Imogene Coca Jewish? Start of Is What about Carl Reiner? AR 6936 Sys#: 000198449 LEO BAECK INSTITUTE Center for Jewish History 15 West 16th Street New York, NY 10011 Phone:(212)744-6400 Fax: (212)988-1305 Email: [email protected] URL: http://www.lbi.org I (c) 1993 Margaret Eisen 1/ //vv*je? - IMOGENE COCA JEWISH? WHAT ABOUT CARL REINER? IS Top Jewish funnymen have New Yorkers take comedy setrriiously. deluxe sandwiches na.ed after them at uptown delis and don't „eed to ta.e a number at deli counters-they te Just pushed to the front of the line. When I was growing up in mNew YYonrrkWss OQuueeeennss in the Fifties, my parents worked long hours iinn cthhoeiirr ssttoorree,, Sam's Luncheonette. It grueling business but one reli i-;eQff ffrr-onmm it was watthing was a comedy on TV on Saturday nights. Hy father, with his dark hair and blacR eyes, was still ha„„ted b, things that had happened to hi. ia Germany before the three of as came to America ia 1938. Evan so, he nearly fell out o£ his chair onto the floor laughing every Saturday night durrng especiaily when Caesar mimic.ed Germans. ,.Your Show of Shows'," laughed-his When my father iaughed at Caesar, his whole body speUs, he .apt Between iaughing stomach, eibows, and all. beiieve that anyone so funny he asked often, finding it hard to Jewish," he CO„ld be anything but Jewish. "But Car! Reiner is said, with some relief. "And Howard Morris is Jewish, too said as Reiner lifted up the skinny Morris to carry him offstage Everyone knew Jackie Gleason wasn't Jewish, but we never « missed his show anyway because my mother's cousin Marvin was his top writer. Whenever we watched Gleason's show we waited until the credits came on. When the name Marvin Marx flashed across the screen, we all said, "There it is," and turned off the TV. My father laughed uncontrollably whenever his favorite Jewish comedian, Jack Benny, did this routine: A holdup man points a gun at Benny, demanding, "Your money or your life." Benny stands there for a while, not saying anything. The holdup man says impatiently, "I said your money or your life." There's a long pause, then Benny says, "I'm thinking, I'm thinking." My father liked Groucho, who used to say, "When I came to this country I didn't have a dime in my pocket. Now I have a dime in my pocket." He laughed at a whole cackle of Jewish comedians of the Golden Age of Comedy: Jack Carter, Ed Wynn, Milton Berle, George Burns, Alan King, Myron Cohen, Eddie Cantor, Sam Levenson, Henny Youngman, Morey Amsterdam My father liked to say funny things himself, but once I saw him cet into trouble because of poor timing He had just heard the joke about two unsuccessful businessmen me of whom had collected insurance moneeyy for a fire while the <ther had collected twice as much for a flood. The first asked the second, "How do you make a flood?' >oon a fter that, while my father and I were in a lamp store the owner told us he was reducing prices to gi t rid of erchandise because his basement was flooded. My father asked m him, "How do you make a flood?" The angry owner actually pushed him out of the store. My father couldn't understand why the man got so mad; he thought the guy had no sense of humor. When he had time, my father read the six New York dailies on his newsstand. He particularly liked two opposing Jewish columnists: liberal Max Lerner of the New York Post and conservative Walter Lippmann o f the New York Herald Tribune Although he hardly ever went farther from home than down the block for a haircut, he liked to read the Jewish columnist Walter Winchell to follow the doings of prominent Jews like Billy Rose owner o f the Diamond Horseshoe; restaurateur "Toots" Shor; and Georgie Jessel, "Toastmaster General" of the United States. For a long time he followed the doings of Shirley Temple, convinced she was Jewish; it took a lot of arguing to convince him she wasn t After my parents sold their luncheonette, they finally had the time to go for a long wa Ik together every evening after supper My father, who never had much patience, used to walk so far ahead of my mother that neighbors -often asked her 'Mrs. Bloch, did you know that your husband is out walking, too? When he became became housebound with a stroke, my father turned into a news junkie, reading newspapers while listening to news on the radio and TV, all at the same time. In politics, he didn't care who was Jewish; he loved Harry Truman, distrusted Henry Kissinger. Despite his vast store of knowledge, he never felt smart. "Why do you always say you're not smart?" I asked him when he was 70. "Julius was the smart one," he said of a long-dead older brother. One day in 1980, when my father was 79, while I was visitinj my parents in Queens, my father fainted and was rushed to the hospital by ambulance. I went to see him as soon as visiting hours permitted. His ft dark eyes looked so sad. Because he couldn't talk, maybe from another stroke, I tried to cheer him up by telling him which doctors walking by looked Jewish and which didn't. He seemed only mildly interested. Instead, his attention went to two tiny leaves that I had discarded on the night table next to his bed. They were leaves I had inadvertently pulled from a hedge right outside the hospital He pointed to them, sort of asking me what they were I brought you flowers," I said He burst out laughing the old Sid Caesar laugh, but quieter and gave me a great big huj Later that night, after I left, his heart gave out and he died ##### End of Is Imogene Coca Jewish? What about Carl Reiner?