DOCUMENT RESUME TM 017 365 ED 338 652 Bierschenk, Bernhard AUTHOR Mentality Measurement and Representation. No. 39. TITLE Lund Univ. (Sweden). Cognitive Science Research. INSTITUTION ISSN-0281-9864 REPORT NO PUB DATE 91 NOTE 17p. Reports - Evaluative/Feasibility (142) PUB TYPE MF01/PC01 Plus Postage. EDRS PRICE *Cognitive Processes; Foreign Countries; Language DESCRIPTORS Usage; *Measurement Techniques; *Research Methodology; *Schemata (Cognition) *Consciousness; *Mental Representation; Natural IDENTIFIERS Language Processing; Perspective Text Analysis; Text Processing (Reading) ABSTRACT Because the scientifif; treatment of the concept of consciousness has been multifaceted, -.here have peen several different approaches to research concerning consciousness. This article gives an introductury account of the research on consciousness. The main hypothesis advanced is based on the premise that consciousness emerges from the cooperative interaction of multiple agents and agencies within naturally produced text. Through Perspective Text Analysis, it is demonstrated that the Kantian schema provides the necessary foundation for making explicit the teleonomic component governing natural language production. As a consequence, the concept of text is redefined so that the textual transformation and recursive restructuring reach their meaning in relation to the concepts of textual dynamics and linkages. Its configurational architecture is demonstrated on the basis of the (AaO) formula. As a result, the entirety of structural relations evolves as a double helical structure. Analysis within the framework of differential topology demonstrates the necessity of cooperating perspective and objective structures in establishing perspective and objective invariance. Five figures illustrate the discussion. A 23-item list of references is included. (Author/SLD) *********************************************************************** Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made from the original document. *********************************************************************** . THIS " "PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE NS. IMPARTMENT OP IOUCATION GRANTED BY MATERIAL HAS BEEN ingovmont mic Oi Educptipapi gamma and INFORMATION h. gvvio-reTr EDUCATIONAL REINMJRCES CENTER IERIC) ss Men reproduced di IThis doCurneM organisation received from the Dotson Or ongrnating it to onsooy Minor changers 'lave Nen mad* iAtOthiCtiOn quality RESOURCES TO THE EDUCATIONAL sodnionaGlitalinthiactOM Ponta I:dwell/or represent otkiel INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC)." ment do not necessarily OERI Melon or pot ay Mentality Representation Measurement and Bernhard Bierschenk No. 39 1991 4 k 1 Mentality Measurement and Representation Bernhard Bierschenk No. 39 1991 Cognitive Science Research Lund University Sweden Adm. editor Editor Postal address Helge Helmersson Bernhard Bierschenk Cognitive Science Research Department of Business Adm, Department of Psychology P.O. Box 7080 Lund University Lund University S-220 07 LUND SWEDEN 3 2 Abstract is multifanous. This has The scientific treatment of the concept of consciousness gives some introductory caused a number of different approaches. The present articles However, the main hypothesis advanced is account of the research on consciousness. cooperative interaction of based on the premise that consciousness emerges from the of Perspective multiple agents and agencies within naturally produced text. By means provides the necessary Text Analysis it is demonstrated that the Kantian schema language foundation for making explicit the teleonomic component governing natural transformation production. Thereby, the concept of text is redefined such that textual of textual and recursive restructuring become their meaning in relation to the concepts demonstrated on the basis of dynamics and linkages. Its configurational architecture is evolve as a double the (AaO) formula. As a result the entirety of structural relations of differential helical structure. Both have been analyzed within the framework topology in order to demonstrate the necessity of cooperating perspective and objective structures in establishing perspective and objective invariance. Subjective Consciousness multifaceted. This has caused a number of The concept of subjective consciousness is his discussion of consciousness, Hebb different definitions (see Natsoulas, 1983). In indicate the state of alertness (1980 p. 20) argues that the concept is used primarily to the individual's capability to adapt of a normal adult person. With alertness it is meant meaning this sense, the concept is equivalent with awareness, to its environment. In refined through the discourse emerging the social or joint use of abstractions gradually through speech. of persons, objects and events into Being aware of something implies an integration 'it'. As is obvious from the scientific significant conceptualizations, often expressed by attribute of matter ('it'). In discussion, consciousness was considered to represent an researchers insisted not only on the the beginning of psychology as a science some depicted in Figure 1, but also on an associate relation between brain and behaviour as immaterial Mind (Pribram, 1969, p. adequate measurement and representation of the 60), System Relation of Mind to Brain in the Cartesian Nervous Figure 1. (Bell-Magendie Separation) I /No' 4 hra/h eelablo al /;) Me Carileaxii, 4/erko4.r trya./em (6tee& feyara te/d& Cartesian nervous system has been separated by As is obvious from Figure 1 the law (Hebb, 1980, P. 32). It stipulates that the ventral means of the Bell-Magendie the motor function of the cortex while the dorsal roots roots of the spinal nerves carry S-R link represents the "reflex". The reflex apply to its sensory areas. Furthermore, the These are generally conceived to be has its own built-in cross-connections. from