Bull. not. Hist. Mus. Land. (Bot.)24(1): 1-34 Issued23June 1994 Pre-Linnaean references for the Macaronesian flora found in Leonard Plukenet's works and collections THE NATURAL tiCTOR JAVIER FRANCISCO-ORTEGA* 12 JUL tta-r DepartmentofBotany, The University ofTexas, Austin, Texas 78713-7640, USA PRESENTED GENERAL LIBRARY ARNOLDO SANTOS-GUERRA Jardin deAclimatacion de La Orotava, CalleRetama Num. 2, E-38400 Puertodela Cruz, Tenerife, Canary Islands, Spain CHARLES E. JARVIS DepartmentofBotany, The NaturalHistory Museum, CromwellRoad, London SW75BD CONTENTS Introduction 1 TaxafoundinPlukenet'sworks 3 Taxafoundin Plukenet'sherbariumbutnotinhisworks 29 Discussion 30 References 31 Systematicindex 33 Bibliographyabbreviationsfoundin Plukenet'sworks 33 SYNOPSIS. A review ofearly references to the flora ofthe Macaronesian region has been carried out through the study of Plukenet's publications and his herbarium collection, now part ofthe Sloane Herbarium in The Natural HistoryMuseuminLondon. Atotalof97descriptionsand54drawingsofMacaronesianplantshasbeenlocatedin the four published works of this English herbalist that appeared between 1691 and 1705. 131 specimens from Macaronesiarepresenting87taxahavebeenfoundinhiscollection;33ofthemdonothaveobviousdescriptionsin hispublishedworksandfivedescriptions,supposedlyofCanarianplants,seemtohavebeenincorrectlyassignedto this region. Phrase-names described by earlier authors that were cited as synonyms by Plukenet have also been studiedbutfewofthemprovedtobeclearlyrelated toMacaronesiantaxa. ThisstudyrevealsthatPlukenet'swork providesthesinglemostimportantpre-LinnaeanaccountoftheMacaronesianflora,andhisherbariumcontainsone ofthe oldest known collectionsofherbarium specimens from this region. The name Campanulacanariensis L. (= Canarinacanariensis(L.) Vatke)islectotypified. INTRODUCTION (Pliny, 1826a; for reviews of Pliny's work and the eastern Atlantic islands see Steffen (1944), Alvarez-Delgado (1945) and Martinez-Hernandez (1992)). The Macaronesian region comprises the archipelagos of the The first European visitors who described the region Canary Islands, Salvages, Azores, Madeira and Cape Verde noticed the peculiarities of its flora in accounts that dated farnodmhsaosutshtreornngMloirnkosccwoitthotChaepneorVtehrwdees.teIrtns fplaorrtascoofntAafirniscaa fRreocmcothienf1o3u4r1te(eBnotnhnteot,si1x9t4e3e)n;thBcoennttiuerrie&s (Lee.g.VeNrinciceorloisnotdhae highnumberofendemics and hasbeentraditionallyregarded early fifteenth century (Cioranescu, 1980); Gomez de Cintra as a relic of the flora which existed in the Mediterranean in the mid fifteenth century (Bonnet, 1940); P. Gomez basin during theTertiary age (Sunding, 1979). Escudero also in the mid fifteenth century (Morales-Padron, The earliest known reference to Macaronesian natural 1978); A. de Palencia in the late fifteenth century (Lopez de history was given in the first century AD by Pliny 'the elder' Toro, 1970), Fernandesin 1507 (Santiago, 1947); Diaz-Tanco who mentioned the abundance of palm and pine trees in in 1520 (Rodrfguez-Monino, 1934; Del Rio-Ayala, 1935); 'Canada' and how, in what seems to be the island of El Nicols (1583); Frutuoso (Serra-Rafolset al., 1964) andTorri- Hierro, there were 'Ferulae' trees which precipitated water ani in 1590 (Torriani, 1978) and Espinosa (1594)). Some of these descriptionswere based on the original names given by *Correspondingauthor TheNaturalHistoryMuseum, 1994 J. FRANCISCO-ORTEGA, A. SANTOS-GUERRA AND C.E. JARVIS thepre-Hispanicinhabitantsoftheseislands. Asearlyas 1341 an original drawing of one of its branches, which facilitated Niccoloso da Recco found that the bark of some Canarian the botanical identification of this species as Ocoteafoetens trees could be used to produce red dyes. Similar accounts (Maynar, 1943). Similarly, in 1576 Clusius gave a detailed were also reported in the early fifteenth century as extensive description and drawing of Dracaena draco based on a tree areasofscrubof'higuieres' (EuphorbiabalsamiferaAiton) in which he found growing in Lisbon in the garden of the Lanzarote and of 'tarajal' (Tamarix canariensis Willd.) in monastery of'S. Maria a Gratia' (Arber, 1938). Fuerteventurawere found by Bontierand Le Vernierrespec- Besides these references, it is also known that soon after tively (Cioranescu, 1980). the conquest of the islands some species were used as wood Nevertheless, theearliestpublishedandmostcompletelistof for building and firewood for sugar mills (Parsons, 1981). endemics of the Macaronesian region, appears to have been Plants were also exploited for products such as dyes (from providedbyDiazTancoin1520.ThisSpanishtravellervisitedthe Parmeliaperlata (Huds.) Ach., Roccellaspp., Laurusazorica Canary Islands between 1505 and 1520 (Rodriguez-Monino, (Seub.) Franco), soda(fromZygophyllumfontanesiiWebb& 