ASSISTING IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF AN AQUAPONIC GREENHOUSE ENTERPRISE An Interactive Qualifying Project submitted to the Faculty of WORCESTER POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Science By Antoine Crews Alexander Noonan Ethan Prihar Paula Rudy Date: 29 April 2016 Report Submitted to: Matt Feinstein The Worcester Roots Project Howard Lucas Greenvitalize Urban Growers Dr. Stephen McCauley Worcester Polytechnic Institute This report represents work of WPI undergraduate students submitted to the faculty as evidence of a degree requirement. WPI routinely publishes these reports on its web site without editorial or peer review. For more information about the projects program at WPI, see http://www.wpi.edu/Academics/Projects i Table of Contents Table of Figures ............................................................................................................................................ iii Table of Tables ............................................................................................................................................. iii Abstract ........................................................................................................................................................ iv Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 1 Background ................................................................................................................................................... 2 Overview of Aquaponics ........................................................................................................................... 2 The Case for Aquaponics in an Urban Setting .......................................................................................... 2 Emerging Urban Food System in Worcester ............................................................................................ 3 Aquaponic Greenhouse Design ................................................................................................................ 5 Aquaponic System Structure ................................................................................................................ 5 Species Requirements .......................................................................................................................... 5 Policies and Funding Considerations .................................................................................................... 6 Methodology ................................................................................................................................................. 6 Objectives Overview ................................................................................................................................. 6 Understanding the Network of Partners Involved with the Worcester Food System ............................. 7 Improve the Physical Greenhouse Structure ............................................................................................ 7 Develop the Biological System ................................................................................................................. 7 Help Develop the Mission and Strategic Goals of GreenVitalize .............................................................. 8 Perform Market Analysis to Inform the Selection of Species to be Grown in the Greenhouse............... 8 Scale the Greenhouse Initiative Beyond the Pilot Site ............................................................................. 8 Findings ......................................................................................................................................................... 9 The Network of Partnerships Involved with the Worcester Food System ............................................... 9 Improving the Physical System ................................................................................................................. 9 Developing the Biological System ............................................................................................................. 9 Strategic Goals or the Greenvitalize Cooperative Enterprise ................................................................. 10 Market Analysis of Species Able to be Grown in an Aquaponic System ................................................ 11 Scale the Greenhouse Initiative Beyond the Pilot Site ........................................................................... 11 Key Findings ............................................................................................................................................ 12 Accomplishments and Deliverables ............................................................................................................ 13 Advancing the Pilot Aquaponic Greenhouse .......................................................................................... 13 Creation of a Forum for Urban Agriculture Discussion .......................................................................... 14 Creation of a Guide for the Creation of an Aquaponic Greenhouse Enterprise .................................... 15 Recommendations ...................................................................................................................................... 16 Immediate Community Outreach Recommendations ........................................................................... 16 ii Immediate Aquaponic Greenhouse Recommendations ........................................................................ 17 Short Term Goals .................................................................................................................................... 17 Long Term Goals ..................................................................................................................................... 18 Aquaponic Greenhouse Business Models for Scaling Up ....................................................................... 19 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................................................................... 19 Works Cited ................................................................................................................................................. 20 Appendix A: Additional Biological System Research ................................................................................... 