DOCUMENT RESUME ED 375 834 IR 055 201 AUTHOR Singh, Diljit TITLE The State of the World's School Libraries. PUB DATE [93) NOTE 19p.; Based on the author's doctoral dissertation, "An International Comparative Study of School Libraries," Florida State University, 1993. PUB TYPE Viewpoints (Opinion/Position Papers, Essays, etc.) Research/Technical (143) Reports (120) EDRS PRICE MFO1 /PCO1 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Developed Nations; Developing Nations; *Educational Change; Educational Improvement; Elementary Secondary Education; Foreign Countries; Global Approach; *Learning Resources Centers; *Library Development; Library Education; Library Role; Media Specialists; *School Libraries; Surveys; Tables (Data) IDENTIFIERS International Surveys ABSTRACT The many changes in the world's social structure require corresponding changes in education. One across-the-system change that needs to be given emphasis is the development of school libraries. The current state of the world's school libraries is generally unsatisfactory. This view is based on the results of an international comparative study of school libraries. Based on the responses from authoritative sources in 64 countries, the study found that school libraries were still absent in some countries, especially in primary schools; that school libraries were given a low priority in education; that the school library was seen as having only a supplementary role in the educational process; and that many teacher-librarians had only minimal training for their positions. There are many challenges ahead in developing school libraries worldwide. This paper puts forward some recommendations and suggestions for international organizations and associations. These recommendations include the need for setting bold yet realistic targets, greater attention to be paid to convincing policy makers about the role of school libraries, ensuring the free and widespread dissemination of information about libraries, and nurturing the development of school libraries in all countries. A list of the countries responding to the survey is appended. (Contains 6 references.) (Author) *********************************************************************** Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made from the original document. *********************************************************************** U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION Office of Educations! Research and Improvement EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC! 0 This document has been reproduced as (*cowed from the person or organization Originating it O Minor changes have been made to improve reproduction Quality Points of view or opinions staled in this dOCu- ment do not necessarily represent offic,al OERI position or pOliCY The State of the World's School Libraries by Diljit Singh "PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE THIS MATERIAL HAS BEEN GRANTED BY Diljit Singh 2 TO THE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC)." BEST COPY AVAILABLE THE STATE OF THE WORLD'S SCHOOL LIBRARIES Diljit _Singh State Education Resource Center, Pahang State Education Department, 26100 Beserah, Kuantan, Pahang, Malaysia. ABSTRACT The many changes in the world's social structure require corresponding changes in education. One across-the-system change that needs to be given emphasis is the development of school libraries. The current state of the world's school libraries is generally unsatisfactory. This view is based on the results of an international comparative study of school libraries. Based on the responses from authoritative sources in sixty-four countries, the study found that school libraries were still absent in some countries, especially in primary schools, that school libraries were given a low priority in education, that the school library was seen as having only a supplementary role in the educational process, and that many teacher-librarians had only minimal training for their jobs. There are many challenges ahead in developing school libraries worldwide. This paper puts forward some recommendations and suggestions for international organizations and associations. These recommendations include the need for setting bold yet realistic targets, greater attention to be paid to convincing policy makers in countries about the role of school libraries, ensuring the free and widespread dissemination of information about libraries, and nurturing the development of school libraries in all countries. Introduction The last two and half decades have seen many changes in the world's social structure. Nations that were once economic powers have had their dominance reduced, large republics have broken up into smaller nations, numerically small religious and cultural groups have become more significant, the green revolution has spread rapidly, and technology, in particular the computer, is playing a major role in every walk of life. In addition, information is becoming a crucial factor in the economic, political, cultural, ecological and technical arenas. In short, the world is changing. It is the responsibility of the schools of today to produce citizens of tomorrow who can survive in this new world order. A citizen of tomorrow needs a higher quality of education, which includes not only the basic 3 Rs, but also knowledge, attitudes 3 and skills that address the changes the world is witnessing. Yet the education systems in most countries are still based on the agricultural economies of the past. In many developing and less developed countries, the rate of economic development has outpaced the changes in education. Changes, if any, have basically consisted of administrative restructuring, introduction of new subjects, curriculum revisions, revised testing procedures and other isolated changes. Areas which cut across the curriculum or the whole education systerri have generally been neglected. Few countries have considered, much less implemented, complete overhauls in their systems of education. The school library is one across-the-system element that has been linked to increasing the quality of education. Many reviews of research studies on school libraries conclude that the presence and active use of a school library can significantly influence student achievement (Mahar 1983, Didier 1985, Haycock 1987, Woo lls 1990, Haycock 1992). Irrespective of whether the role of the library is to encourage students to read widely in their spare time or to ensure that students are effective users of information, the school library has an important role to play in education and in national development. Unlike the isolated changes that have been introduced, the school library is not a new subject to be introduced into the curriculum. The domain of the school library cuts across tilt curriculum. The school library today is no longer a luxury in education; it is a necessity. Yet the state of world's school libraries is generally