FAO SUB-REGIONAL OFFICE FOR THE PACIFIC ISLANDS REPORT ON THE APPLICATION FOR MARKET ACCESS OF ISLAND CABBAGE (Abelmoschus manihot)) FROM FIJI, VANUATU, SAMOA, COOK ISLANDS AND TONGA TO NEW ZEALAND By: MR. HANITELI’O. FA’ANUNU FAO CONSULTANT August 28,2009 FOOD AND AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION OF THE UNITED NATIONS Final Report on the Application for Market Access of Island Cabbage (Abelmoschus manihot ) from Fiji, Vanuatu, Samoa, Cook Islands and Tonga to New Zealand __________________________ (Abelmoschus manihot (L) Medik.) By MR. HANITELI ‘O. FA’ANUNU FAO CONSULTANT August 28, 2009 Table of Content Page Number Table of Content………………………………………………………………………………………….....3 Acknowledgements………………………………………………………………………………………....5 Executive Summary………………………………………………………………………………………...6 Part 1 - Information on Crop……………………………………………………………………………….7 1 Crop…………………………………………………………………………………………7 2 Distribution an Ecology……………………………………………………………………7 3 Variety………………………………………………………………………………………7 4 Botanical Description……………………………………………………………………...9 5 Production Area……………………………………………………………………………9 6 Production………………………………………………………………………………….9 7 Temperature and Rainfall……………………………………………………………….10 8 Harvesting………………………………………………………………………………...10 9 Marketing………………………………………………………………………………….11 10 Uses……………………………………………………………………………………….13 11 References………………………………………………………………………………..13 Part 2 - Pest and Diseases……………………………………………………………………………….15 2A. Summary Tables…………………………………………………………………………15 2A.1. General Plant Pest List for Specific Countries, Identified Commodities and References-SPC Database……………………………….15 2A.2. Additional Plant Pest List - UNDP/FAO-SPEC Survey, 1972………………21 2B. Detail Information of Pest and Diseases………………………………………………24 2B.1. Microsoft Excel Worksheet of Pele Pest Lists 09……………………………24 2B.2. Pest Control, Treatments and Export Pathways……………………………..24 2C Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………..28 Attachments………………………………………………………………………………………………..28 Attachment 1: Pele Pest Lists 09.xls........................................................................................30 Attachment 2: Consultancy Terms of Reference.doc..............................................................39 Attachment 3: Consultancy Travel Itinerary & Work Program.doc..........................................43 Attachment 4: Officials Consulted by Country.doc...................................................................47 3 List of Tables Table 1: Distribution of average temperatures, rainfall and relative humidity for five countries ..... 10 List of Figures Figure 1: Red stems & stalks, green leaves..................................................................................... 8  Figure 2: Round to slightly lobed, green leaves ............................................................................... 8  Figure 3: Deeply lobed and palmate leaves ..................................................................................... 8  Figure 4: Deeply lobed and palmate leaves ..................................................................................... 8  Figure 5: Flowering plant ................................................................................................................. 9  Figure 6: Yellow flower with purple centel ........................................................................................ 9  Figure 7: Maturing fruit capsules ...................................................................................................... 9  Figure 8: Farmer harvesting of terminal Pele stems with leaves still attached .............................. 11  Figure 9: Bundles of Island Cabbage (Pele) at Nausori Market, Fiji .............................................. 11  Figure 10: Bundles of Pele at Talamahu Market, Tonga................................................................ 11  Figure 11: Pele leaves wrapped in Banana leaves for sale at Port Vila Market, Vanuatu ............ 12  Figure 12: Well presented Island Cabbage bundle at Port Vila Market, Vanuatu .......................... 12  Figure 13: Fields of commercially grown Pele for both local and export markets .......................... 13  Figure 14: Farmers Guide for growing Bele (Pele) in Fiji. .............................................................. 25 Figure 15: Spray Programs for Various Crops in Samoa……………………………………………..26 Figure 16: Spray Programs for Vegetable Crops in Cook Islands..………………………………… 27 Figure 17: Spray Programs for Vegetable Crops in Tonga..……………………………………… …28 Figure 18: Suggested Pathway for Export of Island Cabbage ....................................................... 28  4 Acknowledgements This Report is an output of requests from governments of Fiji, Vanuatu, Samoa, Cook Islands and Tonga for FAO Technical Assistance to provide support to the five Pacific Island Countries to collect and provide relevant information which will form the basis to enable New Zealand Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries (NZ MAF) Biosecurity to carry out Risk Analysis Assessment for the Market Access of Island Cabbage (Abelmoschus manihot) and Polynesian Plum (Spondias dulcis) to New Zealand. This is a major task, as indicated in my Terms of Reference and tight work programs so as to meet as many Officials and cover wide areas in all the five countries including New Zealand, and it would not have happened without the excellent assistance provided to me throughout my consultations. The information and data presented in this report were collected during these consultations. Therefore, I am pleased