Project Gutenberg's Critical Miscellanies, Vol. 3 (of 3), by John Morley This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org Title: Critical Miscellanies, Vol. 3 (of 3) Essay 2: The Death of Mr Mill - Essay 3: Mr Mill's Autobiography Author: John Morley Release Date: March 23, 2007 [EBook #20887] Language: English Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 *** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK CRITICAL MISCELLANIES *** Produced by Paul Murray, Janet Blenkinship and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net CRITICAL MISCELLANIES BY JOHN MORLEY VOL. III. ESSAY 2: THE DEATH OF MR MILL ESSAY 3: MR MILL'S AUTOBIOGRAPHY London MACMILLAN AND CO., LIMITED NEW YORK: THE MACMILLAN COMPANY 1904 CONTENTS THE DEATH OF MR. MILL. Peculiar office of the Teacher 37 Mill's influence in the universities and the press 39 His union of science with aspiration 40 And of courage with patience 42 His abstinence from society 45 Sense of the tendency of society to relapse 46 Peculiar trait of his authority 47 The writer's last day with him 48 MR MILL'S AUTOBIOGRAPHY The spirit of search 53 Key to Mill's type of character and its value 54 Sensibility of his intellect 56 Yet no reaction against his peculiar education 57 Quality of the Autobiography 58 One of its lessons—μἑμνησο ἁπιστειν 60 Mill's aversion to the spirit of sect 60 Not a hindrance to systematisation 61 Criticism united with belief 63 Practical difficulties in the union of loyalty with tolerance 64 Impressiveness of Mill's self-effacement 65 His contempt for socialistic declamation 68 Yet the social aim paramount in him 69 Illustrated in his attack on Hamilton 71 And in the Logic 72 The book on the Subjection of Women 75 The two crises of life 77 Mill did not escape the second of them 78 Influence of Wordsworth 79 Hope from reformed institutions 79 This hope replaced by efforts in a deeper vein 80 Popular opinion of such efforts 81 Irrational disparagement of Mill's hope 82 Mill's conception of happiness contrasted with his father's 84 Remarks on his withdrawal from society 88 It arose from no moral valetudinarianism 91 THE DEATH OF MR. MILL. (May 1873.) THE TRAGIC COMMONPLACES OF THE GRAVE SOUND A FULLER NOTE AS WE MOURN FOR ONE OF THE GREATER AMONG THE SERVANTS OF HUMANITY. A STRONG AND PURE LIGHT IS GONE OUT, THE RADIANCE OF A CLEAR VISION AND A BENEFICENT PURPOSE. ONE OF THOSE HIGH AND MOST WORTHY SPIRITS WHO ARISE FROM TIME TO TIME TO STIR THEIR GENERATION WITH NEW MENTAL IMPULSES IN THE DEEPER THINGS, HAS PERISHED FROM AMONG US. THE DEATH OF ONE WHO DID SO MUCH TO IMPRESS ON HIS CONTEMPORARIES THAT PHYSICAL LAW WORKS INDEPENDENTLY OF MORAL LAW, MARKS WITH PROFOUNDER EMPHASIS THE EVER ANCIENT AND EVER FRESH DECREE THAT THERE IS ONE END TO THE JUST AND THE UNJUST, AND THAT THE SAME STRAIT TOMB AWAITS ALIKE THE POOR DEAD WHOM NATURE OR CIRCUMSTANCE IMPRISONED IN MEAN HORIZONS, AND THOSE WHO SAW FAR AND FELT PASSIONATELY AND PUT THEIR REASON TO NOBLE USES. YET THE FULNESS OF OUR GRIEF IS SOFTENED BY A CERTAIN GREATNESS AND SOLEMNITY IN THE EVENT. THE TEACHERS OF MEN ARE SO FEW, THE GIFT OF INTELLECTUAL FATHERHOOD IS SO RARE, IT IS SURROUNDED BY SUCH SINGULAR GLORIOUSNESS. THE LOSS OF A POWERFUL AND GENEROUS STATESMAN, OR OF A GREAT MASTER IN LETTERS OR ART, TOUCHES US WITH MANY A VIVID REGRET. THE TEACHER, THE MAN WHO HAS TALENTS AND HAS VIRTUES, AND YET HAS A FURTHER SOMETHING WHICH IS NEITHER TALENT NOR VIRTUE, AND WHICH GIVES HIM THE MYSTERIOUS SECRET OF DRAWING MEN AFTER HIM, LEAVES A DEEPER SENSE OF EMPTINESS THAN THIS; BUT LAMENTATION IS AT ONCE SOOTHED AND ELEVATED BY A SENSE OF SACREDNESS IN THE OCCASION. EVEN THOSE WHOM MR. MILL HONOURED WITH HIS FRIENDSHIP, AND WHO MUST ALWAYS BEAR TO HIS MEMORY THE AFFECTIONATE VENERATION OF SONS, MAY YET FEEL THEIR PAIN AT THE THOUGHT THAT THEY WILL SEE HIM NO MORE, RAISED INTO A HIGHER MOOD AS THEY MEDITATE ON THE LOFTINESS OF HIS TASK AND THE STEADFASTNESS AND SUCCESS WITH WHICH HE ACHIEVED IT. IF IT IS GRIEVOUS TO THINK THAT SUCH RICHNESS OF CULTURE, SUCH FULL MATURITY OF WISDOM, SUCH PASSION FOR TRUTH AND JUSTICE, ARE NOW BY A SINGLE STROKE EXTINGUISHED, AT LEAST WE MAY FIND SOME NOT UNWORTHY SOLACE IN THE THOUGHT OF THE SPLENDID PURPOSE THAT THEY HAVE SERVED IN KEEPING ALIVE, AND SURROUNDING WITH NEW ATTRACTIONS, THE DIFFICULT TRADITION OF PATIENT AND ACCURATE THINKING IN UNION WITH UNSELFISH AND MAGNANIMOUS [Pg 37] [Pg 38] living. MUCH WILL ONE DAY HAVE TO BE SAID AS TO THE PRECISE VALUE OF MR. MILL'S PHILOSOPHICAL PRINCIPLES, THE MORE OR LESS OF HIS TRIUMPHS AS A DIALECTICIAN, HIS SKILL AS A CRITIC AND AN EXPOSITOR. HOWEVER THIS TRIAL MAY GO, WE SHALL AT ANY RATE BE SURE THAT WITH HIS REPUTA TION WILL STAND OR FALL THE INTELLECTUAL REPUTE OF A WHOLE GENERATION OF HIS COUNTRYMEN. THE MOST EMINENT OF THOSE WHO ARE NOW SO FAST BECOMING THE FRONT LINE, AS DEATH MOWS DOWN THE VETERANS, ALL BEAR TRACES OF HIS INFLUENCE, WHETHER THEY ARE AVOWED DISCIPLES OR AVOWED OPPONENTS. IF THEY DID NOT ACCEPT HIS METHOD OF THINKING, AT LEAST HE DETERMINED THE QUESTIONS WHICH THEY SHOULD THINK ABOUT. FOR TWENTY YEARS NO ONE AT ALL OPEN TO SERIOUS INTELLECTUAL IMPRESSIONS HAS LEFT OXFORD WITHOUT HAVING UNDERGONE THE INFLUENCE OF MR. MILL'S TEACHING, THOUGH IT WOULD BE TOO MUCH TO SAY THAT IN THAT GRAY TEMPLE WHERE THEY ARE EVER BURNISHING NEW IDOLS, HIS THRONE IS STILL UNSHAKEN. THE PROFESSORIAL CHAIRS THERE AND ELSEWHERE ARE MORE AND MORE BEING FILLED WITH MEN WHOSE MINDS HAVE BEEN TRAINED IN HIS PRINCIPLES. THE UNIVERSITIES ONLY TYPIFY HIS INFLUENCE ON THE LESS LEARNED PART OF THE WORLD. THE BETTER SORT OF JOURNALISTS EDUCATED THEMSELVES ON HIS BOOKS, AND EVEN THE BASER SORT ACQUIRED A HABIT OF QUOTING FROM THEM. HE IS THE ONLY WRITER IN THE WORLD WHOSE TREATISES ON HIGHLY ABSTRACT SUBJECTS HAVE BEEN PRINTED DURING HIS LIFETIME IN EDITIONS FOR THE PEOPLE, AND SOLD AT THE PRICE OF RAILWAY NOVELS. FOREIGNERS FROM ALL COUNTRIES READ HIS BOOKS AS ATTENTIVELY AS HIS MOST EAGER ENGLISH DISCIPLES, AND SOUGHT HIS OPINION AS TO THEIR OWN QUESTIONS WITH AS MUCH REVERENCE AS IF HE HAD BEEN A NATIVE ORACLE. AN EMINENT AMERICAN WHO CAME OVER ON AN OFFICIAL MISSION WHICH BROUGHT HIM INTO CONTACT WITH MOST OF THE LEADING