Page | of 1 Subj: Fwd: Brobston Catalog Date: 5/24/2010 1:43:27 P.M. Central Daylight Time From: To: Eric: Could you find out from your friend Fanning what they expect this item to go for ? Would$500 have a good chance of buying it? Tett ----- Original Message----- Date: Mon, 24 May 2010 09:10:03 -0500 (CDT) From: To: Subject: Brobston Catalog Hello Tett: Tony Terranova called me about a catalog in the forthcoming (June 3, 2010) Kolbe auction of the Stack family library. It is lot 399--the Stack's office copy of the Brobston FPL, with buyer's names. Tony thought it might be of interest to one of us. | am going to pass on it. If you are interested in it yiu can reach them at: Kolbe & Fanning 614-414-0855 www.numislit.com Hope al is well. Jim Friday, May 28, 2010 AOL: EricNumis ERIC P. NEWMAN NUMISMATIC EDUCATION SOCIETY 6450 Cecil Avenue, St. Louis, Missouri 63105 Date Preliminary Draft of Letter Rernard Fdison Dear Bunny: I have been thinking about your suggestion that there should be an excellent and complete publication covering United States Half Cents. You have indicated feeling that those pieces belonging to you might be sold at auction. I feel that half cents belonging to Eric P. Newman Numismatic Education Society should be retained by that Foundation and not sold. I would, therefore, in this letter like to present a number of thoughts which the two of us can discuss and possibly develop in more detail. In this letter you will be referred to personally as Tett. In this letter Eric P. Newman Numismatic Education Society, a Missouri not-for-profit corporation, will be referred to as EPNNES. I will be referred to as Eric an individual who is president of EPNNES. There is a specific written record of the ownership of each of the half cents which belong either to Tett and to EPNNES. All of the coins have for many years been routinely kept in a safe deposit box of EPNNES at Commerce Bank in Clayton, MO except when Tett has taken them out for exhibition to or studied and enjoyed by others. Sometimes this involved Tett taking the coins to other distant locations from St. Louis. Neither Eric nor EPNNES have ever removed any of the half cent coins out of the Commerce Bank safe deposit box room after being originally placed there. It seems to me that a marvelous way of creating a spectacular book on US half cents would be for an auctioneer to prepare and publish a detailed illustrated catalog including all of the US half cents owned by Tett and EPNNES. Coins owned by Tett would be offered for sale by the auctioneer in the catalog. The coins owned by EPNNES would be included in the same catalog but are not to be sold. This retention of EPNNES ownership should be clearly specified as to each EPNNES coin in the catalog. Since there would probably be many bidders and buyers of the Tett coins at the auction there should not be created any problem for those eager to buy Tett coins due to the EPNNES coins not being offered for sale. The catalog will list all of the combined group of US half cents in proper date chronological and variety order with a clear designation of which will be for sale and which will not be sold. The coins which will not be sold may increase the amount of bids for those which are to be sold. Page--of3 The proposed catalog is expected to list in detail and in a similar manner each of the half cents owned by Tett and by EPNNES. It will in detail point out which are for sale and which are not for sale. It must be clearly evident in the catalog and in the individual coin listing that the EPNNES items are not for sale but are included in the descriptions for the purpose of present and future knowledge and enjoyment by numismatists and others. In writing the proposed catalog publication the details as to the ownership and history of each half cent the auctioneer may desire to use your actual name, my name, or the EPNNES name. The use of any such names or data may be limited in such a manner as you and EPNNES and myself shall find modest and acceptable. There are various envelopes. etc. in which the half cents are or have been in over the vears. Those coins which belong to Tett and are being sold shall include in such sale any envelopes prepared by Johnson with description, etc., typewritten in red ink. All other red ink typed envelopes shall be retained by EPNNES. Envelopes prepared by Tett (some being various colors) shall be or become the property of the buyer at auction of the coin described if Tett wishes permit them to be furnished to those who buy Tett’s coins. A photocopy in color shall be prepared and furnished to both Tett and EPNNES of all envelopes for all coins sold by Tett and those retained by EPNNES. In addition each Tett and EPNNES shall be entitled to any envelopes which contained coins sold or traded to others