1934)andpublishedalistofatleast12Canarianendemics,using Berth., Mesembryanthemum crystallinum L.), perfumes theoriginalpre-Hispanicnamessuchas'bales'(Plocamapendula (from Convolvulus scoparius L. f.), medicines (from Dra- Aiton), 'thabbaybas', actually 'tabaibas' (Euphorbia spp.) and caena draco} and pitch (from Pinus canariensis) (Schenck, 'tabinaste', actually 'tajinaste' (Echium spp.) (Del Rio-Ayala, 1907; Viera y Clavijo, 1808; 1866-1869; Lobo-Cabrera, A 1935). Analogousdescriptionsweregivenbythe Englishtrader 1988). strong trade based on these products was estab- T. NicolswhomentionedthelocalSpanishnamesof'taybayba', lished between the Canaries and the most important Euro- 'barbusano'(Apolloniasbarbujana(Cav.)Bornm. and'vinatico' pean ports during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries (Perseaindica(L.)Spreng.),forthelatternotingthatitwasatree (Gonzalez-Yanes, 1953; Fernandez-Armesto, 1982; Lobo- 'exceedingheavie, andwillnotrotinaniewater' (Nicols, 1583). Cabrera, 1988) and many references to the granting of However,themostcomprehensiveaccountoftheMacaronesian permission for their exploitation are given in official resolu- florafromthesixteenthcenturywasgivenbyG.Frutuosoin1590 tionsfrom the island council or 'cabildo' (Serra-Rafols, 1949; (Serra-Rafolsetal., 1964).ThisPortuguesenaturalistapparently Serra-Rafols & De la Rosa, 1952, 1965, 1970). Mention of visited the Canary Islands late in the sixteenth century and not Canarianendemicscan alsobefoundinthosedocumentsthat onlylistedmanyoftheirendemicsbutalsobrieflydescribedthe were issued to establish the division of the land after the vegetationofsomeoftheislands. conquest (Serra-Rafols, 1978; Moreno-Fuentes, 1988). These Most of these works provided descriptions of the Canary documents are known as 'datas' and in them names of pine (Pinus canariensis C. Sm.) and the Lauraceae forests Canarian plants are usually given, as the plants were often and put special emphasis upon the orchil lichen (Rocella used to indicate boundaries between different areas. spp.), the Canary palm (Phoenix canariensis Chab.), the Thesefewexamplesaredrawnfromonlyasmall numberof dragon-tree (Dracaena draco L.) and the rain-tree or 'garoe' pre-Linnaean references on Macaronesian endemic plants. (Ocotea foetens (Aiton) Baill.) of El Hierro. In addition, Further research is needed in order to provide a clearer these references gave unique records concerning the use of pictureofthestateofknowledgeofearlyexplorers, herbalists plants by the pre-Hispanic inhabitants ofthe islands (Garcia- and naturalists ofthe flora ofthis region. Morales, 1989)which have been confirmedthrough thestudy Leonard Plukenet was one of the most outstanding bota- of archaeological remains. There is clear archaeological evi- nists ofthe seventeenth century. With its approximately2000 dence of the pre-Hispanic use of Scirpus holoschoenus L. plant drawings, his Phytographia (Phyt.) was one ofthe most (syn. Holoschoenus vulgarisLink) and Phoenixcanariensisas important pre-Linnaean works containing illustrations of textile species (Galvan-Santos, 1980; Rodriguez-Santana, plants. This work was issued in four volumes between 1691 1989), croppingofbarley, wheat, lentil, broadbean andgrass and 1694 (Plukenet, 1691o, 16916, 1693, 1694) and he also pea (Del Arco-Aguilar et al., 1991; Martin-Rodriguez, 1992) had an extensive herbarium with approximately 8000 speci- and the gathering of Pinus canariensis seeds, Pteridium mens (Pulteney, 1790) which was the basis for many of his aquilinum (L.) Kuhn rhizomes (Mathiensen, 1960) and Vis- drawings (Dandy, 1958). This large collection was the result neamocaneraL. f. fruits (Del Arco-Aguilaretal., 1991). The of his enthusiastic acquisition of specimens, particularly of latter was quoted by early chroniclers as having its fruits those exoticplantsthen grown in the most importantgardens eaten raworused to make a kind of'honey' or 'wine' known of Britain. He was also in close contact with most of the as 'cuche' or 'chacerquen' (P. Gomez Escudero in Morales- British herbalists of the time such as Doody, Cuningham, Padron, 1978; Espinosa, 1594). Ray, Sloane and Petiver and was in correspondence with Furthermore these early Canarians were able to make other botanists from abroad (Pulteney, 1790). Most of his weapons and tools using wood of Apollonias barbujana collection is now at The Natural History Museum in London (Cav.) Bornm., Juniperus phoenicea L., Neochamaelea pul- (BM) where it comprises Volumes 84-105 of the Sloane verulenta (Vent.) Erdtman, Olea europaea L. ssp. cerasifor- Herbarium. There are also two unnumbered volumes con- mis (Webb & Berth.) G. Kunkel & Sunding and Pinus taining his specimens which are titled 'Herbarium Vivum canariensis (Diego-Cuscoy, 1961). Plukenetianum' (HVP) and Thesaurus Botanicus'. Between Although a definitive study ofthe European knowledge of 1696 and 1705, Plukenet produced three other works the Macaronesian flora between the fourteenth and eigh- (Plukenet, 1696, 1700, 1705) inwhich he gave descriptions of teenth centuries has not yet been undertaken, there are theplatesillustratedin his Phytographia and also listed many reports which suggest that some of the endemic taxa were more plant species for which drawings were not published. well-known by naturalists during this pre-Linnaean period. These works are Almagestum botanicum (Aim.), Almagesti An example can be found in the Historiageneraly naturalde botanici mantissa (Mant.) and Amaltheum botanicum las Indias by Fernandez de Oviedo (1548). This renowned (Amalth.) in which the taxa are enumerated alphabetically naturalist gave an extensive description of the 'rain-tree' on under their polynomial names. Additional illustrations were the island of El Hierro. Later, in 1590, Torriani reproduced included in the last two of these works, and so about 2740 PRE-LINNAEAN REFERENCES FOR MACARONESIAN FLORA figurescan be foundin Plukenet'sworks as awhole. It seems encouragefurtherresearchconcerningearlyreferencestothe that onlythose plants regarded as exoticwere included in the flora of the Macaronesian region and will contribute to the Phytographia, and the other three publications contain the understanding of how the natural history of this area was rest ofhiscollection (Pulteney, 1790). perceived by European naturalists of the seventeenth cen- The work of Plukenet was greatly admired by Linnaeus tury. who considered his Phytographia to be one of the most List of abbreviations. BL = British Library, BM = The extraordinary pieces of botanical illustration then published Natural History Museum, London (formerly the British (Linnaeus, 1736, 1751). Linnaeus himselffrequently referred Museum (Natural History)), HS = Sloane Herbarium, HVP to Plukenet's polynomials in describing and naming many of = Herbarium Vivum Plukenetianum. The following abbre- hisown species. viations refer to the most frequently used references in this In thispaperwewill review the publicationsofthis English study: Aim.: = Plukenet (1696), Amalth.: = Plukenet herbalist in relation to the Macaronesian flora. The aim of (1705), Linn. = Linnaeus (1753), Gis. - Giseke (1779), this study has been to assess what knowledge of the flora of Mant. - Plukenet (1700), Phyt. - Plukenet (1691a, 1691ft, the region was available to the European herbalists in the 1693, 1694),Ten. = Tenzel (1820), W.B. - Webb & Berthe- seventeenth century. lot (1836-1850). Manuscripts from Plukenet's collection which are held in the Sloane Collection at the Department of Manuscripts in the British Library (BL) have also been studied (see Scott (1904) for the location of Plukenet's manuscripts in the TAXA FOUND IN PLUKENET'S WORKS Sloane Collection). For most of the species listed in his works, Plukenet referred to plant names given by previous herbalists. How- A total of 97 descriptions of Macaronesian plants has been everreferencesto these authorsweregiven in an abbreviated found in Plukenet's works, and each is listed below. In this form and akeyforthemwaspresentedinthefinalpartofthe listeach descriptionisgiven an entry numberfollowed bythe Almagestum. In orderto locate possible previous accounts of polynomial name used by Plukenetin bold. Text notrelevant the Macaronesian taxa, earliernames cited by Plukenet have totheactualdescriptionhasbeenomitted, andisindicatedby also been studied. Nevertheless some of the abbreviated '[. . .]'. Reference to Plukenet's published accounts and references were not listed in Plukenet's key and we have illustrations is given after the phrase-name including the therefore attempted to trace them through the reviews of appropriate page or plate number (abbreviated as 't.'), the botanical literature carried out by Linnaeus (1736), Pritzel latter being followed by the figure number (abbreviated as (1872), Jackson (1881) and Heller (1959) and through the 'f.'). PlatesfromAlmagestibotanldmantissaandAmaltheum resources of the British Library and the Libraries of the botanicum are abbreviated usingthe code 't.' Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew and The Natural History Information compiled for each entry is treated under five Museum. A list clarifying the abbreviations encountered in headings: those ofPlukenet's descriptions that are covered in ourstudy (1) Earlier names and references mentioned by Plukenet appearsatthe endofthispaper. Itis hoped thatthiswill help (coded as Syn.:). Names are given in italics followed by the other researchers to trace some of the early references reference author in parenthesis. Untraced names and refer- mentioned in Plukenet'sworks. ences are cited as they are found in Plukenet's text followed The possible influence of Plukenet's works on subsequent by '[?]'