the transmitting unit cell unidirectional in kind. The entire information transfer of electrical impulses as its carriers. However, in many to the recipient cell consists different connections each leading in an opposite di- cases bidrectionality based on rection has been observed (Konorski, 1969, p. 307). mind and its Though, the establishment of empirical research on the quantitative aspect of the mind to behavioural consequences requires a focus on the the phenomenon of brain relationship. Subjective consciousness refers to inward with the purpose of introspection. It comprises a person's ability to look In a sense, one may be aware either examining internal stimuli and mental processes. thoughts, i.e that something is the case. of one's sensations and feelings or relational of observers and systematic control By focusing on careful framing through training have tried to give evidence to of the attributes of stimulus material, introspectionists it appeared that mental content is the existence of subjective consciousness. To them (internal arising sensations). Consequently, made up entirely of sensations and images Brentano's (1838-1917) proposition: follows that variability, measured in if variability is measured in the same scale unit it magnitude, was investigated on subjective units, is linearly related to its psychological the basis of the model depicted in Figure 2. Mentality Figure 2. Psychophysical Model for Scaling WORLD Psi = World of Experience Phi = Physiological Processing of Reflected Energy Because the mental and physical dimensions are conceived as identical in structure, immediately makes the discrimination of a sphere pertaining to sensation and feeling possible psychophysical scaling. In the psycoophysical approach to measurement and observer's representation of consciousness, it is of fundamental importance that the frame of mind about his judgments can be controlled experimentally. It follows that 5 the sensory content of the objects of the physical and social world for that matter can be measured in terms of their mental or psychological values. Weber's (1795-1978) law concerns just this growth of variability in the judgment of a stimulus attribute (Xi) when growth is a function of stimulus measurement. Fechner (1801-1887) and later Thurstone (1887-1955) contributed with the assumption of the importance of a sensitivity integration. They showed that variability between subjective units is constant within a certain psychological continuum. The most general expression, namely that sensation magnitude (psi) grows as a power function of the stimulus magnitude (phi) has been achieved by Stevens (1906-1973) and has become known as Stevens' law (Stevens, 1978) In terms of the formula in Figure 2 it means that the constant (k) of the expression depends on the units of measurement. Therefore, it is of minor interest. What concerns the psychophysicist is "the value of the exponent which serves as a kind of signature that may differ from one sensory continuum tu another" (Stevens, 1978, p. 13). The structural identity proposed between the world of experience and the world surrounding the individual can be given a logarithmic expression which eliminates all bending of the curves: Log(psi) = beta (log(phi)) + log (k) This formula describes a straight line in log-log coordinates, and the exponent (beta) becomes the slope of the line and consequently, the only significant expression. Both (psi and phi) have been conceptualized as coordinated phenomenological forms of actions and events that can be investigated by the methods of psychophysics. It might often be appropriate to formulate psychophysical laws upon the power function. But "any interpretation is totally dependent on the assumption that the response measure is valid. Otherwise, the power function is no more then a regularity in response bias" (Anderson, 1991 pp. 337-338). Mental Test Scores The important task undertaken by psychometricians (Lord & Novick, 1968, p. 1) was "to provide explicit syntactic (i.e, mathematical) definitions for concepts having semantic (i.e, real world) significance". The authors give their basic definition of mental test scores in the form of a Figure (p. 17) which is equivalent to the model depicted in Figure 3. This model has been proposed by Miller, Galanter, and Pribram (1970, p. 34). It represents a change in response probability, and thus a behavioural or interactive definition of mentality. The model implies a substantial differentiation of cause and effect. The special function of a causal interaction provides for learned connections between the variables of investigation (X) and the measurement of event-related potentials. The number of times a particular item (i) has been processed determines completely the state of the "learning system". Initially, the system processes a given item on the basis of some a priori probability of error. Thus, item (i) is connected to some test characteristics (T) such that the probability for correctly processing item (i) is given by a not necessarily reversible function: f(T) = (p+ i,T) 7 6 Figure 3. Cybernetics of Information Integration xi a(T) op- o p + 1 f(T) n+1 Os( a) a<1 In organizing perceptual and motor processes the item (i) is recursively processed. In each successive run its error probability is reduced by a factor A, where < 1. The a modification of the learning state of the system is eisentially based on the difference or incongruity principle. This means that the probability of an error on the (n + 1) run is related to the probability on the nth run. Formally, this results for person (j) in the following logistic function: T(+ j,i) = aT/1+aT. Any person with this test value (T) has the same chance (fi(T)) to process item (i) correctly. Consequently, mentality is now behaviourally explained as the result of a gradual reduction of error probability through recursive processing. This function produces a "characteristic item curve" (Lord & Novick, 1968, p. 366). Each species, however low on the systematic scale, shows behavioural expressions that include numerous details pointing toward learning (Immelmann, 1979, p.121-133). Certain nets of neurons are assumed to carry a decision function. They are used for transferring activity and to decide on which of two activities should be carried out. Thus, behaviour is equated with the physiological representation depicted in Figure 4. In Figure 4 behavioural response potential is explained in rehttion to the neuronal network as basis of a nervous testing mechanism (Konorski, 1969, p. 308). 