Ethnologue 16/17/18th editions: A comprehensive review: Online appendices Harald Hammarström Language, Volume 91, Number 3, September 2015, pp. s1-s188 (Article) Published by Linguistic Society of America DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/lan.2015.0049 For additional information about this article https://muse.jhu.edu/article/593411/summary Access provided at 19 Jan 2023 00:24 GMT with no institutional affiliation Language 91.3, September 2015 Ethnologue 16/17/18th editions: A comprehensive review: Online appendices Harald Hammarstr(cid:246)m Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics, Nijmegen A Missing Languages This section lists languages which are missing from E16/E17/E18. To be more precise, a language is listed here as missing if: • Extant published literature can make a convincing case that the language exists (or existed, see below), and, • Extant published literature can make a convincing case that the language is not intel- ligible to any language already listed in E16/E17/E18, and, An important note is that we do not list languages which are missing solely in virtue of the interpretation of a dialect situation correctly understood (but interpreted di(cid:27)erently) 1 in E16/E17/E18. This matter is separately treated in Section D . For example, if an E16/E17/E18 entry subsumes a number of varieties with borderline intelligibility, and the facts are correctly indicated (e.g., the names of the varieties as dialects and comments on intelligibility) we do not list such cases here, even if there are good reasons to interpret the same facts as yielding di(cid:27)erent entries. However, if an E16/E17/E18 entry shows signs of misunderstanding (missing the existence of a variety, has an erroneous indication of intelligi- bility level, or a blanket statement with no indicated basis etc.), we do list any variety that is arguably not intelligible as a missing language here. Inallcases, weprovidereferencestotheliteraturethatsupporttheclaimsmaderegarding the missing language in question. A.1 Missing Languages: Australia E16/E17/E18 Athima, a poorly but su(cid:30)ciently attested extinct languages of the Upper Southwest Paman group, is missing. It is related to but di(cid:27)erent from Kunjen [kjn] and Kawarrang-Ogh Undjan [-] (Alpher 2000). E16/E17/E18 Koko Dhawa, an extinct separate language (Sommer 1997a:3, 19) from Kok Kaper (aka Gugubera) [kkp], is missing. 1 A large number of further such cases are taken up in the list of scheduled updates to the iso-639-3 inventory, traceable via http://www.sil.org/iso639-3/changes.asp. s2 E16/E17/E18 Barranbiya, an extinct close relative of Muruwari [zmu], is missing. E16/E17/E18 Bigambal, an extinct Yugambalic language, is missing (Barlow 1873, Math- ews 1902, Ridley 1873, 1875a, Turbayne et al. 1887, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008) E16/E17/E18 The extinct Bindal language recorded by Cunningham, a Greater Maric language arguably a di(cid:27)erent language from the other Bindal languages, is missing (Breen 2009, Cunningham & Gorton 1886). E16/E17/E18 The extinct Bindal language recorded by Gorton, a Greater Maric language arguably a di(cid:27)erent language from the other Bindal languages, is missing (Breen 2009, Cunningham & Gorton 1886). E16/E17/E18 The extinct Bindal language of Mount Elliot, a Greater Maric language arguably a di(cid:27)erent language from the other Bindal languages, is missing (Breen 2009, Gregory 1886). E16/E17/E18 Birrdhawal, an extinct Pama-Nyungan language, is missing (Breen 2009, Gregory 1886). E16/E17/E18 Bunganditj, one of the extinct Victorian Pama-Nyungan languages, is miss- ing (Blake 