported that the only specimen in Reading of Salix x sepulcharis subsp. sepulcharis (a rare weeping willow) had blown down during a storm. The tree is being left to re-root and small twigs have been taken to help re-establish it. 9 Nov 2000 Martin Sell had seen a Comma butterfly. Alan Brickstock reported a Red Admiral. Ken Grinstead had spotted a Brimstone butterfly. 23 Nov 2000 Alan Brickstock had seen Little Egret at Field Farm. 11 Jan 2001 Chris Bucke had seen a Red Admiral at Bix Bottom and Great Tits. Michael Fletcher had had 3 House Sparrows in his garden. Ken Grinstead had seen a Song Thrush 2-3 weeks ago. Martin Sell reported almost an invasion of Blackbirds, Waxwings flying westwards and a pair of Foxes Tony Rayner had seen a bumble bee on Dec 23rd and Dec 29th. 8 Feb 2001 Maureen Baggelly complained that the Council had felled Cherry Plum trees at Woodley Aircraft Museum because of Tower Mustard. June Housden had seen a Muntjac Norman Shaw had seen Tree Creepers every day for a month Martin Sell reported 30 Corn Bunting, Yellowhammers on Downs at Churn; Merlin and Sparrowhawks at Twyford Alan Brickstock mentioned a pair of Smew at the Fox and Hounds pit. Tony Rayner had seen 6 Bewick Swans and 15 mute swans at Benson Brian Sargent mentioned a cock Pheasant and seven females Meryl Beek had had a Pheasant sitting in her back garden Ray Lush reported 50 Lapwing in field at Wokingham 22 Feb 2001 John Marshall saw 15 Pied Wagtails on his lawn Alan Brickstock found Coltsfoot flowering along the Kennet and Avon canal at Burghfield Bridge 8 March 2001 Martin Sell saw bumble bee, and has active Frogs in the garden Alice Ayers reported a pair of Frogs in amplexus (male clasping female) but that the female was unfortunately dead two days later. EXCURSIONS Mery! Beek In common with so many in the countryside, this has been a difficult year for the Society. In the early part of the year reserves and footpaths were closed due to Foot & Mouth restrictions. This resulted in nine meetings, including the annual coach outing, being cancelled. It was possible to reconvene two of the Wednesday walks in that period by changing the venues. Later in the summer, with paths re- opening, some very enjoyable times, with plenty of wildlife observations, have taken place. Most of the missed meetings will be included in next season's programme, giving the secretary an easier year - perhaps she deserves it! 2000 October 21st. Four members went on a general interest morning walk in the Hambleden valley area, beyond Henley. Trees were fruiting in abundance, including Whitebeam, Guelder Rose, Buckthorn, Spindle, Hornbeam and Crab Apple. Muntjac deer were seen, and the rutting of Fallow Deer was heard loudly in nearby woods. About 20 of these deer had been spotted earlier in the week in this area. As usual, Red Kites were seen and a nice group of Long-tailed Tits flew out of a wooded area as the party passed by. November 5th. Fungus foray in California Country Park. Alan Brickstock was not well enough to attend, but Gordon Crutchfield kindly led it. There was a good turnout of 16 people, and 78 species were found. A very interesting find was the uncommon Leptopodia atra. Other species of interest included Cortinarius pholideus, Panellus serotinus, Rhodotus palmatus, Auriscalpium vulgare, and Helvella crispa and lacunosa. December 9th. Ten members enjoyed an afternoon at the Vale & Downland Museum in Wantage. Among other things, this museum has an interactive auditorium presenting the history of the district, including the story of Wantage and the rural life of the surrounding countryside. David Attenborough’s voice was unmistakable in the 4 Aj. commentary! Rhodotus palmatus 2001 January 27th. 11 members went with Martin Sell to Pennington Marshes. It was nice to welcome Neville Diserens who joined the group for the day. A visit into the New Forest on the way home produced sightings of Lesser Spotted Woodpecker and a group of Hawfinches. February 24th. 17 people turned out at Moor Copse to hear Séan O'Leary tell us what can still be identified in the plant world during the winter months. Séan’s special interest is mosses and liverworts and he began with a brief introduction to the rather strange life cycle of these ‘bryophytes’. He then showed examples of ‘pleurocarpous' and ‘acrocarpous’mosses, and described the differences between mosses and liverworts. The exquisite beauty of these tiny plants, which is often ignored, was emphasised. Although no unusual species were