UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO FACULTY LAW of Materials for Citizenship, Immigration and Globalization LAW262H1S; GLA0211H; Spring 2014 Perspective/ICT/SUYRP course SPRING 2014 VOLUME I Professor Ayelet Shachar Faculty of Law University of Toronto aterials reproduced herein are solely for the educational use of students at the 3224 dversity of Toronto Faculty of Law, and are not for commercial sale or use A58S43 2014 v.1 C.1 SORA LASKIN LAW LIBRARY JAN I 3 2014 faculty of law i. UXr/Zj&TY OF TORONTO Materials for Citizenship, Immigration and Globalization LAW262H1S; GLA0211H; Spring 2014 Perspectivg/ICT/SUYRP course SPRING 2014 VOLUME I Professor Ayelet Shachar Faculty of Law University of Toronto The materials reproduced herein are solely for the educational use of students at the University of Toronto Faculty of Law, and are not for commercial sale or use Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2019 with funding from University of Toronto https://archive.org/details/materialsforciti01shac_2 MUNK SCHOOL UNIVERSITY OF # S '\ FA Tn TORONTO rw i UNIVERSITY OF GLOBAL FACULTY OF LAW w TORONTO AFFAIRS Citizenship, Immigration and Globalization LAW262H1S; GLA0211H; Spring 2014 Perspective/ICT/SUYRP course PROFESSOR AYELET SHACHAR Class Meeting Time: Monday 2:10-4:00 Office Hours (FL 408): Monday 4:00-4:30 or by appointment Phone: 416-978-1620; E-mail: [email protected] Faculty Assistant Nancy Bueler: nancy■[email protected] Citizenship and immigration have become a hot-button political issue in recent years in Canada, as well as in many other destination countries. Debates range from admission questions - who should be allowed to enter, according to what criteria, and for how long - to queries about the civil rights of migrants, cultural diversity, and the level of integration that can legitimately be expected from newcomers once they have settled in the country. Another emerging topic is the growing impact of economic remittances, transnational investments, and political contributions by dual citizens in both sending and receiving countries. This course will explore these new developments, placing them in the broader context of Canadian immigration law, history, and policy. We will also refer to comparative evidence from the United States, Australia, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, the United Kingdom, and Singapore, as well as examine the changing conceptions of membership in leading emigrant-sending countries, including Mexico, India, and China. With this global perspective in mind, we will chart the new terrain for Canadian citizenship and immigration law for the twenty-first century. Evaluation • Class participation (15%): Class meetings will be organized around a discussion of each week's readings. Class participation includes attendance, substantive participation in weekly discussions, and one in-class presentation of a comment paper (see below). • 1,250 words (five-page) comment paper (15%): The comment paper will be a critical assessment of one or more of the sources on the reading list. Comment papers are due at 4 p.m. on the day before the class readings are scheduled to be discussed. Please e-mail the comment paper to [email protected]. Each student is expected to use the five-page comment paper to illuminate an important question in the reading or to develop their own coherent argument based on the readings. The submission of the comment paper will be accompanied by a short in- class presentation of the paper. Students must sign up for the oral presentation of one of their comment papers ahead of time, during the second meeting of the seminar. • Final research paper of 6,000-6,500 words (approx. 20 to 25 pages') (70%): The final paper's topic must be pre-approved by the instructor. A one-page outline of your paper and a pretiminary bibliography must be turned in by 2:00 p.m., Monday, February 24, 2014. The final paper is due by 10 a.m. on the last day of the reading period, April 24, 2014 (Records Office). 