STATESMEN THROUGHOUT EUROPE, SAID TO THE PRESENT WRITER:—'THE MAN WHO IMPRESSED ME MOST OF THEM ALL WAS STUART MILL; YOU PLACED BEFORE HIM THE FACTS ON WHICH YOU SOUGHT HIS OPINION. HE TOOK THEM, GAVE YOU THE DIFFERENT WAYS IN WHICH THEY MIGHT FAIRLY BE LOOKED AT, BALANCED THE OPPOSING CONSIDERATIONS, AND THEN HANDED YOU A FINAL JUDGMENT IN WHICH NOTHING WAS LEFT OUT. HIS MIND WORKED LIKE A SPLENDID PIECE OF MACHINERY; YOU SUPPLY IT WITH RAW MATERIAL, AND IT turns you out a perfectly finished product.' Of such a man England has good reason to be very proud. HE WAS STAMPED IN MANY RESPECTS WITH SPECIALLY ENGLISH QUALITY. HE IS THE LATEST CHIEF OF A DISTINCTIVELY ENGLISH SCHOOL OF PHILOSOPHY, IN WHICH, AS HAS BEEN SAID, THE NAMES OF LOCKE, HUME, ADAM SMITH, AND BENTHAM (AND MR. MILL WOULD HAVE ADDED JAMES MILL) MARK THE LINE OF SUCCESSION—THE SCHOOL WHOSE METHOD SUBORDINATES IMAGINATION TO OBSERVATION, AND WHOSE DOCTRINE LAYS THE FOUNDATIONS OF KNOWLEDGE IN EXPERIENCE, AND THE TESTS OF CONDUCT IN UTILITY. YET, FOR ALL THIS, ONE OF HIS MOST REMARKABLE CHARACTERISTICS WAS LESS ENGLISH THAN FRENCH; HIS CONSTANT ADMISSION OF AN IDEAL AND IMAGINATIVE ELEMENT IN SOCIAL SPECULATION, AND A GLOWING PERSUASION THAT THE EFFORT AND WISDOM AND INGENUITY OF MEN ARE CAPABLE, IF FREE OPPORTUNITY BE GIVEN BY SOCIAL ARRANGEMENTS, OF RAISING HUMAN DESTINY TO A PITCH THAT IS AT PRESENT BEYOND OUR POWERS OF CONCEPTION. PERHAPS THE SUM OF ALL HIS DISTINCTION LIES IN THIS UNION OF STERN SCIENCE WITH INFINITE ASPIRATION, OF RIGOROUS SENSE OF WHAT IS REAL AND PRACTICABLE WITH BRIGHT AND LUMINOUS HOPE. HE TOLD ONE WHO WAS SPEAKING OF CONDORCET'S LIFE OF TURGOT, THAT IN HIS YOUNGER DAYS WHENEVER HE WAS INCLINED TO BE DISCOURAGED, HE WAS IN THE HABIT OF TURNING TO THIS BOOK, AND THAT HE NEVER DID SO WITHOUT RECOVERING POSSESSION OF HIMSELF. TO THE SAME FRIEND, WHO HAD PRINTED SOMETHING COMPARING MR. MILL'S REPULSE AT WESTMINSTER WITH THE DISMISSAL OF THE GREAT MINISTER OF LEWIS THE SIXTEENTH, HE WROTE:—'I NEVER RECEIVED SO GRATIFYING A COMPLIMENT AS THE COMPARISON OF ME TO TURGOT; IT IS INDEED AN HONOUR TO ME THAT SUCH AN ASSIMILATION SHOULD HAVE OCCURRED TO YOU.' THOSE WHO HAVE STUDIED THE CHARACTER OF ONE WHOM EVEN THE RIGID AUSTIN THOUGHT WORTHY TO BE CALLED 'THE GODLIKE TURGOT,' KNOW BOTH THE NOBLENESS AND THE rarity of this type. ITS FORCE LIES NOT IN SINGLE ELEMENTS, BUT IN THAT COMBINATION OF AN ARDENT INTEREST IN HUMAN IMPROVEMENT WITH A REASONED ATTENTION TO THE LAW OF ITS CONDITIONS, WHICH ALONE DESERVES TO BE HONOURED WITH THE HIGH NAME OF WISDOM. THIS COMPLETENESS WAS ONE OF THE SECRETS OF MR. MILL'S PECULIAR ATTRACTION FOR YOUNG MEN, AND FOR THE COMPARATIVELY FEW WOMEN WHOSE INTELLECTUAL INTEREST WAS STRONG ENOUGH TO DRAW THEM TO HIS BOOKS. HE SATISFIED THE INGENUOUS MORAL ARDOUR WHICH IS INSTINCTIVE IN THE BEST NATURES, UNTIL THE DUST OF DAILY LIFE DULLS OR EXTINGUISHES IT, AND AT THE SAME TIME HE SATISFIED THE RATIONALISTIC QUALITIES, WHICH ARE NOT LESS MARKED IN THE YOUTHFUL TEMPERAMENT OF THOSE WHO BY AND BY DO THE WORK OF THE WORLD. THIS MIXTURE OF INTELLECTUAL GRAVITY WITH A PASSIONATE LOVE OF IMPROVEMENT IN ALL THE AIMS AND INSTRUMENTS OF LIFE, MADE MANY INTELLIGENCES ALIVE WHO WOULD OTHERWISE HAVE SLUMBERED, OR SUNK EITHER INTO A DRY PEDANTRY ON THE ONE HAND, OR A WINDY, MISCHIEVOUS PHILANTHROPY ON THE OTHER. HE SHOWED HIMSELF SO WHOLLY FREE FROM THE VULGARITY OF THE SAGE. HE COULD HOPE FOR THE FUTURE WITHOUT TAKING HIS EYE FROM THE REALITIES OF THE PRESENT. HE RECOGNISED THE SOCIAL DESTINATION OF KNOWLEDGE, AND KEPT THE ELEVATION OF THE GREAT ART OF SOCIAL EXISTENCE EVER BEFORE him, as the ultimate end of all speculative activity. ANOTHER SIDE OF THIS RARE COMBINATION WAS HIS UNION OF COURAGE WITH PATIENCE, OF FIRM NONCONFORMITY WITH SILENT CONFORMITY. COMPLIANCE IS ALWAYS A QUESTION OF DEGREE, DEPENDING ON TIME, CIRCUMSTANCE, AND SUBJECT. MR. MILL HIT THE EXACT MEAN, EQUALLY DISTANT FROM TIMOROUS CAUTION AND SELF-INDULGENT VIOLENCE. HE WAS UNRIVALLED IN THE DIFFICULT ART OF CONCILIATING AS MUCH SUPPORT AS WAS POSSIBLE AND ALIENATING AS LITTLE SYMPATHY AS POSSIBLE, FOR NOVEL AND EXTREMELY UNPOPULAR OPINIONS. HE WAS NOT ONE OF THOSE WHO STRIVE TO SPREAD NEW FAITHS BY BRILLIANT SWORDPLAY WITH BUTTONED FOILS, AND HE WAS NOT ONE OF THOSE WHO RUN AMUCK AMONG THE IDOLS OF THE TRIBE AND THE MARKET-PLACE AND THE THEATRE. HE KNEW HOW TO KINDLE THE ENERGY OF ALL WHO WERE LIKELY TO BE PERSUADED BY HIS REASONING, WITHOUT STIMULATING IN A CORRESPONDING DEGREE THE ENERGY OF PERSONS WHOSE CONVICTIONS HE ATTACKED. THUS HE HUSBANDED THE STRENGTH OF TRUTH, AND AVOIDED WASTEFUL FRICTION. PROBABLY NO ENGLISH WRITER THAT EVER LIVED HAS DONE SO MUCH AS MR. MILL TO CUT AT THE VERY ROOT OF THE THEOLOGICAL SPIRIT, YET THERE IS ONLY ONE PASSAGE IN THE WRITINGS PUBLISHED DURING HIS LIFETIME—I MEAN A WELL- KNOWN PASSAGE IN THE LIBERTY—WHICH COULD GIVE ANY OFFENCE TO THE MOST DEVOUT PERSON. HIS CONFORMITY, ONE NEED [Pg 39] [Pg 40] [Pg 41] [Pg 42] [Pg 43] HARDLY SAY, NEVER WENT BEYOND THE NEGATIVE DEGREE, NOR EVER PASSED BEYOND THE CONFORMITY OF SILENCE. THAT GUILTY AND GRIEVOUSLY COMMON PUSILLANIMITY WHICH LEADS MEN TO MAKE OR ACT HYPOCRITICAL PROFESSIONS, ALWAYS MOVED HIS DEEPEST abhorrence. And he did not fear publicly to testify his interest in the return of an atheist to parliament. HIS COURAGE WAS NOT OF THE SPURIOUS KINDS ARISING FROM ANGER, OR IGNORANCE OF THE PERIL, OR LEVITY, OR A RECKLESS CONFIDENCE. THESE ARE ALL VERY EASY. HIS DISTINCTION WAS THAT HE KNEW ALL THE DANGER TO HIMSELF, WAS ANXIOUS TO SAVE PAIN TO OTHERS, WAS BUOYED UP BY NO RASH HOPE THAT THE WORLD WAS TO BE PERMANENTLY BETTERED AT A STROKE, AND YET FOR ALL THIS HE KNEW HOW TO PRESENT AN UNDAUNTED FRONT TO A MAJORITY. THE ONLY FEAR HE EVER KNEW WAS FEAR LEST A PREMATURE OR EXCESSIVE UTTERANCE SHOULD HARM A GOOD CAUSE. HE HAD MEASURED THE PREJUDICES OF MEN, AND HIS DESIRE TO AROUSE THIS OBSTRUCTIVE FORCE IN THE LEAST DEGREE COMPATIBLE WITH EFFECTIVE ADVOCACY OF ANY IMPROVEMENT, SET THE SINGLE LIMIT TO HIS INTREPIDITY. PREJUDICES WERE TO HIM LIKE PHYSICAL PREDISPOSITIONS, WITH WHICH YOU HAVE TO MAKE YOUR ACCOUNT. HE KNEW, TOO, THAT THEY ARE OFTEN BOUND UP WITH THE MOST VALUABLE ELEMENTS IN