M •J 1 UMASS/AMHERST 312Qbb 02fl2 3bMD 1 HHHHHH it:?--1 ' ijtl"l!.H'j;; jpjnlFsl AIR QUALITY AND HEALTH HAZARDS AT SKATING RINKS December, 1994 )) ) ) ) HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES HOUSE POST AUDIT AND Mil BUREAU OVERSIGHT H P A O ROOM 146 STATE HOUSE BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS 02133-1053 00b UK! AIR QUALITY AND HEALTH HAZARDS May AT SKATING RINKS U On.*** 199s December, 1994 Of k Depl'^^«s THIS REPORT WAS PREPARED AND ISSUED UNDER THE MANDATES OF MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL LAW, CHAPTER 3, SECTIONS 63 AND 64. MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE Chairman William P. Nagle, Jr. Vice Chairman Thomas M. Petrolati D-Northampton (D-Ludlow) ( Representative John C. Klimm Representative Patrick F. Landers D-Bamstable (D-Palmer) ( Representative Ronald Mariano Representative Vincent G. Mannering (D-Quincy) (D-West Roxbury) Representative William J. McManus Representative Mary C. Rogeness D-Worcester R-Longmeadow ( ( Representative William M. Straus Representative Michael J. Sullivan (D-Mattapoisett) (R-Abington) . Representative Warren E Tolman D-Watertown ( BUREAU DIRECTOR/GENERAL COUNSEL Thomas W. Hammond, Jr. SCOPE OF EXAMINATION : The House Post Audit and Oversight Bureau (the "Bureau"), under the direction of the House Post Audit and Oversight Committee, (the "Committee") has conducted a preliminary inquiry into the issue of indoor air quality within state and privately owned skating rinks in Massachusetts. Based upon a written complaint, the Bureau began its examination of indoor air quality in skating rinks in January of 1993. The Bureau conducted interviews with rink personnel as well as authorities in the air quality assessment community to ascertain the quality of air within Massachusetts skating rinks. The Bureau also reviewed documents relating to independent air quality studies and current standards in the two states which have regulations or laws relating to ambient air quality inside skating rinks. In addition, the Bureau reviewed a set of draft guidelines developed by the Massachusetts Department of Public Health ("DPH") aimed specifically at indoor air quality in skating rinks. Initially, the Bureau focused its examination on concerns about the health risks posed by Carbon Monoxide ("CO") gas to rink occupants. After consulting with experts in the indoor air quality field and reviewing several independent reports, it became apparent that other gases such as Nitrogen Dioxide ("N0 ") also posed potentially serious health risks. 2 Based on its preliminary inquiry, the Bureau finds that there are sufficient health risks to warrant the immediate establishment of minimum safety requirements for indoor air quality at skating rinks. The Bureau recommends that the safety provisions called for in this report be codified into fully enforceable regulations. Digitized by the Internet Archive 2013 in http://archive.org/details/airqualityhealthOOmass Compliance with indoor air quality safety provisions should be mandatory for all skating rink operators in order to increase protection of the health and safety of people who use these facilities. Two incidents which occurred in Massachusetts in recent years have underscored the need for the Commonwealth to develop regulations for indoor air quality in skating rinks. In Rockland in 1991 and Hamilton in 1993, 54 and 59 people respectively, were taken to area hospitals with severe cases of CO poisoning after being exposed to high levels of CO in skating rinks. The source of CO poisoning in each incident was attributed to poorly tuned or inadequately maintained ice resurfacing machines. ' The Bureau found that these incidents could have been minimized or avoided had regular and proper maintenance of ice resurfacing machines taken place. Proper maintenance of these resurfacing machines is an important procedure for controlling toxic emissions.2 In response to the incidents in Rockland and Hamilton, a coalition was established consisting of the DPH, the Department of Environmental Management (the "DEM"), the Metropolitan District Commission (the "MDC"), the Department of Labor and Industries' Division of Occupational Hygiene (the "DOH") and rink owners. This coalition sought to create safety standards for skating rinks by the end of 1994. The Bureau also found that the potential for exposure to toxic gasses in skating rinks has been significantly understated. The Bureau found that public health experts have identified adverse health impacts that result form exposure to toxic gases in skating rinks. 'Hamilton Document, 1993; Rockland Document, 1991 2Bauer and Spengler 1994; p. 432 Virtually all reported incidents of toxic exposure in Massachusetts skating rinks involved extreme cases where many people became seriously and required hospitalization. When ill severe exposure incidents occur, it is relatively easy to attribute the resulting severe illnesses to toxic gas exposure at the skating rink. Based on its own inspections and investigations, the Bureau found that other incidents of unhealthy exposure to toxic gases go unreported because they are not as severe as those requiring hospitalization. This is primarily due to the fact that the general public does not directly attribute the symptoms of toxicity to exposure and therefore may not report ill effects experienced after attending or participating in an event in a skating rink. Symptoms of exposure are often flu-like and may be confused with the influenza virus or the symptoms of the common cold. The Bureau's examination of indoor air quality in skating rinks revealed toxicity incidents involving adverse impacts to skaters and employees were more common with high levels of CO than with high levels of N0 The increased frequency of CO incidents may be 2. N0 due to the fact that symptoms of toxicity do not appear immediately after an incident. 2 Consequently, the symptoms of N0 toxicity may not be directly attributed to the rink 2 environment by the individuals who are adversely impacted. POLLUTION SOURCE : The primary source of harmful pollutants found in skating rinks is the internal combustion engines which power ice resurfacing machines used to maintain ice surfaces. Combustion engine by-products are present in varying degrees in all skating rinks which