O R L O IV B IE IN R B W R E IG L A L N (ER &D E D S ) ARCHAEOLOGY OF A R S A LT C H A E Salt is an invisible object for research in archaeology. However, ancient O L writings, ethnographic studies and the evidence of archaeological O exploitation highlight it as an essential reference for humanity. Both an G edible product and a crucial element for food preservation, it has been used Y by the fi rst human settlements as soon as food storage appeared (Neolithic). O F As far as the history of food habits (both nutrition and preservation) is concerned, the identifi cation and the use of that resource certainly proves a S A revolution as meaningful as the domestication of plants and wild animals. L On a global scale, the development of new economic forms based on the T management of food surplus went along an increased use of saline resources through a specifi c technical knowledge, aimed at the extraction of salt from ARCHAEOLOGY OF its natural supports. Considering the variety of former practices observed until now, a pluralist S A LT approach based on human as well as environmental sciences is required. It allows a better knowledge of the historical interactions between our societies and this “white gold”, which are well-known from the Middle-Ages, but more hypothetical for earlier times. Th is publication intends to present the most recent progresses in the fi eld of salt archaeology in Europe and beyond; it also exposes various APPROACHING AN INVISIBLE PAST approaches allowing a thorough understanding of this complex and many- faceted subject. Th e complementary themes dealt with in this book, the EDITED BY broad chronological and geographical focus, as well as the relevance of the ROBIN BRIGAND AND OLIVIER WELLER results presented, make this contribution a key synthesis of the most recent research on this universal topic. ISSBNid 97e8-s90t-o88n90e-30 3P-8ress S ISBN: 978-90-8890-303-8 id e s t o n 9 789088 903038 e Brigand_cover_v1.indd 1 3-2-2015 11:59:17 This is a digital offprint from: Robin Brigand and Olivier Weller (eds) 2015: Archaeology of Salt. Approaching an invisible past. Leiden: Sidestone Press. © 2015, individual authors Published by Sidestone Press, Leiden www.sidestone.com ISBN 978-90-8890-303-8 PDF e-book: ISBN 978-90-8890-304-5 Lay-out & cover design: Sidestone Press Photograph cover: Salt layers in the Târgu Ocna salt mine (county Bacău, Romania) Olivier Weller 2009 Contents Foreword 7 Techniques of salt making: from China (Yangtze River) to their 13 world context Pierre Gouletquer and Olivier Weller Pre-Columbian salt production in Colombia – searching for the evidence 29 Marianne Cardale Schrimpff The salt from the Alghianu beck (Vrancea County, Romania): 47 a multifaceted ethnoarchaeological approach Marius Alexianu, Felix Adrian Tencariu, Andrei Asăndulesei, Olivier Weller, Robin Brigand, Ion Sandu, Gheorghe Romanescu, Roxana-Gabriela Curcă, Ștefan Caliniuc and Mihaela Asăndulesei First salt making in Europe: a global overview from Neolithic times 67 Olivier Weller A complex relationship between human and natural landscape: 83 a multidisciplinary approach to the study of the roman saltworks in “Le Vignole-Interporto” (Maccarese, Fiumicino-Roma) Maria Cristina Grossi, Sandra Sivilli, Antonia Arnoldus-Huyzendveld, Alessandra Facciolo, Maria Lucrezia Rinaldi, Daria Ruggeri and Cinzia Morelli Ancient salt exploitation in the Polish lowlands: recent research 103 and future perspectives Józef Bednarczyk, Joanna Jaworska, Arkadiusz Marciniak and Maria Ruiz Del Arbol Moro Prehistoric salt production in Japan 125 Takamune Kawashima New data and observations related with exploitation and transport 139 of salt in Transylvanian prehistory (Romania) Gheorghe Lazarovici and Cornelia-Magda Lazarovici Spatial analysis for salt archaeology: a case study from 157 Moldavian Neolithic (Romania) Robin Brigand and Olivier Weller The salt of Rome. Remarks on the production, trade and consumption 183 in the north-western provinces Ulrich Stockinger Competing on unequal terms: saltworks at the turn of the 199 Christian era Thomas Saile Salt in Roman Britain 211 Isabella Tsigarida Authors info 221 First salt making in Europe: a global overview from Neolithic times Olivier WELLER CNRS, UMR  8215 Trajectoires, Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne, Maison de l’Archéologie et de l’Ethnologie, 21 allée de l’Université, F-92023 Nanterre cedex, France Abstract. This paper deals with the origin of salt production and discusses different approaches ranging from technology, ethnoarchaeology and paleoenvironmental studies to chemical analyses. Starting from the current research on the Neolithic exploitation of salt in Europe, we examine the types and nature of the salt resources (sea water, salt springs, soil or rock), the diversity of archaeological evidence as forms of salt working. We also scrutinize the types of production for these early forms of salt exploitation, with or without the use of crudely-fired clay vessels (briquetage). Finally, we contextualize the socio-economic dimensions and highlight both the diversity of salt products, as well as their