CHARACTER AND LIFE, AND HENCE HE FEARED THAT VIOLENT SURGERY WHICH IN ERADICATING A FALSE OPINION FATALLY BRUISES AT THE SAME TIME A TRUE AND WHOLESOME FEELING THAT MAY CLING TO IT. THE PATIENCE WHICH WITH SOME MEN IS AN INSTINCT, AND WITH OTHERS A FAIR NAME FOR INDIFFERENCE, WAS WITH HIM AN acquisition of reason and conscience. THE VALUE OF THIS WISE AND VIRTUOUS MIXTURE OF BOLDNESS WITH TOLERANCE, OF COURAGEOUS SPEECH WITH COURAGEOUS RESERVE, HAS BEEN ENORMOUS. ALONG WITH HIS DIRECT PLEAS FOR FREEDOM OF THOUGHT AND FREEDOM OF SPEECH, IT HAS BEEN THE CHIEF SOURCE OF THAT LIBERTY OF EXPRESSING UNPOPULAR OPINIONS IN THIS COUNTRY WITHOUT SOCIAL PERSECUTION, WHICH IS NOW SO NEARLY COMPLETE, THAT HE HIMSELF WAS AT LAST ASTONISHED BY IT. THE MANNER OF HIS DIALECTIC, FIRM AND VIGOROUS AS THE DIALECTIC WAS IN MATTER, HAS GRADUALLY INTRODUCED MITIGATING ELEMENTS INTO THE ATMOSPHERE OF OPINION. PARTLY, NO DOUBT, THE SINGULAR TOLERANCE OF FREE DISCUSSION WHICH NOW PREVAILS IN ENGLAND—I DO NOT MEAN THAT IT IS AT ALL PERFECT—ARISES FROM THE PREVALENT SCEPTICISM, FROM INDIFFERENCE, AND FROM THE INFLUENCE OF SOME OF THE MORE HIGH-MINDED OF THE CLERGY. BUT MR. MILL'S STEADFAST ABSTINENCE FROM DRAWING WHOLESALE INDICTMENTS AGAINST PERSONS OR CLASSES WHOSE OPINIONS HE CONTROVERTED, HIS GENEROUS CANDOUR, HIS SCRUPULOUS RESPECT FOR ANY GERM OF GOOD IN WHATEVER COMPANY IT WAS FOUND, AND HIS LARGE ALLOWANCES, CONTRIBUTED POSITIVE ELEMENTS TO WHAT MIGHT OTHERWISE HAVE BEEN THE NEGATIVE TOLERANCE THAT COMES OF MORAL STAGNATION. TOLERANCE OF DISTASTEFUL NOTIONS IN OTHERS BECAME ASSOCIATED IN HIS PERSON AT ONCE WITH THE widest enlightenment, and the strongest conviction of the truth of our own notions. HIS CAREER, BESIDE ALL ELSE, WAS A PROTEST OF THE SIMPLEST AND LOFTIEST KIND AGAINST SOME OF THE MOST DEGRADING FEATURES OF OUR SOCIETY. NO ONE IS MORE ALIVE THAN HE WAS TO THE WORTH OF ALL THAT ADDS GRACE AND DIGNITY TO HUMAN LIFE; BUT THE SINCERITY OF THIS FEELING FILLED HIM WITH AVERSION FOR THE MAKE-BELIEVE DIGNITY OF A LUXURIOUS AND ARTIFICIAL COMMUNITY. WITHOUT EITHER ARROGANCE OR BITTERNESS, HE STOOD ALOOF FROM THAT CONVENTIONAL INTERCOURSE WHICH IS MISNAMED SOCIAL DUTY. WITHOUT EITHER DISCOURTESY OR CYNICISM, HE REFUSED TO PLAY A PART IN THAT DANCE OF MIMES WHICH PASSES FOR LIFE AMONG THE UPPER CLASSES. IN HIM, TO EXTRAORDINARY INTELLECTUAL ATTAINMENTS WAS ADDED THE GIFT OF A FIRM AND STEADFAST SELF-RESPECT, WHICH UNFORTUNATELY DOES NOT ALWAYS GO WITH THEM. HE FELT THE REALITY OF THINGS, AND IT WAS EASIER FOR A WORKMAN THAN FOR a princess to obtain access to him. It is not always the men who talk most affectingly about our being all of one flesh and BLOOD, WHO ARE PROOF AGAINST THOSE MYSTERIOUS CHARMS OF SUPERIOR RANK, WHICH DO SO MUCH TO FOSTER UNWORTHY CONCEPTIONS OF LIFE IN ENGLISH SOCIETY; AND THERE ARE MANY PEOPLE CAPABLE OF ACCEPTING MR. MILL'S SOCIAL PRINCIPLES, AND THE THEORETICAL COROLLARIES THEY CONTAIN, WHO YET WOULD CONDEMN HIS MANLY PLAINNESS AND AUSTERE CONSISTENCY IN ACTING ON THEM. THE TOO COMMON TENDENCY IN US ALL TO MORAL SLOVENLINESS, AND A LAZY CONTENTMENT WITH A LITTLE FLACCID PROTEST AGAINST EVIL, FINDS A CONSTANT REBUKE IN HIS CAREER. THE INDOMITABLE PASSION FOR JUSTICE WHICH MADE HIM STRIVE SO LONG AND SO TENACIOUSLY TO BRING TO JUDGMENT A PUBLIC OFFICIAL, WHOM HE CONCEIVED TO BE A GREAT CRIMINAL, WAS WORTHY OF ONE OF THE STOUTEST PATRIOTS IN OUR SEVENTEENTH-CENTURY HISTORY. THE SAME MORAL THOROUGHNESS STIRRED THE SAME INDIGNATION IN HIM on a more recent occasion, when he declared it 'a permanent disgrace to the Government that the iniquitous sentence on the gas-stokers was not remitted as soon as passed.' MUCH OF HIS MOST STRIKING QUALITY WAS OWING TO THE EXCEPTIONAL DEGREE IN WHICH HE WAS ALIVE TO THE CONSTANT TENDENCY OF SOCIETY TO LOSE SOME EXCELLENCE OF AIM, TO RELAPSE AT SOME POINT FROM THE STANDARD OF TRUTH AND RIGHT WHICH HAD BEEN REACHED BY LONG PREVIOUS EFFORT, TO FALL BACK IN HEIGHT OF MORAL IDEAL. HE WAS KEENLY SENSIBLE THAT IT IS ONLY BY PERSISTENT STRIVING AFTER IMPROVEMENT IN OUR CONCEPTIONS OF DUTY, AND IMPROVEMENT IN THE EXTERNAL MEANS FOR REALISING THEM, THAT EVEN THE ACQUISITIONS OF PAST GENERATIONS ARE RETAINED. HE KNEW THE INTENSE DIFFICULTY OF MAKING LIFE BETTER BY EVER SO LITTLE. HENCE AT ONCE THE EXALTATION OF HIS OWN IDEAS OF TRUTH AND RIGHT, AND HIS EAGERNESS TO CONCILIATE ANYTHING LIKE VIRTUOUS SOCIAL FEELING, IN WHATEVER INTELLECTUAL OR POLITICAL ASSOCIATION HE FOUND IT. HENCE ALSO THE VEHEMENCE OF HIS PASSION FOR THE UNFETTERED AND UNCHECKED DEVELOPMENT OF NEW IDEAS ON ALL SUBJECTS, OF ORIGINALITY IN MORAL AND SOCIAL points of view; because repression, whether by public opinion or in any other way, may be the means of untold waste of GIFTS THAT MIGHT HAVE CONFERRED ON MANKIND UNSPEAKABLE BENEFITS. THE DISCIPLINE AND VIGOUR OF HIS UNDERSTANDING MADE HIM THE LEAST INDULGENT OF JUDGES TO ANYTHING LIKE CHARLATANRY, AND EFFECTUALLY PREVENTED HIS UNWILLINGNESS TO LET THE SMALLEST GOOD ELEMENT BE LOST, FROM DEGENERATING INTO THAT WEAK KIND OF UNIVERSALISM WHICH NULLIFIES SOME OTHERWISE good men. [Pg 44] [Pg 45] [Pg 46] [Pg 47] SOME GREAT MEN SEIZE UPON US BY THE FORCE OF AN IMPOSING AND MAJESTIC AUTHORITY; THEIR THOUGHTS IMPRESS THE IMAGINATION, THEIR WORDS ARE WINGED, THEY ARE AS PROPHETS BEARING HIGH TESTIMONY THAT CANNOT BE GAINSAID. BOSSUET, FOR INSTANCE, OR PASCAL. OTHERS, AND OF THESE MR. MILL WAS ONE, ACQUIRE DISCIPLES NOT BY A COMMANDING AUTHORITY, BUT BY A MODERATE AND IMPERSONAL KIND OF PERSUASION. HE APPEALS NOT TO OUR SENSE OF GREATNESS AND POWER IN A TEACHER, WHICH IS NOBLE, BUT TO OUR LOVE OF FINDING AND EMBRACING TRUTH FOR OURSELVES, WHICH IS STILL NOBLER. PEOPLE WHO LIKE THEIR TEACHER TO BE AS A KING PUBLISHING DECREES WITH HERALD AND TRUMPET, PERHAPS FIND MR. MILL COLOURLESS. YET THIS HABITUAL EFFACEMENT of his own personality marked a delicate and very rare shade in his reverence for the sacred purity of truth. MEDITATION ON THE INFLUENCE OF ONE WHO HAS BEEN THE FOREMOST INSTRUCTOR OF HIS TIME IN WISDOM AND GOODNESS QUICKLY BREAKS OFF, IN THIS HOUR WHEN HIS LOSS IS FRESH UPON US; IT CHANGES INTO AFFECTIONATE REMINISCENCES FOR WHICH SILENCE IS MORE FITTING. IN SUCH AN HOUR THOUGHT TURNS RATHER TO THE PERSON THAN THE WORK OF THE MASTER WHOM WE MOURN. WE RECALL HIS SIMPLICITY, GENTLENESS, HEROIC SELF-ABNEGATION; HIS GENEROSITY IN ENCOURAGING, HIS EAGER READINESS IN HELPING; THE WARM KINDLINESS OF HIS ACCOST, THE FRIENDLY BRIGHTENING OF THE EYE. THE LAST TIME I SAW HIM WAS A FEW DAYS BEFORE HE LEFT England.