2003a, 2011, Blake & Reid 1998, Mathew 1899, Mathews 1903b, 1904b, Schmidt 1912, 1912, 1912, 1913, 1914, 1917/1918, 1917/1918, Smith 1880). E16/E17/E18 Dhudhuroa, one of the extinct Victorian Pama-Nyungan languages, is miss- ing (Blake & Reid 2002, Blake 2011, Blake & Reid 1995, 1998, Mathew 1899, Mathews 1909, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16 Ganai, an extinct Pama-Nyungan language, is missing (Blake & Reid 1995, Bulmer 1887c, Fesl 1985, Gardner 1996, Hercus 1969, Smyth 1878) E16/E17/E18 Giya, anextinctEasternMariclanguage, ismissing(Breen2009,Curr1887, Shea 1887). E16/E17/E18 Gudjal, an extinct Northern Maric language, is missing (Breen 2009, Lukin 1886, Sutton 1973a,b). E16/E17/E18 Guwar, anextinctBandjalangiclanguage, ismissing(Je(cid:27)eries2011,Watkin & Hamilton 1887). E16/E17/E18 Guyambal, an extinct Yugambalic language, is missing (Bench of Magis- trates, Queenbulla District 1887, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16/E17/E18 The language of Hawkesbury, an extinct Yuin-Kuri language, is missing (Jones2008,Mathews1897,1903a,1904b,Tuckerman1887,Wafer&Lissarrague2008). E16 Ikaranggal, an extinct Rarmul Paman language, is missing (Palmer 1884, 1886, Ray 1907, Sommer 1976, no date). s3 E16/E17/E18 Kabikabi, an extinct Eastern Waka-Kabic language, is missing (Bell 2003, Holmer 1983, Meyer & Uhle 1883, Ridley 1866, 1873). E16/E17/E18 Karruwali, an extinct Central Karnic language, is missing (Anonymous 1886, Breen 1971). E16/E17/E18 Kaurna, an extinct but possibly reviving Thura-Yura language, is missing (Amery 2004, Amery & O’Brien 2007, Amery 1996, 1998, Simpson & Hercus 2004, Teichelmann & Sch(cid:252)rmann 1840). E16/E17/E18 The extinct language of the lower Darling and lower Lachlan (of the Lower Murray subgroup), is missing (Horgen 2004, Macdonald 1886a,b, Smyth 1878, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16/E17/E18 The extinct Lower Riverland language (of the Lower Murray subgroup), is missing (Eyre 1845, Grimwade 1975, Horgen 2004, Moorhouse 1846, 1886, Pratt 1886, Taplin 1872, 1879). E16 The extinct Lower Southern Aranda (an Arandic language), is missing (Belt 1886, Hale 1962, London & Mueller 1886, Warburton 1886). E16/E17/E18 Minkin, a poorly attested extinct language of possible Tangkic a(cid:30)liation, is missing (Coward 1886, Tryon & O’Grady 1990). E16/E17/E18 Mithaka, an extinct Central Karnic language, is missing (Bowern 2001, Breen 1971, Mathew 1899). E16 Narungga, a Southern Thura-Yura language, is missing (Black 1920, Eira 2010, Koch 2009, K(cid:252)hn 1886, Simpson & Hercus 2004, Taplin 1879, Tindale 1936). E16/E17/E18 Nauo, an extinct Thura-Yura language, is missing (Hercus & Simpson 2001, Sch(cid:252)rmann 1879, Simpson & Hercus 2004). E16/E17/E18 Ngadjuri, an extinct Thura-Yura language, is missing (Berndt & Vogelsang 1941, Simpson & Hercus 2004, Warie-Read et al. 2009). E16/E17/E18 Ngardi, a Ngumpin language, is missing (Honeyman 2005, McConvell & Laughren 2004). E16/E17/E18 Ngumbarl, an extinct Nyulnyulan language, is missing (Bowern 2010). E16/E17/E18 TheextinctNorthernInlandYuinlanguageoftheYuinsubgroup, ismissing is missing (Besold 2003, Illert 2001, Koch 2011, Mathews 1901a, 1904a, Ridley 1873, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16/E17/E18 The extinct Northern Sunraysia language the Lower Murray subgroup, is missing is missing (Cameron 1885, Horgen 2004, McFarlane 1886, Smyth 1878, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). s4 E16/E17/E18 Pallanganmiddang,anEasternVictorianlanguage,ismissing(Blake&Reid 1999, Blake 2011, Blake & Reid 1995, 1998, Smyth 1878, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16/E17/E18 