Chapman University Chapman University Digital Commons Art Faculty Articles and Research Art 2010 Baciccio's Beata Ludovica Albertoni Distributing Alms Karen J. Lloyd Chapman University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at:http://digitalcommons.chapman.edu/art_articles Part of theAncient History, Greek and Roman through Late Antiquity Commons,Ancient, Medieval, Renaissance and Baroque Art and Architecture Commons,Art and Design Commons, Catholic Studies Commons,Christianity Commons, and theOther History of Art, Architecture, and Archaeology Commons Recommended Citation Lloyd, Karen J. "Baciccio's Beata Ludovica Albertoni Distributing Alms."Getty Research Journal2 (2010): 1-18. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Art at Chapman University Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Art Faculty Articles and Research by an authorized administrator of Chapman University Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Baciccio's Beata Ludovica Albertoni Distributing Alms Comments This article was originally published inGetty Research Journal, volume 2, in 2010. Copyright The author This article is available at Chapman University Digital Commons:http://digitalcommons.chapman.edu/art_articles/16 Baciccio's Beata Luaovica Albertoni Alms Distributing Karen J. Lloyd [n 1970, the Getty Museum acquired a painting by the Genoese master Giovanni Battista Gaulli (1639-1709), known as Baciccio, which had recently appeared on the market in London (fig. 1). Identified in the collection as Saint Francesca Romana Giving Alms, the work was previously unknown, the provenance going back only to a private collection in Geneva.1 Burton B. Fredricksen dated the painting to around 1675/76, based on similari ties to Baciccio's altarpieces for San Francesco a Ripa (The Madonna and Child with Saint Anne, 1674) and Sant'Andrea al Quirinale (Death of Saint Francis Xavier, 1676).2 A closer look at the iconography reveals that the painting's main figure is not Francesca Romana (born Francesca Bussi de' Ponziani, 1384-1440),but rather another Roman noblewoman, the Beata Ludovica Albertoni (1473-1533). Knowing the correct subject, we can identify the patron for Baciccio's picture, redate the work precisely, and reconstruct the context in which it was produced. Establishing this information also allows us to make some com ments on the artistic relationship between Baciccio and Gian Lorenzo Bernini, reexamin ing the currents of creative influence between the two artists and positing a more active and independent role for Baciccio in the decoration of the Altieri chapel in San Francesco a Ripa than has thus far been assumed. Silhouetted in front of a dark wall that underscores the distinct glow of a nimbus around her head, the young woman in Baciccio's Beata Ludovica Albertoni Distributing Alms wears a long black dress and white veil and offers a small loaf of bread to a burly, bare-shouldered man seated on the ground to her right. Her left hand, tight to her waist, holds a bright red book and draws up the energetically unruly veil. At her feet are a plain bowl filled with dark liquid and two more loaves of bread for distribution. Leaning against the seated man are two animated children who examine another of the loaves, while in the middle ground a mother with an infant held to her shoulder moves away, food in hand. Two figures appear in the distance at center, conversing and gesturing toward the woman, presumably remarking on her generosity. Behind the figures on the left side, the composition opens to a landscape of thick trees that partially obscure vaguely familiar, but unspecific, classical buildings. Although Santa Francesca Romana is traditionally shown in a black dress and white veil and holding a book—as in the altarpiece in the chapel of Tor de' Specchi, the Roman monastery founded by the saint (fig. 2) —the Getty painting lacks her guardian Getty Research Journal, no. 2 (2010): 1-18 © Karen J. Lloyd 1 This content downloaded from 206.211.139.204 on Fri, 06 Mar 2015 17:22:49 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Fig. l. Giovanni Battista Gaulli, known as Baciccio (Italian, 1639-1709). Saint Francesco. Romana Giving Alms [here identified as Beata Ludovica Albertoni Distributing Alms], ca. 1675 [here dated 1671], oil on canvas, 210.2 x 137.2 cm (82V4 x 54 in.). Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum (70.PA.30) angel, her constant attribute, and this omission should have raised questions about the identification of the figure.3 The key iconographical element in this painting is instead the bread, which, as seen in the center foreground, is studded with coins.4 The eldest child, who is the only figure to look directly out of the painting and engage the viewer, calls attention to this detail by pointing to several silver pieces that she holds in her right hand. Ayounger brother clambers up to grab at them. The coin-studded loaf of bread is a standard iconographical attribute of the Beata Ludovica Albertoni, a Franciscan tertiary who was noted for her charity and beatified in January 1671 by Pope Clement X Altieri (reigned 1670-76).5 2 GETTY RESEARCH JOURNAL, NO. 2 (2010) This content downloaded from 206.211.139.204 on Fri, 06 Mar 2015 17:22:49 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Sfe^;wHr-:A'Xi': (&ANYM STI'.VJE-Blf,! fAl\Eug*m/w-V ET. ifKS ipA\ osuv»s. J 1 lk' '.fXVN tSPISTl ?AVE:fe'. Fig. z. Antoniazzo Romano (Italian, before 1452-between 1508 and 1512) and studio. Santa Francesca Romana (detail), 1468, altar fresco. Rome, Monastero di Tor de' Specchi. Photograph courtesy Monastero delle Oblate di S. Francesca Romana Lloyd Baciccio's Beata Luaovica Albertoni 3 This content downloaded from 206.211.139.204 on Fri, 06 Mar 2015 17:22:49 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Ludovica s feast day was officially celebrated for the first time on 31 January 1671. The date of her beatification is not coincidental: between 1669 and 1670, Cardinal Emilio Altieri (from 1670 on, Pope Clement X) adopted three members of the Albertoni family, Ludovica's direct descendents, to ensure his family's survival and strengthen his hold on the Curia.7 Abruptly vaulted from shabby nobility to the highest echelons of Roman society, the new Altieri nephews made the most of their short time in power, accumulat ing substantial incomes and constructing monumental works of art.8 The pope moved swiftly, beatifying their ancestor—and adding to the glory of both families—within that first, active year of his reign. The new AJtien family was composed of Cardinal Paluzzo (died 1698), who took on the role of cardinal nephew and right-hand man to the pope; Gaspare (died 1720), who married Laura Altieri, Clement X's first cousin once removed and sole heir to the family fortune; and Angelo (died 1706), Gaspare's father. Of the three, only Angelo was without a clear role in the new family hierarchy, and his art patronage strongly suggests that he retained the strongest ties to his natal family.9 Although much of the literature on Altieri patronage instinctively identifies Paluzzo as the decisive figure in family projects, we now know that it was Angelo who paid for and oversaw Bernini's work in the Altieri chapel (fig. 3) .10 Angelo's dedication to Ludovica Albertoni was evidently profound: like the Altieri chapel, his funerary chapel in Santa Maria in Campitelli, unveiled in 1705, also has a shared dedication to the beata and features another monumental marble honoring her memory, namely Lorenzo Ottoni's Beata Ludovica Albertoni Adoring the Holy Family (1696-1702).11 It should not be a surprise to find that Angelo was also the patron of Baciccio's Ludovica Albertoni. Baciccio s earliest biographers, Lione Pascoli and Carlo Giuseppe Ratti, tell us that the Genoese artist produced "some paintings" for "Prencipe Altieri,"12 and Altieri inven tories indicate that the family had several paintings of the beata in their palace, includ ing a "large one" with a black frame in the main gallery and another with a gold frame in the lower guardaroba.n Baciccio was also intimately familiar with Ludovica's image. As a result of changes made to the beatification process by Pope Urban VIII (1623-44), for Ludovica's beatification to be successful it was fundamental to prove that she had been actively venerated for at least one hundred years.14 The Altieri called upon experts in art history, connoisseurs, and artists to testify that existing depictions of Ludovica were of the necessary age; two of these witnesses were Giovanni Pietro Bellori and Baciccio.15 Bellori and Baciccio described each element of Ludovica's iconography and swore that the earli est surviving monumental depiction of her, a sixteenth-century fresco in the Albertoni :hapel in the church of Santa