24 Appendix B: Fish Species for Cultivation ..................................................................................................... 26 Appendix C: Plant Species for Cultivation ................................................................................................... 26 Appendix D: Aquaponic Greenhouse Business Models .............................................................................. 27 Cooperatives ........................................................................................................................................... 27 Community Owned Corporations ........................................................................................................... 28 Small Ownership Groups ........................................................................................................................ 28 Crowdsourcing ........................................................................................................................................ 28 Appendix E: Organizations Interviewed ...................................................................................................... 30 Appendix F: Additional Background Research ............................................................................................ 34 The rise of Urban Food Production ........................................................................................................ 34 The Food desert of Worcester ................................................................................................................ 34 Greenhouse Structure ............................................................................................................................ 34 Appendix G: Creating an Aquaponic Greenhouse Enterprise ..................................................................... 35 Table of Figures Figure 1 Diagram of food deserts in Worcester using information from a recent international census. Updated March, 2015 (Breneman, 2015) ..................................................................................................... 4 Figure 2 Temperature Graph ...................................................................................................................... 13 Figure 3 Leak in the Greenhouse Roof ........................................................................................................ 14 Figure 4 Forum Front Page.......................................................................................................................... 15 Figure 5 Section from the Guide ................................................................................................................. 16 Table of Tables Table 1 Types of Aquaponic Systems ............................................................................................................ 5 Table 2 Species requirements, adapted from table 7.1 (Sommerville, 2014) .............................................. 6 Table 3 List of Organizations to be Contacted ............................................................................................ 17 iii Abstract The goal of this project was to aid The Worcester Roots Project by advancing the progress of their pilot aquaponic greenhouse, and assist Greenvitalize by exploring options to expand their startup enterprise. To accomplish this goal, our team designed the biological system and assessed the structural integrity of the greenhouse. We also developed a strategic plan for Greenvitalize's enterprise and conducted market analysis of viable species to grown in the greenhouse. This project resulted in a forum that allows Greenvitalize to act as a source of urban farming knowledge and collaboration, and a guide to assist individuals interested in aquaponics to create an enterprise similar to Greenvitalize. iv Introduction A major problem in the U.S. is a lack of access to local fresh foods. Over 23 million people in the U.S. currently reside in food deserts like Worcester. The U.S. Department of Agriculture defines a food desert as a low income area with limited access to transportation that is located more than 1 mile (in urban areas) or more than 10 miles (in rural areas) from a supermarket (Breneman, 2015). Limited access to fresh produce and availability of processed foods has contributed to the nation’s obesity epidemic. Most international produce is either heavily preserved or withered by the time that it reaches Worcester’s urban areas. This leaves people living in the urban areas of Worcester unable to get fresh produce at a reasonable price. Currently, organizations in Worcester are attempting to remedy this problem of food insecurity. One such organization is The Worcester Roots Project. Worcester Roots is an organization that works with the community toward social, economic, and environmental justice by aiding in the creation of local co-ops and providing educational programs on the subjects of contaminated soil, development of green jobs, and more. Worcester Roots’ commitment to aiding the community, one area that Worcester Roots’ focuses on include food justice and food access. Worcester’s abundance of abandoned plots can contribute to a solution to the food desert. According to RealtyTrac data, there are over 400 homes available for purchase in Worcester County that are identified as abandoned (Knothe, 2014). These vacant lots provide an excellent area for building vertical gardens, greenhouses, and other systems to provide fresh produce to the community. An aquaponics greenhouse can provide local fresh produce. In cold climates food can be grown year round if the aquaponics greenhouse is insulated properly. Urban communities can use vacant as potential plots lots accessible to urban plots and growers. Giving local residents’ access to fresh foods leads too much more than improving the health of the community. For example, Growing Power in Milwaukee Wisconsin has been a leader in urban food systems since 1993. Since its inception, Growing Power has offered education programs, created a local source of fresh produce, and served as a center of innovation for its community. Currently, Growing Power has 50 licensed day care gardens created to teach children about urban farming. They also have several urban farming operations throughout Milwaukee. The viability of aquaponics