TheextinctSouthernCoastalYuinlanguageoftheYuinsubgroupismissing is missing (Liston 1993, Mathews 1902, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16/E17/E18 The extinct Southern Inland Yuin language of the Yuin subgroup is missing is missing (Bulmer 1887a,b, Bunce 1851, Du VØ & Bulmer 1887, Eyre 1845, Hercus 1969, Koch 2011, Lhotsky 1839, Mathews 1908, Police Magistrate, Queanbeyan 1887, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16/E17/E18 The extinct original Sydney language (of the Kuri subgroup), is missing is missing (Collins 1887, Hunter 1887, Kohen 1984, Marsden 1834, Mathews 1901b, Ridley 1873, Steele 2005, Troy 1992, 1994a,b, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16 Tagalaka, a Southwest Paman language, is missing (Sutton 1976a). E16/E17/E18 Umiida-Unggarangu, an extinct Worrorran language, is missing (Capell & Coate 1984, McGregor & Rumsey 2009). E16/E17/E18 Winjarumi, an extinct Worrorran language, is missing (Capell & Coate 1984, McGregor & Rumsey 2009). E16 Unggumi, an extinct Worrorran language, is missing (Capell 1940, 1940, Capell & Coate 1984, McGregor & Rumsey 2009). E16/E17/E18 The extinct Upper Riverland of the Lower Murray subgroup is missing is missing (Fulford 1886, Horgen 2004, Pegler 1886, Taplin 1879). E16/E17/E18 Yarli, an extinct Pama-Nyungan language subgrouping with Baagandji, is missing (Austin 2003, Crozier & Dewhurst 1886, Hercus & Austin 2004, Morton 1886, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). E16/E17/E18 The long extinct and poorly attested Tasmanian languages are missing al- together. The exact number of languages in evidence is uncertain but a tradition of scholarship (Bowern 2012, Bowern & Lau 2011, Crowley & Dixon 1981, Jones 1974, Schmidt 1952) recognizes some seven languages which may be divided up as Western Coastal Tasmanian, the Northeastern Tasmanian dialect chain, Oyster Bay-Big River- Little Swanport, Port Sorell, South-Eastern Tasmanian Hinterland, Bruny Island and Ben Lomond-Cape Portland, E16/E17/E18 Yagara, an extinct language of the East Queensland Border Pama Nyungan subgroup, is missing (Holmer 1983, Lauterer 1900, Minjerribah Moorgumpin 2011, Ridley 1873, 1875a,b, 1887, Watkin & Hamilton 1887). E16 Yorta Yorta, an extinct Eastern Victorian language, is missing (Blake 2011, Blake & Reid 1995, 1998, Bowe & Morey 1999, Smyth 1878, Wafer & Lissarrague 2008). s5 E16/E17/E18 Yulparija, a Martuwangkic language, is missing (Burridge 1996, Hansen 1984). E16 Yuru, an extinct Nyawaygic language, is missing (Breen 2009, O’Connor 1886, Wurm 2007). E16/E17/E18 The language consisting of the two dialects Kawarrang and Ogh Undjan is missing. There is a Gugu Mini [ggm] entry and the name Gugu Mini has been applied to Ogh Undjan (Sommer 1997b:1-3, Sommer 1976:133-144) as well as to Ikarranggal [ikr] (Sommer no date:1-2,Sommer 1976:133-144), but the [ggm]-entry is classi(cid:28)ed as a Rarmul Pama language, implying that it refers to Ikarrangal rather than Kawarrang- Ogh Undjan (which is not a Rarmul Pama language). The closest relative of Ogh Undjan is Ow Oykangand or possibly Kuuk Thayoore but they are not as close as to be even nearly intelligible (Sommer 1969:12, Black 2004:253). E16 Kalaamaya, a Pama-Nyungan language, related to the Mirning group languages but not intelligible with the varieties already included (Kalarko [kba], Ngadjunmaya [nju]) is missing (Nash 2002). A wordlist was recorded as late as 1960 so it survived beyond 1950 (O’Grady 2001). E16/E17/E18 Dharumbal, aPama-Nyungan languagesurvivingwellbeyond1950, ismiss- ing. The Bayali [bjy] entry has alternate names that indicate Dharumbal, but Bayali, Dharumbal’s neighbour to the south, is certainly a di(cid:27)erent language, being only 21% lexicostatistically cognate with Dharumbal (Terrill 2002:15). E16 Yaygir, a Pama-Nyungan language discovered only in 1973, is missing (Crowley 1979). 