1 Reading Materials • The reading materials will draw upon Canadian and comparative jurisprudence and legislation governing citizenship and immigration law, as well as contemporary political theory, globalization studies, and social science literature. The reading material is assembled in a course packet. Citizenship, Immigration and Globalization, edited by Professor Shachar (Faculty of Law, University of Toronto, 2014). The course packet is available for purchase at the Law School's bookstore. Additional copies will be placed on short-term reserve at the Bora Laskin Law Library. Course materials will also be posted on Blackboard. VOLUME ONE_ I. Foundations 1. The Classic Model of Sovereignty and the Challenges of Migration in the 21st Century "Citizenship," in Immigration and Citizenship: Process and Policy, ed. Thomas Alexander Aleinikoff et al. (5th ed.. West, 2003), p. 1.1 "Methodological Preliminaries" in Lea Ypi, "Justice in Migration: A Closed Borders Utopia?" 16 Journal of Political Philosophy (2008), pp. 392-393 .2 "Migration at a glance," in Report oftlw Global Commission on International Migration (GCIM, 2005); available at www.gcim.org/ en/finalreport .4 2. Membership's Boundaries and the Shifting Borders of Immigration Rogers Brubaker, "Citizenship as Social Closure," in Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany (Harvard University Press, 1992), pp. 21-34.7 "Who are the Harraga?" in Branko Milanovic, The Have and the Have-Notes (Basic Books, 2011), pp. 130-134 .21 Saskia Sassen, Losing Control? Sovereignty in an Age of Globalization (Columbia University Press, 1996), pp. 1-6; 59-75 .24 Ayelet Shachar, "The Shifting Border of Immigration Regulation," 3 Stanford Journal of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties (2007), pp. 165-193.48 Bruce Ackerman, Social Justice in the Liberal State (Yale University Press, 1980), pp. 93-95 .78 Gary S. Becker, "An Open Door for Immigrants —The Auction" Wall Street Journal, October 14,1992, A14 .81 2 II. Who Belongs? Citizenship and Immigration Law in a Nutshell 3. Who Naturally Belongs to the Political Community and on What Basis? " - Ayelet Shachar, " Citizenship" in The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Lazo, ed. Michel Rosenfeld and Adras Sajo (Oxford University Press, 2012), pp. 1002-1019.83 Fourteenth Amendment, U.S. Constitution.103 Warsame v. Canada, Communication No. 1959/2010, CCPR/C/102/D/1959/2010 (2010).104 Re Ortiz-Martinez, Board of Immigration Appeals, File No. A-27-645-795, May 25, 2007 .116 Twenty-Seventh Amendment of the Constitution Act 2004 [Ireland].121 4. Family-Sponsored Immigration Categories Who is Family? - "Family Class - Canada" in Emily Carasco et. al.. Immigration and Refugee Lazo: Cases, Materials, and Commentary (Emond Montgomery, 2007), pp. 369-382 .123 Government Notices, Department of Citizenship and Immigration, Immigration and Refugee Protection Act ("Conditional Permanent Residence") Vol. 145, No. 13, March 26, 2011 .131 Tobi Cohen, "Critics raise concerns about new marriage fraud measures," o.canada.com, October 26, 2012 .134 Carol Sanders, "New super visa super disappointing," Winnipeg Free Press, Dec. 21, 2011 .136 Denise Hansen, "Popular Super Visa gets mixed reviews from applicants," March 7, 2013, canadianimmigrant.ca.139 Richard Fausset, "Binational Gay Couples in Immigration Bind" Los Angeles Times, July 10, 2006.143 US Immigration and Customs Enforcement, "Applicability of Prosecutorial Discretion Memoranda to Certain Family Relations," Oct. 5, 2012.146 National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v. Minister of Home Affairs, 148 C.C.T. 10/99 [South Africa] . 3 C 130/02 Zambrano, Official Journal of the European Union, 30.4.2011 .151 Anja Wiesbrock, "The Zambrano Case: Relying on Union citizenship rights in 'internal situations/" EUDO Citizenship Observatory (EUI, March 2011) .152 5. Employment-Based Immigration: Point System for the Highly Skilled Citizenship and Immigration Canada, News Release: An Immigration System that Works for Canada, Dec. 19, 2012.155 Ayelet Shachar, "The Race for Talent: Highly Skilled Migrants and Competitive Immigration Regimes" 81 NYU Law Review 148 (2006) .157 Melissa Fama, "A New Era for Canada's International Student Program," Canadian Diversity, Winter 2011.210 Canadian Council for Refugees, "Canadian immigration: changing priorities" (April 2011). 