Post-Anarchism Rousselle T02234 00 pre 1 24/12/2010 10:47 Rousselle T02234 00 pre 2 24/12/2010 10:47 Post-AnArchism A reader Edited by Duane Rousselle and Süreyyya Evren Fernwood Publishing hAlifAx & WinniPeg www.fernwoodpublishing.ca Rousselle T02234 00 pre 3 24/12/2010 10:47 first published 2011 by Pluto Press 345 Archway road, london n6 5AA and 175 fifth Avenue, new York, nY 10010 www.plutobooks.com Distributed in the United states of America exclusively by Palgrave macmillan, a division of st. martin’s Press llc, 175 fifth Avenue, new York, nY 10010 Published in canada by fernwood Publishing 32 oceanvista lane, Black Point, nova scotia, B0J 1B0 and 748 Broadway Avenue, Winnipeg, mB r3g 0x3 www.fernwoodpublishing.ca fernwood Publishing company limited gratefully acknowledges the financial support of the government of canada through the canada Book fund, the canada council for the Arts, the nova scotia Department of tourism and culture and the Province of manitoba, through the Book Publishing tax credit, for our publishing program. library and Archives canada cataloguing in Publication Post anarchism : a reader / Duane rouselle, süreyyya evren includes bibliographical references and index isBn 978–1–55266–433–9 1. Anarchism. i. rouselle, Duane, 1982– ii. evren, süreyyya, 1972– hx833.P68 2010 335'.83 c2010–907567–6 copyright © Duane rousselle and süreyyya evren 2011 the right of the individual contributors to be identified as the authors of this work has been asserted by them in accordance with the copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. British library cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British library isBn 978 0 7453 3087 7 hardback isBn 978 0 7453 3086 0 Paperback (Pluto Press) isBn 978 1-55266 433 9 Paperback (fernwood) library of congress cataloging in Publication Data applied for this book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental standards of the country of origin. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Designed and produced for Pluto Press by chase Publishing services ltd, 33 livonia road, sidmouth, ex10 9JB, england typeset from disk by stanford DtP services, northampton, england simultaneously printed digitally by cPi Antony rowe, chippenham, UK and edwards Bros in the UsA Rousselle T02234 00 pre 4 24/12/2010 10:48 contents Preface vii Duane Rousselle Acknowledgements ix Introduction: How New Anarchism Changed the World (of Opposition) after Seattle and Gave Birth to Post-Anarchism 1 Süreyyya Evren PARt 1: WHEN ANARCHISm mEt POSt-StRuCtuRAlISm 1. Post-Structuralism and the Epistemological Basis of Anarchism 23 Andrew M. Koch 2. Is Post-Structuralist Political theory Anarchist? 41 Todd May 3. Post-Anarchism and Radical Politics today 46 Saul Newman 4. Post-Anarchism Anarchy 69 Hakim Bey PARt 2: POSt-ANARCHISm HItS tHE StREEtS 5. Empowering Anarchy: Power, Hegemony and Anarchist Strategy 75 Tadzio Mueller 6. Hegemony, Affinity and the Newest Social movements: at the End of the 00s 95 Richard J.F. Day 7. the Constellation of Opposition 117 Jason Adams 8. Acracy_Reloaded@post1968/1989: Reflections on Postmodern Revolutions 139 Antón Fernández de Rota PARt 3: ClASSICAl ANARCHISm RElOADED 9. things to Do with Post-Structuralism in a life of Anarchy: Relocating the Outpost of Post-Anarchism 151 Sandra Jeppesen Rousselle T02234 00 pre 5 24/12/2010 10:48 vi Post-AnArchism 10. Anarchy, Power and Post-Structuralism 160 Allan Antliff 11. Post-Anarchism: A Partial Account 168 Benjamin Franks PARt 4: lINES Of flIGHt 12. Buffy the Post-Anarchist Vampire Slayer 183 Lewis Call 13. Sexuality as State form 195 Jamie Heckert 14. When theories meet: Emma Goldman and ‘Post-Anarchism’ 208 Hilton Bertalan 15. Reconsidering Post-Structuralism and Anarchism 231 Nathan Jun 16. Imperfect Necessity and the mechanical Continuation of Everyday life: A Post-Anarchist Politics of technology 250 Michael Truscello Contributors 261 Index 263 Rousselle T02234 00 pre 6 24/12/2010 10:48 Preface Post-anarchism has been of considerable importance in the discussions of radical intellectuals across the globe in the last decade. In its most popular form, it demonstrates a desire to blend the most promising aspects of traditional anarchist theory (centrally, the attitude of hostility in the face of represen- tation) with developments in post-structuralist and postmodern thought. However, since its inception, it has also posed a broader challenge to the reification of anarchist theory. It might be argued, as lewis Call suggests in this book, that today ‘a kind of post-anarchist moment has arrived’; whether or not this moment marks the final becomings of a vanishing philosophical mediator whereby what used to be explicitly regarded as ‘post-anarchism’ has simply become ‘anarchism’ (post-anarchism without its defining critique against ‘traditional anarchism’) is a matter for future investigation. However, I remain convinced that post-anarchism is the radical contemporary equivalent of the traditional anarchist discourse which, without proper force and direction, remains as impotent or as strong as traditional anarchism ever has been. In this sense, I would suggest that post-anarchism is simply another word to describe a paradigm shift that erupted at the broader level of anarchist philosophy and which has yet to be fully developed on the streets. Post-anarchism decentralizes the political movement, motions toward tactical rather than strategic action, brings anarchist thought into touch with a range of influences (in this sense post-anarchism reflects a ‘cultural studies’ approach) and provides the foundation for a thousand lines of