2 E16 Anguthimri, a Pama-Nyungan language, is missing (Crowley 1981). E16/E17/E18 Theextinct, butquitewell-attested, Kulinlanguagesaremissingaltogether. One of the Kulin languages was the Western Victoria language (Wafer & Lissarrague 2008), which was not necessarily extinct by 1950 (Hercus 1969). E16/E17/E18 Another extinct, but quite well-attested, Kulin languages is Warrnambool which is also missing (Blake 2003b, 2011, Blake & Reid 1995, 1998, Mathew 1899, Wilkinson 1978). E16/E17/E18 Theextinct, butquitewell-attested, Kulinlanguagesaremissingaltogether. One of the Kulin languages was Woiwurrung (Blake 1991), which was not necessarily extinct by 1950 (Hercus 1969). E16/E17/E18 Theextinct, butquitewell-attested, Kulinlanguagesaremissingaltogether. OneoftheKulinlanguageswastheWathawurrunglanguage(Blakeetal.1998a), which was not necessarily extinct by 1950 (Hercus 1969). E16/E17/E18 Theextinct, butquitewell-attested, Kulinlanguagesaremissingaltogether. One of the Kulin languages was the Colac language (Blake et al. 1998b), which was not necessarily extinct by 1950 (Hercus 1969). 2 I wish to thank Jean-Christope Verstraete for dicussion on this language. s6 E16/E17/E18 Uwinymil, a recently extinct Western Gunwinyguan language is missing ((Harvey 2003a:285), Parkhouse 1896:2) E16/E17/E18 An extinct, presumably Western Gunwinyguan language, recorded as Wul- wulam is missing (Harvey 2003b). The language is attested only in a short wordlist but this wordlist is not explainable as Warray [wrz] or any other neighbouring language (Harvey 2003b:299). E16 Kuuk Yak (as a dialect or language) is missing (Gaby 2006). E16/E17/E18 Gurindji Kriol, an Australian mixed language, is missing (McConvell & Meakins 2005, Meakins 2011), though noted in the comments to the Gurindji [gue] entry: (cid:16)Gurinji children’s language is a mixed language from Gurinji and Kriol(cid:17). E16/E17/E18 Light Warlpiri, an Australian mixed language, is missing (O’Shannessy 2006). E16/E17/E18 Bularnu, a Pama-Nyungan language of the Southern Ngarna, Thawa group is missing (although erroneously listed as a dialect of Yindjilandji [yil] in the Southern Ngarna, Ngarru subgroup, see Breen 2004). E16/E17/E18 Wulguru, an extinct Nyawaygic language, is missing (Donohue 2007b) E16/E17/E18 Yirandhali, an extinct Maric language, is missing (Breen 2009) E16/E17/E18 Pirriya, an extinct Karnic language, is missing (Barrett 2005, Breen 1990b). E16/E17/E18 Kuungkari of the Barcoo river, another extinct Karnic language, is missing (Barrett 2005, Breen 1990a). (E16 has an entry for Kunggari [kgl] but the data in this entry matches the Bidjara-like language of Upper Nebine and Mungallala creeks and not the similarly named Kuungkari, of Barcoo river). E16/E17/E18 Guwa, an extinct Greater Maric language, is missing (Barrett 2005, Blake & Breen 1990). E16/E17/E18 Yanda, another extinct Greater Maric language, is missing (Barrett 2005, Breen 1990c). E16/E17/E18 Walangama, an extinct Norman Pama language, is missing (Armit 1886, Black 1980, Sutton 1973b). E16/E17/E18 Wuthathi, an extinct northern Paman language, is missing (Hale 1966, Seligmann & Pimm 1907). E16/E17/E18 Gudang, another extinct northern Paman language, is missing (Hale 1966, Jardine 1886). E16/E17/E18 Mpalityan-Lutigh, another extinct northern Paman language, is missing (Hale 1966, Sommer 1976). s7 E16/E17/E18 Yinwum, another extinct northern Paman language, is missing (Hale 1966, Sommer 1976). E16/E17/E18 The extinct northern Paman language comprising the lects Tyanngayt, Mamngayt, Ntrwangayt and Ntrangit, is missing (Hale 1966, Hey 1903). E16/E17/E18 Ngkot, yet another extinct northern Paman language, is missing (Hale 1966). E16/E17/E18 Aritinngitigh, yet another extinct northern Paman language, is missing (Hale 1966). E16/E17/E18 Mbiywom, yet another extinct northern Paman language, is missing (Hale 1966). E16 Kok-Nar, an extinct Norman Pama language, is missing (Breen 1976). A.2 Missing Languages: Africa E16/E17/E18 Shiwa,aGaboneseBantuA80language,missing(DougŁre2007,OllomoElla 2008, 2013). It is most closely related to Kwasio [nmg], but about equally close to it as anypairoftheclosestA80languageswithseparateE17/E18entries(Cheucle2014:516, Grollemund 2012). E17/E18 Auyokawa, an extinct West Chadic B1 relative of Bade, is missing (Bro(cid:255) 1996, Haruna 2008, Schuh 2001, Temple 1919). E17/E18 Teshenawa, an extinct West Chadic B1 relative of Bade, is missing (Bro(cid:255) 1996, Schuh 2001). E16/E17/E18 Baazem,anewlydiscoveredYukubeniclanguage,ismissing(Lovegren2012). E16/E17/E18 Boro, an extinct language Na-Togo language of Togo, is missing (Seidel 1898, Westermann 1922). E17/E18 Gafat,arelativelyrecentlyextinctEthiosemiticlanguage,ismysteriouslymissing. It has a long history of scholarship (Adelung & Vater 1812, Beke 1846, Hetzron 1997, Leslau 1945). E16/E17/E18 Gbin, anextinctbutattestedlanguageofC(cid:244)ted’Ivoireismissing(Delafosse 1904, Paperno no date). E16/E17/E18 Girirra, an Ethiopian language likely of the Eastern Omo-Tana subgroup of Cushitic, is missing (Askale 1998, Banti 2005, Castellani 1938). E16/E17/E18 Theextinctbutwell-knownAncientEgyptianlanguageismissing(Loprieno 1995). E16/E17/E18 Guanche, the enigmatic poorly attested extinct original language of the Canary islands, is missing (W(cid:246)lfel 1965). s8 E16/E17/E18 Meroitic, an enigmatic poorly attested extinct language of North Sudan, is missing (Gri(cid:30)th 1909, Rilly 2003, 2007, Rowan 2006). E16/E17/E18 Old Nubian, an extinct but well-attested language of North Sudan and Southern Egypt, is missing (Browne 2002, 1997, Khalil 1988, Zyhlarz 1928). E16/E17/E18 A series of extinct Bushman lects forming a language which may be called Lower Nosop, is missing (Bleek 1937, 1939-1940, G(cid:252)ldemann 2014, Traill 1999). E16/E17 A series of extinct Bushman lects forming a language which may be called Vaal- Orange, is missing from E16/E17 (Bleek 1939-1940, 1956, Meinhof 1928-1929). E16/E17/E18 Njanga,arguablyadistinctlanguagefromKwanja[knp],ismissing(Connell 1998, Gri(cid:30)ths & Robson 2010, Robson 2011). E16/E17/E18 Data in Klieman (2003, 1997), Sato (1992) of the language spoken by the Mikaya, Bambengangale and Baluma in the Republic of Congo are so di(cid:27)erent from other languages in the Likouala-Sangha Bantu subgroup that a separate entry is re- quired. These lects are not covered in any form in any other entry in E16/E17/E18. E16/E17/E18 There is a small amount of data on a now extinct enigmatic language of GhanacalledMpra(Blench2012c,1999,Goody1963). ItismissingfromE16/E17/E18. E16/E17/E18 Theextinctbutwell-attestedPhoenician-Puniclanguageismissing(Friedrich 1951, Harris 1936, Kerr 2010). E16/E17/E18 According to van der Burgt (1902), the language of the Kitwa among the Rundi speak a language of their own (in addition to Kirundi itself) which is not un- derstood by the neighbouring Watussi and the Wahutu speakers and has the same grammar as Kirundi but is lexically di(cid:27)erent (the bulk of which is nevertheless of Rundi origin!). This language is missing from E16/E17/E18. E16/E17/E18 