characteristics, which go well beyond dietary roles. Keywords. Salt production, Neolithic, Europe, methodology, archaeological evidence. Résumé. Cet article traite de l’origine de la production de sel et aborde différentes approches allant de la technologie, l’ethnoarchéologie, les études paléoenvironnementales aux analyses chimiques. A partir des recherches actuelles sur l’exploitation néolithique du sel en Europe, nous examinons les types et la nature des ressources en sel (eau de mer, source salée, sol ou sel gemme), la diversité des indices archéologiques comme les formes d’exploitation. Nous examinons également les types de production pour ces premières formes d’exploitation du sel, avec ou sans utilisation de terre cuite (briquetage). Pour finir, nous cherchons à mieux définir les dimensions socio-économiques de ces productions ainsi la diversité des sels produits qui dépassent de loin le seul rôle alimentaire. Mots clés. Production de sel, Néolithique, Europe, méthodologie, indices archéologiques. weller 67 If today salt is an ordinary good, a practically inexhaustible substance, both alimentary and industrial, this hasn’t been the case in countless pre-industrial societies. It is at least since the Neolithic that European agropastoral societies have sought to extract it from its natural sources, or more precisely since the 6th millennium BC. Nowadays we likely associate the exploitation of salt with coastal salt marshes. Yet a great share of the production still comes from artificial heating of brine or simply from the extraction of rock salt. If regular table salt, or sodium chloride, seems an inexhaustible natural commodity, neither its geographic distribution, nor its physical forms are uniform. Salt is found in either solid (rocks, outcrops, earths, sands, plants) or liquid form (sea or spring waters, bodily fluids). Furthermore, it is present in highly variable concentrations, ranging from a few grams for blood or urine, to almost 200 g/l for certain salt springs or enclosed seas, attaining an average of 30 g/l for oceanic waters. It crystallizes at concentrations of around 330 grams per litre of water. Faced with this disparity in concentration and distribution, humanity resorted to a wide assortment of extraction techniques. Nonetheless, apart from the exploitation of rock salt, salt extraction most often consists, in some cases after the lixiviation of a salty solid, of processing a liquid by subjecting it to a natural (solar salt) or artificial (ignigenous salt) evaporation process, until crystallisation is achieved (see Gouletquer and Weller, in this volume, fig. 1). The grained salt obtained can be then used as such or packaged as hard blocks of standardised shapes and weights. In this form, it can be preserved or readily transported and then traded over long distances. The diversity of methods observed across the world seem intimately linked to the environmental contexts and the type of saliferous resources exploited; it also mirrors the quality of the sought product (type of salts, salted ashes, grained salt, or salt blocks), and to the specificities of the demand and of the social context (Gouletquer et al. 1994). The issue of origins If archaeologists and scholars have examined the ancient mines or the abundant debris of fired clay (briquetage) from after the Iron Age up to the 18th century, research on the origins of salt exploitation, harking to the Early Neolithic, has not yet even commenced. At a first glance, one can easily understand why, in the absence of the very object of research, the issue of salt exploitation remained poorly addressed for the prehistoric period. However, if nothing has remained of the product, the archaeological realities around salt exploitation have been ascertained in the field with the help of various types of evidences, which inform us non-vicariously of the techniques employed (catchments, pottery or charcoal accumulations), or more indirectly of their impact on the environment, the territorial organisation, or the circulation of goods. Besides the discussion on the archaeological remains themselves, it is the general question of the function of salt which emerges. Indeed, how can we explain the appearance of this new exploitation of the natural environment? What were 68 archaeology of salt the reasons for which the simple occasional collecting from a furrowed rock or from the edge of a salt spring were not sufficient anymore to these early Neolithic salt-producing communities, which now set themselves to separate the salt from its natural support (water, rocks, soils or plants) and, as such, to produce a hard, transportable and shaped salt? While many researchers have turned to biology and psychology to answer this question, others have looked for answers in ethnographic investigations. Indeed, does the biological hypotheses, according to which salt was an essential nutritional element within the new Neolithic alimentary diet, suffices to explain its exploitation? In order to confront the hypotheses of the nutritionists with the archaeological realities, and to characterise the production of salt and its socio-economic