[1] HE CAME TO SPEND A DAY WITH ME IN THE COUNTRY, OF WHICH THE FOLLOWING BRIEF NOTES HAPPENED TO BE WRITTEN AT the time in a letter to a friend:— 'HE CAME DOWN BY THE MORNING TRAIN TO GUILDFORD STATION, WHERE I WAS WAITING FOR HIM. HE WAS IN HIS MOST EVEN AND MELLOW HUMOUR. WE WALKED IN A LEISURELY WAY AND THROUGH ROUNDABOUT TRACKS FOR SOME FOUR HOURS ALONG THE ANCIENT GREEN ROAD WHICH YOU KNOW, OVER THE HIGH GRASSY DOWNS, INTO OLD CHALK PITS PICTURESQUE WITH JUNIPER AND YEW, ACROSS HEATHS AND COMMONS, AND SO UP TO OUR WINDY PROMONTORY, WHERE THE MAJESTIC PROSPECT STIRRED HIM WITH LIVELY DELIGHT. YOU KNOW HE IS A FERVENT BOTANIST, AND EVERY TEN MINUTES HE STOOPED TO LOOK AT THIS OR THAT ON THE PATH. UNLUCKILY I AM IGNORANT of the very rudiments of the matter, so his parenthetic enthusiasms were lost upon me. 'OF COURSE HE TALKED, AND TALKED WELL. HE ADMITTED THAT GOETHE HAD ADDED NEW POINTS OF VIEW TO LIFE, BUT HAS A DEEP DISLIKE OF HIS MORAL CHARACTER; WONDERED HOW A MAN WHO COULD DRAW THE SORROWS OF A DESERTED WOMAN LIKE AURELIA, IN Wilhelm Meister, SHOULD YET HAVE BEHAVED SO SYSTEMATICALLY ILL TO WOMEN. GOETHE TRIED AS HARD AS HE COULD TO BE A GREEK, YET HIS FAILURE TO PRODUCE ANYTHING PERFECT IN FORM, EXCEPT A FEW LYRICS, PROVES THE IRRESISTIBLE EXPANSION OF THE MODERN SPIRIT, AND THE INADEQUATENESS OF THE GREEK TYPE TO MODERN NEEDS OF ACTIVITY AND EXPRESSION. GREATLY PREFERS Schiller in all respects; turning to him from Goethe is like going into the fresh air from a hothouse. 'SPOKE OF STYLE: THINKS GOLDSMITH UNSURPASSED; THEN ADDISON COMES. GREATLY DISLIKES THE STYLE OF JUNIUS AND OF GIBBON; INDEED, THINKS MEANLY OF THE LATTER IN ALL RESPECTS, EXCEPT FOR HIS RESEARCH, WHICH ALONE OF THE WORK OF THAT CENTURY STANDS THE TEST OF NINETEENTH-CENTURY CRITICISM. DID NOT AGREE WITH ME THAT GEORGE SAND'S IS THE HIGH-WATER MARK OF PROSE, BUT yet could not name anybody higher, and admitted that her prose stirs you like music. 'SEEMED DISPOSED TO THINK THAT THE MOST FEASIBLE SOLUTION OF THE IRISH UNIVERSITY QUESTION IS A CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY, THE RESTRICTIVE AND OBSCURANTIST TENDENCIES OF WHICH YOU MAY EXPECT TO HAVE CHEEKED BY THE ACTIVE COMPETITION OF LIFE WITH men trained in more enlightened systems. Spoke of Home Rule. 'MADE REMARKS ON THE DIFFERENCE IN THE FEELING OF MODERN REFUSERS OF CHRISTIANITY AS COMPARED WITH THAT OF MEN LIKE HIS FATHER, IMPASSIONED DENIERS, WHO BELIEVED THAT IF ONLY YOU BROKE UP THE POWER OF THE PRIESTS AND CHECKED SUPERSTITION, ALL WOULD GO WELL—A DREAM FROM WHICH THEY WERE PARTIALLY AWAKENED BY SEEING THAT THE FRENCH REVOLUTION, WHICH OVERTHREW THE CHURCH, STILL DID NOT BRING THE MILLENNIUM. HIS RADICAL FRIENDS USED TO BE VERY ANGRY WITH HIM FOR LOVING Wordsworth. "WordsWORTH," I USED TO SAY, "IS AGAINST YOU, NO DOUBT, IN THE BATTLE WHICH YOU ARE NOW WAGING, BUT AFTER you have won, the world will need more than ever those qualities which Wordsworth is keeping alive and nourishing." In HIS YOUTH MERE NEGATION OF RELIGION WAS A FIRM BOND OF UNION, SOCIAL AND OTHERWISE, BETWEEN MEN WHO AGREED IN NOTHING else. 'SPOKE OF THE MODERN TENDENCY TO PURE THEISM, AND MET THE OBJECTION THAT IT RETARDS IMPROVEMENT BY TURNING THE MINDS OF SOME OF THE BEST MEN FROM SOCIAL AFFAIRS, BY THE COUNTER-PROPOSITION THAT IT IS USEFUL TO SOCIETY, APART FROM THE QUESTION OF ITS TRUTH,—USEFUL AS A PROVISIONAL BELIEF, BECAUSE PEOPLE WILL IDENTIFY SERVICEABLE MINISTRY TO MEN WITH SERVICE OF GOD. THINKS WE CANNOT WITH ANY SORT OF PRECISION DEFINE THE COMING MODIFICATION OF RELIGION, BUT ANTICIPATES THAT IT WILL UNDOUBTEDLY REST UPON THE SOLIDARITY OF MANKIND, AS COMTE SAID, AND AS YOU AND I BELIEVE. PERCEIVES TWO THINGS, AT ANY RATE, WHICH ARE LIKELY TO LEAD MEN TO INVEST THIS WITH THE MORAL AUTHORITY OF A RELIGION; FIRST, THEY WILL BECOME MORE AND MORE IMPRESSED BY THE AWFUL FACT THAT A PIECE OF CONDUCT TO-DAY MAY PROVE A CURSE TO MEN AND WOMEN SCORES AND EVEN HUNDREDS OF YEARS AFTER THE AUTHOR OF IT IS DEAD; AND SECOND, THEY WILL MORE AND MORE FEEL THAT THEY CAN ONLY SATISFY THEIR SENTIMENT OF GRATITUDE TO SEEN OR UNSEEN BENEFACTORS, CAN ONLY REPAY THE UNTOLD BENEFITS THEY HAVE INHERITED, BY diligently maintaining the traditions of service. 'AND SO FORTH, FULL OF INTEREST AND SUGGESTIVENESS ALL THROUGH. WHEN HE GOT HERE, HE CHATTED TO R—— OVER OUR LUNCH, WITH SOMETHING OF THE SIMPLE AMIABLENESS OF A CHILD, ABOUT THE WILD FLOWERS, THE WAYS OF INSECTS, AND NOTES OF BIRDS. HE WAS IMPATIENT FOR THE SONG OF THE NIGHTINGALE. THEN I DROVE HIM TO OUR LITTLE ROADSIDE STATION, AND ONE OF THE MOST delightful days of my life came to its end, like all other days, delightful and sorrowful.' [Pg 48] [Pg 50] [Pg 51] ALAS, THE SORROWFUL DAY WHICH EVER DOGS OUR DELIGHT FOLLOWED VERY QUICKLY. THE NIGHTINGALE THAT HE LONGED FOR FILLS THE DARKNESS WITH MUSIC, BUT NOT FOR THE EAR OF THE DEAD MASTER: HE RESTS IN THE DEEPER DARKNESS WHERE THE SILENCE IS UNBROKEN FOR EVER. WE MAY CONSOLE OURSELVES WITH THE REFLECTION OFFERED BY THE DYING SOCRATES TO HIS SORROWFUL COMPANIONS: HE WHO HAS ARRAYED THE SOUL IN HER OWN PROPER JEWELS OF MODERATION AND JUSTICE AND COURAGE AND NOBLENESS AND TRUTH, IS EVER READY FOR THE JOURNEY WHEN HIS TIME COMES. WE HAVE LOST A GREAT TEACHER AND EXAMPLE OF KNOWLEDGE AND VIRTUE, BUT MEN WILL LONG FEEL THE PRESENCE OF HIS CHARACTER ABOUT THEM, MAKING THEM ASHAMED OF WHAT IS INDOLENT OR SELFISH, AND ENCOURAGING THEM TO ALL DISINTERESTED LABOUR, BOTH IN TRYING TO DO GOOD AND IN TRYING TO FIND OUT what the good is,—which is harder. MR. MILL'S AUTOBIOGRAPHY. Chercher en gémissant—SEARCH WITH MANY SIGHS—THAT WAS PASCAL'S NOTION OF PRAISEWORTHY LIVING AND CHOOSING THE BETTER PART. SEARCH, AND SEARCH WITH MUCH TRAVAIL, STRIKES US AS THE CHIEF INTELLECTUAL ENSIGN AND DEVICE OF THAT EMINENT MAN WHOSE RECORD OF HIS OWN MENTAL NURTURE AND GROWTH WE HAVE ALL BEEN READING. EVERYBODY ENDOWED