Maria d'Aracoeli, was proof of the longevity of her cult.16 io these circumstantial connections between Baciccio, Ludovica Albertoni, and the Altieri, we can add precise documentary evidence, namely the receipt for the Getty painting. Angelo Altieri's payment records for the years 1670 and 1671 include the fol lowing entry: "The bookkeeper is ordered to make the payment of 105 scudi to Giovanni Battista Gaulli Painter in recognition of a painting of the Beata Ludovica made for our 4 GETTY RESEARCH JOURNAL, NO. 2 (2010) This content downloaded from 206.211.139.204 on Fri, 06 Mar 2015 17:22:49 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Fig. 3. Cappella Altieri, San Francesco a Ripa, Rome on the feast day of Beata Ludovica Albertoni, 31 January 2009. Photo: Karen J. Lloyd use, February 22nd 1671.105 scudi, Angelo Altieri."17 The date provided by the payment is earlier than that proposed for the Getty painting by Fredricksen and supported by Maurizio Fagiolo delPArco, yet it falls within a reasonable timeframe, given what we know of the developing style of the artist. The painting was probably begun late in 1670 or early in 1671 and finished, as we shall see, by the end of January 1671.18 It has suffered significant damage, yet one can see that the original execution is rough, particularly in the middle-ground and background figures and in details such as a visible pentimento in Ludovica's left hand.19 The slightly raw quality suggests either that it was meant to be seen from a distance or that it was executed in some haste; the latter appears the more likely conclusion. The date provided by the payment record corroborates the stylistic evidence. For example, the Ludovica Albertoni shares significant similarities with Baciccio's picture of Saint Louis Beltran in Santa Maria sopra Minerva, which is dated 1671 to 1674.20 Robert Enggass observed that Baciccio depicted Beltran with distinctly elongated proportions, particularly in his lower half, where the "length between the kneeling saint's waist and his knee would almost suffice for an entire leg."21 The Getty picture of Ludovica Alber toni shares precisely these characteristics, which are also found in Bernini's later works, Lloyd Baciccio's Beata Ludovica Albertoni 5 This content downloaded from 206.211.139.204 on Fri, 06 Mar 2015 17:22:49 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions such as the angels ror the Ponte Sant Angelo: the beata has a relatively short torso and an exaggerated, long, gently curving lower half. Baciccio's painting of Beltran was definitely installed by 1674, but it may have been made just after the Spanish Dominican's canoniza tion in 1671. The stylistic similarities between these two works would suggest that both were executed early in 1671. One of the pressing questions regarding Baciccio's Ludovica Albertoni is that of its intended purpose.22 The payment states that it was made "for our [Angelo's, or the Altieri's] use" (per nostro servitio). The proposed execution date, around January 1671, suggests that the painting was intended to play a role in the celebration of Ludovica's feast day on the 31st of that month. A further payment supports this hypothesis. On 30 January 1671, Angelo ordered 25 scudi to be paid for the gilding of a "very large frame for the altarpiece of the Beata Ludovica, entirely burnished with a plaster ground."23 Assuming that this is the same painting referred to in the 22 February payment, then the payment date for the frame, the day before Ludovica's feast day, also fits the timeline suggested for Baciccio's painting.24 Aspects or the composition itself indicate that it was intended for use as an altar piece.25 Placed over an altar, the torn loaves of bread and the dark liquid just visible in the bowl make a direct connection to the enactment of the sacrament that would have taken place below. Eucharistic references pertain to Ludovica as well: her seventeenth-century biographers stress that among her saintly qualities was the ability to subsist on the tiny amount of bread and wine that she consumed during the mass.26 Aspects of the paint ing's composition indicate that it was meant to be installed just above eye level: we see down into the bowl in the lower half of the painting, but not significantly under the edge of Ludovica's veil. Such an arrangement would have been appropriate had the painting been placed above the