identified in the field, Platygyrium repens, a rarity which is known from this site, was confirmed later. This was the last meeting before access to the countryside was stopped due to the Foot & Mouth outbreak. May 13th. Janet Welsh and the owner Andrew Hawkins led 11 members and a dog around Flowercroft Wood and Kent's Hill starting from Peppard church. These woodlands, which appear as thick hedges on a map of Harpsden parish dated 1586, were partly planted up with conifers in the 1960s but nevertheless retain a good woodland flora, if somewhat dispersed. Andrew explained that the management aim is to fell the conifers in stages to return the woodland to a deciduous cover. Additional coppicing and general clearance is carried out by the Green Gym from Sonning Common. Acid gravels overlie the chalk slopes to give a variety of soil types and tucked away in the south-eastern comer is a lovely, secluded west-facing hillside of species-rich chalk grassland. The woods, which have some large internal wood banks, support three scarce plants in Oxon: Green Hellebore, Narrow Buckler-fern and Scaly Male-fern. On the damp rides Wood Sorrel is locally abundant and also seen were Yellow 3 Pirnpernel, Creeping Jenny, Bog Stitchwort and Water Mint (the latter was a new record). Grass Snakes were uncovered from the reptile sheets. It was a bit early to appreciate the grassland in its full glory though the anthills had two typical spring-flowering species of open, well-drained soils: Early Forget-me- not and Common Cornsalad. There were a few Twayblades on the scrub edge and many spikes of last year’s Carline Thistle in the open turf. Later in the season, Wild Thyme, Yellow-wort, Common Milkwort, Pyramidal Orchid, Autumn Gentian and Common Dodder can be found. May 16th. Burghfield pits with Martin Sell. 13 people present. In the last UR hour of a rather overcast evening, the party listened to superb nightingale song, which sent everybody on their way very happy! June 9th. Alan Brickstock lead an excellent outing to Old Burghclere Pit, with 17 people and two dogs. White Helleborine, Twayblade, Common Spotted Orchid, Fly Orchid, Milkwort and Cowslip were all in profusion. It was interesting to see the effect of two fenced off areas on Fly Orchid and Cowslip. Inside the fence there was a dense mass of Cowslip seed-heads, whereas outside there were none to be seen — all eaten by rabbits. The Fly Orchids were also far superior inside the exclosures. The whole reserve had been very heavily cropped by rabbits, to the detriment of many species, but we still made nearly the ‘ton’, with 99 species recorded. Sadly, the Candytuft which used to grow here on the bare chalk areas seem to have died out — Alan has not seen them for the last couple of years. a Fly Orchid June 22nd. The Society made a return trip to the familiar stamping ground of the Warburg Reserve, led by Rod d'Ayala, for an evening walk and picnic meal. This was followed by an evening of moth trapping under the expert guidance of Martin Townsend and Geoff Martin. August Sth. The visit to Sliding Hill, south Oxfordshire, co-incided with a welcome sunny interlude after much rain and 15 people turned out for the Society’s first visit to this site. The Iron Age encampment, high on the chalk, has a rich flora cropped by rabbits and gardened by ants. Common Rockrose, Wild Thyme and Small Scabious are abundant. There are several colonies of Wild Candytuft and plenty of late-flowering blooms were found. Chalkhill Blue butterflies were numerous and a Silver-spotted Skipper was seen, the site’s notable rarity. August 18th. 9 people and one dog went on a walk in the Ashbury downland area. This was designed to link with the Vale & Downland museum visit last December. It was a wettish afternoon, which had attracted large numbers of snails in the hedgerows. The party could have done with a malacologist! Ashbury village was interesting with its chalk block and sarsen stone cottages and a church with a south facing Norman door. A fine Duke of Argyll’s Tea Tree.