. studies ofthe Macaronesian flora was analysed by reviewing (2) Citation of Plukenet's descriptions in works by subse- the utilization of Plukenet's names by Linnaeus (Richter, quent authors dealing with the Macaronesian flora (coded as 1835-1840) and Webb & Berthelot (1836-1850). Further His.:). The binomial name withwhich Plukenet's polynomial research in this area was undertaken through the study of has been identified by Linnaeus (1753), Giseke (1779), those identifications of Plukenet's drawings provided by Tenzel (1820) and Webb & Berthelot (1836-1850) (coded as Giseke (1779) and Tenzel (1820) and ofLinnaeus' annotated Linn., Gis., Ten. and W.B. respectively) is given in square copies of Plukenet's works held at the Linnean Society of brackets. London. (3) Taxonomic determinations of Plukenet's polynomials Taxonomic determination ofphrase-names or polynomials (coded as Del.:). Labelled specimens used in establishing given by Plukenet was undertaken after study of his her- these determinations (made by us) and their location in HS barium collection at the Department of Botany (BM). This are given in square brackets. Additional information is given was facilitated by the fact that many of the specimens were in square brackets. Nomenclature and taxonomy follows labelled by Plukenet with references to the plate and figure Hansen & Sunding (1993); endemic taxa are marked with an numbers ofhis works. Plukenet's handwriting was compared asterisk. Illegible handwriting is indicated as [illeg.]. Deter- with that found in Dandy (1958) and in his correspondence minationswhich areonlybasedon Plukenet'sdescription and fromthe Sloane Collectionatthe DepartmentofManuscripts not on drawings or specimens from his collection are indi- inthe BL. Forthose labelswhich apparentlywerenotwritten catedwith '[?]'. by Plukenet, specimens were checked with the original illus- (4) Other herbarium specimens (coded as Oth.:). Under this trations foundin hisworks. Labelled specimenswhich do not heading we list those specimens ofMacaronesian taxa found seem to be similar to their respective illustrations are also in Plukenet's collection which are not labelled with a corre- reportedin thisstudy. There arealsosomecollectionsthatdo spondingpolynomial orareference to Plukenet'sworks. not have an obvious description or illustration in Plukenet's (5) Comments (coded as Com.:). Under this heading we published work and there are also Macaronesian specimens provide supplementary information including Spanish com- which have no label. mon names reported by Plukenet, origin of material and It is hoped that the results presented here will help to other relevant details found in the original description or in J. FRANCISCO-ORTEGA,A. SANTOS-GUERRAANDC.E. JARVIS Plukenet's herbarium. This study ofSpanish common names 8. Apocynum arboreum ad Elaeagni faciem accedens givenbyPlukenethasdrawnonthestudiesofVierayClavijo Canariense, siliquis binis Nerii aemulis, (Cornicar (1866-1869), Ceballos & Ortuno (1951), Kunkel (1971) and Iitsukmis vulgo) apidbus recurvis Aim.: 35 (1696), Santos-Guerra (1983). Phyt.:t. 260,13(1694). 1. Acetosa arborescens, subrotundo folio; ex Insulis Syn.: Nelem-pala (Rheede tot Draakenstein, 1689). Fortunatis Aim.: 8 (1696), Mant.: 3 (1700), Phyt.: t. DOetth..::PHeSr9i5pl:o5c5a.laevigata Aiton [HS 99: 83]. 252, f. 3 (1694). Com.: Plukenet reported the common name 'Cornicar'; Syn.: Lunaria magorumArabum Ital. Lunaria diMagiArabi plants ofthis species are known as 'comical' in the Canaries. (Lobelius, 1576), Lunaria magorum Arabum (Lobelius, This species was described twice by Plukenet (see entry 10), 1581), Lunaria Oxalidisrotundaefolio(Bauhin, 1596), Oxalis thisdescription beingbased on adult plants. rotundi folia frequentissima: a Rovillio picta, sed non descripta: sorte Lunaria Magorum Arabum (Pona, 1601), Lunaria magorum Arabum quid? (Bauhin, 1623), Lunaria 9. Apocynum scandens, angustis Rosmarinae foliis, e magorumArabum (Bauhin & Cherler, 1651). Maderaspatan. Nannary-chedde Malabarorum. Huic His.: Rumex lunariaL. [Linn.; Gis.; Ten.; W.B.]. multum convenit Illucl, quod ex Insulis Canarinis, olim Det.: * Rumexlunaria L. [HS 93: 9, 95: 12]. nobis transmittebatur, & in Almagesto nostro Oth.:HS99: 14, HVP: 4. memoratur Amalth.: 19, t. 361, f. 1 (1705). 2. Adianthum album Canariense, ramosius Aim.: 11 10. Apocynum scandens angusto Rorismarini folio, ex (1696). Insulis Fortunatis [. . .] Henio Hispanis vulgo Aim.: 37 (1696), Mant.: 17 (1700), Phyt.: t. 261, f. 2 (1694). 3. Alsine spuria repens ex Insulis Fortunatis folio Hederae terrestris, molli, & incano Aim.: 24 (1696), Syn.: Naru-nindi (Rheede tot Draakenstein, 1690), Apo- cynum Hispanicum frutescens Linariae folio (Tournefort, Phyt.: 1.256(1694). 