Vol. 41, 1998 Human Development Founded 1958 as ‘Vita Humana’ by H. Thomae (1958-1981) Former Editors: M.L. Langeveld (1963-1974) B.L. Neugarten (1963-1969), K.F. Riegel (1970-1977) W. Edelstein (1982-1987), J.A. Meacham (1977-1987) H. Sinclair (1982-1987), D. Kuhn (1988-1996) Editor Advisory Editors Barbara Rogoff, Curt Acredolo, Davis, Calif. Shirley Brice Heath, Santa Cruz, Calif. Paul B. Baltes, Berlin Stanford, Calif Linda Burton, Deanna Kuhn, New York, N.Y University Park, Pa. Jan Luczynski, Krakow Associate Editor Joseph J. Campos, Ingvar Lundberg, Géieborg Berkeley, Calif. Sharon Nelson-LeGall, Anne Colby, Menlo Park, Calif. Pittsburgh, Pa. Claes von Hofsten, William A. Corsaro, 4. Bame Nsamenang, Bamenda Umea/Charlottesville, Va. Bloomington, Ind. Pablo del Rio Pereda, Salamanca William Damon, Bernard Schneuwly, Geneva Stanford, Calif. Scania de Schonen, Paris Judith F. Dunn, London Esther Thelen, Emilia Ferreiro, Mexico City Bloomington, Ind Kurt W. Fischer, Michael Tomasello, Atlanta, Ga. Cambridge, Mass. Jaan Valsiner, Worcester, Mass Alan Fogel, Salt Lake City, Utah James Wertsch, St. Louis, Mo. Cynthia T. Garcia Coll, Sheldon H. White, Providence, R.I. Cambridge, Mass. Jacqueline J. Goodnow, Sydney James Youniss, Paul L. Harris, Oxford Washington, D.C. Giyoo Hatano, Tokyo Basel - Freiburg: Paris: London - New York: KARG E R New Delhi- Bang-k Sinogakpor e - Tok-y Syodne y KARGER All rights reserved Copyright 1998 by S. Karger AG No part of this publication may be translated into P.O. Box, CH-4009 Basel (Switzerland) other languages, reproduced or utilized in any Printed in Switzerland on acid-free paper by S. Karger form or by any means, electronic or mechanical Reinhardt Druck, Basel Medical and Scientific Publishers including photocopying, recording, microcopy Basel - Freiburg - Paris - London ing, or by any information storage and retrieval New York « New Delhi: Bangkok system, without permission in writing from the publisher or, in the case of photocopying, direct Singapore * Tok+y Syodne y payment of a specified fee to the Copyright Clear- ance Center (see “General Information’) Contents Vol. 41, 1998 Human Development No.1 Essay Review 134 A Time of Epistemic Transformation and Editor's Note Responsibility. Essay Review of Ethnography and Human Development: Context and Meaning in Behind the Scenes: Observations of the Editorial Social Inquiry by Richard Jessor, Anne Colby and Process Richard A. Shweder Rogoff, B. (Santa Cruz, Calif.) Falmagne, R.J. (Worcester, Mass.) Paper Children’s Theory of Mind: An Experiential Interpretation No. 3 Nelson, K.; Plesa, D.; Henseler, S. (New York, N.Y.) Paper Commentaries: Theory of Mind, Humpty Dumpty, and the Icebox Use and Misuse of the Culture Construct Wilde Astington, J.W. (Toronto) Baumrind, D. (Berkeley, Calif.) Theories behind Theories of Mind Lillard, A. (Charlottesville, Va.) Commentaries Cultural Practices, Oppression, and Morality Paper ruriel, E. (Berkeley, Calif.) Darwin’s Baby and Baby's Darwin: The Emergence of Postculturalism Mutual Recognition in Observational Research Nucci, L.; Neblo, M.A. (Chicago, Ill.) Conrad, R. (Amherst, Mass.) Paper Commentary: Constructing One's Self in the City of the Silent: A Preponderance of the Evidence Dialogue, Symbols, and the Role of ‘As-if’ in Self- Keegan, R.T. (Pleasantville, N.Y.) Development Josephs, I.E. (Magdeburg) Commentaries No. 2 Narrative, Play, and Development Bamberg, M. (Worchester, Mass.) Paper The Role of Pretense and Language in the Development of Self How to Grow a Baby: A Reevaluation of Image-Schema and Piagetiun Action Approaches to Géncii, A.; Gaskins, S. (Chicago, Ill.) Representation Miiller, U.; Overton, W.F. (Philadelphia, Pa.) Essay