to acknowledge the technical assistance by FAO and in particular Dr. Vili Fuavao, the FAO Sub Regional Representative of SAPA, Dr. Matairangi Purea and Staff for the consultancy and all support on the logistics of travel and work program appointments to the five Pacific Island Countries, including New Zealand. There was excellent collaboration from NZ MAF Biosecurity, in particular Dr. Viliami Fakava, Senior Adviser, for Plant Imports and Standards, and staff for all support and arrangements for meetings with MAF Biosecurity officials in both Auckland and Wellington. It contributed very much to understanding the responsibilities and operations of the NZ MAF Biosecurity regarding importations of produce from the Islands. The creation and provision of the Microsoft Excel Worksheet of Pele List 09 is most valuable in sorting out the pests of the five countries. . I was overwhelmed with the excellent support and helpfulness from the Heads of Agriculture, Senior Staff and Officials, Produce Exporters and Traders, and Growers of Fiji, Vanuatu, Samoa, Cook Islands and Tonga. I had wonderful support in organizing my visits and appointment from the FAO Contact Points in the all five countries. It was a very good feeling to have positive support from the locals, thus giving a good indication of their wishes and desires to open up new market access in New Zealand. The Secretariat of the Pacific Community is a major provider of Pests and Diseases Database for the Pacific Islands and was the main source for me. Ms Luisa Korodrau and Dr. Lex Thomson were very helpful indeed in accessing information on Pele. I had wonderful support from Mr. Chris Cocker, the Trade Commissioner for the Pacific Islands Trade and Investment Commission in Auckland, for provision of transportation and in particular his staff Mr. Joe Fuavao, who made my appointments and market visits possible, I would not have covered much without his help. 5 Executive Summary Island cabbage is indigenous to Southeast Asia, but an ancient introduction to Melanesia and from Fiji to Western Polynesia. It is a very popular green vegetable or spinach in Vanuatu, Fiji and Tonga, though still a minor crop and less popular in Samoa and Cook Islands. The plant grows extremely well in the main islands of Fiji, Vanuatu, Samoa, Cook Islands and Tonga. Island Cabbage in all five countries is not known by named varieties, but rather by leaf form and leaf color. It is open pollinated, and there are numerous varieties as noted by varying leaf shapes and colors. Three main types are grown throughout the five countries and they are: i. Round to slightly lobed green leaf, (sometimes referred to as white), very soft and nice texture when cooked; ii. Deeply lobed and palmate leaves, tend to be more tough and fibrous when harvested late; and iii. A hybrid of reddish stems and leaf stalks with green leaves There is no available acreage data in all the five countries. Island cabbage is considered a minor crop though it is common to abundant in both rural and urban food gardens and backyard gardens. It has great potentials for commercial cultivations in all five countries as it is an easy crop to cultivate, fast growing, and very nutritious. Island cabbage is propagated vegetative from stem cuttings. It takes two months to mature and about eight major harvesting before replanting again. Most of the home garden Pele is grown organically, except when they are grown commercially for both the local and export markets. On consultation with Island Importers of produce in New Zealand, there are strong indications of good market potentials for Island cabbage at the Island retailer shops and flea markets such as Otara and Mangere or around where most Islanders live. There is very good market potential for Island Cabbage in New Zealand for Pacific Islanders and having the Market Access will open up new trading opportunities on this commodity for Fiji, Vanuatu, Samoa, Cook Islands and Tonga. Fiji is exporting fresh Island cabbage leaves to Canada and also blanched and frozen leaves to USA Mainland, Hawaii, Australia and New Zealand. Tonga also exports small quantities of frozen leaves to New Zealand. The blanching at high heat and frozen form appears to be the best option for export. However, all the five countries would prefer to have both options of fresh and frozen forms open for their choice. Island cabbage is a Non Fruit fly Host, though it is a host for a wide range of pests and diseases so are its relatives of okra and other hibiscus species. This crop is an easy one to grow and fast growing. It could easily be commercially developed with the appropriate pathways for its cultivation with spray regime, packaging, Quarantine treatment and certification for export to New Zealand. The Fiji Ministry of Primary Industries has a defined production and pesticides spray programs for the commercial cultivation of Island cabbage, though the other four countries have similar production and pesticides spray programs for temperate vegetables which they could use on the Island cabbage too. All the five countries have approved pathways for export of commodities to New Zealand which could be modified and used for Island cabbage. Shown in Figure 18 of this report is an Appropriate and Suggested Pathway to be developed and adopted for the Export of Fresh Island Cabbage Leaves to New Zealand. 