unsatisfactory. This is the view based on an international survey of school libraries carried out in 1993. This paper highlights the results of the relevant portions of the study. [The full study is not reported here, and the interested reader is referred to (Singh, 1993)1. This paper goes on to suggest means for the greater development, as seen from a developing country perspective. It is hoped that the results of this study and the recommendations in this paper can be used as a starting point in the efforts to improve the school libraries and, in turn, the quality of education worldwide. The Study An international survey of school libraries was carried out in 1993 as part of a Ph.D. dissertation requirement. The main aim of the study was to examine school library systems across nations. In order to do so, a series of indicators and variables for the comparison of school libraries was first established by surveying thirty leaders in the field of school librarianship from twenty-nine countries. The indicators and variables were then used as a basis to survey the current state of school libraries internationally. The full study basically involved the following steps, some of which were carried out concurrently with others: Selected library and education literature from the past twelve years was first analyzed to 1. obtain an overview of the existing state of knowledge on school libraries internationally. A survey of the literature was also carried out to establish a preliminary list of indicators 2. and variables for the comparison of school libraries internationally. This preliminary list of indicators and variables was presented, in the form of a 3. questionnaire, to an international panel of experts on school librarianship to obtain a professional judgement on a valid set of indicators for international comparisons. An authoritative source of information on school libraries was identified in each of the 4. approximately 190 countries of the world with the assistance of the country's embassy in the United States or the country's representative to the United Nations. The indicators and variables derived in step 3 above were used to formulate a \.2 5. questionnaire. The questionnaire was sent to the official sources identified in step 4, for them to describe the current status of schoo' libraries in their respective countries. In the meantime, information on the demographic, economic and social conditions of the 6. countries was compiled from authoritative published sources. The information obtained in step 5 above was correlated with selected demographic, 7. economic and social indicators obtained in step 6 for the countries, to determine if any relationships existed. The information obtained in steps 1 and 5 was verified, where possible, through analysis 8. of documents supplied by the respondents. The information obtained in step 5 was corroborated, where possible, with information 9. at the 21st International obtained from interviews with international participants Association of School Librarianship conference in Belfast. All available relevant information was then synthesized to answer the research questions 10. of the study. The Findings Of the 185 questionnaires sent out in January 1993, 64 countries replied by the end of April, giving a return rate of 34.8% (see Appendix A for list of responding countries). Based on 5 the analysis of responses from these sixty-four countries, the findings can be summarized in the tables that follow. The tables show the percentage of countries which gave the corresponding responses; more detailed information can be found in the original study report of Singh, 1993. Table 1 Library Facilities in Schools Extent of Libraries within the Schools Primary Secondary All schools have centralized libraries % 12.5 28.1 % At least half of schools have centralized libraries 70 45 % % None of the schools have centralized libraries % % 1.6 16 Access to Any Library (Inside or Outside the Schools) Primary Secondary All primary schools have access to some form of library 52.8 % 67.3 % At least half of schools have access to some form of 73.6 % 80 % library None of the schools have access to some form of library 3.8 % 0 % Table 2 Philosophy of School Library Country's Philosophy on School Library Percentage The school library has a central role in education 21.8 % The school library has a supplementary role in education 43.6 % The school library is a good thing to have when resources allow 32.7 % for it Table 3 Ranking of Library among School Services Service Rank Textbooks 1 Science Laboratories and Equipment 2 Guidance and Counselling 3 Sports and Athletics 4 Vocational/Technical Education 5 Health Services 6 School Library 7 Special Education 8 Countries which Ranked School Library as Percentage Highest 1.8% Lowest 9.1% Table 4 Role of School Library Role Percentage No defined role % 16.7 As a place for pupils to study when they are free 3.7 % For recreational reading, viewing and/or listening % 11.1 For enrichment of the learning process 59.3 % For instruction requiring library materials and/or services 3.7 % For finding specific information and ideas 3.7 % Table 5 Inclusion of School Libraries in Educational Development Plans Inclusion in Educational Development Plans Percentage School libraries INCLUDED in development plans 89.1 % School libraries NOT included in development plans % 10.9 Table 6 Schools with Teacher-Librarians Presence of Teacher-Librarians Primary Secondary With teacher-librarian in ALL schools % % 13.5 21 With teacher-librarian in SOME schools 67 75 % % WITHOUT any teacher-librarians at all 4 % % 19.5 Table 7 Schools with Full-Time Teacher-Librarians Full-Time Teacher-Librarians Secondary Primary WITH full-time teacher-librarians % % 10 1.5 WITHOUT full-time teacher-librarians 90 98.5 % % Table 8 Role of Teacher-Librarians Role Percentage No defined role 31.5 % As a librarian, making resources available to teachers and students 27.8 % As a specialist teacher, instructing teachers and students on how to 29.6 % use the library As an instructional partner, jointly planning and implementing the 5.6 % curriculum with teachers Table 9 Education of Teacher-Librarians Level of Education/Training in Librarianship Percentage No special training 21.8 % In-service training only 27.3 % Certificate or equivalent level % 14.5 Diploma or associate degree level % 12.7 Bachelor's or Master's degree or higher % 1.8 Table 10 Collections of School Libraries Type of Material Primary Secondary Print materials 100 100 % % Audio materials and associated equipment 42.9 50.0 % % Visual materials and associated equipment 40.7 37.6 % % Electronic materials and associated equipment 25.9 14.3 % % Communication. equipment % 13.0 % 6.1 Table 11 Existence of Standards and/or Guidelines Existence of Mandatory Standards for School Libraries Percentage Yes 36.4 % No 63.6 % Existence of Guidelines for School Libraries Percentage 70.9 % Yes 29.1% No , 10