WITH ENERGETIC INTELLIGENCE HAS A MEASURE OF THE SPIRIT OF SEARCH POURED OUT UPON HIM. ALL SUCH PERSONS ACT ON THE SOCRATIC MAXIM THAT THE LIFE WITHOUT INQUIRY IS A LIFE TO BE LIVED BY NO MAN. BUT IT IS THE RARE DISTINCTION OF A VERY FEW TO ACCEPT THE MAXIM IN ITS FULL SIGNIFICANCE, TO INSIST ON AN OPEN MIND AS THE TRUE SECRET OF WISDOM, TO PRESS THE EXAMINATION AND TESTING OF OUR CONVICTIONS AS THE TRUE WAY AT ONCE TO STABILITY AND GROWTH OF CHARACTER, AND THUS TO MAKE OF LIFE WHAT IT IS SO GOOD FOR US THAT IT SHOULD BE, A CONTINUAL BUILDING UP, A CEASELESS FORTIFYING AND ENLARGEMENT AND MULTIPLICATION OF THE TREASURES OF THE SPIRIT. TO MAKE A POINT OF 'EXAMINING WHAT WAS SAID IN DEFENCE OF ALL OPINIONS, HOWEVER NEW OR HOWEVER OLD, IN THE CONVICTION THAT EVEN IF THEY WERE ERRORS THERE MIGHT BE A SUBSTRATUM OF TRUTH UNDERNEATH THEM, AND THAT IN ANY CASE THE DISCOVERY OF WHAT IT WAS THAT MADE THEM PLAUSIBLE WOULD BE A BENEFIT TO TRUTH,' [2]—TO THRUST OUT THE SPIRIT OF PARTY, OF SECT, OF CREED, OF THE POORER SORT OF SELF-ESTEEM, OF FUTILE CONTENTIOUSNESS, AND SO TO SEEK AND AGAIN SEEK WITH UNDEVIATING SINGLENESS OF MIND THE RIGHT INTERPRETATION OF OUR EXPERIENCES—HERE IS THE GENUINE SEAL OF INTELLECTUAL MASTERY and the true stamp of a perfect rationality. THE MEN TO WHOM THIS IS THE IDEAL OF THE LIFE OF THE REASON, AND WHO HAVE DONE ANYTHING CONSIDERABLE TOWARDS SPREADING A DESIRE AFTER IT, DESERVE TO HAVE THEIR MEMORIES GRATEFULLY CHERISHED EVEN BY THOSE WHO DO NOT AGREE WITH ALL THEIR POSITIVE OPINIONS. WE NEED ONLY TO REFLECT A LITTLE ON THE CONDITIONS OF HUMAN EXISTENCE; ON THE URGENT DEMAND WHICH MATERIAL NECESSITIES INEVITABLY MAKE ON SO IMMENSE A PROPORTION OF OUR TIME AND THOUGHT; ON THE SPACE WHICH IS NATURALLY FILLED UP BY THE ACTIVITY OF ABSORBING AFFECTIONS; ON THE FATAL POWER OF MERE TRADITION AND REPORT OVER THE INDIFFERENT, AND THE FATAL POWER OF INVETERATE PREJUDICE OVER SO MANY EVEN OF THE BEST OF THOSE WHO ARE NOT INDIFFERENT. THEN WE SHALL KNOW BETTER HOW TO VALUE SUCH A TYPE OF CHARACTER AND LIFE AS MR. MILL HAS NOW TOLD US THE STORY OF, IN WHICH INTELLECTUAL IMPRESSIONABLENESS ON THE MOST IMPORTANT SUBJECTS OF HUMAN THOUGHT WAS SO CULTIVATED AS ALMOST TO ACQUIRE THE STRENGTH AND QUICK RESPONSIVENESS OF EMOTIONAL SENSIBILITY. AND THIS, WITHOUT THE TOO COMMON DRAWBACK TO GREAT OPENNESS OF MIND. THIS DRAWBACK CONSISTS IN LOOSE BELIEFS, TAKEN UP TO-DAY AND SILENTLY DROPPED TO-MORROW; VACILLATING OPINIONS, CONSTANTLY BEING EXCHANGED FOR THEIR CONTRARIES; FEEBLE CONVICTIONS, APPEARING, SHIFTING, VANISHING, IN THE QUICKSANDS OF AN unstable mind. NOBODY WILL IMPUTE ANY OF THESE DISASTROUS WEAKNESSES TO MR. MILL. HIS IMPRESSIONABLENESS WAS OF THE VALUABLE POSITIVE KIND, WHICH ADDS AND ASSIMILATES NEW ELEMENTS FROM MANY QUARTERS, WITHOUT DISTURBING THE ORGANIC STRUCTURE OF THE WHOLE. WHAT HE SAYS OF ONE STAGE IN HIS GROWTH REMAINED GENERALLY TRUE OF HIM UNTIL THE VERY END:—'I FOUND THE FABRIC OF MY OLD AND TAUGHT OPINIONS GIVING WAY IN MANY FRESH PLACES, AND I NEVER ALLOWED IT TO FALL TO PIECES, BUT WAS INCESSANTLY OCCUPIED IN WEAVING IT ANEW. I NEVER IN THE COURSE OF MY TRANSITION WAS CONTENT TO REMAIN, FOR EVER SO SHORT A TIME, CONFUSED AND UNSETTLED. WHEN I HAD TAKEN IN ANY NEW IDEA, I COULD NOT REST TILL I HAD ADJUSTED ITS RELATIONS TO MY OLD OPINIONS, AND ASCERTAINED EXACTLY HOW FAR ITS EFFECT OUGHT TO EXTEND IN MODIFYING OR SUPERSEDING THEM' (P. 156). THIS CAREFUL AND CONSCIENTIOUS RECOGNITION OF THE DUTY OF HAVING ORDERED OPINIONS, AND OF RESPONSIBILITY FOR THESE OPINIONS BEING BOTH AS TRUE AND AS CONSISTENT WITH ONE ANOTHER AS TAKING PAINS WITH HIS MIND COULD MAKE THEM, DISTINGUISHED MR. MILL FROM THE MEN WHO FLIT AIMLESSLY FROM DOCTRINE TO DOCTRINE, AS THE FLIES OF A SUMMER DAY DART FROM POINT TO POINT IN THE VACUOUS AIR. IT DISTINGUISHED HIM ALSO FROM THOSE SENSITIVE SPIRITS WHO FLING THEMSELVES DOWN FROM THE HEIGHTS OF RATIONALISM SUDDENLY INTO THE PIT OF AN INFALLIBLE CHURCH; AND FROM THOSE WHO, LIKE LA MENNAIS, MOVE VIOLENTLY BETWEEN FAITH AND REASON, BETWEEN TRADITION AND INQUIRY, BETWEEN THE FULNESS OF DEFERENCE TO AUTHORITY AND THE FULNESS OF individual self-assertion. ALL MINDS OF THE FIRST QUALITY MOVE AND GROW; THEY HAVE A SUSCEPTIBILITY TO MANY SORTS OF NEW IMPRESSIONS, A MOBILITY, A FEELING OUTWARDS, WHICH MAKES IT IMPOSSIBLE FOR THEM TO REMAIN IN THE STERN FIXITY OF AN EARLY IMPLANTED SET OF DOGMAS, WHETHER PHILOSOPHIC OR RELIGIOUS. IN STOICAL TENACITY OF CHARACTER, AS WELL AS IN INTELLECTUAL ORIGINALITY AND CONCENTRATED FORCE OF UNDERSTANDING, SOME OF THOSE WHO KNEW BOTH TELL US THAT MR. MILL WAS INFERIOR TO HIS FATHER. BUT WHO DOES NOT FEEL IN THE SON THE SERIOUS CHARM OF A POWER OF ADAPTATION AND PLIABLENESS WHICH WE CAN NEVER ASSOCIATE WITH THE HARDY AND MORE RIGOROUS NATURE OF THE OTHER? AND IT WAS JUST BECAUSE HE HAD THIS SENSIBILITY OF THE INTELLECT, THAT THE HISTORY OF WHAT IT DID FOR HIM IS SO EDIFYING A PERFORMANCE FOR A PEOPLE LIKE OURSELVES, AMONG WHOM THAT QUALITY IS SO EXTREMELY UNCOMMON. FOR IT WAS THE SENSIBILITY OF STRENGTH AND NOT OF WEAKNESS, NOR OF MERE OVER-REFINEMENT AND SUBTLETY. WE MAY ESTIMATE THE SIGNIFICANCE OF SUCH A DIFFERENCE, WHEN WE THINK HOW LITTLE, AFTER ALL, THE SINGULAR GIFTS OF A NEWMAN OR A [Pg 53] [Pg 52] [Pg 54] [Pg 55] [Pg 56] MAURICE HAVE DONE FOR THEIR CONTEMPORARIES, SIMPLY BECAUSE THESE TWO EMINENT MEN ALLOWED CONSCIOUSNESS OF THEIR own weakness to 'sickly over' the spontaneous impulses of their strength. THE WONDER IS THAT THE REACTION AGAINST SUCH AN EDUCATION AS THAT THROUGH WHICH JAMES MILL BROUGHT HIS SON,—AN EDUCATION SO INTENSE, SO PURELY ANALYTICAL, DOING SO MUCH FOR THE REASON AND SO LITTLE FOR THE SATISFACTION OF THE AFFECTIONS, —WAS NOT OF THE MOST VIOLENT KIND. THE WONDER IS THAT THE CRISIS THROUGH WHICH NEARLY EVERY YOUTH OF GOOD QUALITY HAS TO PASS, AND FROM WHICH MR. MILL, AS HE HAS TOLD US, BY NO MEANS ESCAPED, DID NOT LAND HIM IN SOME OF THE EXTREME FORMS OF TRANSCENDENTALISM. IF IT HAD DONE SO THE RECORD OF THE JOURNEY WOULD NO DOUBT HAVE BEEN MORE ABUNDANT IN MELODRAMATIC INCIDENTS. IT WOULD HAVE DONE MORE TO TICKLE THE FANCY OF 'THE PRESENT AGE OF LOUD DISPUTES BUT WEAK CONVICTIONS.' AND IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN FOUND MORE TOUCHING BY THE LARGE NUMBERS OF TALKERS AND WRITERS WHO SEEM TO THINK THAT A HISTORY OF A CAREFUL MAN'S OPINIONS ON GRAVE AND DIFFICULT SUBJECTS OUGHT TO HAVE ALL THE RAPID MOVEMENTS AND UNEXPECTED TURNS OF A ROMANCE, AND THAT A BOOK WITHOUT RAPTURE AND EFFUSION AND A GREAT MANY CAPITAL LETTERS MUST BE JOYLESS AND DISAPPOINTING. THOSE OF US WHO DISLIKE LITERARY HYSTERIA AS MUCH AS WE DISLIKE THE COARSENESS THAT MISTAKES ITSELF FOR FORCE, MAY WELL BE GLAD TO FOLLOW THE MENTAL HISTORY OF A MAN WHO KNEW HOW TO MOVE AND GROW WITHOUT ANY OF THESE REACTIONS AND LEAPS ON THE ONE HAND, OR ANY OF THAT OVERDONE REALISM ON THE OTHER, WHICH MAY ALL MAKE A MORE striking picture, but which do assuredly more often than not mark the ruin of a mind and the nullification of a career. IF WE ARE NOW AND THEN CONSCIOUS IN THE BOOK OF A CERTAIN WANT OF SPACING, OF CHANGING PERSPECTIVES AND LONG VISTAS; IF WE HAVE PERHAPS A SENSE OF BEING TOO NARROWLY ENCLOSED; IF WE MISS THE RELISH OF HUMOUR OR THE OCCASIONAL RELIEF OF IRONY; WE OUGHT TO REMEMBER THAT WE ARE BUSY NOT WITH A WORK OF IMAGINATION OR ART, BUT WITH THE PRACTICAL RECORD OF THE FORMATION OF AN EMINENT THINKER'S MENTAL HABITS AND THE SUCCESSION OF HIS MENTAL ATTITUDES. THE FORMATION OF SUCH MENTAL HABITS IS NOT A ROMANCE, BUT THE MOST ARDUOUS OF REAL CONCERNS. IF WE ARE LED UP TO NONE OF THE ENKINDLED SUMMITS OF THE SOUL, AND PLUNGED INTO NONE OF ITS ABYSSES, THAT IS NO REASON WHY WE SHOULD FAIL TO BE STRUCK BY THE PALE FLAME OF STRENUOUS SELF-POSSESSION, OR TOUCHED BY THE INGENUOUSNESS AND SIMPLICITY OF THE SPEAKER'S ACCENTS. A GENERATION CONTINUALLY EXCITED BY NARRATIVES, AS STERILE AS VEHEMENT, OF STORM AND STRESS AND SPIRITUAL SHIPWRECK, MIGHT DO WELL, IF IT KNEW THE THINGS THAT PERTAINED TO ITS PEACE, TO PONDER THIS UNVARNISHED HISTORY—THE HISTORY OF A MAN WHO, THOUGH HE WAS NOT ONE OF THE PICTURESQUE VICTIMS OF THE WASTEFUL TORMENTS OF AN UNEASY SPIRITUAL SELF-CONSCIOUSNESS, YET LABOURED so patiently after the gifts of intellectual strength, and did so much permanently to widen the judgments of the world. IF MR. MILL'S AUTOBIOGRAPHY HAS NO LITERARY GRANDEUR, NOR ARTISTIC VARIETY, IT HAS THE RARER MERIT OF PRESENTING FOR OUR CONTEMPLATION A CHARACTER THAT WAS INFESTED BY NONE OF THE SMALLER PASSIONS, AND WARPED BY NONE OF THE MORE UNINTELLIGENT ATTITUDES OF THE HUMAN MIND. WE HAVE TO REMEMBER THAT IT IS EXACTLY THESE, THE SMALLER PASSIONS ON THE ONE HAND, AND SLOVENLINESS OF INTELLIGENCE ON THE OTHER, WHICH ARE EVEN WORSE AGENCIES IN SPOILING THE WORTH OF LIFE AND THE ADVANCE OF SOCIETY THAN THE MORE IMPOSING VICES EITHER OF THOUGHT OR SENTIMENT. MANY HAVE TOLD THE TALE OF A LIFE OF MUCH EXTERNAL EVENTFULNESS. THERE IS A RARER INSTRUCTIVENESS IN THE QUIET CAREER OF ONE WHOSE LIFE WAS AN INCESSANT EDUCATION, A PERSISTENT STRENGTHENING OF THE MENTAL HABIT OF 'NEVER ACCEPTING HALF-SOLUTIONS OF DIFFICULTIES AS COMPLETE; NEVER ABANDONING A PUZZLE, BUT AGAIN AND AGAIN RETURNING TO IT UNTIL IT WAS CLEARED UP; NEVER ALLOWING OBSCURE CORNERS OF A SUBJECT TO REMAIN UNEXPLORED, BECAUSE THEY DID NOT APPEAR IMPORTANT; NEVER THINKING THAT I PERFECTLY UNDERSTOOD ANY PART OF A SUBJECT UNTIL I UNDERSTOOD THE WHOLE' (P. 123). IT IS TRUE THAT THIS MENTAL HABIT IS NOT SO SINGULAR IN ITSELF, FOR IT IS THE COMMON AND INDISPENSABLE MERIT OF EVERY TRULY SCIENTIFIC THINKER. MR. MILL'S DISTINCTION LAY IN THE DELIBERATE INTENTION AND THE SYSTEMATIC PATIENCE WITH WHICH HE BROUGHT IT TO THE CONSIDERATION OF MORAL AND RELIGIOUS AND SOCIAL SUBJECTS. IN THIS REGION HITHERTO, FOR REASONS THAT ARE NOT DIFFICULT TO SEEK, THE EMPIRE OF PREJUDICE AND PASSION HAS BEEN SO MUCH stronger, so much harder to resist, than in the field of physical science. SECT IS SO READY TO SUCCEED SECT, AND SCHOOL COMES AFTER SCHOOL, WITH CONSTANT REPLACEMENT OF ONE SORT OF ORTHODOXY BY ANOTHER SORT, UNTIL EVEN THE PRINCIPLE OF RELATIVITY BECOMES THE BASE OF A SET OF ABSOLUTE AND FINAL DOGMAS, AND THE VERY DOCTRINE OF UNCERTAINTY ITSELF BECOMES FIXED IN A KIND OF AUTHORITATIVE NIHILISM. IT IS, THEREFORE, A SIGNAL GAIN THAT WE NOW HAVE A NEW TYPE, WITH THE OLD WISE DEVICE, ΜἙΜΝΗΣΟ ἉΠΙΣΤΕΙΝ— be sure that you distrust. DISTRUST YOUR OWN BIAS; DISTRUST YOUR SUPPOSED KNOWLEDGE; CONSTANTLY TRY, PROVE, FORTIFY YOUR FIRMEST CONVICTIONS. AND ALL THIS, THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE DOMAIN WHERE THE INTELLIGENCE RULES. IT WAS CHARACTERISTIC OF A MAN OF THIS TYPE THAT HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN SEIZED BY THAT MEMORABLE PASSAGE IN CONDORCET'S LIFE OF TURGOT TO WHICH MR. MILL REFERS (P. 114), AND WHICH EVERY MAN WITH AN active interest in serious affairs should bind about his neck and write on the tablets of his heart. 'TURGOT,' SAYS HIS WISE BIOGRAPHER, 'ALWAYS LOOKED UPON ANYTHING LIKE A SECT AS MISCHIEVOUS.... FROM THE MOMENT THAT A SECT COMES INTO EXISTENCE, ALL THE INDIVIDUALS COMPOSING IT BECOME ANSWERABLE FOR THE FAULTS AND ERRORS OF EACH ONE OF THEM. THE OBLIGATION TO REMAIN UNITED LEADS THEM TO SUPPRESS OR DISSEMBLE ALL TRUTHS THAT MIGHT WOUND ANYBODY WHOSE ADHESION IS USEFUL TO THE SECT. THEY ARE FORCED TO ESTABLISH IN SOME FORM A BODY OF DOCTRINE, AND THE OPINIONS WHICH MAKE A PART OF IT, BEING ADOPTED WITHOUT INQUIRY, BECOME IN DUE TIME PURE PREJUDICES. FRIENDSHIP STOPS WITH THE individuals; but the hatred AND ENVY THAT ANY OF THEM MAY AROUSE EXTENDS TO THE WHOLE SECT. IF THIS SECT BE FORMED BY THE MOST ENLIGHTENED MEN OF THE NATION, IF THE DEFENCE OF TRUTHS OF THE GREATEST IMPORTANCE TO THE COMMON HAPPINESS BE THE OBJECT OF ITS ZEAL, THE MISCHIEF IS STILL WORSE. EVERYTHING TRUE OR USEFUL WHICH THEY PROPOSE IS REJECTED WITHOUT EXAMINATION. ABUSES AND ERRORS OF EVERY KIND ALWAYS HAVE FOR THEIR DEFENDERS THAT HERD OF PRESUMPTUOUS AND MEDIOCRE MORTALS, WHO ARE THE BITTEREST ENEMIES OF ALL CELEBRITY AND RENOWN. SCARCELY IS A TRUTH MADE CLEAR, BEFORE THOSE TO WHOM IT WOULD BE PREJUDICIAL CRUSH IT UNDER THE NAME OF A SECT THAT IS SURE TO HAVE ALREADY BECOME ODIOUS, AND ARE CERTAIN TO KEEP IT FROM OBTAINING SO MUCH AS A HEARING. TURGOT, THEN, WAS PERSUADED THAT PERHAPS THE GREATEST ILL YOU CAN DO TO TRUTH IS TO DRIVE THOSE WHO LOVE IT TO FORM THEMSELVES INTO A SECT, AND THAT