1694), Apocynumfruticosum scandens, Genistae, Hispanicae Com.: None ofthe drawings published by Plukenet in Phyt.: facie,floribusluteisodoratis (Sloane, 1696). Accordingtothe t. 256 appears to correspond with the description in the description (Mant.: 17) the name Apocynum (forte) caule Almagestumandwebelievethatthecitingofthisplatewasan tenui alte scandens capsulis echinatis was used by Banister error. (1693). However, we have been unable to find this name in thiswork. Det.: Periploca laevigata Aiton [HS 99: 85]. 4. Amaranthus Siculus spicatus, radice perenni [. . .] Com.: The Spanish common name 'Henio' is mentioned by ex Insula Maderensi Aim.: 26 (1696), Phyt.: t. 260, f. 2 Plukenet. However, plants of this species are known as (1694). 'comical' in the Canary Islands. The species was described twice by Plukenet (see entry no. 8), this second entry being Syn.: Amaranthus Siculus spicatus, radiceperenni (Boccone, based on young plants which are morphologically rather 1674). differentfrom adultindividuals. His.: Achyranthes aspera L. [Linn.; Gis.; W.B.], A. argentea Lam. [Ten.]. Det.: Achyranthesaspera L. [HS95: 41; 99: 61]. 11. Aquifolium laeve non spinosum, angustiore folio Oth.:HS97:78. Lauri; ex Insula Palma Amalth.: 19 (1705). 5. AnagalIidis facie Frutex Canariensis Aim.: 29 CDeotm..::* DIleetxecramnianraiteinsoins Pboaisre.d[?o].n the description and on a (1696). specimen found in HS 189: 12 in J. Cuningham's collection from La Palma, made on the island in the late seventeenth 6. Anonis viscosa lutea, non spinosa, minor. Ex Insula century. Pico Amalth.: 15(1705). Syn.: Anonis viscosa lutea non spinosa minor Lusitanica 12. Aquifolium amplissimis foliis Minus corrugatum ex (Hermann, 1698). Insulis Fortunatis Aim.: 38 (1696), Mant.: 18 (1700), Phyt.: t. 262, f. 1(1694). 7. Anonis viscosa lutea milis capreolata erecta foliis His.: Ilexplatyphylla Webb & Berth. [W.B.]. splendentibus glabris [. . .] ex Insulis Fortunatis ad nos Det.: * Ilexperado Aiton ssp. platyphylla (Webb & Berth.) allataestMant.: 15(1700). Tutin[HS95: 60]. Syn.: Plukenet gave the following synonym: Anonis (sorte) annua lutea, siliqua glabra breviori (Morison, 1680). How- ever, the name found in Morison's work is 'Anonis lutea annuarectahirsuta viscosasiliquishirsutisbrevioribus, nobis\ PRE-LINNAEAN REFERENCES FORMACARONESIAN FLORA 13. Arbor Americana amplioribus subrotundis duris & 15. Arbuscula baccifera Canariensis, Syringae nervosis foliis, fructu pugni majoris magnitudine. caeruleae foliis, purpurantibus venis, fructu Insulis Fortunatis & Jamaicensibus nostratibus Mamee monopyreno. Yerva-mora Hispanorum [. . .] nuncupatur [. . .] Mommina, s. Mamee arbore [. . .] Yerva-Mora ab Hispanis quoque dicitur Solanum Hujus autem fructus ut Mala-granata sunt putamine baccis rubris & aureis; Ipsum tamen Solani ethymon corticoso. Mammee Canarinae folijs, & facie, Arbor ex ob quandam in quibusd partibus similitudinem longe Insula Johanna Aim.: 39 (1696), Mant.: 125 (1700), pluribus iisque diversissimis stirpium generibus ab Phyt.: t. 268, f. 1 (1694), Phyt.: t. 204, f. 2 (1694). eodem Populo imponi consuevit: Affinitas ergo formae & coloris baccarum eo sorsan Hispanos Canariense Syn.: Mamey (Nieremberg, 1635), Anda Brasiliensibus induxit, ut hujus Arbusculam Yerva Mora (i.e.) Solani (Marggraf&, 1648), Arbor vinifera Couton Juglandi similis titulo insigniverint Aim.: 42 (1696), Mant.: 21 (1700). (Bauhin Cherler, 1650). sDpeetc.i:esMaismfmoeuandaminerHicSan9a6:L.17[0a.hIetrbhaarsiaumlasbpeelciwmheinchfosrtattheiss cSaynn.t:e nTeirlivaissoprutrepuarrebiosrirnascigenmiotsoa,,flfoorleiopelnotnagipoertialsoubptuurspualrbeio- 'Mammee vera Arboris loium ex Insula Canarina' and does (Sloane, 1696). not have any reference to Plukenet's works. However it His.: Boseayervamora L. [Although Linnaeus published this irseasneomtbhleerssthpeeciillmuesntriantiHonSd9e9p:ic9t1ewdhiincPhhyrte.f:erts.t2o68t,hifs.p1l.aTtehebruet nsyanmoenoyrmigoinnallylyininth1e75t3w,elhfethcietdeidtiPolnukoefnehti'ssSpyosltyenmoaminaaltuarsaea without any mention of a collection site. The plant given in (Linnaeus, 1767); W.B.]