6 Part 1 - Information on Crop 1. Crop Scientific name : Abelmoschus manihot (L) Medik. Synonym : Hibiscus manihot L. Family : Malvaceae Common name : Island Cabbage Fiji : Bele Vanuatu : Island cabbage Samoa : Lau Pele Cook Islands : Raukau viti Tonga : Pele 2. Distribution and Ecology Island cabbage is indigenous to Southeast Asia, but an ancient introduction to Melanesia and from Fiji to Western Polynesia. It is a very popular green vegetable or spinach in Vanuatu, Fiji and Tonga. It is a minor crop and less popular in Samoa and Cook Islands. It is found to grow extremely well in Fiji, Vanuatu, Samoa, Cook Islands and Tonga. 3. Variety The Island Cabbage in all five countries is not known by named varieties, but rather by leaf form and leaf color. Island Cabbage is open pollinated, and there are numerous varieties as noted by varying leaf shapes and color. Vanuatu for instant has over 70 different varieties being tested by the Department of Agriculture and Rural Development. However, on the farmer’s fields in the five countries, three main types are grown throughout mainly for their softness, less fibrous and good taste when cooked. These are: i. Roundish green leaf, (sometimes referred to as white), very soft and nice texture when cooked; ii. More lobe and palmately shaped leaves, tend to be more tough and fibrous when harvested late; and iii. A hybrid of reddish green round leaves 7 Figure 1: Red stems & stalks, green leaves Figure 2: Round to slightly lobed, green leaves Figure 3: Deeply lobed and palmate leaves Figure 4: Deeply lobed and palmate leaves 8 It is most interesting to note that all five countries appear to have the same preferences for the above three varieties. 4. Botanical Description It is a fast growing erect perennial sub-shrub one to five meters in height. Leaves are alternate, simple, slightly fleshy, variably – shaped, margins entire to deeply lobed, facilate, surfaces bright green to red – green or purplish. Flowers are moschus like, yellow with dark purple center. Fruits are beaked, oblong and dehiscent capsule containing numerous pubescent seeds. Figure 5: Flowering plant Figure 6: Yellow flower with purple Figure 7: Maturing fruit capsules center 5. Production Area The Island cabbage is growing extremely well in the wet areas of all the five countries. It is grown in Vanuatu as number one spinach for the local people. In Fiji, and Tonga, it ranks number two to taro leaves. It grows extremely well in Samoa and Cook Islands but is relatively new to them and thus not as common as in Vanuatu, Fiji and Tonga. It is grown both as a backyard and commercial crop in Vanuatu, Fiji and Tonga. 6. Production There is no available acreage data in all the five countries. It is considered a minor crop though it is common to abundant in both rural an urban food gardens and backyard gardens in Vanuatu, Fiji and Tonga. It is not as common in Samoa and Cook Islands, but it has great potential for more cultivation in all five countries as it is a very easy crop to cultivate, fast growing, and very nutritious. Island cabbage is commonly propagated vegetative from stem cuttings to maintain true to type varieties though seeds could be use too. Generally, it takes two months to mature and about eight major harvesting before replanting again. Most of the home garden pele is grown organically, except when they are grown commercially for both the local and export markets. It is only in Fiji that the Ministry of Primary Industries has defined pesticides spray programs for the commercial cultivation of Island cabbage, though the other four countries, especially in Tonga, have similar pesticides spray programs for temperate vegetables that they may use on the Island cabbage too. 9 7. Temperature and Rainfall There are many variations in the climatic conditions between the five countries due to the land and ocean mass. However, they all enjoy a tropical maritime climate without great extreme of heat or cold. All five countries experience the same distinct wet season from November to April and dry season from May to October. They are all exposed and vulnerable to the cyclonic periods during the wet season from November to April and similarly to prolong dry spells and prolong wet conditions associated with La Nina and El Nino phenomenon. The high countries of Fiji, Vanuatu and Samoa experience flash flooding during the wet season. The five countries are within the ‘Ring of Fire’ in the Pacific Ocean and thus experience earthquakes and tsunami threats/warnings. The Island cabbage is found to be thriving well in the low/medium climates of these five countries. It requires good even rainfall distribution for fast, lush and green growth. It does not do well in dry sites, with the leaves rather leathery appearance and fibrous. Table 1 below shows the distribution of Average Temperatures, Rainfall and Relative Humidity for the five countries. Table 1: Distribution of average temperatures, rainfall and relative humidity for five countries Country Average Temperature Average Rainfall Average Relative Humidity Fiji 18 - 32˚C 1500 – 6000 mm 65 – 90% Vanuatu 21 – 27˚C 1500 – 4000 mm 75 – 80% Samoa 19 - 32.2˚C 2000 - 5000 mm 70 – 91% Cook Islands 21 – 28˚C 2000 mm 84 % Tonga 18 – 30˚C 1673 – 2453 mm 80.6% 8. Harvesting There are two main ways of harvesting: i. Picking of individual leaves, breaking it off from the leaf stalk. This is mostly for home use and for export. ii. Cutting off the terminal stem, 6-8 leaves below the terminal bud. This is both for home use and also for sale on the local market. This technique will encourage growth of new branches and more leaves. Harvesting could be repeated up to eight times or more depending on the health of the plant, before replanting again of new crop. Also for home use, the leaves are picked for cooking and the stems are used for planting materials. 10