City Research Online City, University of London Institutional Repository Citation: Voss, A. (1992). Magic, astrology and music: the background to Marsilio Ficino's astrological music therapy and his role as a Renaissance magus. (Unpublished Doctoral thesis, City University London) This is the accepted version of the paper. This version of the publication may differ from the final published version. Permanent repository link: https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/7977/ Link to published version: Copyright: City Research Online aims to make research outputs of City, University of London available to a wider audience. Copyright and Moral Rights remain with the author(s) and/or copyright holders. URLs from City Research Online may be freely distributed and linked to. Reuse: Copies of full items can be used for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-profit purposes without prior permission or charge. Provided that the authors, title and full bibliographic details are credited, a hyperlink and/or URL is given for the original metadata page and the content is not changed in any way. City Research Online: http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/ [email protected] MAGIC. ASTROLOGY AND MUSIC THE BAQOUND TO MARSILIO FICINO ASOLIOGICAL !&JSIC THERAPY AND HIS ROLE AS A RE4AISSPNCE MAG'JS ANGELA M. VOSS Ph.D. Thesis Music Department, City University June 1992 O2O25249 TT I 4 7" /;çi" - f 11 • • ,•' •- •.. rb\ j_/'/ 1- ii ;;;4 ;i ,d _________ - -tI I ii . ,-- • - I_ * , 4 -I / II ,I 'I I.**;•: -. / I 1 4 ;( • * iij .•I • /'/ i jI , 1 P4 I/f /1 / I I I 1 Ii I. ;7 • - .- — — • • .'- ,d.L._ • Busto di Marsil,o Ficino, Andrea di Piero Ferrucci (1522). Firenze, Santa Maria dcl Fiore. Acknowledgements page 4 Abstract 5 INTRODUc'rI ON 6 References to Introduction 13 CHAPTER ONE: MtJSICA MUNDANA Prsca Theo1og a - Ficino's Ancient Authorities Part One: Plato 1.1. Prologue 16 1.2. The Timaeus and Pythagorean harmonia 21 1.3. The World-soul 24 1.4. Husica mundana 29 1.5. The Epinoinls 34 Part Two: Hermes 1.6. The Corpus Hermeticuin 41 1.7. Hermes and mythology 44 1.8. The aichemical Mercurius 46 1.9. The Plrnander 51 1.10. The Sun 55 Part Three: Plotinus 1.11. The cosmic ballet 60 References to chapter one 69 CHAPTER TWO: !IUSI CA HUMANA Natural and Spiritual Magic in the Platonic Tradition Part One: Philosophical Magç 2.1. IntroductIon 87 2.2. Magic and mysticism 89 2.3. Plato and magic 95 2.4. Daemons 99 2.5. Divine frenzy 101 2.6. Pythagorean music therapy 105 2.7. Ritual and education 107 2.8. Plotinus 109 2.9. Images 115 2.10. Earthly beauty 121 Part Two: Practical Magic 2.12. Theurgy 123 2.13. InvocatIons 126 2.14. Time 130 2.15. Statue-magic 136 2.16. Divination 142 2.17. Astrology 146 2.18. Conclusion: cognition 149 References to chapter two 155 -2- CHAPTER THREE: FICINO AND ASTROLOGY Part One: On the Knowledge of Divine Things 3.1. Notio 171. 3.2. Divinatory and 'scientific' astrology 179 3.3. Ptolemaic astrology 182 3.4. Arabic astrology 185 Part Two: Ficino and Determinism 3.5. 'The affinity of nature' 190 3.6. The Disputatlo contra ludicium astrologorum 192 3.7. Fate and free-will 194 3.8. The rational soul 205 3.9. Contingency 208 3.10. Providence 209 3.11. 'Petty ogres' 212 3.12. Signification 215 3.13. Portents 220 3.14. Prediction 221 References to chapter three 231 CHAPTER FOUR: MARSILIO FICINO, THE SE(X)ND ORPHEUS Part One: Natural Magic 4.1. Ficino, doctor of souls 254 4.2. Spiritus 260 4.3. The alchernical conlunctio 263 4.4. Sympathetic magic in De vita coel I tus comparanda 268 4.5. Images 278 4.6. The power of words and song 281 Part Two: Musica Instrumenta1I 4.7. Orpheus redlvlvus 288 4.8. The Orphic hymns 292 4.9. Harmonia 296 4.10. Ficino as lrnprovvlsat ore 309 4.11. Performance practice 312 4.12. Musical form 323 References to chapter four 330 Appendix 1 368 Appendix 2 370 BIBLIOQAPHY 377 -3- A(NOWLEDG1ENTS I should like to thank the following people, without whose help, encouragement and constant faith in my work this thesis would never have been completed: Peter Arnmann, Dr. charles Burnett at the Warburg Institute, Noel Cobb, Geoffrey Cornelius, Graeme Tobyn and the Latin translation group at the Company of Astrologers, Darby