The Johns Hopkins University Press Director’s Circle Book for 2011 The Johns Hopkins University Press gratefully acknowl- edges members of the 2011 Director’s Circle for supporting the publication of works such as Hart Crane’s Poetry. Anonymous Alfred and Muriel Berkeley John and Bonnie Boland Darlene Bookoff Jack Goellner and Barbara Lamb Charles and Elizabeth Hughes John T. Irwin John and Kathleen Keane Mary L. Kelly X. J. and Dorothy Kennedy Eric R. Papenfuse and Catherine A. Lawrence Jane Wilson McWilliams Anders Richter Guenter B. Risse R. Champlin and Debbie Sheridan Winston and Marilyn Tabb Daun and Patricia Van Ee This page intentionally left blank John T. Irwin Hart Crane's Poetry "Appollinaire lived in París, I live in Cleveland, Ohio" The Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore © 2011 The Johns Hopkins University Press All rights reserved. Published 2011 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 The Johns Hopkins University Press 2715 North Charles Street Baltimore, Maryland 21218-4363 www.press.jhu.edu Grateful acknowledgment is made to Word & Image, Raritan Review, and the Regents of The University of Arizona for permission to use revised versions of the following previously published material: “Foreshadowing and Foreshortening: The Prophetic Vision of Origins in Hart Crane’s The Bridge,” Word & Image 1 ( July–September 1985): 288–312; “Hart Crane’s The Bridge, I,” Raritan Review 8 (Spring 1989): 70–88; “Hart Crane’s The Bridge, II,” Raritan Review 9 (Summer 1989): 99–113; and “The Triple Archetype: The Presence of Faust in The Bridge,” Arizona Quarterly 50 (Spring 1994): 51–73. “Back Home Again in Indiana: Hart Crane’s The Bridge” was originally published in the Raritan Review and then reprinted in Romantic Revolutions: Criticism and Theory, edited by Kenneth Johnston and Herbert Marks (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1990), 269–96. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Irwin, John T. Hart Crane’s poetry : “Appollinaire lived in Paris, I live in Cleveland, Ohio” / John T. Irwin. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. isbn-13: 978-1-4214-0221-5 (hardcover : acid-free paper) isbn-10: 1-4214-0221-1 (hardcover : acid-free paper) 1. Crane, Hart, 1899–1932—Criticism and interpretation. I. Title. ps3505.r272z725 2011 811'.52—dc22 2011004060 A catalog record for this book is available from the British Library. Special discounts are available for bulk purchases of this book. For more information, please contact Special Sales at 410-516-6936 or As always, for Meme, my beloved. And for the outrageous Harold This page intentionally left blank Contents Preface xi Part One. The Bridge § 1 The Pictorial and the Poetic; The Bridge as a Prophetic Vision of Origins 3 § 2 The Visual Structure of Prophetic Vision; a Simultaneous Glimpse Before and Behind 7 § 3 Spengler’s Reading of Perspective as a Culture-Symbol 23 § 4 The Bridge and the Paintings in the Sistine Chapel; Moses and Jesus: Columbus and Whitman; Joseph Stella; El Greco’s Agony in the Garden; the Grail; Dionysus and Jesus 29 § 5 Counterpoint in The Bridge 36 § 6 Foreshadowing and Lateral Foreshadowing; the Grail Quest; Eliot’s The Waste Land 46 § 7 The Return to Origin; the Total Return to the Womb; the Primal Scene; Vision and Invisibility; the Dual Identification 53 § 8 The Reversal of the Figures of Father and Mother in “Indiana”; Crane’s Dream of the Black Man by the River; Crane’s Quarrel with His Father; the Composition of “Black Tambourine” 66 § 9 Crane’s Dream of His Mother’s Trunk in the Attic 76 § 10 Fantasies of Return to the Womb and the Primal Scene; Three Dimensions Reduced to Two as a Sign of Body Transcendence; the Triple Archetype; Goethe’s Faust; Plato’s Cave Allegory as a Sublimated Womb Fantasy; Helen as Mother; the Influence of Williams and Nietzsche; Demeter, Kore¯, and the Amerindian Corn Mother 87 § 11 Building the Virgin; Crane’s “To Liberty”; Lazarus’s “The New Colossus”; Helen and Psyche; Astraea and the Constellation Virgo; Demeter and Kore¯; the Virgin Mary and Queen Elizabeth I 102 § 12 The Education of Henry Adams; Arnold’s “Stanzas from the Grande Chartreuse”; Wandering between Two Worlds; Seneca’s Medea; Whitman and the Rebound Seed 112 § 13 “Three Songs”; Golden Hair; “Quaker Hill” and the Motherly Artist; the Return of the Golden Age; Astraea and Atlantis 121 § 14 Epic Predecessors: Aeneas and Dido; Survival through a Part- Object; Stellar Translation and the Golden-Haired Grain 125 § 15 The Historical Pocahontas and the Mythical Quetzalcoatl; Prescott, Spence, and D. H. Lawrence as Influences on The Bridge; Waldo Frank’s Our America and the Image of Submergence 135 § 16 Nietzsche and the Return of the Old Gods; Zarathustra and Quetzalcoatl; the Eagle and the Serpent; the Dance 148 § 17 The Aeneid, Book 6, and “The Tunnel”; “Cutty Sark” and Glaucus in viii Ovid; Burns’s “Tam o’ Shanter”; Glaucus in Keats’s Endymion 158 Contents § 18 Time and Eternity in “Cutty Sark”; Stamboul Rose, Atlantis Rose, and Dante’s Rose; Moby-Dick and “Cutty Sark” 163 § 19 The Historical Cutty Sark; Hero and Leander; Jason and the Argo; Dante and the Argo 170 § 20 Constellations and The Bridge 178 § 21 Constellations Continued; Panis Angelicus 186 § 22 Time and Eternity; Temporal Narrative and Spatial Configuration; the Bridge as Memory Place; “Atlantis”; One Arc Synoptic of All Times 196 § 23 “Atlantis” and the Image of Flight; Shelley’s “To a Skylark”; Pater and the Tears of Dionysus 207 § 24 Love and Light; Love-as-Bridgeship; Pater and Botticelli’s Venus; Venus and the Rainbow; Foam-Born; Pyramids and Fire; From Ritual to Romance; Venus and Adonis 212 § 25 Three Structures; the Visualization of the Womb Fantasy in The Last Judgement ; the Transumptive Relationship 224 § 26 Michelangelo’s Self-Portrait; Marsyas and the Suffering Artist 233 Part Two. White Buildings and “The Broken Tower” § 1 “Legend,” “Black Tambourine,” “Emblems of Conduct,” “My Grandmother’s Love Letters,” “Sunday Morning Apples” 245 § 2 “Praise for an Urn,” “Garden Abstract,” “Stark Major,” “Chaplinesque” 255 § 3 “Pastorale,” “In Shadow,” “The Fernery,” “North Labrador” 268 § 4 “Repose of Rivers,” “Paraphrase,” “Possessions” 273 § 5 “Lachrymae Christi” 289 § 6 “Passage” 304 § 7 “The Wine Menagerie,” “Recitative” 313 § 8 “For the Marriage of Faustus and Helen” 326 § 9 “At Melville’s Tomb,” “Voyages I, II, III” 343 § 10 “Voyages IV, V, VI” 359 § 11 “The Broken Tower” 371 Notes to Part One: The Bridge 385 Works Cited 399 Index 405 ix Contents