. nPhoytt.a: ts.p2e6c8i,esf.f1r(omHSt9h9e: M1a10c)arisonneotsioafnM.floarmae.riWceanacaanndointliys DHeSt.9:6:* B1o71sebaeyloenrgvsamtoortahiLs.s[paechieesr.baPrliuukmenseptecaismseocniaftoeudndthiins assume that Plukenet incorrectly assigned the illustration specimen with the figure in Phyt.: t. 204, f. 2 and the from Phyt.: t. 268, f. 1 to his description of M. americana. description of entry 13 (Aim.: 39). However his description Plukenet also indicated that the drawing found in Phyt.: t. of B. yervamora does not refer to this illustration. In fact in 204, f. 2 was of this species. However this plate and its Aim.: 39 he identified it as a species ofMammea; this is also correspondingspecimen (HS96: 1A71) areofBoseayervamora confirmed by one ofthe labels ofthe specimen which states: L. which is a Canarianendemic. description ofthis species 'A Mamee Mamaya s. Momin'. Plukenet's accounts for B. was also provided by Plukenet (for further discussion see yervamora (Aim.: 42,Mant.: 21)areextremelyprecisein,for entry 15)]. example, the citation of the common name used in the Canaries. It is therefore surprising that he did not assign the illustration from Phyt.: t. 204, f. 2 (HS 96: 171) to the 14. An Arbor mirabilis ex Insula Ferro aquam stillaus description]. Mant.: 171(1700). Com.: Plukenet reported the use of the name 'Yerba-Mora' in the Canary Islands, where it is known as 'hierbamora', sASiyrmnbi.lo:irs,Saabgqoaunpaeumnmisqetusitleldlaenisqcuo(olrBoafrureuhteiixncias&lfbeorCuh(leMaraclneeiard,oil1e&6a5n0Sd)yrl,oviOjm,mobn1rt59ia8on)no, ha'irysebrodvreaesmacorreixap'tairoagnnednftr'eohoemd&iAoinmvdi.or:'i.di1T8fho1li,isiMsnaeanltme.eg:anis9t9ea,rlsnvoaarmmieeenglatytiiosHne[ed.de.ri.an] nullis aedificiorum vestigiis, habere, in montibus stagnum Nequeprorsus abhorres a Yerva Mora Canariensibus Hispa- aarmbaorraesesximiclainsdifdeirourliaebusexpoqtuuiibusiuacqunudaaex(pPrliinmya,tur1,826eo)n,igrIins nHies.derHaujhueslix[.L..)..] non autem scandit haec sed erigitur (= prima earum, cui nomem est Embrion, aedificia nee suntnee fuerunt, iuga montium stagnis madescuntferulae surgunt ad arboris magnitudinem: earum quae nigrae sunt, expressae 16. Arbuscula Canariensis Salicis, aut potius Oleae liquorem reddunt amarissimum, quae candidae, aquas revo- Sylv. Barbadensium foliis & facie, seminibus ad tactum amrubnotresecteinatmesp,otaufifearecnctoemVoodsastiaos, N(Sootl,iniuns,Po1m95p8o)m,,FeMreullaaems[u?n]t, (SqnuaapnTdroemeantousrtirsa)tiebcuaspsvuulligso.cuinmHsotrrte.piRteugp.roSfainlciteintibus, SddwPielaetsa.gcnhartlaipaivpbee.etngiub3ou.nemmefcmenraniopuimenms9asG5beFa.leler[eQ?u]ntul.ouaasctPmerl.(aau1cek5Pee8aP7ninlt)eaaitnc'ntiSaatashleiigssgmoaiupplquemeubnmmlouiitemcesaDdsetieniooitasnhimc.feoF.refHiroodulewllsaeocwvteireanarge- JhGsaeuecmjoiournbsgai.aladiLoapolumnedsdacoWgenennstaeetxmsmoSahenramabbiusensttciecubrlouiansuevmne[an.ptira.eaen.e]ttseiQuranuimtotoacqduuaanmVmnaCposulcrcuuiurlnriaiamDa.e Det.: * Ocoteafoetens (Aiton) Benth. & Hook.f. [there isno Speciebus Malabarorum Aim.: 44 (1696), Phyt.: t. herbarium specimen for this species in Plukenet's collection, 313, f. 1 (1694). determination has been based on the sixteenth century illus- tration given byTorriani (1978)]. Det.: * Justicia hyssopifolia L. [HS93: 140]. Com.: Fromthe accountofthisspeciesitseemsthatPlukenet based his description on material grown by George London, whowasMasterGardenerand DeputySuperintendentofthe Royal Gardens under William III. The description found in entry34 alsoseems referable to/. hyssopifolia. J. FRANCISCO-ORTEGA,A. SANTOS-GUERRAANDC.E. JARVIS 17. Arbutus angustiori folio non serrato ex Insulis Oth.: HVP: 28. Fortunatis. Aut potius Cerasus Canariensis Adrachne Com.: The use ofthe common name 'Magala' is indicated in foliis magis acuminatis, fructu parvo, Fragiformi, the description. Thisspecies is known locally as 'magarza'. & monopyreno Cerasis nostratibus plumirum divers! Aim.: 49 21. Campanula Canariensis Regia. s. Medium radice (1696). tuberosa, foliis sinuatis, coefiis, Atriplicis aemulis, Syn.: Morocoks (Ogilvy, 1671). ternis circa caulem ambientibus, flore amplo pendulo, eiaDnxecttH.ee:pSnttMaa9yt5irl:viaebc1ea0ld4few;athyeiiatrcmhdAiolnsettasaottnienoso[nta'Asbhrpeabesaucrtiubmaseenennynoonrfem[ftaiehldrileseegn.sc]pbeeeacxtsioeCedasAniiasormnif.no:iutsn4h'd9e; sncpouelncocireevsifgpleetar,mimunbecioumrreuitanimdleapnotJseaitn[au.,a.rii.n]oH,ionfrtletor.reCRsoenegdviiootiltHvaAumilpmot.r:ounm, resemblance of this specimen to Plukenet's original descrip- 76-77 (1696), Phyt.: t. 276, f. 1 (1694). tion. It seems that this species was described twice as the Syn.: Cachruiaqua (Hernandez, 1651), Totoncaxoxo coyollin description isvirtuallyidentical to that found in entry23]. (Hernandez, 1651). His.: Campanula canariensis L. [Linn.; Gis.; Ten.; W.B.]. 18. Arbutus serratis foliis Canarina, cortice Det.: * Canarinacanariensis (L.) Vatke [HS95: 133; 99: 161; circumrupto, sive duodecies Anni spatio, corticem 102: 160]. abjiciens, ex Insula Tenerifa nobis est allata Aim.: 49 Oth.: HS 87: 79; 92: 38; 104: 59; HVP: 33. Com.: Plukenet reported that plants of this species were (1696). cultivated in the Royal Garden at Hampton Court Palace, in His.: ArbutuscanariensisVeill. [W.B.]