THESE IN TURN CAN COMMIT NO MORE FATAL MISTAKE than to have the vanity or the weakness to fall into the trap.' [Pg 57] [Pg 58] [Pg 59] [Pg 60] [Pg 61] YET WE KNOW THAT WITH MR. MILL AS WITH TURGOT THIS DEEP DISTRUST OF SECT WAS NO HINDRANCE TO THE MOST CAREFUL SYSTEMATISATION OF OPINION AND CONDUCT. HE DID NOT INTERPRET MANY-SIDEDNESS IN THE FLACCID WATERY SENSE WHICH FLATTERS THE INDOLENCE OF SO MANY OF OUR CONTEMPORARIES, WHO LIKE TO HAVE THEIR EARS AMUSED WITH A NEW DOCTRINE EACH MORNING, TO BE HELD FOR A DAY, AND DROPPED IN THE EVENING, AND WHO HAVE LITTLE MORE SERIOUSNESS IN THEIR INTELLECTUAL LIFE THAN THE BUSY INSECTS OF A SUMMER NOON. HE SAYS THAT HE LOOKED FORWARD 'TO A FUTURE WHICH SHALL UNITE THE BEST QUALITIES OF THE CRITICAL WITH THE BEST QUALITIES OF THE ORGANIC PERIODS; UNCHECKED LIBERTY OF THOUGHT, UNBOUNDED FREEDOM OF INDIVIDUAL ACTION IN ALL MODES NOT HURTFUL TO OTHERS; BUT ALSO CONVICTIONS AS TO WHAT IS RIGHT AND WRONG, USEFUL AND PERNICIOUS, DEEPLY engraven on the feelings by early education and general unanimity of sentiment, and so firmly grounded in reason and the TRUE EXIGENCIES OF LIFE, THAT THEY SHALL NOT, LIKE ALL FORMER AND PRESENT CREEDS, RELIGIOUS, ETHICAL, AND POLITICAL, REQUIRE TO BE PERIODICALLY THROWN OFF AND REPLACED BY OTHERS' (P. 166). THIS WAS IN SOME SORT THE TYPE AT WHICH HE AIMED IN THE FORMATION OF HIS OWN CHARACTER—A TYPE THAT SHOULD COMBINE ORGANIC WITH CRITICAL QUALITY, THE STRENGTH OF AN ORDERED SET OF CONVICTIONS, WITH THAT PLIABILITY AND THAT RECEPTIVENESS IN FACE OF NEW TRUTH, WHICH ARE INDISPENSABLE TO THESE VERY CONVICTIONS BEING HELD INTELLIGENTLY AND IN THEIR BEST ATTAINABLE FORM. WE CAN UNDERSTAND THE FORCE OF THE EULOGY ON JOHN AUSTIN (P. 154), THAT HE MANIFESTED 'AN EQUAL DEVOTION TO THE TWO CARDINAL POINTS OF LIBERTY AND DUTY.' THESE ARE THE correlatives in the sphere of action to the two cardinal points of Criticism and Belief in the sphere of thought. WE CAN IN THE LIGHT OF THIS DOUBLE WAY OF VIEWING THE RIGHT BALANCE OF THE MIND, THE BETTER UNDERSTAND THE COMBINATION OF EARNESTNESS WITH TOLERANCE WHICH INCONSIDERATE PERSONS ARE APT TO FIND SO AWKWARD A STUMBLING-BLOCK IN THE SCHEME OF philosophic liberalISM. MANY PEOPLE IN OUR TIME HAVE SO ILL UNDERSTOOD THE DOCTRINE OF LIBERTY, THAT IN SOME OF THE MOST ACTIVE CIRCLES IN SOCIETY THEY NOW COUNT YOU A BIGOT IF YOU HOLD ANY PROPOSITION TO BE DECIDEDLY AND UNMISTAKABLY MORE TRUE THAN ANY OTHER. THEY PRONOUNCE YOU INTEMPERATE IF YOU SHOW ANGER AND STERN DISAPPOINTMENT BECAUSE MEN FOLLOW THE WRONG COURSE INSTEAD OF THE RIGHT ONE. MR. MILL'S EXPLANATION OF THE VEHEMENCE AND DECISION OF HIS FATHER'S DISAPPROVAL, WHEN HE DID DISAPPROVE, AND HIS REFUSAL TO ALLOW HONESTY OF PURPOSE IN THE DOER TO SOFTEN HIS DISAPPROBATION OF THE DEED, GIVES THE READER A WORTHY AND MASCULINE NOTION OF TRUE TOLERANCE. JAMES MILL'S 'AVERSION TO MANY INTELLECTUAL ERRORS, OR WHAT HE REGARDED AS SUCH, PARTOOK IN A CERTAIN SENSE OF THE CHARACTER OF A MORAL FEELING.... NONE BUT THOSE WHO DO NOT CARE ABOUT OPINIONS WILL CONFOUND THIS WITH INTOLERANCE. THOSE, WHO HAVING OPINIONS WHICH THEY HOLD TO BE IMMENSELY IMPORTANT, AND THEIR CONTRARIES TO BE PRODIGIOUSLY HURTFUL, HAVE ANY DEEP REGARD FOR THE GENERAL GOOD, WILL NECESSARILY DISLIKE, AS A CLASS AND IN THE ABSTRACT, THOSE WHO THINK WRONG WHAT THEY THINK RIGHT, AND RIGHT WHAT THEY THINK WRONG: THOUGH THEY NEED NOT BE, NOR WAS MY FATHER, INSENSIBLE TO GOOD QUALITIES IN AN OPPONENT, NOR GOVERNED IN THEIR ESTIMATION OF INDIVIDUALS BY ONE GENERAL PRESUMPTION, INSTEAD OF BY THE WHOLE OF THEIR CHARACTER. I GRANT THAT AN EARNEST PERSON, BEING NO MORE INFALLIBLE THAN OTHER MEN, IS LIABLE TO DISLIKE PEOPLE ON ACCOUNT OF OPINIONS WHICH DO NOT MERIT DISLIKE; BUT IF HE NEITHER HIMSELF DOES THEM ANY ILL OFFICE, NOR CONNIVES AT ITS BEING DONE BY OTHERS, HE IS NOT INTOLERANT: AND THE FORBEARANCE WHICH FLOWS FROM A CONSCIENTIOUS SENSE OF THE IMPORTANCE TO MANKIND OF THE EQUAL FREEDOM OF ALL OPINIONS IS THE ONLY TOLERANCE WHICH IS COMMENDABLE, OR TO THE HIGHEST MORAL ORDER OF MINDS, POSSIBLE' (P. 51). THIS IS ANOTHER SIDE OF THE CO-ORDINATION OF CRITICISM AND BELIEF, OF LIBERTY AND DUTY, WHICH ATTAINED IN MR. MILL HIMSELF A COMPLETENESS THAT OTHER MEN, LESS FAVOURED IN EDUCATION AND WITH LESS ACTIVE POWER OF SELF-CONTROL, ARE NOT LIKELY TO REACH, BUT TO REACH IT OUGHT TO BE ONE OF THE PRIME OBJECTS OF THEIR MENTAL DISCIPLINE. THE INCULCATION OF THIS PECULIAR MORALITY OF THE INTELLIGENCE IS ONE OF THE MOST URGENTLY NEEDED PROCESSES OF OUR TIME. FOR THE CIRCUMSTANCE OF OUR BEING IN THE VERY DEPTHS OF A PERIOD OF TRANSITION FROM ONE SPIRITUAL BASIS OF THOUGHT TO ANOTHER, LEADS MEN NOT ONLY TO BE CONTENT WITH HOLDING A QUANTITY OF VAGUE, CONFUSED, AND CONTRADICTORY OPINIONS, BUT ALSO TO INVEST WITH THE HONOURABLE name of candour a weak reluctance to hold any one of them earnestly. MR. MILL EXPERIENCED IN THE FOUR OR FIVE LAST YEARS OF HIS LIFE THE DISADVANTAGE OF TRYING TO UNITE FAIRNESS TOWARDS THE OPINIONS FROM WHICH HE DIFFERED, WITH LOYALTY TO THE POSITIVE OPINIONS WHICH HE ACCEPTED. 'AS I HAD SHOWED IN MY POLITICAL WRITINGS,' HE SAYS, 'THAT I WAS AWARE OF THE WEAK POINTS IN DEMOCRATIC OPINIONS, SOME CONSERVATIVES, IT SEEMS, HAD NOT BEEN WITHOUT HOPES OF FINDING ME AN OPPONENT OF DEMO CRACY: AS I WAS ABLE TO SEE THE CONSERVATIVE SIDE OF THE QUESTION, THEY PRESUMED THAT LIKE THEM I COULD NOT SEE ANY OTHER SIDE. YET IF THEY HAD REALLY READ MY WRITINGS, THEY WOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT AFTER GIVING FULL WEIGHT TO ALL THAT APPEARED TO ME WELL GROUNDED IN THE ARGUMENTS AGAINST democracy, I unhesitatingly decided in its favour, while recommending that it should be accompanied by such institutions AS WERE CONSISTENT WITH ITS PRINCIPLE AND CALCULATED TO WARD OFF ITS INCONVENIENCES' (P. 309). THIS WAS ONLY ONE ILLUSTRATION OF WHAT CONSTANTLY HAPPENED, UNTIL AT LENGTH, IT IS HARDLY TOO MUCH TO SAY, A MAN WHO HAD HITHERTO ENJOYED A SINGULAR MEASURE OF GENERAL REVERENCE BECAUSE HE WAS SUPPOSED TO SEE TRUTH IN EVERY DOCTRINE, BECAME DOWNRIGHT UNPOPULAR AMONG MANY CLASSES IN THE COMMUNITY, BECAUSE HE SAW MORE TRUTH IN ONE DOCTRINE THAN ANOTHER, AND BROUGHT the propositions for whose acceptance he was most in