Reviews A Cultural-Historical Approach to Mind. Commentaries: Essay Review of Mind and Social Practice Selected Writings of Sylvia Scribner by Ethel Tobach Primacy of Action in Early Ontogeny Rachel Joffe Falmagne, Mary Brown Parlee, Rochat, P.; Striano, T. (Atlanta, Ga.) Laura M.W. Martin and Aggie Scribner Kapelman Babies Think before They Speak Hedegaard, M. (Aarhus) Mandler, J.M. (La Jolla, Calif.) Defining the ‘Radical Middle’. Essay Review of Rethinking Innateness: A Connectionist Perspective Reply: on Development by Jeffrey L. Elman, Elizabeth A. Bates, Mark H. Johnson, Action Theory of Mind and Representational Theory Annette Karmiloff-Smith, Domenico Parisi, and of Mind: Is Dialogue Possible? A Reply to Mandler, Kim Plunkett and Rochat and Striano Newcombe, N.S. (Philadelphia, Pa.) Miiller, U.; Overton, W.F. (Philadelphia, Pa.) KARG E R 1998 S. Karger AG, Basel Fax +41 61 306 12 34 Access to full text and tables of contents E-Mail [email protected] including tentative ones for forthcoming issues www.karger.com www.karger.com/journals/hde/hdecont.htm No. 4 No. 5-6 Paper Paper Individual and Collective Representations in Social Learning to Stand Alone: The Contemporary Context: A Modest Contribution to Resuming the American Transition to Adulthood in Cultural and Interrupted Project of a Sociocultural Historical Context Developmental Psychology Arnett, J.J. (College Park, Md.) Nicolopoulou, A.; Weintraub, J. (Bethlehem, Pa.) Commentaries Commentaries: Responsibility and Self-Respect: How Alone Do Institutions Are Real but Internalization Is Not Americans Stand? Olson, D.R. (Toronto) Modell, J. (Pittsburgh, Pa./Providence, R.1.) Dissolving Boundaries between Collective and The Meaning of Independence and Responsibility Individual Representations: A Welcome Whiting, B.B. (West Tisbury, Mass.) Contribution to Developmental Psychology The Social Criteria of Adulthood Azmitia, M. (Santa Cruz, Calif.) Schlegel, A. (Tucson, Ariz.) Paper Paper 245 The Study of Social Interaction in Educational Settings: Accomplishments and Unresolved Issues When Solo Activity Is Not Privileged: Participation and Internalization Models of Development Mehan, H. (La Jolla, Calif.) Matusov, E. (Newark, Del.) Commentary. Commentaries What's Different about Learning in Schools as Compared to Family and Community Settings? Dualisms Displaced: From Crusades to Analytic Distinctions Paradise, R. (Santa Cruz, Calif.) Valsiner, J. (Worcester, Mass.) internalization, Participation, and Ethnocentrism Essay Reviews Carelli, M.G. (Umea) 279 The Development of Social Responsibility as a Meaning Making Process: The Role of Schools Essay Review of Children’s Social Consciousness Essay Reviews and the Development of Social Responsibility by A Paradigm Shift in the Study of Development S. Berman Essay Review of Emerging Minds by R.S. Siegler Yates, M. (Hollywood, Calif.) Granott, N. (Richardson, Tex.) Face Off! On the Baby and the Bath Water: Essay Review of The Psychology ofF acial Ecological Approaches to Development Expression Essay Review of Evolving Explanations of Edited by J. Russell and M. Fernandez-Dols Development. Edited by C. Dent-Read and Camras, L.A. (Chicago, Ill.) P. Zukow-Goldring Completing the Construction of the Life Span Bremner, J.G. (Lancaster) Essay Review of Multiple Paths of Midlife if It Has a History, You Can't Categorize It Development by Margie E. Lachman and Essay Review of Metaphysics and the Origin of Jacquelyn Boone James (eds.) Species by Michael Ghiselin Lerner, R.M. (Chestnut Hill, Mass.) Charlesworth, W.R. (Minneapolis, Minn.) Acknowledgment Author Index Vol. 41, 1998 Subject Index Vol. 41, 1998 Human Development Vol. 41, 1998 Contents