Costello, Dr. Patrick Curry, Professor Joscelyn Godwin, Peter Kingsley, the Latin translation group of the School of Economic Science, Eva Loewe and the Lacemakers group of the London Convivium for Archetypal Studies, Dr. Thomas Moore, Andrew Mouldey, Linda Proud, Kathleen Raine, Anthony Rooley, Pfofessor Malcolm Thoup at the City University, and especially Philip Weller for many hours of discussion, translation and moral support. I grant powers of discretion to the University Librarian to allow this thesis to be copied in whole or in part without further reference to me. This permission covers only single copies made for study purposes, subject to normal conditions of acknowledgement. -4- ABSTRACT This thesis is structured in four substantial chapters with sub- sections. The first two cover the background to Ficino's thought, the second two present his own attitudes towards magic, astrology and music. chapter one is concerned with aspects of xnusica inundana as represented by Ficino's three main authorities, Plato, Hermes Trismegistus and Plotinus. Firstly I present the fundamental ideas underlying Ficino's mode of thought and musical practice: the structure of the cosmos, Pythagorean harmonia arid the human soul as microcosm, concluding with the nature of Platonic wisdom. Secondly I consider the role of Hermes and the Hermetic texts with their emphasis on intuitive revelation, aichemical transformation and the imagination. From, this synthesis of the intellectual and the intuitive emerges Plotinus, whose understanding of cosmic sympathy and resonance has profound implications for a significatory attitude towards astrology. chapter two moves on to musica humana, and the magical means by which the Pythagorean and Platonic traditions aspired to bring the human soul into harmony with the cosmos. I discuss the nature of magic and mysticism, of occult ritual and the value of a symbolic mode of perception. The first half deals with Platonic and Plotinian attitudes towards magic, which were predominantly spiritual; the second half considers the practical magical rituals of theurgy, as revealed through the writings of the neo-platonists Iainblichus and Proclus and the Chaldaean Oracles. The central notion, that of time and its two orders, leads to a consideration of astrology as divination and a conclusion on the way of being and perception on which the efficacy of 'magic' depends. The second half of the thesis is directly concerned with Ficino's own synthesis of this material. Chapter three firstly presents his formulation of ways of knowing as found in the lamblichus Commentary, then considers the implications of this for his attitude towards astrology. The 'scientific' astrology of Ptolemy and the syncretic tradition of the Arabs leads to a presentation of the dilemma between the scientific and divinatory approaches. I then discuss Ficino's reaction to astrological determinism and his own views in relation to his Disputatio contra iudicium astrologorum and Commentary on Plotinus. Finally, chapter four brings both astrology and music Into focus as the ingredients of Ficino's practices of natural magic. I discuss his ideas concerning the nature of hearing, the function of the musician and the concepts of spiritus and anhrna mundi in connection with the sympathetic magic of De vita coelltus comparanda. Ficino's attitude towards the power of words and song and his rules for composing astrological music lead us to the final section on muslca Instrurnentalis - Ficino's role as the 'second Orpheus'. Contemporary anecdotes, the importance of Orpheus as a model and the rediscovery of the Orphic hymns precede a more historical discussion of Ficino as a music theorist and improvisor within the context of 15th century Italian musical culture. I speculate on his instrument, Renaissance performance practice and musical repertoire, concluding with examples of relevant musical forms. -5- It1TROD(JCTI ON In the Prooeiium to his great Tbeologla Platonica, Ficino tells the reader how he has felt called upon to explain his synthesis of Platonism and Cristianity to those who "separate the study of philosophy from holy religion".