OXFORD JOURNAL OF LEGAL STUDIES VOLUME 16 Published on behaif of The Faculty of Law, University ooff Oxfofre) d OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS 1996 General Editor: J. Eekelaar Editorial Committee: P. Cane, J. W. Davis, J. Gardner, S. Gardner, C. Gray, J. Hackney, J. Horder, C. McCrudden, D. Prentice Oxford University Press, Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP Oxford New York Toronto Delhi Bombay Calcutta Madras Karachi Petaling Jaya Singapore Hong Kong Tokyo Nairobi Dares Salaam Cape Town Melbourne Auckland and associate companies in Beirut Berlin Ibadan Nicosia © Oxford University Press 1996 except where otherwise indicated CONTENTS ARTICLES BRIGHT, CHRISTOPHER, EU Competition Policy: Rules, Objectives and Deregulation CONAGHAN, JOANNE, Gendered Harms and the Law of Tort: Remedying (Sexual) Harassment Cooper, Davina, Institutional Illegality and Disobedience: Local Government Narratives Dyzennaus, Davip, Hermann Heller and the Legitimacy of Legality ELEFTHERIADIS, PAvLOS, The Analysis of Property Rights ENDICOTT, TIMOTHY, Linguistic Indeterminacy ENONCHONG, NELSON, Breach of Contract and Damages for Mental Distress GARDNER, JOHN, Discrimination as Injustice GIBBONS, THOMAS, Defamation Reconsidered GRANTHAM, Ross, Doctrinal Bases for the Recognition of Proprietary Rights Ha.pin, ANDREW, The Concept of a Legal Power Harris, J. W., Who Owns my Body? JACKSON, JOHN, Analysing the New Evidence Scholarship: Towards a New Conception of the Law of Evidence Lucy, WILLIAM N. R., Adjudication for Pluralists McCOoLaGan, AILEEN, Common Law and the Relevance of Sexual History Evidence ROBERTSON, BERNARD, The Currency and the Constitution: Lessons from ‘a rather small place’ Suaw, Jo, European Union Legal Studies in Crisis? Towards a New Dynamic SIMESTER, A. P., Moral Certainty and the Boundaries of Intention TASIOULAS, JOHN, In Defence of Relative Normativity: Communitarian Values and the Nicaragua Case WHITTAKER, SIMON, Privity of Contract and the Tort of Negligence: Future Directions Wiikinson, T. M., Dworkin on Paternalism and Well-being REVIEW ARTICLES Beck, ANTHONY, Foucault and Law: the Collapse of Law’s Empire Back, Jutia M., An Economic Analysis of Regulation: One View of the Cathedral CANE, PETER, Corrective Justice and Correlativity in Private Law Dewar, JOHN, Family, Law and Theory FLEMING, JOHN G., Product Liability De-Constructed Janis, MaRK, The New Oppenheim and its Theory of International Law SapuRsKI, WojciecH, On ‘Seeing Speech Through an Equality Lens’: A Critique of Egalitarian Arguments for Suppression of Hate Speech and Pornography SYPNOWICH, CHRISTINE, Feminism and the Critique of Political Theory Tomkins, ApAM, Inventing Human Rights Law and Scholarship Warp, IAN, The European Constitution and the Nation State SHORTER ARTICLES ALLAN, JAMES, Bills of Rights and Judicial Power—A Liberal’s Quandary BiGwoop, Rick, Undue Influence: ‘Impaired Consent’ and “Wicked Exploitation’? Ho, Lusina, The Nature of Restitution—A Reply LEGISLATION {Entries refer to statutes receiving substantial discussion or criticism in this volume] UNITED KINGDOM Child Support Act 1991 726, 728 et seq Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 277 Defective Premises Act 1972 201-2, 215 sl 201-2 s2 202 Domestic Violence and Matrimonial Proceeding Act 1976 412-13 Education Reform Act 1988 258-9, 269 Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 76 Human Organ Transplants Act 1989 75 et seq Local Government Finance Act 1988 260-1 Rates Act 1984 260 Sale of Goods Act 1979 (amended 1994) s14 225 et seq Sex Discrimination Act 1975 412-13, 426 Sexual Offences Act 1956 sl 294, 307 Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1976 s2 275 et seq s 2(4) 280 et seq Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977 60 Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 227 OTHER COUNTRIES ALI Restatement Second, Torts (US) s 402A 185 et seq ss 5 221 Civil Rights Act 1964 (US) Title VII 356-7 Code Civile (Fr) 201 et seq, 219 Art 1792 201 Reserve Bank Act 1959 (Aus) s 10(2) Reserve Bank of New Zealand Act 1989 s8 s12 s13 s15 s17 s18 s 20 s 49 s 169 Statute of the International Court of Justice Art 36(2) EUROPEAN UNION TREATY Article 4(2) of Regulation 17/62 557-8 Articles 30—6 248 Article 85(1) 535 et seq CASES {Entries refer to cases receiving substantial discussion or criticism in this volume] Addis v Gramophone Co Ltd (1909) 618-40 Associated Provincial Picture House Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation (1948) 27, 401, 403 Attorney-General for Hong Kong v Reid (1994) 563 et seq Balsamo v Medici (1984) 222 Bogie (1992) 283, 305 Burris v Azadani (1995) 410, 420-2 Commission v Belgium (Wallonia Waste Ban Case) (1993) (EC) 248 Charleston vy News Group Newspapers (1995) 602-3 Coditel SA v Cine Vog Films SA No. 2 (Coditel IT) (ECR) (1982) 537 et seq Donoghue v Stevenson (1932) 480-1, 482 European Night Services (1994) (EC) 538 Godwin v Uzoigwe (1993) 423-4, 428 Henderson v Merrett Syndicates Ltd sub nom Deeny v Gooda Walker Ltd (1994) 191 et seq Hobbs (1875) 635, 639 Johnson v Santa Clara Transportation Agency (1987) (US) 356 et seq Edwards v Bell (1824) 606-7 Junior Books v Veitchi Co Ltd (1983) 191, 198n, 205, 206, 216, 225 Khorasandjian v Bush (1993) 410, 418-22, 428 Krausz (1973) 294 et seq Lipkin Gorman v Karpnale Ltd (1992) 518, 525-6 Lord Napier and Eltrick v Hunter (1993) 575 et seq Moore v Regents of the University of California (1988) (US) 77 et seq Morgan v Odhams Press (1971) 604-5 Morgans v Launchbury (1973) 217 (Nicaragua v US) Merits (1986) (World Court) 85-128 Nungesser KG (LC) and Kurt Eisele v Commission (1978) (EC) 538 Ojutiku v Manpower Services Commission (1982) 362-3, 365 Patel v Patel (1988) 412, 420, 421 R v Brown (1994) R v Ealing LBC ex p Times Newspapers Ltd (1986) R v Hyam (1975) R v Nedrick (1986) R v Riley (1887) R v Viola (1982) Re Goldcorp Exchange Ltd (in receivership) (1995) Rookes v Barnard (1964) Simaan v Pilkington (1988) SMS (1992) Société Technique Miniére v Maschinenbau Um (1966) (ECR) 537, 540, 542 Straffen (1952) 297-8 Westdeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale v Islington London BC (1994) 519, 527 White v Jones (1995) 191 et seq Wilkinson v Downton (1897) 417-22 Wygant v Jackson Board of Education (1986) (US) 356 et seq