earnest eagerly before the public. IN A SIMILAR WAY THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY SHOWS US THE PICTURE OF A MAN UNITING PROFOUND SELF-RESPECT WITH A SINGULAR NEUTRALITY WHERE HIS OWN CLAIMS ARE CONCERNED, A SINGULAR SELF-MASTERY AND JUSTICE OF MIND, IN MATTERS WHERE WITH MOST MEN THE SENSE OF THEIR OWN PERSONALITY IS WONT TO BE SO EXACTING AND SO EASILY IRRITATED. THE HISTORY OF INTELLECTUAL EMINENCE IS TOO OFTEN A HISTORY OF IMMODERATE EGOISM. IT HAS PERHAPS HARDLY EVER BEEN GIVEN TO ANY ONE WHO EXERTED SUCH INFLUENCE AS MR. MILL DID OVER HIS CONTEMPORARIES, TO VIEW HIS OWN SHARE IN IT WITH SUCH DISCRIMINATION AND EQUITY AS MARKS EVERY PAGE OF HIS BOOK, AND AS USED TO MARK EVERY WORD OF HIS CONVERSATION. KNOWING AS WE ALL DO THE LAST INFIRMITY OF EVEN NOBLE MINDS, AND HOW DEEP THE DESIRE TO ERECT HIMSELF POPE AND SIR ORACLE LIES IN THE SPIRIT OF A MAN WITH STRONG CONVICTIONS, WE MAY VALUE THE MORE HIGHLY, AS WELL FOR ITS RARITY AS FOR ITS INTRINSIC WORTH, MR. MILL'S QUALITY OF SELF- EFFACEMENT, AND HIS STEADFAST CARE TO LOOK ANYWHERE RATHER THAN IN HIS OWN PERSONAL MERITS, FOR THE SOURCE OF ANY OF those excellences which he was never led by false modesty to dissemble. MANY PEOPLE SEEM TO FIND THE MOST INTERESTING FIGURE IN THE BOOK THAT STOICAL FATHER, WHOSE AUSTERE, ENERGETIC, IMPERIOUS, [Pg 62] [Pg 63] [Pg 64] [Pg 65] [Pg 66] AND RELENTLESS CHARACTER SHOWED THE TEMPERAMENT OF THE SCOTCH COVENANTER OF THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY, INSPIRED BY THE PRINCIPLES AND PHILOSOPHY OF FRANCE IN THE EIGHTEENTH. NO DOUBT, FOR THOSE IN SEARCH OF STRONG DRAMATIC EFFECTS, THE LINES OF THIS STRENUOUS INDOMITABLE NATURE ARE FULL OF IMPRESSIVENESS. [3] BUT ONE OUGHT TO BE ABLE TO APPRECIATE THE DISTINCTION AND STRENGTH OF THE FATHER, AND YET ALSO BE ABLE TO SEE THAT THE DISTINCTION OF THE SON'S STRENGTH WAS IN TRUTH MORE REALLY IMPRESSIVE STILL. WE ENCOUNTER A MODESTY THAT ALMOST SPEAKS THE LANGUAGE OF FATALISM. PIECES OF GOOD FORTUNE THAT MOST PEOPLE WOULD ASSUREDLY HAVE EITHER EXPLAINED AS DUE TO THEIR OWN PENETRATION, OR TO THE RECOGNITION OF THEIR WORTH BY OTHERS, OR ELSE WOULD HAVE REFRAINED FROM DWELLING UPON, AS BEING NO MORE THAN EVENTS OF SECONDARY IMPORTANCE, ARE BY MR. MILL INVARIABLY RECOGNISED AT THEIR FULL WORTH OR EVEN ABOVE IT, AND INVARIABLY SPOKEN OF AS FORTUNATE ACCIDENTS, HAPPY TURNS IN THE LOTTERY OF LIFE, OR IN SOME OTHER QUIET FATALISTIC PHRASE, EXPRESSIVE OF HIS DEEP FEELING HOW MUCH WE OWE TO INFLUENCES OVER WHICH WE HAVE NO CONTROL AND FOR WHICH WE HAVE NO RIGHT TO TAKE ANY CREDIT. HIS SAYING THAT 'IT WOULD BE A BLESSING IF THE DOCTRINE OF NECESSITY COULD BE BELIEVED BY ALL quoad THE CHARACTERS OF OTHERS, AND DISBELIEVED IN REGARD TO THEIR OWN' (P. 169), WENT EVEN FURTHER THAN THAT, FOR HE TEACHES US TO ACCEPT THE DOCTRINE OF NECESSITY quoad THE MOST MARKED FELICITIES OF LIFE AND CHARACTER, AND TO LEAN LIGHTLY OR NOT AT ALL UPON IT IN REGARD TO OUR DEMERITS. HUMILITY IS A RATIONALISTIC, NO LESS THAN A CHRISTIAN GRACE—NOT HUMILITY IN FACE OF ERROR OR ARROGANT PRETENSIONS OR SELFISHNESS, NOR A HUMILITY THAT PARALYSES ENERGETIC EFFORT, BUT A STEADFAST CONSCIOUSNESS OF ALL THE GOOD GIFTS WHICH OUR FORERUNNERS HAVE MADE READY FOR US, AND OF THE WEIGHT OF OUR RESPONSIBILITY FOR TRANSMITTING THESE HELPFUL FORCES TO A NEW GENERATION, NOT diminished but augmented. IN MORE THAN ONE REMARKABLE PLACE THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY SHOWS US DISTINCTLY WHAT ALL CAREFUL STUDENTS OF MR. MILL'S BOOKS SUPPOSED, THAT WITH HIM THE SOCIAL AIM, THE REPAYMENT OF THE SERVICES OF THE PAST BY DEVOTION TO THE SERVICES OF PRESENT AND FUTURE, WAS PREDOMINANT OVER ANY MERELY SPECULATIVE CURIOSITY OR ABSTRACT INTEREST. HIS PREFERENCE FOR DEEPLY RESERVED WAYS OF EXPRESSING EVEN HIS STRONGEST FEELINGS PREVENTED HIM FROM MAKING ANY EXPANSIVE SHOW OF THIS GOVERNING SENTIMENT. THOUGH NO MAN WAS EVER MORE FREE FROM ANY TAINT OF THAT BAD HABIT OF US ENGLISH, OF DENYING OR PALLIATING AN ABUSE OR A WRONG, UNLESS WE ARE PREPARED WITH AN INSTANT REMEDY FOR IT, YET HE HAD A STRONG AVERSION TO MERE SOCIALISTIC DECLAMATION. PERHAPS, IF ONE MAY SAY SO WITHOUT PRESUMPTION, HE WAS NOT INDULGENT ENOUGH IN THIS RESPECT. I REMEMBER ONCE PRESSING HIM WITH SOME ENTHUSIASM FOR VICTOR HUGO,—AN ENTHUSIASM, ONE IS GLAD TO THINK, WHICH TIME DOES NOTHING TO WEAKEN. MR. MILL, ADMITTING, THOUGH NOT TOO LAVISHLY, THE SUPERB IMAGINATIVE POWER OF THIS POETIC MASTER OF OUR TIME, STILL COUNTED IT A FATAL DRAWBACK TO HUGO'S WORTH AND CLAIM TO RECOGNITION THAT 'HE HAS NOT BROUGHT FORWARD ONE SINGLE PRACTICAL PROPOSAL FOR THE IMPROVEMENT OF THE SOCIETY AGAINST WHICH HE IS INCESSANTLY THUNDERING.' I VENTURED TO URGE THAT IT IS UNREASONABLE TO ASK A POET TO DRAFT ACTS OF PARLIAMENT; AND THAT BY BRINGING ALL THE STRENGTH OF HIS IMAGINATION AND ALL THE MAJESTIC FULNESS OF HIS SYMPATHY TO BEAR ON THE SOCIAL HORRORS AND INJUSTICES WHICH STILL LIE SO THICK ABOUT US, HE KINDLED AN INEXTINGUISHABLE FIRE IN THE HEARTS OF MEN OF WEAKER INITIATIVE AND LESS IMPERIAL GIFTS ALIKE OF IMAGINATION AND SYMPATHY, AND SO PREPARED THE FORCES OUT OF WHICH PRACTICAL PROPOSALS AND SPECIFIC IMPROVEMENTS MAY BE EXPECTED TO ISSUE. THAT SO OBVIOUS A KIND OF REFLECTION SHOULD NOT HAVE PREVIOUSLY INTERESTED MR. MILL'S JUDGMENT IN FAVOUR OF THE WRITER OF THE Outcasts, THE Legend of the Ages, THE Contemplations, ONLY SHOWS HOW STRONG WAS HIS DISLIKE TO ALL THAT SAVOURED OF THE GRANDIOSE, AND HOW AFRAID HE ALWAYS WAS OF EVERYTHING THAT SEEMED TO DISSOCIATE EMOTION FROM RATIONALLY DIRECTED EFFORT. THAT HE WAS HIMSELF INSPIRED BY THIS EMOTION OF PITY FOR THE COMMON PEOPLE, OF DIVINE RAGE AGAINST THE INJUSTICE OF THE STRONG TO THE WEAK, IN A DEGREE NOT INFERIOR TO VICTOR Hugo himself, his whole career most effectually demonstrates. IT IS THIS DEVOTION TO THE SUBSTANTIAL GOOD OF THE MANY, THOUGH PRACTISED WITHOUT THE NOISY OR OSTENTATIOUS PROFESSIONS OF MORE EGOISTIC THINKERS, WHICH BINDS TOGETHER ALL THE PARTS OF HIS WORK, FROM THE System of Logic DOWN TO HIS LAST SPEECH ON THE LAND QUESTION. ONE OF THE MOST STRIKING PAGES IN THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY IS THAT IN WHICH HE GIVES HIS REASONS FOR COMPOSING THE REF...