HISTORY OF POLITICAL ECONOMY ADvisorRY Boarb: Jiirgen Backhaus, Anthony Brewer, Bruce J. Caldwell, David Collard, Barry Gordon, Peter Groenewegen, Robert F. Hébert, Abra- ham Hirsch, Terence Hutchison, Don Lavoie, Axel Leijonhufvud, Philip Mirowski, D. E. Moggridge, Mary Morgan, Laurence S. Moss, Don Pa- tinkin, Malcolm Rutherford, Margaret Schabas, William O. Thweatt Epitor: Craufurd D. W. Goodwin ASSOCIATE Epitrors: A. W. Coats, Neil de Marchi, E. Roy Weintraub Book Review Epitor: S. Todd Lowry ASSISTANT TO THE Epitor: Jeff C. Roggenbuck Volume 23 DURHAM, NORTH CAROLINA DUKE UNIVERSITY PRESS 199] 780 History of Political Economy 23:4 (1991) Contents of Volume 23 ARTICLES Ancil, Ralph E. and Antecedents and Implications of Hirsch’s David R. Hakes Positional Goods Andvig, Jens Christopher Verbalism and Definitions in Interwar Theoretical Macroeconomics Barkai, Haim Schmoller on Money and the Monetary Dimension of Economics Birken, Lawrence Lenin’s Revolution in Time, Space and Economics and Its Implications: An Analysis of Imperialism Blaug, Mark Second Thoughts on the Keynesian Revolution Brems, Hans Price Theory: A Stylized History Brems, Hans Addendum to Jérn Henrik Petersen Brewer, Anthony Economic Growth and Technical Change: John Rae’s Critique of Adam Smith Buurman, Gary B. A Comparison of the Single Tax Proposals of Henry George and the Physiocrats Cartwright, Nancy Replicability, Reproducibility, and Robustness: Comments on Harry Collins Cesarano, Filippo De Viti de Marco as a Monetary Economist Cetina, Karin Knorr Epistemic Cultures: Forms of Reason in Science Chapple, Simon Did Kalecki Get There First? The Race for the General Theory Collins, H. M. The Meaning of Replication and the Science of Economics Cottrell, Allin and “Natural Rate” Mutations: Keynes, Michael Syron Lawlor Leijonhufvud and the Wicksell Connection Edgell, Stephen and John Rae and Thorstein Veblen on Conspicuous Rick Tilman Consumption: A Neglected Intellectual Relationship Ekelund, Jr., Robert B. and Geometric Analogies and Market Demand Mark Thornton Estimation: Dupuit and the French Contribution Endres, A. M. Menger, Wieser, BOhm-Bawerk and the Analysis of Economizing Behavior Green, Francis Marx, Malthus, and Wages: A Comment on Cottrell and Darity History of Political Economy 23:4 (1991) Groll, Shalom See Orzech, Ze’ev B. Hakes, David R. See Ancil, Ralph E. Hammond, J. Daniel Frank Knight’s Antipositivism Heertje, Arnold Three Unpublished Letters by David Ricardo Houghton, John W. Cultural Theory as Applied to the History of Economic Thought: A Case Study Janssen, Maarten C. W. What is This Thing Called Microfoundations? Koropeckyj, I. S. The Contribution of Mykhailo Tuhan-Baranovsky to Monetary Economics Kurer, Oskar John Stuart Mill and the Welfare State Lawlor, Michael Syron See Cottrell, Allin Llombart, Vicent The Discurso sobre el modo de fomentar la industria popular and the Discurso sobre el fomento de la industria popular, Two Editions of the Same Work by Campomanes: A Reply to D. R. Street Moss, Laurence S. Thomas Hobbes’s Influence on David Hume: The Emergence of a Public Choice Tradition Niehans, Jiirg Bohm-Bawerk versus John Doe: The Interest Controversies O Grada, Cormac An Early Irish Reaction to Malthus Orzech, Ze’ev B. and Otto Bauer’s Business Cycle Theory: An Shalom Groll Integration of Marxian Elements Perrotta, Cosimo Is the Mercantilist Theory of the Favorable Balance of Trade Really Erroneous? Petersen, Jorn Henrik A Reply to My Commentators Prasch, Robert E. The Ethics of Growth in Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations Prendergrast, Renee Cantillon and the Emergence of the Theory of Profit Shionoya, Yuichi Schumpeter on Schmoller and Weber: A Methodology of Economic Sociology Skaggs, Neil T. John Fullarton’s Law of Reflux and Central Bank Policy Sockwell, W. D. Contributions of Henry Brougham to Classical Political Economy Stein, Bruno Pay-As-You-Go, Partial Prefunding, and Full Funding in American Social Security Street, Donald R. The Discurso sobre el modo de fomentar la industria popular and the Discurso sobre el fomento de la industria popular: A Reply to Vicent Llombart 782 History of Political Economy 23:4 (1991) Thornton, Mark See Ekeland, Jr., Robert B. Tilman, Rick See Edgell, Stephen Waterman, A. M. C. “The Canonical Classical Model of Political Economy” in 1808, as Viewed from 1825: Thomas Chalmers on the “Natural Resources” Weintraub, E. Roy Reconstructing Economic Knowledge Weintraub, E. Roy Allais, Stability, and Liapunov Theory Book REVIEWS Alter, Carl Menger and the Origins of Austrian Economics (Vaughn) Augello, et.al., eds., Le cattedre di economia politica in Italia (Hyse) Balabkins, Not by Theory Alone: The Economics of Gustav von Schmoller and Its Legacy to America (Betz) Clarke, The Keynesian Revolution in the Making: 1924-1936, and Meltzer, Keynes's Monetary Thoughi: A Different Interpretation (Bateman) Feiwel ed., Joan Robinson and Modern Economic Theory (vol. 1); and Feiwel ed., The Economics of Imperfect Competition and Employment: Joan Robinson and Beyond (vol. Il) (Harcourt) Garvey and Garvey, Economic Law and Economic Growth: Antitrust, Regulation and the American Growth System (Gonce) Goldman, ed., The Blind Victorian Henry Fawcett and British Liberalism (Polkinghorn) Hayes, Industry and Ideology: IG Farben in the Nazi Era (van der Linden) Hirsch and de Marchi, Milton Friedman: Economics in Theory and Practice (Hammond) Hirsch and de Marchi, Milton Friedman: Economics in Theory and Practice (Frazer) Hollander, Classical Economics (Young) Howsen, ed., The Collected Papers of James Meade, vols. 1-2 (Darity) Immler, Vom Wert der Natur (Karsten) Ingrao and Israel, The Invisible Hand: Economic Equilibrium in the History of Science (Walker) Lawson, et al, eds., Kaldor’s Political Economy (Blitch) Morgan, The History of Economics (Kapuria-Foreman) Neufeldt, The Economist: Henry Thoreau and Enterprise (Brandis) Perelman, Marx’s Crises Theory: Scarcity, Labor, and Finance (Pack) Tarbuck, Bukharin’s Theory of Equilibrium (Clark) Turner, Joan Robinson and the Americans; (Harcourt) Vaggi, The Economics of Francois Quesnay (Pressman) Walker, ed., Perspectives on the History of Economic Thought (Brandis) West, Adam Smith and Modern Economics: From Market Behaviour to Public Choice (Samuels) Whitaker, ed., Centenary Essays on Alfred Marshall (Henderson)