. south-west London. Det.: * Arbutus canariensis Veill. [there is a specimen ofA. canariensisin HS95: 104which, althoughnotexplicitlylinked Lectotypification ofCampanula canariensis to any page number of the Almagestum, bears three labels Linnaeus which agree with the original description from Aim.: 49]. Com.: One of the main features of this species is that Linnaeus' protologue for this name (Fig. 1) in Speciesplan- individuals change their bark regularly. This was noticed by tarum (Linnaeus, 1753) comprises a new diagnostic phrase Plukenet and was mentioned both in the description (Aim.: name (C. foliis hastatis dentatis oppositis petiolatis, capsulis 49) and on the specimen labels. quinquelocularibus), the citation oftwo synonyms from Lin- naeus (1738, also cited via van Royen, 1740) and Plukenet 19. Atriplex angustifolia Canariensis, maritima, (1694, 1696), and the statement 'Habitat in insulis Canariis'. dentata, repens. Flos de AInmo Hispanis dicta Aim.: The diagnosis is a modification of that used in his earlier 61, 399 (1696), Phyt.: t. 326, f. 3 (1694). H(soeretuFisg.cl2i)f,fobruttiaununsfowrhteurneateLliynnnaoeumsatpeurbilailsehxeidstasninileliutshterrattihoen Syn.: Atriplex angustifolia maritima dentata (Ray, 1686), Clifford or Linnaean (LINN, S, UPS, H, MW) herbaria. Atriplexargentea dentatacurassavica (Hermann, 1689). Apartfrom Linnaeus' figure, the onlyothervisualelementin Det.: Atriplex glauca L. [there is now no specimen upon the protologue is the Plukenet illustration (see Fig. 3). which Plukenet's account was based; a tentative determina- Although it is perhaps a little more stylized than that tion has been made based on the drawing from the Phy- executed by Ehret for Clifford (for Hortus cliffortianus), it tographia]. showsthe formofthecorollamuch more clearly, and hasthe Com.: The use of the common name 'Flos de Alumo' is considerable advantage that there is a voucher specimen in reported by Plukenet, though plants ofA. glauca are known the Plukenet Herbarium upon which the illustration was in the Canary Islands by the names 'saladillo', 'salado' and evidentlybased. Both illustrationsundoubtedlybelongtothe 'marisma'. plant known as Canarinacanariensis (L.) Vatke, so there are no taxonomic complications associated with this choice. Although the Clifford illustration would have been more 20. Ituphthaiinurn Canariense Leucanthemum, Cotulae & familiar to Linnaeus, the existence of the voucher material foetidae crassioribus foliis, radice, acrisapore, makes us favour instead Plukenet's illustration and we for- fervido [. . .] Magala ab Insulanis nuncupatur Aim.: mally choose Campanula Canariensis regia s. Medium radice 73 (1696), Phyt.: t. 272, f. 6 (1694). tuberosa, foliis sinuatis,. . . Plukenet, Almagestum Bot. 76 Syn.: Pyrethrumflore Bellidis (Bauhin, 1623). (1696); Phytographia t. 276, f. 1 (1694) as the lectotype His.: Chrysanthemumfrutescens L. [Linn.; Gis.], Pyrethrum * frutescens (L.) Gaertn. [Ten.], Argyranthemum frutescens Cattle fubJivifo. CAA/IPANULA (L.) Sch. Bip. [W.B.]. ctnarinft. if. foliis haftatis dcntatis oppofitls pe- sDceetn.s:[*thAerregyisraanstpheceimmuemnfirnutHeSsc9e5n:s2(0L0.)ofScAh..frBuitpe.scsesnps.wfhruitceh- Catlmiipooliaabnt.ius,lHoacratpf.foluilcilisisjfh.nqfut6ia$ot.qisute.dleo8nc.tualtRaiosry,i.bcurl.suu.gldebd.et1e4r7m.inatefo- bears a label which states 'Cotula e Canarinis Ins.' but the Campanula canartcnfisregia f. Medium radice tubcrofa, material resembles the figure found in Phyt.: t. 272, f. 6. foliis finuatis czfiis atriplicis xmulis ternis circum aPlnudkietniestPhiyntc.o:rret.ct2l7y2,cift.e6d wPhhyitc.h:at.gr2e7e2s,wfi.t5h ftohretdheisscrsippetciioens., HnbcftiltuaalmtemmienoairrxuaftubililieasnnttCieab.nuasPr,iiinfskl..orTeafima.m7p6l.o1.1p7en6d/u.lio.:. colore Subsequent taxonomic works from Linn., Gis., Ten. and W.B: noted this error and established that the correct draw- Fig. 1 TheoriginalprotologueofCampanulacanariensisLinnaeus ingforthis name is that in Phyt.: t. 272, f. 6]. (1753). PRE-LINNAEAN REFERENCES FOR MACARONESIAN FLORA Fig.2 Ehret'sillustrationofCampanulafoliishastatisdentatis, cauledeterminatefoliosefrom Linnaeus'Hortus Cliffortianus (1738). J. FRANCISCO-ORTEGA,A. SANTOS-GUERRAANDC.E. JARVIS (typotype in Herb. Sloane 99: 161, BM) of Campanula 28. Cupressus nana, Canariensis fructu minore. In canariensis L. Palma quoque Insula una ex Fortunatis oritur haec arbos Aim.: 125 (1696), Mant.: 61 (1700). 22. Carduus Acanthoides, s. incanus minor, elegans, ex Syn.: Arbor cujus fructus Abhel (Clusius, 1576), Habhel Insula Maderensi Aim.: 85 (1696), Phyt.: t. 274, f. 1 (Clusius, 1601a, Cupresso similis Arbor in Syria (Bauhin, (1694). 1623), UytPersien kontdaarde Com Taxa (Rauwolf, 1707). Det.:Juniperuscf.phoenicea L. [?] Det.: Galactitestomentosa Moench [HS 99: 170]. Com.: Determinationbasedon thedescription. Itisnotewor- thythat aspecimen ofthisspeciesis also foundin HS 189: 32 inJ. Cuningham'scollectionfromLaPalma. Wewere unable 23. Cerasus Canariensis, mucronato Lauri angustiore to find an earlieredition ofRauwolfswork. folio, fructu parvo Fragiformi, Ossiculo tuberculoso, monopyreno Aim.: 95 (1696), Mant.: 43 (1700). 