8 7 Figure 4. Design for Sensori-Motor (= S-R) Associations. No S-S Associations are Assumed CAI,S learn nec 017S T11 HozIor Caotd- (cfbeecA) bed./:0 74,r fiymvre= Notior(--: S-i42) 4/0 J%-s 4,a0clazt/e'.2,fi Affeata Yfooxiv As a result, consciousness has now been totally removed from empirical measurement and representation. The TOTE model differentiates between sequences of events and consequent information processing. No provision is made for any independent activity. Moreover, this postulated internal fiip-flop mechanism relates the behavioural response of the organism to electrochemical (or biochemical) balance theories. It follows that dominant patterns in the neuronal net are directly related to action, implying that the cause of behaviour is implicit and consequently insensitive to changes in the environmental context. To summarize: "Mentality" is a Function of a Dominant Pattern plus a Causal Control Potential. However, these action patterns are theoretically empty, because information flow has been defined within a strict S-R framework and thus, in terms of associative networks. Its related logic is insignificant for an understanding of human information processing and shows only limited usefulness as instrument for computer simulation. "Computer molecules" cannot really be compared to natural cell assemblies. Their purpose is to "act" on command like a switch to determine whether a nerve cell will or will not participate in a network. 9 8 Intentionality as Mark of Mentality With more information having become available it is now apparent that the intention of the individual defines its scope of action. But to fulfil the development of genetically encoded patterns of behaviour, especially during early stages, "telotaxis" has to give directiveness to "intentional movements" (Hess, 1970, pp. 44, 54). This is the function of focusing in the orientation toward objects and events. To make this insight apparent and to stress the evolutionary character of inherited behaviour it is self-referential and that operate on self- necessary to anticipate brain processes that are constructed criteria. Making these processes measurable depends on one's ability to discover transformations for its precision. By specifying the transformations involved in moving from one state to another allows for a scientific approach. The brain's evolutionary stnicture is assumed to determine the state dependencies of the components carrying intention and orientation respectively. Genetic epistemology (Piaget, 1978) and developmental psychology (Werner & Kaplan, 1963) as well as analytic biology (Sommerhoff, 1950; Wolsky & Wolsky, 1976) have demonstrated that the general cooperation of the individual with its environment requires the teleonomic concept in order for the individual to express an "intended" and "oriented" schematizing. Monod (1971) assumes that all behaviour is "teleonomic" inasmuch as behaviour is directed towards the environment. Further, observing behaviour in language :s hardly possible without a model and a procedure for schematizing, because observation presupposes not only that a structure can be specified but also that intentionality and orientation can be observed. In order to get hold of the intention it becomes necessary to apply the Schema concept to the observation. What is missing in the current approaches toward the study of mind is an understanding of the relationship between proximal and final causation of these components as well as their relationship to transformation. The only way of directing is a modeling of these by a respectable inquiry into the development of brain processes studying natural language production with a Kantian approach. Therefore, the main thesis advanced in the following is based on the premise that information processed in absence of natural language is inaccessible to the mind, because the asymmetries and discontinuities in natural language production are reflecting various degrees of human consciousness. Consequently, the brain as self-referential system becomes only accessible through the dynamics and linkage relations manifested in natural language expressions. At the moment of text production the dynamics and structure of the original events become part in the development of a course which has to be measured and represented topologically. This may be done by observing how the action component of the (Aa0) formula becomes realized in natural language. By binding its values with respect to the complementary role of the A's and O's all possible events can be represented in binary matrices. In the course, both structure and process are modified through successive contributions of new linkage relations formed or broken within a Phase space. Characteristic of the A-function is that it must always be distinguishable and the empirical context be known. On the basis of the original structural information necessary for the development of consciousness it will be possible to bring about the teleonomic component governing language production. This may be illustrated with a verbal expression taken from an interview about municipal economics presented in Bierschenk and Bierschenk (1986 b). The text of concern to the present analysis is the following (the translation from free flowing 1 0