combined with Worcester Roots and their partner, Greenvitalize, provides the opportunity to create a similar operation to Growing Power. The Worcester Roots Project, along with a network of partners, have built a pilot aquaponic greenhouse in the Main South neighborhood of Worcester. Worcester Roots' immediate goal is to use the aquaponic greenhouse system to lead an open source effort to establish a co-op called Greenvitalize, which will address the health, cultural, and economic needs of the community. This project aims to not only generate jobs and provide access to locally grown fresh produce, but to serve as a model or communities-based greenhouse initiatives. The pilot site consists of a greenhouse structure containing the first prototype of an aquaponic system (Chatani et al, 2015). Greenvitalize is beginning to winterize the greenhouse, populate the system with plants and fish, and develop the business enterprise. The goal of this project is to assist Worcester Roots and the emerging cooperative Greenvitalize by advancing the development of the pilot aquaponic greenhouse and to help Greenvitalize develop 1 strategic goals, the mission of the aquaponic greenhouse enterprise, and explore strategies for scaling up beyond the pilot site. This will be achieved by:  Understanding the network of partners  Improving the physical structure and aquaponic system  Developing the biological system  Helping develop the mission and strategic goals of Greenvitalize  Performing market analysis to determine the species to be grown  Assessing different ways to scale up the initiative beyond the pilot site. Background Overview of Aquaponics Aquaponics is an integration of aquaculture and hydroponics. The defining feature of an aquaponic system is a soilless system that uses water circulated between plants and fish (Love et. all, 2014). In this manner, waste produced by the fish becomes fertilizer for the plants, thus drastically reducing inputs of nutrients into the system and waste output (Chatani et al, 2015 section i.ii). Fish and other aquatic species excrete ammonia (NH ) as waste. A portion of this waste ionizes in water to 3 produce ammonium (NH ). Nitrifying bacteria within the system convert ammonia (NH ) to nitrite (NO2 –) 4 3 and then to nitrate (NO3 –). Plants, which require large amounts of nitrogen to grow, absorb the nitrate from the water (Tyson et al, 2011). This allows for the production of food products from a natural system without the use of environmentally toxic fertilizers. The Case for Aquaponics in an Urban Setting The need for a change in our current food system has become evident through its shortcomings. The existence of Food deserts and the necessity of genetic modification of produce are both evidence of an emerging problem in the fundamental culture of food acquisition in America. Many communities do not have access to fresh produce. The US Department of Agriculture considers an area a “food desert” when low income areas with limited access to transportation are more than 1 mile (in urban areas) or more than 10 miles (in rural areas) from a supermarket. Distances between the farm and the customer can result in quality complications with produce. Worcester is part of a growing assemblage of food deserts in the U.S. This becomes an epidemic when considering the health implications of this problem. “In general these studies find that better access to a supermarket is associated with a reduced risk of obesity and better access to convenience stores is associated with increased risk of obesity.”(Breneman, 53-54, 2009). Improving access to fresh produce via community driven farming could enhance the wellbeing of the community. Allowing a community to grow its own food also closes the gap between supply and demand for culturally specific produce. A growing trend to combat to the distance between the source of the produce and where it’s sold has been genetic modification. “Currently, up to 92% of U.S. corn is genetically engineered, as are 94% of soybeans and 94% of cotton (cottonseed oil is often used in food products). It has been estimated that upwards of 75% of processed foods on supermarket shelves – from soda to soup, 2 crackers to condiments – contain genetically engineered ingredients.”(About, 2015). Many of these plants are created to increase yield. Some are engineered to resist disease and pests. The existing methods of agriculture fall short in regard to meeting the demands for a growing population. Agriculture uses pesticides to protect large fields from parasites, neglecting to account for the effects these chemicals have on the cultivators and ecosystem. A study in India showed that workers exposed to pesticides showed more health complications than those in other occupations: “When queried about symptoms of peripheral sensory neuropathy in the form of tingling sensation, burning/pricking pain in hands or feet, 40% of the pesticide sprayers and 9.1% of persons engaged in other occupations, had these complaints.” (Mathew, 2015). Four common pesticides in use today are also known to have a toxic effect on the larvae of the honey bee (Zhu, 2015). This can have devastating effects on the ecosystem. Aquaponics does not require pesticides because it grows produce in a closed system with a limited exposure to open air. Instead, aquaponic greenhouses can use pest control systems to distinguish between insects that are harmful to the crops and those that help the crops (Greer, 1999). By integrating fish farming with crop production, the problem of fish farming’s environmental toxicity is reduced. “Fish-farming contributing to marine waters eutrophication, feces and uneaten food pellets from fish farms alter the organic matter in the sediment, which can change the consumption of oxygen and cause local eutrophication.”(Mancuso, p.88) The advantage of using aquaponics as an urban farming supplement to the food system is the flexibility and efficiency of this type of farming. A comparison can be made by food output per area used: “Another way of looking at it is that over the course of a year, aquaponics will generate about 35,000 pounds of edible flesh per acre, while the grass-fed beef will generate about 75 pounds in the same space.”