UUnniivveerrssiittyy ooff SSoouutthh FFlloorriiddaa DDiiggiittaall CCoommmmoonnss @@ UUnniivveerrssiittyy ooff SSoouutthh FFlloorriiddaa USF Tampa Graduate Theses and Dissertations USF Graduate Theses and Dissertations 11-3-2004 PPrreehhiissttoorriicc SShheellll AArrttiiffaaccttss ffrroomm tthhee AAppaallaacchhiiccoollaa RRiivveerr VVaalllleeyy AArreeaa,, NNoorrtthhwweesstt FFlloorriiddaa Eric Eyles University of South Florida Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the American Studies Commons SScchhoollaarr CCoommmmoonnss CCiittaattiioonn Eyles, Eric, "Prehistoric Shell Artifacts from the Apalachicola River Valley Area, Northwest Florida" (2004). USF Tampa Graduate Theses and Dissertations. https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/etd/1026 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the USF Graduate Theses and Dissertations at Digital Commons @ University of South Florida. It has been accepted for inclusion in USF Tampa Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ University of South Florida. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Prehistoric Shell Artifacts from the Apalachicola River Valley Area, Northwest Florida by Eric Eyles A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement of the degree of Master of Arts Department of Anthropology College of Arts and Sciences University of South Florida Major Professor: Nancy Marie White, Ph.D. Brent R. Weisman, Ph.D. Trevor Purcell, Ph.D. Date of Approval: November 3, 2004 Keywords: Shell artifacts, Prehistoric archaeology, Cultural Resources, Northwest Florida, Apalachicola River Valley ©Copyright 2004, Rev. Eric Christopher Eyles Dedication Three things stand out in my life above all others as pinnacles of pride and accomplishment: completing this thesis comes in a distant third. First and foremost rates my marriage. Without my wife, Cary Hopkins Eyles, I would never have taken on graduate school in the first place, and I would no doubt be wandering aimlessly through life. Her love, encouragement, and calls back to reality have grounded my experiences within a sane and joyful dance, and she fills my days with shining laughter. I would also like to dedicate this work to both my sister-in-law, Meli Mossey, and her husband Mike Mossey. Without their help and support, my second-best accomplishment could not have taken place: my removal, service, and re-installation of the engine from my Volkswagen. They two are always there for me, and I could ask for no better friends. No dedication would ring true without speaking of my parents, Andrea and Walter Eyles. It was their guidance and direction that ultimately made all of this possible--from giving me eyes to see the beauty of my wife, to the confidence to work on my car, to the Scotch- Irish stubbornness to see a thesis to its end. Thanks Mom and Dad. Acknowledgments No thesis is the product of one person. Rather, a whole host of people come together to guide, influence, and encourage the student. To all my family and friends, I say thank-you. To Dr. White, my mentor, I cannot imagine having gotten through this with anyone else. Thank-you Dr. Purcell and Dr. Weisman for making me stretch just a little bit more. Thank-you to Jennifer and Mark Foley--I know I would have starved to death if you hadn't fed me--both with food and spiritual support. Thanks to my brother, Matt Eyles, for being such a rock. Thanks to my sisters, Jennifer Dietz and Heather Perrin--you have always been there for me. To all the Foleys, Trasks, Hopkins, Enrights, and Eyles, the aunts, uncles, cousins, nieces, nephews, and to all those who have gone before me--I feel the deepest gratitude. To Nelson Rodriguez, my best friend; Rae Harper, April Buffington, Robert Whalen, Cory McNeil Bennett, Karen Mayo, Jon and Cea Catuccio, you are my friends, and have seen me through this. I would also like to say a special thanks to the following for keeping me from losing my mind: The Dave Matthews Band, They Might Be Giants, Donna the Buffalo, Peter Murphy, and Tampa's own WMNF 88.5. Table of Contents List of Tables iii List of Figures v Abstract xi Chapter