altar in the Altieri chapel in San Francesco a Ripa before Bernini added an architectural recess for his statue of the beata (1674).27 Given the size, date, and composition of Baciccio's painting, with its clear iconographical references to the Eucha rist, one can safely conclude that it was employed as the main altarpiece during the first celebration of the beata's feast day in 1671. t rom an early age Ludovica Albertoni desired to devote herself to a religious life.28 Familial concerns prevailed, however, and instead she married Giacomo della Cetera and had three daughters before della Cetera's death in 1506. In her widowhood, Ludovica joined the third order of Franciscans and devoted her life to charity and prayer, she died in 1533 and was buried in the Altieri chapel, her husband's family chapel in San Francesco a Ripa. Although during her life she was seen to undergo miraculous experi ences, for example, levitating at mass after receiving the host, her vite are more notable "or their emphasis on her charity and good deeds than for miracles, ecstasies, or mystic experiences. It is not surprising to tind a case of mistaken identity between Ludovica Albertoni md Francesca Romana, as a strong congruence between the two women was established is part of a deliberate canonization strategy long undertaken by the Albertoni family. 5 GETTY RESEARCH JOURNAL, NO. 2 (2010) This content downloaded from 206.211.139.204 on Fri, 06 Mar 2015 17:22:49 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Fig. 4. Ludovica Albertoni, 16th century, fresco. Rome, San Francesco a Ripa, Cappella Altieri. Photo: Karen J. Lloyd Fig. 5. Ludovica Albertoniy 17th century (?), fresco. Rome, Cappella Santa Francesca Romana, San Bartolommeo all'Isola. Photo: Karen J. Lloyd Both women were widows, and Ludovica is known to have been particularly devoted to Francesca, carrying a piece of her veil in constant veneration.29 The two were frequently shown together in chapel decorations from the late sixteenth century on. They appear, along with Saints Agnes and Cecilia, in the pendentives of the Albertoni chapel in the church of Santa Maria d'Aracoeli, where they are dressed identically but labeled, so the identifications are clear.30 As part of a decorative campaign that took place around 1622, these frescoes were replicated, without the captions, in the Altieri chapel.31 Ludovica is represented three times in this chapel—in the pendentive fresco by Cristoforo Grippi, in Bernini's statue, and in an anonymous sixteenth-century fresco to the right of the altar (fig. 4). The latter was no doubt Baciccio's main source, and in essence his work reads as a restatement and embellishment of this earlier work. In this simple image, the hidden coins are not visible, but presumably that element of the story would have been familiar to those coming to the chapel to honor the beata's memory. Although previously unremarked, the anonymous sixteenth-century fresco of Ludovica is replicated in another fresco located on the nave side of one of the piers fram ing the chapel of Santa Francesca Romana in the church of San Bartolommeo all'Isola (fig. 5). While difficult to date due to significant damage and overpainting, the initial fresco likely dates from the seicento and indicates that Ludovica's iconography was stan dardized and narrowly diffused in the topography of Rome.32 Again, it is notable that this Baciccio's Beata Ludovica Albert oni This content downloaded from 206.211.139.204 on Fri, 06 Mar 2015 17:22:49 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions COMPENDIO DEI, LA VITA D E L L A. B E A T A LODOVICA ALBERTONI DELLA CETERA VEDOVA ROMANA RELIGIOSA DEL TERZ'ORDINE DI SAN FRANCESCO Con I'aggiwua d'alcuni Epigrdmmi di CeJare Solatij Romano , Dcdicato aU'IIluftriffimo, & iccellentiffimo Sig. Principe DON GASPARO ALTIERI NIPOTE DI NOSTRO SIGNORE, E GENERALE DI SANTA CHIESA &c. IN ROMA, Nclla Scampcrta del Manciui, 1671. Gon lic(/f~*dc$upe>-iori. Fig. 6. Title page showing the Beata Ludovica Albertom giving alms. From Cesare Solatio, Compendio della vita della beata Lodouica Albertoni della Cetera vedoua romana... (Rome: Nella Stamperia del Mancini, 1671). Photograph courtesy Biblioteca nazionale centrale di Roma 8 GETTY RESEARCH JOURNAL, NO. 2 (2010) This content downloaded from 206.211.139.204 on Fri, 06 Mar 2015 17:22:49 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions