<DOCINFOAUTHOR""TITLE"Higher-OrderTheoriesofConsciousness:AnAnthology"SUBJECT"AdvancesinConsciousnessResearch,Volume56"KEYWORDS""SIZEHEIGHT"220"WIDTH"150"VOFFSET"4"> Higher-OrderTheoriesofConsciousness AdvancesinConsciousnessResearch AdvancesinConsciousnessResearchprovidesaforumforscholarsfromdifferentscientific disciplinesandfieldsofknowledgewhostudyconsciousnessinitsmultifacetedaspects.Thus theSerieswillinclude(butnotbelimitedto)thevariousareasofcognitivescience,including cognitivepsychology,linguistics,brainscienceandphilosophy.TheorientationoftheSeries istowarddevelopingnewinterdisciplinaryandintegrativeapproachesfortheinvestigation, descriptionandtheoryofconsciousness,aswellasthepracticalconsequencesofthisresearch fortheindividualandsociety. SeriesA:TheoryandMethod.Contributionstothedevelopmentoftheoryandmethodin thestudyofconsciousness. Editor MaximI.Stamenov BulgarianAcademyofSciences EditorialBoard DavidChalmers EarlMacCormac UniversityofArizona DukeUniversity GordonG.Globus GeorgeMandler UniversityofCaliforniaatIrvine UniversityofCaliforniaatSanDiego RayJackendoff JohnR.Searle BrandeisUniversity UniversityofCaliforniaatBerkeley ChristofKoch PetraStoerig CaliforniaInstituteofTechnology UniversitätDüsseldorf StephenKosslyn †FranciscoVarela HarvardUniversity C.R.E.A.,EcolePolytechnique,Paris Volume56 Higher-OrderTheoriesofConsciousness:AnAnthology EditedbyRoccoJ.Gennaro Higher-Order Theories of Consciousness An Anthology Editedby Rocco J. Gennaro IndianaStateUniversity JohnBenjaminsPublishingCompany Amsterdam(cid:1)/(cid:1)Philadelphia TM Thepaperusedinthispublicationmeetstheminimumrequirements 8 ofAmericanNationalStandardforInformationSciences–Permanence ofPaperforPrintedLibraryMaterials,ansiz39.48-1984. LibraryofCongressCataloging-in-PublicationData Higher-ordertheoriesofconsciousness:ananthology/editedbyRoccoJ. Gennaro. p. cm.(AdvancesinConsciousnessResearch,issn1381–589X;v. 56) Includesbibliographicalreferencesandindexes. 1.Consciousness.2.Self-consciousness.3.Thoughtandthinking.4. Phenomenologicalpsychology.I.Gennaro,RoccoJ.II.Series. B105 C477H54 2004 126-dc22 2004041066 isbn9027251916(Eur.)/1588114953(US)(Hb;alk.paper) isbn9027251924(Eur.)/1588114961(US)(Pb;alk.paper) ©2004–JohnBenjaminsB.V. Nopartofthisbookmaybereproducedinanyform,byprint,photoprint,microfilm,or anyothermeans,withoutwrittenpermissionfromthepublisher. JohnBenjaminsPublishingCo.·P.O.Box36224·1020meAmsterdam·TheNetherlands JohnBenjaminsNorthAmerica·P.O.Box27519·Philadelphiapa19118-0519·usa Table of contents Contributors ix Acknowledgmentsanddedication xi Chapter1 Higher-ordertheoriesofconsciousness:Anoverview 1 RoccoJ.Gennaro PartI: Defendersofhigher-ordertheories Chapter2 Varietiesofhigher-ordertheory 17 DavidM.Rosenthal Chapter3 Higher-orderthoughts,animalconsciousness,and misrepresentation:AreplytoCarruthersandLevine 45 RoccoJ.Gennaro Chapter4 Higher-orderglobalstates(HOGS):Analternativehigher-order modelofconsciousness 67 RobertVanGulick Chapter5 ThesuperiorityofHOPtoHOT 93 WilliamG.Lycan Chapter6 HOPoverFOR,HOTtheory 115 PeterCarruthers  Tableofcontents Chapter7 Ahigherordersyntacticthought(HOST)theoryofconsciousness 137 EdmundT.Rolls Chapter8 Assumptionsofasubjectivemeasureofconsciousness:Threemappings 173 ZoltánDienesandJosefPerner PartII: Criticsofthehigher-orderapproach Chapter9 Whatphenomenalconsciousnessislike 203 AlexByrne Chapter10 EitherFORorHOR:Afalsedichotomy 227 RobertW.Lurz Chapter11 AcoldlookatHOTtheory 255 WilliamSeager Chapter12 HOTtheoriesofconsciousness:Moresadtalesofphilosophical intuitionsgoneastray 277 ValerieGrayHardc astle Chapter13 Afewthoughtstoomany? 295 WilliamS.Robinson Chapter14 Higherorderrepresentationinamentalisticmetatheory 315 DonelsonE.Dulany Tableofcontents  Chapter15 Ouch!Anessayonpain 339 ChristopherS.Hill Indexofnames 363 Indexoftopics 365 Contributors AlexByrne ChristopherS.Hill DepartmentofLinguistics DepartmentofPhilosophy andPhilosophy BrownUniversity MassachusettsInstituteofTechnology Providence,RI02912,USA Cambridge,MA02139,USA [email protected] [email protected] PeterCarruthers RobertW.Lurz DepartmentofPhilosophy DepartmentofPhilosophy UniversityofMaryland BrooklynCollege CollegePark,MD20742,USA 2900BedfordAvenue [email protected] Brooklyn,NY11210,USA [email protected] ZoltánDienes DepartmentofPsychology UniversityofSussex WilliamG.Lycan BrightonBN19QG,UK DepartmentofPhilosophy [email protected] UniversityofNorthCarolina atChapelHill DonelsonE.Dulany ChapelHill,NC27599,USA DepartmentofPsychology [email protected] UniversityofIllinois,Urbana-Champaign 603EastDanielStreet Champaign,IL61820,USA JosefPerner [email protected] DepartmentofPsychology UniversityofSalzburg RoccoJ.Gennaro Hellbrunnerstrasse34 DepartmentofPhilosophy A-5020Salzburg,AUSTRIA RootHallA-138D [email protected] IndianaStateUniversity TerreHaute,IN47809,USA [email protected] WilliamS.Robinson DepartmentofPhilosophy ValerieGrayHardcastle andReligiousStudies DepartmentofPhilosophy 402CattHall VirginiaPolytechnicInstitute IowaStateUniversity Blacksburg,VA24061,USA Ames,IA50011,USA [email protected] [email protected]  Contributors EdmundT.Rolls WilliamSeager DepartmentofExperimentalPsychology DivisionofHumanities/Philosophy UniversityofOxford UniversityofTorontoatScarborough SouthParksRoad Scarborough,Ontario OxfordOX13UD,UK CANADAM1C1A4 [email protected] [email protected] DavidM.Rosenthal RobertVanGulick. DepartmentofPhilosophy DepartmentofPhilosophy andCognitiveScience 541HallofLanguages GraduateCenter,CityUniversity SyracuseUniversity ofNewYork Syracuse,NY13244,USA 3655thAvenue [email protected] NewYork,NY10016,USA [email protected]