flight; post-anarchism brings traditional anarchism into new relationships with the outside world. I believe that it is only those anarchists who speak within the broader trend of post-anarchism, a trend which is situated uniquely in the present context, who are capable of grappling with today’s issues. today’s anarchists may not be post-structuralist but they surely embody the element of post-structuralism’s critique and the presumption of its focus in various ways. the book that you are holding aims to demonstrate this point. the post-anarchists have been under attack. the brunt of this attack emerges from other anarchists who argue that the post-anarchists have too hastily declared a new tradition for themselves through highly selective and reductive readings of the traditional literature. this is the critique of the post- anarchist reduction of traditional anarchist literature. A second and emerging critique is that the post-anarchists have given up on the notion of ‘class’ and have retreated into obscure and intoxicating academic diatribes against a tradition built of discursive straw. In any case, it is without any question that post-anarchism has proved itself worth a second look: if one considers oneself a radical today, one will have to exercise extreme caution to avoid the force and influence of the post-anarchists. One need not be a post-anarchist vii Rousselle T02234 00 pre 7 24/12/2010 10:48 viii Post-AnArchism to appreciate what post-anarchism has to offer and the condition it seeks to explain; it is in this spirit of exploration and possibility that I offer, with Süreyyya Evren, Post-Anarchism: A Reader. And for making these essays accessible to the wider public and to an anarchist-sympathetic readership, we make absolutely no apologies. Our aim in this book is to offer readers the most comprehensive and up-to-date collection of post-anarchist material at an affordable price and in an accessible way in order to re-stimulate debates about its importance as a general movement of thought. my hope is that this book will help to resolve lingering tensions about the discourse through which post-anarchists are often accused of speaking (what lacan has called the ‘discourse of the university’). likewise, many anarchist academics are suspicious of the prefix ‘post-’. the range of perspectives brought together in this volume demonstrates that there is diversity within post-anarchism and that critics should be made aware of their own reduction of the ‘post-anarchist’ body of thought. What will surely be regarded as an academic pursuit by practising anarchists, and what will no doubt be regarded as an anarchist pursuit by thinking academics, has ostensibly been resolved into a mutual rejection of sorts. Here, one should be careful to distinguish academic writing from academic patronage (writing from the academy should in all cases be distinguished from writing for the academy) – a conflation that is very often assumed rather than argued convincingly. my best advice is to take what one finds useful in the post-anarchist literature and to dispose of what one finds to be in the service of the ‘university’; here, we can only offer the tools and it is your job to build your own shelter. Duane Rousselle Rousselle T02234 00 pre 8 24/12/2010 10:48 Acknowledgements Duane Rousselle: I would like to thank Jason Adams for his invaluable assistance in providing the needed infrastructure and motivation for this project; Aragorn! for his friendship and support in pursuing this and other projects; Süreyyya Evren for partaking in long late-night discussions about post-anarchism and for his support and effort during the tiresome editing process; uri Gordon, Saul Newman and Stevphen Shukaitis for offering advice and direction; Richard J.f. Day, who rescued me from three narrowly avoided disasters; mohammed Jean-Veneuse for teaching me the value and meaning of friendship; the Department of Sociology at the university of New Brunswick for their kind donation of $50 toward reprint/permissions costs for this book; the faculty of Arts at the university of New Brunswick for their kind donation of $150 toward reprint/permissions costs for this book; Pluto Press (especially David Castle and Will Viney), who have been supportive and more than a pleasure to work with; all contributors for believing in the project and making this book happen, especially those who worked with me to produce original material; and, lastly, but surely not least, Joady Jardine, my dancing star, for her endless encouragement and inspiration. Süreyyya Evren: I would like to thank my post-anarchist comrades in turkey, especially Erden Kosova and Bülent usta, who have been with me for the last 15 years, helping to transform my post-anarchist politics into a general approach to culture; all the world post-anarchists I have met in person; Jason Adams, Saul Newman and lewis Call for their commitment to post-anarchist philosophy despite the rise of debates; and Duane Rousselle for never giving up with this project. I would also like to thank Ruth Kinna and Dave Berry from loughborough university for making it possible for me to work on all of these subjects within an embracing academic environment and for always being there whenever I needed advice; my ‘anti-post-anarchist’ comrade Alex Pritchard for always keeping the anarchist collective spirit up; and matt Wilson, the anti-taboo anarchist in loughborough, for all of his support and friendship. lastly, to everyone waiting for the party we will have in my home when the book hits the shelves: my little ones, Yaz and Ada, and my dear Neval ... ix Rousselle T02234 00 pre 9 24/12/2010 10:48