(Lycium barbarum) overhung a wall in the village, and Pellitory of the Wall (Parietaria judaica) was also admired. The unexpected piece de resistance was found at the end of the walk in a field under the chalk downland — a splendid solitary Woolly Thistle (Cirsium eriophorum) just coming out! September 1st. Malcolm Storey lead 17 people around Bucklebury Common in the sunshine. Several fungi were identified, together with Heath Rush and the three common species of Heather. Unfortunately the Heather had bloomed early this year and was almost over — at the beginning of September it is usually at its best. September 15th. Chris Bucke lead 7 people and a dog in lovely walking conditions from Ramsbury via the green lanes to Axford, returning through meadows beside the River Kennet and past Ramsbury Manor. Quantities of pathside Blackberries, Dewberries and Damsons were consumed. Belted galloway and highland cattle were admired. The stars of the walk were Swans: Black-necked, near Axford Farm and Black, on and near the lake at Ramsbury Manor. A gentle relaxing walk. September 30th. Alan Brickstock lead a Fungus foray at Wildmoor Heath. Despite a terrible forecast, a number of brave forayers had a dry morning, but a second group in the afternoon got very wet! There were nice Chanterelles and also Hydnum rufescens. Lactarius, Mycena and Russula were better represented here than at any other foray this season, leading to a respectable total of 76 species. Ken Thomas has led 5 Wednesday walks in the Checkendon, Compton, Rotherfield Greys, Padworth Common and Aborfield areas. A change has been to start the walks at 10.15 am, instead of in the afternoon, and pub snacks & drinks after the walk have been enjoyed. All leaders are thanked for the time and energy they have put into the excursions. Numbers participating have been better this year than for several recent seasons. There will be plenty of variety in the year ahead, so come and join in! Mery! Beek. In addition, 4 bird watching meetings have been led by Martin Sell. WEDNESDAY AFTERNOON WALKS Alan Brickstock The April walk had to be cancelled owing to Foot and Mouth restrictions, so the first one was at Checkendon In May, although this had to be slightly modified for the same reason, and this necessitated starting and finishing with some road walking. Nevertheless six people and three dogs much enjoyed a very good walk through some attractive woodlands, followed by lunch at the Four Horse-shoes. The church of John the Evangelist at Stoke Row has some beautiful windows by a local artist. One is supposed to contain a thimble, although we were unable to find it, but we did find a very nice Bat in one window, reflecting the artist's name — Bat! 67 species of spring flowers were found, but none of great note. | unfortunately missed the June walk — to my shame | forgot! The July walk was at Rotherfield Greys on a warm mainly overcast day, but with a few sunny spells. Eight people and three dogs had a superb walk followed by an excellent lunch. Exactly 100 species of plants this time; more interesting species included Round-leaved Cranesbill, Wall Rue, Orpine, Lesser Snapdragon, Fool's Parsley, Corn Marigold, Crow Garlic, and a fine array of Pyramidal Orchids. An excellent day! The August walk was at Ufton Nervet, with a good turnout of 11 plus three dogs enjoying a varied walk with lots to see, including 65 species of plants and nine species of fungi. The outstanding finds were a very nice group of the uncommon Boletus sanguineus, a strikingly blood-red species, and a plant which puzzled us for a while, but turned out to be Water Purslane. This is locally common in wet ground along paths etc., as it was here. Also of interest was the cultivation relict Phacelia tanacetifolia. The final Wednesday walk of the summer season was round Arborfield and the River Loddon in September. Six people and three dogs — the ‘hard core’! — on a cloudy and very windy day, with drizzle at times, followed by a very good lunch at Shinfield. 60 species of plants, including Purple Loosestrife, Trifid Bur-marigold, Yellow Balsam (Jewel Weed) and Flowering Rush. The chapel here was early 13th century, rebuilt in 1256, but with only ruins remaining. These have a fine Yew tree, possibly dating from the 13th century? JOTTINGS FROM A FAMILY’S ARCHIVES -| Cradle Naturalist — Caversham When my very young brother said “Dad has gone to the natural MYSTERY meeting” wasn't he wiser than he could have realised? This thought came to me while listening to Rod d’Ayala’s presidential address in October, “Why some plants are rare”. Rod gave the example of Military Orchids growing happily in Homefield Wood in the Chilterns, and after that they are found growing in a nature reserve in Suffolk, while Monkey Orchids grow only at Hartslock and in Kent. It’s a mystery why these orchids are not found in other suitable growing places. The talk in November by Dr. Richard Fortey on Evolution showed many biological mechanisms