(l) Ficino's vocation was to bring theory and practice, intellect arid will, knowledge and experience into a harmony which transcended all opposition, and he sought to achieve this through a ritual, symbolic use of both astrology and music in a therapeutic context of natural magic'. -, The writing of this thesis has, in many ways, been a personal journey of deepening experience and psychological integration. Over the past seven years (a cycle of Saturn) Marsilio Ficino has assumed the role of a daimon, leading me to confront the most difficult and complex issues in my life and somehow asking to be put to rest. I embarked on this task without knowing exactly what he was asking of me - I now realise that the process has been an alchemical one of unification, with both internal and external purposes. As a practising astrologer I had always felt very strongly that Ficino's attitude towards astrology had been, on the whole, misrepresented by scholars, and that an attempt should be made to bridge the seemingly Irreconcilable gulf between the practising astrologers and the academic historians who write about it. In the course of translating Ficino's Dlsputatlo contra 1udlciu astrologorum, Llber de Sole and excerpts from his Couaentaries on Plot inus and lamblichus, I became aware that the essential problem was not one of wilful antagonism, but of the misapprehension of the mode of perception required to enter into Ficino's way of understanding the world. For Ficino, there had to be a way of combining, as In astrological practice itself, the fluid, subjective 'irrational' content of qualitative experience within the the firm outer framework of an objective structure. In this sense, I humbly attempt to imitate Ficino himself, who constantly sought to lead his readers to a participatory awareness of the dimension of life coiiuuonly regarded as 'occult, and to a valuation of that dimension as equally essential to psychological and physical health as that of rational objectivity. -6- In Plato and Hermes Trismegistus, Ficino found supreme representatives of the ways of being he strove to integrate: intellectual rigour and clarity and intuitive, mystical revelation. In the writings of Plotinus, thirty years later, he found a synthesis of the two and a supreme justification for astrology as a divinatory, not a 'pseudo-scientific', art. Out of this emerged his extraordinary feat of the imagination, the Liber de vita, in which the reader is encouraged towards health of mind, soul and body through a diet of philosophical contemplation, magical practices and rituals, astrological awareness and musical activity. rt is here that Ficino formulates his unique astrological music-therapy, a consideration of which will form the culmination of this thesis. The theme of the three musics, undana, huRana and instru.entalis(2) is a constant unifying motif throughout my work. For the Platonist, life itself is music - instrumental and vocal music merely imitating the true music of the cosmos, which finds its counterpart in the motions of the human soul. True music is harmony of thought, word and deed, and this may be fostered through the right use of audible music and song, if it is performed with a ritual attitude of religious intent. Ficino's 'new' therapeutic combination of music and astrology recovers a lost dimension - that of the divinatory 'moment' which allows the individual "a free participation in destiny".(3) This was of course a hall-mark of the Renaissance - a re-birth of faith in man's capacity to overcome the limitations of a fate-bound existence and be master of himself, in celebration of his own 'divine' potential. Ficino's vocation was to lead men to this realisation through exhorting them to "see with different eyes", to develop what we might term a symbolic attitude towards life, to understand that to see astrology and audible music as .etaphors for reality is to facilitate a harmonising of the soul which can only lead to true happiness. Bearing this in mind, I make no apology for frequent reference to the work of C.G. Jung, who has perhaps been the greatest twentieth- century spokesman for the very union of mind and soul to which Ficino dedicated his life. In Jung's writings I have found a constant source of Inspiration, clarifying and illuminating - In psychological terms - Ficino's aichemical quest. -7--