(Bernstein, 2011). Further advantages of aquaponics area utilization include the ability to house these systems in smaller spaces. Agriculture requires acres of open field while aquaponics systems can be set up inside of closed spaces such as abandoned buildings or warehouses (Bernstein, 2011). Another consideration is the use of resources. In America, we have developed a food system in which food is generated far from demand. This way of living uses more resources than necessary and alienates us from our food source. The environment benefits from fuel saved by growing food closer to the consumers. “-Hong Kong and Singapore already both produce more than 20 percent of their meat and vegetables within the city limits.”(Bernstein, 2011). Using aquaponic greenhouses is just one way to accomplish this. Emerging Urban Food System in Worcester There are sections of the Worcester community that can only access fresh produce if they have a car that can drive them to the nearest store (as shown in Fig. 2). Not having fresh produce within walking distance or near a local bus route severely limits the ability for the community to access fresh food. 3 FIGURE 1 DIAGRAM OF FOOD DESERTS IN WORCESTER USING INFORMATION FROM A RECENT INTERNATIONAL CENSUS. UPDATED MARCH, 2015 (BRENEMAN, 2015) Because of the food desert present in Worcester, many organizations have been created to combat the dwindling access to fresh produce. Community Supported Agriculture (CSA) is a program that pays a farm in advance for a share of the produce. Some CSA programs even allow for a flexible monthly payment plan (Lebeaux, 2015). Nuestro Huerto is a community farm that donates some crops to local businesses while also connecting the community to their food source. (Solin, 2015). Stone Soup Community Center provides the community with social, environmental, and economic justice through many programs including the greenhouse initiative that our team is assisting in. (Stone, 2015) The Regional Environmental Council (REC) also focuses on action to support environmental, social, and economic justice (What, 2015). The Worcester Roots Projects is a community driven organization focusing on economic, social, and environmental justice. They aim to support the struggle of the common person to live a healthy life in a non-toxic environment. Currently Worcester Roots has invested in efforts to create an aquaponic greenhouse that runs on a co-operative business model. Stone Soup Kitchen has partnered with Worcester Roots to ensure the community and surrounding neighborhood of Main South benefit from the aquaponic greenhouse as well. Maine South is a key focus for this project because it is designated as a food desert in figure 1, and is also designated as an environmental justice focus area. Greenvitalize is another cooperative greenhouse enterprise taking initiative in the project led by Howard Lucas. FIGURE 2 WORCESTER ROOTS GREENHOUSE AT STONE SOUP COMMUNITY CENTER 4 Aquaponic Greenhouse Design The defining feature of an aquaponic system is a soilless system using water circulated between plants and fish (Love et all, 2014). Previously there was a team at WPI focused on the development of the structure and biological system of the aquaponic greenhouse. In this section, we will discuss both the decisions the previous team made regarding the design of the aquaponic system at Stone Soup Community Center and decisions yet to be made. Aquaponic System Structure Type Media Filled Grow Bed Nutrient Film Deep Water Culture Technique (floating raft method) Pros Easy for beginners due No special grow Best for commercial to lack of filter medium required application Flexible choice of size Easy to adapt from because of high and shapes other existing output structures Can be automated Cons Less harvest crops than Limited to small root Requires special filters other techniques systems to avoid root rot TABLE 1 TYPES OF AQUAPONIC SYSTEMS Species Requirements Species Temperature Total Nitrite Dissolved Crude Growth- (C) ammonia (mg/liter) Oxygen protein rate nitrogen (mg/liter) in feed (Grow- (mg/liter) (%) out stage) Vital Optimal Common 4-34 25-30 <1 <1 >4 30-38 600 grams carp in 9-11 months Nile tilapia 14-36 27-30 <2 <1 >4 28-32 600 grams in 6-8 months Channel 5-34 24-30 <1 <1 >3 25-36 400 grams catfish in 9-10 months Rainbow 10-18 14-16 <0.5 <0.3 >6 42 1000 trout grams in 14-16 months Flat head 8-32 20-27 <1 <1 >4 30-34 750 grams mullet in 9-11 5 months Giant river 17-34 26-32 <0.5 <2 >3 35 30 grams prawn in 4-5 months Barramundi 18-34 26-29 <1 <1 >4 38-45 400 grams in 9-10 months TABLE 2 SPECIES REQUIREMENTS, ADAPTED FROM TABLE 7.1 (SOMMERVILLE, 2014) Policies and Funding Considerations Because the issue of food deserts and urban food systems lacking fresh sources of produce is a national problem, there are grants that are available to help establish startup funds for urban farming enterprises. The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) provides several food programs for low income families and people over the age of 60. These programs aim to provide a nutritious diet for people who traditionally may lack access to a proper healthy diet. The USDA also created the Competitive Grants Program, which awards 8.64 million to allow people to create community food projects, planning projects, training, and technical assistance. Aquaponic greenhouse programs can fall under all of these sections depending on its stage of development. Worcester currently has limited existing regulations for aquaponics greenhouses. However, Boston uses Article 89 to properly regulate 37 different urban farming initiatives, including aquaponic greenhouses. Article 89 defines aquaponics as a “means the cultivation of fish and plants together in a constructed, recirculating system utilizing natural bacterial cycles to convert fish wastes to plant nutrients, for distribution to retailers, restaurants and consumers.” (Article 89) Methodology The goal of this project was to aid The Worcester Roots Project by advancing the progress of their pilot aquaponic greenhouse, and assist Greenvitalize by exploring options to expand their startup enterprise. Objectives Overview 1. Understand network of partners involved with the Worcester food system 2. Improve the physical structure and aquaponic system 3. Develop the biological system 4. Help develop the mission and strategic goals of GreenVitalize 5. Perform market analysis to inform the selection of species to be grown in the greenhouse 6. Scale the greenhouse initiative beyond the pilot site 6