prior to the present. The ownership of half cents belonging to EPNNES and to be included in the proposed published summary shall preferably remain in St. Louis, Missouri and be under the control of EPNNES at all times hereafter. Whoever is selected to study, image and describe each half cent shall have the privilege of examining such EPNNES half cents for such period as may be necessary to complete the description, measurement and imaging of such coins. Whether or not the Tett owned half cents should remain in St. Louis during the preparation of the sales catalog writing period may be determined by Tett. The cataloger should furnish Tett and EPNNES each 10 or more copies of the publication. Tett and EPNNES shall agree not to sell such copies but may donate them to family and friends at their discretion. The cataloger shall furnish free copies to ANA, ANS, CW, EAC and such athers acs it wishes Tett shall negotiate such commissions or payment details for auctioning Tett’s items as he and the auctioneer may agree upon. EPNNES shall not be involved in any such financial arrangements. There is one coin (1793 half cent Cohen 2 in uncirculated condition originally purchased by Tett from the Alvord collection) which was donated by Tett to EPNNES many years later. It was retained in the EPNNES safe deposit box. You recalled putting it into a larger holder (I don’t know when) and it has never been located since then. Whether it was misplaced, lost or stolen when temporarily removed by Tett for exhibition or study is not known by Tett but Tett is still searching for it. Eric and EPNNES have no knowledge about its disappearance except through Tett Monday. February 27. 2012 AOL: EricNumis Eric has never removed it at any time before or after it became property of EPNNES. It is written in your list of your gifts to EPNNES Ifthe missing 1793 Cohen 2 half cent is not found or recovered prior to the auction sale perhaps you should agree to substitute for the missing 1793 Cohen 2 half cent another 1793 half cent belonging to you in similar condition and more or less the same value for EPNNES to own and not be sold. One of the 1796 forgery half cents now owned by Tett could be used to equalize in part the value of the missing or stolen 1793 piece. I believe Tett owns several 1796 half cent forgeries at this time. There are several different later dates electrotvpe half cent fakes belong to EPNNES in the Commerce Bank safe deposit box where Tett now stores half cents and these electrotypes shall remain the property of EPNNES. What insurance against loss or damage to half cents during the period of publication preparation shall he fairnished for either Tett ar FPNNES or hoth is a matter to he discnssed The first publicity for the auction should not begin until the cataloger, auctioneer, and Tett have agreed to such date. This letter is to be amended for final form and Eric would like Tett to suggest improvements and changes Fric Page 1 of 2 Subj: Re: 1794 dollar mystery Date: 8/22/2012 1:38:07 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time From: To: Hi, Eric- | have included a scanned copy of the page from the Col. Green inventory that lists the 1794 and 1795 silver dollars. (Please let me know if you have any trouble opening this file. It should just open up when you click on it.) Please note that most are listed by their Haseltine Type, noted as "H1","H2", etc. It certainly appears that the good Colonel did indeed own 2 uncirculated 1794 silver dollars at the time of the inventory. | would hazard to guess that they may have been sold prior to the purchases made by you and Mr. Johnson. This is why a listing of the material that you and Mr. Johnson purchased from the Green Estate is critical to my research. We had scheduled a review of these records during my last visit to your home, but | obviously did not have time in my alloted time. Hopefully, | can get this data during our next visit. | will gather and send you the information on the 1794 dimes. So far, | have input the following into my Green coin database: Half Cents, Large Cents, Colonials, Twenty Cent Pieces, Half Dollars and Silver Dollars. | have around half of the Quarters entered. The number of Half Dollars and Quarters owned by Col. Green was enormous. | still lack inputting an amazing 20+ pages of Quarters. The most important data that | was going to get from you, | do not have. | really need to get copies of all Half Cents purchased by you and Mr. Johnson. You furnished me a list of half cents that you and Mr. Johnson selected for yourselves, but | do not have a listing of the remaining half cents. | will make this a priority for our next visit. These records were not among the small, hard cover notebooks that you had out on your dining room table. | know this may sound like an insurmountable task, but | have been seriously thinking about matching up your ALL of the purchases with the inventory. | think this could be an invaluable service to the collector community. It would also help in the planned book to be authored by myself and John Danreuther. | would think that you would be VERY interested, as am I, in knowing just what all that you and Mr. Johnson bought out of the estate as compared to what all was IN the estate. | am definitely interested to see what coins were sold prior to your purchases! | seriously think you might find the results of this study more important to you than to me!!! You and | could then study and speculate as to where the "other" coins went to. We do know where some of the major gold went. We do not know where almost all of the foreign material went. We also do not know where the bank notes, encased postage, and hard times tokens went. Did you and Mr. Johnson purchase the Patterns collection. It was simply fantastic. Wednesday, August 22, 2012 AOL: EricNumis Page 2 of 2 We can talk and plan this soon. Thanks for your time and help. | think we can have some joint entertainment with this project. Mike From: To: Sent: Tuesday, August 21, 2012 10:19 AM Subject: 1794 dollar mystery Mike:: While half asleep last night | began to try to solve your current Green enigma about the 1794 uncirculated pair of US dollars. It occurred to me that because the listing in your wonderful summary included those in a category of US gold coins and other items unrelated to dollars that dollars could have been an error in transcription. | began to speculate how it could have happened. The listing from which it was transcribed might have had a "d" after the 1794 which was intended to be "dime" and not "dollar".From memory there were some uncirculated 1794 dimes (dismes). | have that dime data in a list prepared by Johnson for the Green group we received.. Perhaps you can see what your list shows as to other 1794 dimes. Ten cents a dance may be applicable. Eric. Wednesday, August 22, 2012 AOL: Brobably the easiest method of understanding my methods of coin digitization and display is for me to list the steps and reasons. 1) Digitizing I'm using Kodak's PhotoCD method. It gives me 24 bit color (RGB) and a resolution of about 1700 x 1700 pixels across a coin. The original picture is about 18 megabytes which reduces to about 8.5 when the "picture" is trimmed. I've tried doing my own digitizing but find that it would take about $20,000 worth of equipment to duplicate the resolution and noise free picture | get with Kodak. 2) Display Iam currently using a TI 34020 chip board for graphics. I have found that 800x600 seems to give enough resolution to work with. Since the original data is a little over twice this it gives me some room on zooming without ixetrepicanon, Iv . a date on a coin Ere | . 020 chip I can / Dom baste ja i aa le ly operations big Miedound CBs fe was about the t I can manipulate nb . 1 ae y should have 32 Ne 1 are te ea Ube paatagcaple yet whether the etn eww gr a __iics board or not. COLA tyl y think that two , 5 ow ia pre 2 ‘“ ke would like to Tw g them. See you soon...... ey ‘ ae 1 Probably the easiest method of understanding my methods of coin digitization and display is for me to list the steps and reasons. 1) Digitizing I'm using Kodak's PhotoCD method. It gives me 24 bit color (RGB) and a resolution of about 1700 x 1700 pixels across a coin. The original picture is about 18 megabytes which reduces to about 8.5 when the "picture" is trimmed. I've tried doing my own digitizing but find that it would take about $20,000 worth of equipment to duplicate the resolution and noise free picture I get with Kodak. 2) Display Iam currently using a TI 34020 chip board for graphics. I have found that 800x600 seems to give enough resolution to work with. Since the original data is a little over twice this it gives me some room on zooming without pixel replication. My goal was to have the screen fill with a date on a coin without having noticeable "stair stepping". By using the 34020 chip I can write downloadable code for the board and have some of my operations perform much quicker. One of the points I made in the talk was about the unportance of dot pitch on the monitor. 3) My main computer program uses a DOS Extender so that I can manipulate ny pictures in memory. [run in 16 megabytes, but probably should have 32 to make some of the operations go faster. I haven't decided yet whether the final program that | produce will require a 34020 chip graphics board or not. 4) The production of a CD-ROM disc is my goal. I actually think that two discs will be required because of the number of pictures I would like to publish. I don't know if the slides are of any help but I am including them. See you soon....... Bre