ShanjoisalanguageofZambiawhichappearsasadialectofTonga(Zambia) [toi] in E16/E17/E18. However, it turns out that Shanjo is not intelligible to Tonga and does not even subgroup with Tonga (Bostoen 2009, de Luna 2008, 2010) and thus merits an entry of its own. E16/E17/E18 The Nyala [nle] entry lists two dialects West Nyala and East Nyala. But the WestNyalalanguagespokenontheshoresofLakeVictoriainBusiadistrictinKenyais a di(cid:27)erent language from the non-adjacent East Nyala spoken inland (Kanyoro 1983). The two are not mutually intelligible (Ochwaya-Oluoch 2003:7-8) despite both having the name Nyala and being the the Abaluyia group. One of the two is thus missing from E16/E17/E18. E16/E17/E18 Belueli, a Pygmy language spoken at Apare in the Ituri forest area of NE Congo, is missing. It is not intelligible to neighbouring Bali [bcp] and appears to the in the Nyali-Ndaka-Mbo-Budu-Vanuma subgroup (Schebesta 1953). s9 E16/E17/E18 Nabit is listed as a dialect of Farefare [gur], but it is not intelligible with Farefare (Gi(cid:27)en 2013:100) and should thus be listed as a separate language. E16/E17/E18 Nterato is a language in the northern Guang area in Ghana recorded by Jack Goody in 1956 (Goody 1963), but with only two speakers still remaining at the time. The language is related to the other north Guang languages but is di(cid:27)erent from all of them (Kropp Dakubu 2013). It is missing. E16/E17/E18 Ngubi is a Sira (B.40) Bantu language in Gabon distinct from all other Sira (B.40) languages (Agadji Ayele 2002, Aleko & PuŁch 1988, PuŁch 1988). It is missing. E16 Tondi Songway Kiini, a Songhay language not intelligible to other Eastern Songhay languages listed in E16, is missing (Heath 2005). E16/E17/E18 On grounds of mutual unintelligibility, Penange Dogon merits a separate entry from other Dogon languages (Heath 2014d), and is missing from E16/E17/E18. E16 Ongroundsofmutualunintelligibility, NangaDogonmeritsaseparateentryfromother Dogon languages (Bertho 1953, Heath 2014c), and is missing from E16. E16 On grounds of mutual unintelligibility, Bankan Tey Dogon merits a separate entry from other Dogon languages (Blench 2005b, Heath 2014a), and is missing from E16. E16 On grounds of mutual unintelligibility, Bankan Tey Dogon merits a separate entry from other Dogon languages (Heath 2014b), and is missing from E16. E16 On grounds of mutual unintelligibility, Tirange Dogon merits a separate entry from other Dogon languages (Bertho 1953, Heath 2014e), and is this missing from E16. E16 On grounds of mutual unintelligibility, Ampari Dogon merits a separate entry from otherDogonlanguages(Blench&Douyon2005,Hochstetler etal.2004), andismissing from E16. E16 On grounds of mutual unintelligibility, Mombo Dogon merits a separate entry from other Dogon languages (Bertho 1953, Prokhorov 2012), and is missing from E16. E16 Yoti, a language of the Yendang group, requires a separate entry (Blench no date). It is listed in E16 as a dialect of Yendang [yen] because most Yoti speak Yendang as well, but Yoti is not close to being a dialect of Yendang, and is, in fact closer to Bali [bcn] and Kpasham [pbn] (Blench no date). E16/E17/E18 Lebu Wolof is listed as a dialect of (Senegalese-Mauretanian) Wolof [wol]. However, Lebu Wolof is not intelligible to other Wolof speakers, e.g., Wolof speakers cannot readiy understand the text specimina of Lebu in Angrand (1952), as opposed to Gambian Wolof [wof] which is intelligible to (Senegalese-Mauretanian) Wolof [wol] but uses a di(cid:27)erent written standard and source of loanwords. The distinctness of Lebu Wolof is hidden by the fact that all Lebu Wolof speakers are also bilingual in non-Lebu Wolof.