implications, it is necessary to develop a pluridisciplinary approach and to multiply the ethnographic, historical, environmental, archaeometric, and experimental observations. It was therefore necessary to make use of several methods that, conjoined, can shed light on the archaeological realities. By illustrating our set goal with various case studies from across Europe, we seek to tackle the issue of salt exploitation from the methodological standpoint of different approaches that may be incurred, and of the elements that so far seem diagnostic. Also, we will see how the study of known or newly brought to light vestiges and of relative archaeological contexts can allow a reconsideration of the diversity of functions performed by salt, in which alimentation is not necessary the cornerstone. Archaeological evidences Whether or not one adheres to the biological argument, prehistorians have only recently considered other possible functions of salt in these early agricultural societies. Yet we know that the scarcity of exploitable natural resources meant that at specific times in history salt played an important economic and social role, prior to being bestowed with the multiple day-to-day applications we are now fully aware of (preservative, adjuvant for the dairy industry, tanning agent, metallurgy of precious metals, dye-fixing, medication…). Moreover, it has long been held that – just like with the production techniques of the Iron Age – salt exploitation was dependent just on the identification of vestiges or fired-clay structures collectively known as briquetage. Today, the variety of forms of exploitation recognised by both ethnography and archaeology (Alexianu et al. eds. 2011; Cassen et al. 2008; Cassen and Weller 2013; Fíguls and Weller 2007; Harding 2013; Hocquet et al. 2001; Monah et al. 2007; Nikolov and Bacvarov 2012; Pétrequin et al. 2001; Weller 2002; Weller et al. 2008) allows us to return to the issue of the function of certain material remains, and to advance new hypotheses on the place of this irreplaceable substance also in the domestic, technical and socio-economic spheres. The directly-observable material remains of prehistoric salt production can sometimes be found in the form of wooden catchments or fittings, but most often it consists of accumulations of fired clay (or briquetage) comprising debris from ancient heating installations and fragments of salt pans, accumulations of charcoal and ashes, unearthed structures, or, in the case of rock salt exploitation, of stone weller 69 Figure 1. Neolithic wooden wells from Fontaines Salées, Saint-Père-sous-Vézelay, Yonne, France (drawing P. Pétrequin and photos O. Weller). tools. We should note that no such remains are known at present for salt marshes, and that such inventions should be placed to the Roman period (not the Middle Ages), as shown by the excavations from Vigo in Portugal (Castro Carrera 2008). Spring catchment and fittings The construction of catchment systems and retention basins around the salt springs is difficult to ascertain in cases of heavy erosion or rapid sedimentation. However, French examples such as the spring from Moriez in the Alps, where researchers unearthed the frame of an ancient wattle dated to around 5600 BC (Morin et al. 2008), or that from Grozon in the Jura, where the salt workers erected a true horseshoe-shaped bulwark for protecting the spring (Pétrequin et al. 2001), suggest that the search for such structures should continue. In the past, many wooden structures were observed during works of rehabilitation or for capturing the salt springs, but their dating is often problematic (missing elements, brief remarks at the moment of discovery…). The most eloquent are the 19 oak trunks from Fontaines Salées in Saint-Père-sous-Vézelay (Yonne, France) (fig. 1), formerly attributed to the onset of the Iron Age and nowadays re- examined and dated dendrochronologically to the 23rd century BC, that is to say contemporary with the Bell Beaker culture (Bernard et al. 2008). 70 archaeology of salt Figure 2. Evidences of salt exploitation in Central and Eastern Europe between the 5th and 4th millenniums BC: 1- accumulation of firewood places from the Early Neolithic at Lunca-Poiana Slatinei (Romania); 2- Succession of archaeological layers extremely rich in pottery from the Precucuteni and Cucuteni cultures at Țolici-Hălăbutoaia (Romania); 3, 4- Briquetage from the Cucuteni culture (Lunca and Țolici, Romania); 5- Briquetage from the Vinča culture (Tuzla, Bosnia-Herzegovina); 6- Briquetage with an element of a stove, corroded ceramic and model from Barycz VII (Poland) (photos and drawings O. Weller except drawings 5- Benac 1978 and 6- Jodłowski 1977). Fired-clay vessels (or Briquetage) The exploitation of salt during the Neolithic and Chalcolithic seems to have been in some cases particularly dynamic, on account of the considerable quantities of fragments of ceramic moulds accumulated around certain salt springs, sometimes associated with combustion structures or residues (Weller 2002a). This is the case with salt springs from Little Poland, Bosnia-Herzegovina, Romanian Moldavia weller 71