One: Introduction The Project and Goals of the Research 1 Chapter Two: Geographic and Environmental Setting 13 Shell Artifact Raw Materials 19 Chapter Three: Prehistoric Cultural Background 24 Paleo-Indian Period 24 Archaic Period 26 Woodland Period 27 Mississippian Period 31 Lamar/ Protohistoric Period 32 Chapter Four: Shell Tool Categories, Distributions, and Previous Studies 36 Chapter Five: Methods 53 Raw Materials and Research Biases 65 Economics of Shellfishing 71 Establishing Types 74 Chapter Six: Laboratory Research 77 Apalachicola Shell Tool Types 80 Specifics 86 Hammer 86 Cutting-edge Tool 93 Grinder/ Pulverizer 104 Tool Blank 104 Shell Handle 108 Bi-pointed Columellae 110 Columella Tool 111 Adze 118 Cup or Dipping Vessel 121 Dish 125 Scoop/ spoon 126 Scraper/ spatula 133 Awl 136 Plane 137 Bead 137 Perforated Shell 143 Probable Tool 149 Indeterminate 161 Worked Shell 165 Debitage 172 Spire-Apex 173 Fragments 173 Chapter Seven: Summary and Conclusions 188 References 194 Appendix One Correspondence Regarding Cliona Sponges 204 ii List of Tables Table 1 Summary of Archaeological Sites Producing Shell Artifacts in the Apalachicola River Valley 6 Table 2 Shellfish Species Represented in the USF Apalachicola Collection Utilized as Prehistoric Artifacts 20 Table 3 Comparison of Artifact Types Listed in Marquardt 1992 and the USF Apalachicola Collection 50 Table 4 Tool Categories, with Maximum, Minimum, Average, and Modal Lengths, in centimeters 82 Table 5 Gastropod Hammer tools from the USF Apalachicola Collection 86 Table 6 Gastropod Cutting Tools in the USF Apalachicola Collection 98 Table 7 Distribution of Bipointed Columella Shell Tools 110 Table 8 Distribution of Columella Tools 114 Table 9 Distribution of Adze Shell Tools 118 Table 10 Distribution of Shell Dishes 125 Table 11 Distribution of Shell Scoop/ Spoons 126 Table 12 Distribution of Shell Spatulas 133 Table 13 Distribution of Perforated Shell 145 Table 14 Distribution of Indeterminate Shell Tools 161 Table 15 Distribution of Worked Shell 168 iii Table 16 Distribution of Shell Debitage 176 Table 17 Distribution of Gastropod Apices 178 Table 18 Distribution of Shell Fragments 180 iv List of Figures Figure 1 State of Florida with Research Area Identified 2 Figure 2 Apalachicola River Area with Shell Artifact Sites Identified 3 Figure 3 Apalachicola River Area with Sites Included in the USF Apalachicola Collection Identified 4 Figure 4 The Six Counties Included in this Study 14 Figure 5 Shell Hammer from Sam's Cutoff Shell Mound 28 Figure 6 Generic lightning whelk shell redrawn from Luer 1986a 37 Figure 7 Lightning whelk and horse conch shells 38 Figure 8 Lightning whelk shell cup from the Corbin Tucker site 40 Figure 9 Carved Shell Gorget from Jackson County 43 Figure 10 Example of Two Shell Hammers (redrawn from C.B. Moore 1921) 44 Figure 11 Example of Two Hafted Shell Hammers (redrawn from C.B. Moore 1921) 45 Figure 12 Shell Hammer as depicted in C.B. Moore 47 Figure 13 Ecofact showing bag wear 59 Figure 14 Ecofact showing bag wear 60 v Figure 15 2 Modern plastic "Pan" scraper-spatulas 63 Figure 16 Categorization Tree for Shell Classification 79 Figure 17 Shell Adzes, demonstrating Cliona damage 81 Figure 18 Gastropod Shell Handles 84 Figure 19 Distribution of Sites Producing Shell Hammers 87 Figure 20 Shell Hammer from Lighthouse Bayou site 88 Figure 21 Shell Hammer from Lighthouse Bayou site 90 Figure 22 Shell Hammer from Van Horn Creek Shell Mound 91 Figure 23 Shell Hammers from Richardson's Hammock 92 Figure 24 Shell Hammer in the Process of Reduction 94 Figure 25 Shell Hammers from Lighthouse Bayou site 95 Figure 26 Shell Hammers from Lighthouse Bayou site 96 Figure 27 Shell Hammer from Cape St. George West site 97 Figure 28 Distribution of Sites Producing Gastropod Cutting Tools 98 Figure 29 Cutting-edge tools from Lighthouse Bayou site 100 Figure 30 Shell Cutting-edge tools from Richardson's Hammock 101 Figure 31 Cutting-edge tool from Gotier Hammock 102 Figure 32 Cutting-edge tools from Thank-You-Ma'am Creek and Depot Creek shell middens 103 Figure 33 Gastropod shell grinder from Black's Island 105 vi