29. Cytisus arboreus, Canariensis, oblongo folio, & Morococks argentea holosericea lanugine subtus villoso, flore Syn.: (Ogilvy, 1671). Det.: MyricafayaAlton [?]. pallidiori [. . .] Texo Insulanis nuncupatur Aim.: 128 Com.: Description virtually identical to that found in entry (1696), Phyt.: t. 277, f. 4 (1694). 17. Syn.: Cytisus albussylvestris (Cordus, 1561), CytisusAlpinus (Dalechamps, 1586), Cytisus albicans, folio Trifolii vulgaris 24. Cicutae fatuae nostrati similis, Planta Maderensis (Bauhin, 1623). Aim.: 104(1696). HDiest..::C*ytCihsaumsapercoylitfiesruusspLr.olf.if[eWr.uBs.](.L. f.) Link ssp. proliferus var.proliferus [HS96: 2]. p25u.rpCuirsetiusselaxtiIfnosluialamaPijcoorMtarninte.r:vi4s9i(n1c7a0n0o).folio, floribus nPCloaummk.ee:ne'ttP,eljaoh'notwsiesveoufrs,edtrheifpsoorrstpipenlcgainettshseaocrfoemEmrkioncnoawnsnacmopaeasrTie'axeosL'c.o.boTsnsh'pe., Syn.: Ledon (Belon, 1553), Ledon tertium Cyprium (Clusius, platycodon (Webb & Berth.) Hansen & G. Kunkel. 1601a), Cistus Ledon cretense (Bauhin, 1623), Cistus Ledon latifolium Creticum (Bauhin & Cherler, 1651), Cistus Ledon 30. Cytisus Canariensis, microphyllos, angustifolius, latifolium Creticum Triumfet(Cupani, 1696). prorsus incanis [. . .] Esta Insulanis nuncupatur Aim.: 128 (1696), Phyt.: t. 277, f. 5 (1694). 26. Convolvulus Canariensis, longioribus foliis Syn.: Cytisus minoribus foliis, ramulis tenellis villosis (Bau- mollibus, & incanis. Ahilo-porro Salvages Hispanis hin, 1623), Cytisus Hispanicus, primus Clusiifolio virescente & nt.u3n2c5u,paf.tu1r(1A6i9m4.):. 114 (1696), Mant.: 54 (1700), Phyt.: DH(ieBsta..u::hiT*enliTneelCichnaeenralcreairne,anrs1ii6es5n0s()iL.s.)(WL.e)bWbe&bbBe&rthB.er[tWh..B.][.HS 96: 2. Syn.: Convolvulus marinus Catharticus foliis Acetosae flore Plukenet did not give a figure number for this species in his niveo (Plumier, 1693). Almagestum, but there is a herbarium specimen of T. canar- His.: Convolvulus canariensis L. [Linn.; Gis.; Ten.; W.B.]. iensis which bears Plukenet's handwriting and indicating that Det.: * Convolvuluscanariensis L. [HS 93: 110]. it relatesto Phyt.: t. 277, f. 5]. Com.: The common name 'Ahilo-porro Salvages' is men- Oth.: HS 87: 117, 93: 132, 100: 14. tioned in the description. However Convolvulus species bear Com.: T. canariensis is known in the Canary Islands as the common names 'corregiiela', 'chaparro', 'guaydil', 'lena 'retamon', 'retama de cumbre' or 'gildana'. However noel' whereas the name 'ajo porro' is used for plants of Plukenetreportedthe common name of'Esta'. Allium spp. 31. Cytisus Canariensis, microphyllos, cauliculis villosis angustis viridibus foliis [. . .] Mysalva 27. Convolvulus Canariensis minimus, flore Insulanis, dicta Aim.: 128 (1696), Mant.: 63 (1700), ochroleuco, semine nigro. Hartelauena Indigenis dictus Phyt.: t. 277, f. 6(1694). Aim.: 400 (1696), Phyt.: t. 324, f. 4 (1694). Syn.: Cytisus Hispanicus siliquis Ornithopodij (Bauhin, His.: Sarothragentianoides L. [Gis.]. 1620), Cytisus Montis Calcaris (Bauhin & Cherler, 1650). Det.: * Convolvulusfruticulosus Desr. [there is a specimen His.: Genista canariensis L. [Linn.; Gis.; Ten.],Adenocarpus without a label of this Canarian endemic in HS 93: 110. It foliolosus (Aiton) DC. [W.B.]. resembles the drawing published by Plukenet and a tentative Det.: * Adenocarpus foliolosus (Aiton) DC. [HS 96: 2. determination has been made based on it]. Plukenet did not give a figure number for this species in his Com.: Plukenet mentioned the use of the common name Almagestum, butthereisaherbarium specimenofA.foliolo- 'Hartelauena' (perhaps a derivation of 'corregiiela'). For sus which bears Plukenet's handwriting indicating that it common names of Convolvulus species see entry no. 26. It is corresponds to fig. 6, and therefore the identifications pro- worth mentioning that according to the description the spe- vided by Linnaeus, Tenzel and Giseke were incorrect. Webb cies bears yellow flowers, however C. fruticulosus does not & Berthelot (1842) realised this error in their account of bearflowers with this colour. Genista canariensis L. and assigned Phyt.: t. 277, f. 5 for G. PRE-LINNAEAN REFERENCES FOR MACARONESIAN FLORA Fig.3 Plukenet'sillustrationofCampanula Canariensisregias. Mediumradicetuberosa,foliissinuatis, fromhisPhytographia,t. 276, f. 1 (1694),thelectotypeofCampanulacanariensisL.,Sp. PI. 1: 168(1753),designatedhere. 10 J. FRANCISCO-ORTEGA, A. SANTOS-GUERRAANDC.E. JARVIS Fig.4 Plukenet'sillustrationofDigitallaffinisCanariensisSolidaginisacutisfoliisleviterpilosis, . . (= Isoplexiscanariensis(L.) Loud.) fromhisPhytographia, t. 325, f. 2(1694).