Finnish Yearbook of International Law Finnish Yearbook of International Law Volume 21, 2010 IusGentiumAssociation HartPublishing Oxford&Portland,Oregon PublishedbyHartPublishing,Oxford HartPublishing,16CWorcesterPlace,OX12JW Telephone:+44(0)1865517530Fax:+44(0)1865510710 E-mail:[email protected] Website:www.hartpub.co.uk PublishedinNorthAmericaby HartPublishing c/oInternationalSpecializedBookServices 920NE58thAvenue,Suite300 Portland,OR97213-3786,USA Telephone:+15032873093ortoll-free:(1)8009446190 Fax:+15032808832 E-mail:[email protected] Website:www.isbs.com ©2013 IusGentiumAssociationandtheauthors Allrightsreserved.Nopartofthispublicationmaybereproduced,storedinaretrievalsystem,or transmitted,inanyformorbyanymeans,withoutthepriorpermissionofHartPublishing,or asexpresslypermittedbylaworunderthetermsagreedwiththeappropriatereprographicrights organisation.Enquiriesconcerningreproductionwhichmaynotbecoveredbytheaboveshould beaddressedtoHartPublishingattheaddressabove. Theeditorswelcomeunsolicitedcontributionsrelatedtointernationallaw.Generalinformation forauthorsanda detailedguide to theYearbook’s house style canbe foundat www.fybil.org. Communicationstotheeditorsshouldbeaddressedto: FinnishYearbookofInternationalLaw ErikCastrénInstituteofInternationalLawandHumanRights P.O.Box4(Yliopistonkatu3) FI-00014UniversityofHelsinki,Finland E-mail:[email protected] TheIusGentiumAssociationgratefullyacknowledgesthesupportoftheLegalDepartmentofthe FinnishMinistryforForeignAffairstothepublicationoftheYearbook. BritishLibraryCataloguinginPublicationDataAvailable ISBN:978-1-84946-225-9 ISSN:0786-6453 Printed and bound by CPI Group (UK) Ltd, Croydon, CR0 4YY Finnish Yearbook of International Law Editor-in-Chief JanKlabbers Executive Editor PaavoKotiaho Editors PetraHagelstam RainLiivoja PekkaNiemelä SørenBergRasmussen SilkeTrommer Associate Editors ShakiraBedoyaSánchez M.JoseBelmonteSánchez JuhaRainne TobiasBräutigam RiikkaKoskenmäki PamelaSlotte KirstenJ.Fisher JensKremer VarroVooglaid AnnaHuilaja TaruKuosmanen JuhoVuori MaijaHäll IlonaNieminen KristianWohlström Layout VillePeltokorpi Editorial Advisory Board ChairJarnaPetman RuthDonner MarttiKoskenniemi EsaPaasivirta KariHakapää ErkkiKourula AllanRosas LauriHannikainen PirkkoKourula HolgerRotkirch PäiviKaukoranta RaimoLahti MartinScheinin EskoKiuru MarjaLehto MarkkuSuksi OutiKorhonen Ari-MattiNuutila International Advisory Board ChairBengtBroms OveBring Vladimir-ĐuroDegan BrunoSimma ChristineChinkin ChristianDominicé SirIanSinclair JamesCrawford VladimírKopal HughW.A.Thirlway AnneOrford Honorary Board ChairKariT.Takamaa VeijoHeiskanen TuomasKuokkanen RitvaSaario JuhaniKortteinen JuhaniParkkari MattiTupamäki vi Contents Symposium: The International Criminal Court and the Responsibility to Protect PekkaNiemelä TheInternationalCriminalCourtandtheResponsibilitytoProtect: SynergiesandTensions 1 DavidChandler BornPosthumously:RethinkingtheSharedCharacteristicsoftheICC andR2P 5 PäiviKaukoranta FinnishPerspectivesontheICCandR2P 15 FrédéricMégret ICC,R2P,andtheInternationalCommunity’sEvolvingInterventionist Toolkit 21 SarahM.H.Nouwen ComplementarityinPractice:CriticalLessonsfromtheICCforR2P 53 AnneOrford FromPromisetoPractice?TheLegalSignificanceoftheResponsibilityto ProtectConcept 65 KofiQuashigah TheFutureoftheInternationalCriminalCourtinAfricanCrisisand ItsRelationshipwiththeR2PProject 89 BenjaminN.Schiff LessonsfromtheICCforICC/R2PConvergence 101 vii Debate:The Law of the Common: Globalization, Property and New Horizons of Liberation JohnD.Haskell&PaavoKotiaho IntroductoryNote 109 GuntherTeubner SocietalConstitutionalismandthePoliticsoftheCommon 111 AntonioNegri TheLawoftheCommon 125 Articles GeorgeRodrigoBandeiraGalindo ConstitutionalismForever 137 DorotaA.Gozdecka HumanRights,FundamentalRightsandtheCommonConstitutional TraditionsintheProtectionofReligiousPluralismandDiversity inEurope–AStudyintheDemocraticParadox 171 RobertKnox StrategyandTactics 193 PamelaSlotte TheReligiousandtheSecularinEuropeanHumanRightsDiscourse 231 StellanVinthagen LegalMobilizationandResistanceMovementsasSocialConstituentsof InternationalLaw 287 Book Reviews & Review Essays EditedbyRainLiivoja DanielJanse OlivierCorten,TheLawagainstWar:TheProhibitionontheuseof ForceinContemporaryInternationalLaw 331 JanKlabbers CharlesLeben,TheAdvancementofInternationalLaw 343 WilliamSchabas DavidNersessian,GenocideandPoliticalGroups 345 viii New Finnish Doctoral Dissertations in International Law EevaNykänen FragmentedStatePowerandForcedMigration:StudyonNon-State ActorsinRefugeLaw 353 StatementbyJanVedsted-Hansen 357 RenéUrueña NoCitizensHere:GlobalSubjectsandParticipationinInternationalLaw 362 StatementbyWouterWerner 369 Finnish State Practice VirpiLaukkanen ElementsofFinnishStatePracticein2009–2010 377 IusGentiumAssociation 397 ix