proved by scientific experiment and observation. But what of the rest of creation? Still plenty of mystery here! Taxonomy, understanding of ecosystems & life cycles all have their place, but |, for one, am glad that there is a lot else out there for us all to wonder at. MEETINGS (2000-2001) Catherine Butcher Fifty members attended the first lecture of the season which was held on 26th October 2000. This was given by Mr.Nick Bowles and entitled “Butterflies of the Chiltern Escarpment’. Unfortunately, he forgot to bring his slides, for which he offered profuse apologies. However his lecture was so interesting, giving us a fascinating insight into the life cycle of butterflies and moths, that this was soon forgotten. We learned that butterflies were mainly territorial, living in fragmented pockets of habitat. Four species hibernated during the winter months, the Peacock butterfly being the longest living butterfly in this country. He mentioned rare species, Chalkhill Blue, Adonis Blue, Silver Spotted Skipper and migrants from the Continent. We were told that the Monarch butterfly could fly for seventy two hours, without landing, provided it was warm enough. Many hundreds of them are blown over from America. They only live for 4 — 5 days and then perish, exhausted from flying across the Atlantic. On 9th November we were once again pleased to welcome Mr. Victor Scott who had visited the Society on two previous occasions. Forty members and friends attended this excellent lecture with slides of five different areas of Southern Ireland, where he and his wife have enjoyed several holidays. Southern Ireland has a mild climate with plentiful rain. The central area is agricultural, the least forested and contains acid peat bogs. Geologically, the west coast, including the Burren in County Clare, is limestone. The botany of Ireland holds many mysteries, as the country supports many plants which have their origins in other parts of the world, including the Americas and Mediterranean lands. There is uncertainty as to whether some plants have been introduced by man or have re-appeared from distant pre-ice age times before the division of the present continents. The first, area visited was in Connemara National Park, near the group of mountains known as the Twelve Pins, which rise to around 3,000 ft. Here grow quite naturally well away from any human habitations, some very unexpected plants, including New Zealand Flax, Red-hot Pokers and Pyrennean Hebes. Two forms of heather, St. Dabeoc’s Heath (Daboecia cantabrica) and Mackay's Heath (Erica mackaiana) grow. On the acid shales and conglomerates in the mountains of Kerry are found the Large- flowered Butterwort (Pinguicula grandiflora), \rish Spurge (Euphorbia hyberna) and the endemic St. Patrick's cabbage (Saxifraga spathularis). The central area is the marshy catchment of the upper Shannon river. The pitcher plant (Sarracenia purpurea) originating from North America makes its home here. On the coast line there are many creatures and plants, including large colonies of jelly fish, seaweeds and sea anemones. The best loved area is the Burren, an area of limestone pavement supporting a very large number of alkaline-loving plants including Baneberry (Actaea spicata), Hoary Rock-rose (Helianthemum canum) and Burnet Rose (Rosa pimpinellifolia) in several colours. Southern Ireland is a wonderful country for the botanist especially, and is the only place in the world where plants originating in Iceland, the Arctic, the Alps and Pyrennees, all merge naturally. Another popular lecturer, Mr.Mike Read, spoke on “The Arctic Riviera” to 44 members. He had been working as assistant photographer to Hugh Miles of the BBC in the making of “The Kingdom of the Ice Bear’. He had stayed in Greenland for seven weeks from June to July. Starting from Reykjavik he showed slides of Eider Duck, Arctic Terns and Glaucous Gulls, which were in abundance. He then travelled to the Orsted Valley where he showed wonderful slides of glaciers and huge ice caps. After teaming up with four others, Mike and his team flew over huge snow fields and set up camp filming Musk Ox, Arctic Hare and Turnstones. The views over the Valley were stupendous where there was much vegetation. Mountain Avens and Arctic Poppies were widespread. Suddenly there was a severe change in the weather and filming came to a standstill. Mr. Read returned home after seven weeks of peace and solitude. He left with mixed emotions. His last memory was of sitting spellbound by the