Dr. Charles D. Horning Collection of CAPPED BUST DIME ERRORS INTRODUCTION CAPPED BUST DIME ERRORS Collectors of bust coinage usually begin with a basic type set that may progress Creating a meaningful bust dime error collection was certainly the most to a date set of an individual series. As collectors become more involved, they daunting of journeys. In the more than three decades that I have collected may advance to a die marriage set of a favorite coin. At some point, they will bust dimes, I have only found 13 unique examples. Unfortunately, there was a begin to hit a wall in finding new marriages for their sets. That interest may 14th that I passed on, to my now great chagrin; God rest you, Henry Hilgard. then expand to the esoterica of numismatics, including terminal die states, love tokens, merchant counter stamps and the caviar of collectibles-errors. Dr. Horning Purchasing an R-6 bust dime marriage was a known task within a defined explored each of these areas in his favorite series, the Capped Bust Dime. price range - actually a reasonable task in comparison. I began collecting bust His enthusiasm for the errors stemmed from numerous conversations with fellow dimes by die marriage in earnest in 1990, having burned out as a numismatic collectors at the annual ANA conventions. Here he met and became friends with accumulator, with little knowledge and limited direction. two of the error giants of bust coinage, Dr. Henry Hilgard and Russell Logan. His conversations with these two JRCS Hall of Fame members helped convince Due to the encouragement of my mentor Brad Karoleff, I began my efforts to him that much was to be learned from studying the errors. While Henry and Russ build the best capped bust dime collection I could afford. Reading a great deal, collected errors of all denominations, Charlie restricted his purchases to the dimes. gleaning gems from the greats of the hobby, especially Russ Logan, I began to better understand the minting process. The collection presented here is the culmination of years searching dealers’ stocks at conventions and networking with other collectors by both Charlie After the Bill Subjack sale in December 1992, I began to collect bust dimes and me. The errors are ALL rare and the opportunity to purchase them is even in earnest. Outside of my primary collection, I think I became known as the more rare. They were unwanted from their origin and culled from the system garbage man. My collection soon included every cud I could find, love tokens, when discovered. Many of these were re-minted, obscuring their error status, counterstamps and the rarest quarry of all - Mint errors. especially when factoring in the wear they would have received in circulation. The pieces that could not be successfully recycled were melted. If one believes These Mint mistakes were the red headed step child of collecting. Generally in the approximate 3% survival rate for average bust coinage, one can only ratty condition, too rare to catalogue, rarely mentioned in texts or publications, imagine the miniscule surviving numbers for the errors. they became privately traded. “What are you willing to pay? You’ll never find another…” The Charles D. Horning collection of Capped Bust Dime Errors is offered here as a collection. The purchase of an entire grouping like this will likely save the collector In truth, every mint error is truly unique. Most, more than likely, went into the decades of work attempting to duplicate something close to this collection. reject pile - never to see the light of day, much less any circulation. Consider that the Hilgard collection did not come to public auction and the last sale that had this many dime errors was the Logan collection in 2001! For early Federal coinage, it was not until the Russ Logan sale in November 2002, that bust errors were fully described, appreciated and auctioned. The The Logan collection contained 10 Capped Bust Dime errors in the sale. prices realized from this auction created the first de facto price guide for early Charlie was able to accumulate 13 pieces in his collecting career including 3 directly federal Mint errors. from the Logan sale. The others were sourced from numerous shows and private transactions. The latest collection to come to market, that of Dr. John McCloskey, These gems became the ultimate esoterica of the bust dime world. Essentially, included only one, a 15% off center 1821 which sold for $4560. Other auction all of the examples in my collection are at least an R-7, a few being unique. comparisons are difficult to locate as many errors are still privately traded. To this day, no full accounting of the extant population has been or ever will be published. The Horning collection offers one a unique opportunity to obtain a collection decades in the making saving the buyer both time and, likely, money in the long Garnered from the trash heaps and the luminaries, these masterpieces of the run. Who knows what prices for these unique specimens may do in the future? Mint’s malfunction will, hopefully, find an appreciative home. Charlie would like to see the collection go to an appreciative numismatist who will continue to add specimens to the set and knowledge to the collecting community. Charles D. Horning, DDS Bradley S. Karoleff, NLG 1814 JR1 11% off center strike very 1820 JR7 Double struck obverse fine details slight pitting light scratch VF30. One sided double struck coins obverse and heavier scratch on are a result of two planchets being fed the reverse. This coin sports a fine into the minting chamber at a time. pedigree. Russ Logan obtained it from One receives an obverse strike and the Subjack sale in July of 1992 for the other a reverse image. They are $1075. It next appeared in the Logan then fed back into the press to receive collection lot 2015 in November 2002 a “normal” strike resulting in a uniface where Charlie purchased it for $2300. double struck coin. This coin exhibits Included with the coin is Russ’ original doubling in the dentils and stars, flip insert, the insert from the B&M sale in 2002 and Charlie’s especially 8-13. Originally sold by annotated envelope. All major off center bust dimes are rare and JJ Teaparty to an unknown collector this one has the added cache of having been in the collections of then to Charlie from Brian Greer in 2004. two of the authors of Early United States Dimes. 