214 Demetrios G. Papademtriou and Madeleine Sumption, Rethinking Points Systems and Employer-Selected Immigration, Migration Policy Institute, June 2011 .218 Naomi Alboim and Karen Cohl for May tree. Shaping the Future: Canada's Rapidly Changing Immigration Policies, Oct. 2012, pp. 44-45, 54-57 .229 "Letter to The Times: Nobel prize-winners in science have been enriching and enhancing British science and society for decades," October 7, 2010 .234 Yudhijit Bhattacharjee, "US Immigration: Groups Urge Easing of Restrictions on Visa Policies Affecting Scientists," 304 Science 943 (2004).235 Statement and Recommendations on Visa Problems Harming America's Scientific, Economic, and Security Interests, written by leaders of the academic community .236 Brenda S. A. Yeoh, "Bifurcated Labour: The Unequal Incorporation of Transmigrants in Singapore" 97 Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie (2006), 26-37 .241 4 VOLUME TWO__ 6. Temporary Low-Skilled Migration Programs; Domestic Workers; Undocumented Migrants; Earned Citizenship Citizenship and Immigration Canada, News Release: Canada Welcomes Highest Number of legal immigrants in 50 years while taking action to maintain the integrity of the immigration system, February 13, 2011.*.1 Martin Ruhs and Philip Martin, "Numbers vs. Rights: Trade-Offs and Guest Worker Programs," 42 International Migration Review 249 (2008) .3 Michael Walzer, Spheres of Justice: A Defense of Pluralism and Equality (Basic Books, 1983) pp. 52-61 .20 Valeria Otonelli and Tiziana Torresi, "Inclusivist Egalitarian Liberalism and Temporary Migration: A Dilemma," 20 Journal of Political Philosophy 202 (2012) .28 Cindy Hahamovitch, "The Lessons of Belle Glade," New York Tunes, July 18, 2013 .41 Jennifer Gordon, "Transnational Labor Citizenship," 80 Soutlwrn California Law Review 502 (2007), pp. 503-510 .43 ILO, "Convention Concerning Decent Work for Domestic Workers" 15A, International Labour Organization, 2011 .51 "My Life as an Illegal," Texas Monthly, July 2006 .61 Ayelet Shachar, "Earned Citizenship: Property Lessons for Immigration Reform," 23 Yale Journal of Law & the Humanities 110 (2011), pp. 110-158 .68 U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, I Am a Young Person Who Airived in The United States as a Child (Childhood Arrival), Nov. 15, 2012.117 7. Asylum Seekers, Forced Migration & Movie Screening''Well-Founded Fear" UNHCR, "Asylum and Refugee Status Determination" in UNHCR Statistical Yearbook 2010, pp. 40-45 .U9 Citizenship and Immigration Canada, Making Canada's Asylum System Faster and Fairer: New Asylum System Comes into Force Dec. 15, 2012, Nov. 30, 2012 .125 Peter Showier, "New Refugee Bill Will Not Give Refugees a Fair Chance to Tell 127 Their Stories," Refugee Forum, University of Ottawa. 5 Professor Shachar will offer introductory comments before the screening of the documentary, which will be shown in class during our regular meeting time. III. THE NEW FRONTIERS OF CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION 8. Shared Values; State and Religion; Return of Assimilation? "France/Secularism/' Statement made by Jacques Chirac, President of the Republic, Paris, January 28, 2004.128 Rogers Brubaker, "The Return of Assimilation? Changing perspectives on immigration and its sequels in France, Germany, and the United States," 24 Ethnic and Racial Studies 531 (2001) .129 John R Bowen, "How the French State Justifies Controlling Muslim Bodies: From Harm-Based to Values-Based Reasoning," 78 Social Research 325 (2011) .147 Bill 60, Charter affirming the values of State secularism and religious neutrality and of equality between women and men and providing a framework for accommodation requests, 1st Sess, 40th Leg., Quebec, National Assembly, 2013.171 Marian Scott, "Most immigrants to Quebec feel attachment to Canada: Poll," The Gazette, May 6, 2013 .178 Ayelet Shachar, "Interpretation Sections (27 and 28) of the Canadian Charter," in Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, eds., Errol Mendes and Stephane Beaulac (5th ed., LexisNexis, Canada, 2013), pp. 165-178 .181 R v. N.S., 2012 SCC 72.189 Alberta v. Hutterian Brethren of Wilson Colony [2009] 2 S.C.R. 567 . 190 Ayelet Shachar, "Religion, State, and the Problem of Gender: New Modes of Citizenship and Governance in Diverse Societies," 50 McGill Law Journal 49 (2005) .202 9. Citizenship Tests in Public Law and the Rise of Privatized Diversity Amitai Etzioni, "Citizenship Tests: A Comparative, Communitarian Perspective," 78 Political Quarterly 353 (2007) .214 Liav Orgad, "Illiberal Liberalism: Cultural Restrictions on Migration and Access to Citizenship in Europe," 58 American Journal of Comparative Law (2010), pp. 53-83 225 6