1821 JR8 Double struck obverse 1823/2 JR3 incomplete “clipped” VF25 dark patina. Another of the planchet VG8 dark patina. Charlie one-sided double struck coins most had this marked as a 5% clip at 2–3:00 noticeable around 12:00 on the with a very light Blaksley effect directly obverse. The letters of LIBERTY are opposite the clip to help in authen- also doubled and the dentils are off tication. This is one of the largest 50% creating an interesting look. “clips” I’ve seen in the Capped Bust dime series. All incomplete planchet errors are rare on bust coins as they basically served as bullion in the early history of the United States. 1828 flipover double struck in collar NGC VG10. Too bad this one did not survive in better condition! Part of the shield is visible on Liberty’s portrait and the fields are compromised from the reverse design. A decidedly flat area at stars 3-4 is the most noticeable feature. The outline of the Eagle’s wing is clearly visible over the end of the bust and various letters of UNITED STATES OF AMERICA are visible in the fields at the periphery. The reverse shows much less evidence of the previous strike but the eagle is very flatly struck as a result. Doubling in the dentils is evident as well as some deformities in the field from the previously struck stars. Charlie purchased the coin from Henry Hilgard in 2012 and his letter of sale for $1300 is included with the coin. 1832 JR2 incomplete “clipped” 1832 JR4 slightly broadstruck planchet XF45 with original surfaces. VF20. Charlie had listed this as an Another “clipped” planchet, this one off-center strike but I believe it to be slightly smaller than the last, appearing broadstruck. It appears the planchet at 12:00. Additionally, it also has an edge was not centered in the collar as cud at 6:30 in the reeding. This another the coin is slightly egg shaped with interesting coin with a great provenance. an additional “rim” from 1–5:00. It appeared on the cover of Errorscope The error is clearly visible without magazine in June of 1985. It was owned magnification. Charlie obtained this by “Lonesome John” and went to Bill coin at the CSNS convention in Subjack (a dime book author) then to Russ Logan as lot 2116 in 2015 for $200. his sale to Charlie. Here is another chance to add your name to an impressive pedigree. Russ paid almost $400 for the piece in 1992 and Charlie purchased it from the B&M auction for $575. Flip inserts from Subjack, Logan and the B&M Logan sale are included. 1833 JR9 Uncentered broadstrike 1833 JR9 Partial collar strike PCGS F12 with original surfaces. NGC MS61, white and lusterous. Charlie obtained this coin from the Unfortunately, the mint error is Heritage ANA sale, lot 8344, in partially concealed under the edge 2004. It was described as “An area of the NGC slab. Charlie obtained of unstruck surface is widest near this coin in July of 2006 for $1700. 12:00 on the obverse. A deeply toned This is a rare opportunity to add lavender-brown piece with a hint of an uncirculated mint error to verdigris, a somewhat wavy surface, your collection. and a few notable marks on the reverse. The portrait has a couple of faint pinscratches. Obviously, a rare type to encounter broadstruck. From the Velma & Bowie Lynch Collection.” Charlie was all in at $527 for this coin. A copy of the catalog page from the Heritage auction is included. 1835 JR5 Double struck in collar 1835 JR5 double struck VF25 exhibiting formerly in an old ANACS F detail charcoal surfaces. I found the coin for net VG8 holder. The net grading is Charlie in 2016 and described it as such; from an old scratch. The doubling “Double struck. First strike in collar with is most noticeable on the date and blank planchet lying partially across ob- stars 1-4 on the obverse. The reverse verse creating the depression across the exhibits the strongest doubling at obverse. The reverse received AT LEAST a partial strike as evidenced by the lettering ERICA. The coin is attractively darkly under the other letters in EPU on scroll toned with blue and gold highlights. and the doubling on the left wing and Charlie purchased it at the Central head of eagle. This likely jammed the press. After clearing the coining States show in 2003 for $315. The chamber, the partially struck coin was put back in the collar and struck original sticker from the ANACS slab normally. The reverse is clearly the star of this coin with a strongly doubled and Charlie’s flip insert are included. left wing, eagle’s head and UN of Unum. This is one of my favorite coins in the collection. Charlie paid me the bargain price of $350 for it in 2016. 1835 JR1 Partial brockage strike AU50 1837 JR2 Misaligned die strike VG8. with original dusty surfaces. In 2002 our This is another ex: Russ Logan coin. friend, Steve Crain, contacted me about Russ had obtained it via eBay in 2001 this coin. His friend, and collecting partner, paying $175. It was housed in a SEGS Stan Kubaki had discovered this coin holder which was soon broken open at a show. Stan was mainly, like Steve, by Russ. Charlie obtained it from the interested in the half dimes and wanted B&M Logan sale in 2002 as lot 2170 to sell the error dime. The brockage for the ridiculous price of $75. I guess evidence is visible on the raised portion everyone fell asleep at the end of the of the rim both obverse (6:00) and reverse dime section except me! Included is (12:00). There are also three dentil tracks on Miss Liberty’s cheek under the original SEGS tag, Russ’ flip insert her eye. There is a minor indentation over the date which is not related and the B&M lot card. to the error. Included with the coin is Stan’s flip insert, Charlie’s envelope and the original letter offering the coin from Steve Crain to me.