3 223 06587 0041 yie Drive Environmental and Design Study Environmental Study tial reduction San Francisco County Transportation Authority (SFCTA) is proposing to replace Doyle Drive ated in the Presidio of San Francisco (the Presidio), within the Golden Gate Recreation Area, 'an Francisco County, California. The Presidio has been part of the National Park system ce 1994 and a National Historic Landmark since 1962. The Doyle Drive roadway has been ermined to be a contributing structure to the landmark. Doyle Drive is maintained and naged by Caltrans within a right-of-way originally granted by the Army and is now under the a federal corporation that manages Area B ofthe Presidio (see rvice manages Area A (see Figure 1). 5/S is the southern approach of U.S. 101 to the Golden Gate I CO approach ramps, one beginning at the intersection of Marina he other at the intersection of Richardson Avenue and Lyon ist Highway) merges into Doyle Drive approximately one mile anciscoPublicLibrary proach (see Figures 1 and 2). Tive links the City of San Francisco, the Peninsula, Marin County rnm^r./ •'rforrnation Center 1 Gate Bridge. As part of the primary north-south freeway link in raricisco Public Library arries over 144,000 weekday travelers, including public transit arkin Street, 5th Floor rancisco, CA 94102 if a median or shoulders, Doyle Drive does not meet current RENCE BOOK for safety. If the structure is not replaced, structural degradation, )f heavy traffic and exposure to salt air, may cause Caltrans to taken from the Library J coming years. In addition, the eastern portion of the aging n zone also presents the potential for the existing structure to fail Gate Bridge toll plaza, no vehicular access into the Presidio is — 3 Drive. The existing structure crosses over several historic ...a- o - tion, is a visual and audible intrusion on the Main Post and onal cemetery in its low viaduct section, and is a physical barrier between Crissy Field and rest of the Presidio {Report ofthe Doyle Drive Task Force to the San Francisco Board of ervisors [Doyle Drive Task Force Report], 1993). purposes for replacing Doyle Drive include significantly improving traffic conditions on the way and the structural and seismic safety of the roadway. Multimodal transportation rnatives and traffic conditions on local roadways can also be addressed in the project. rnatives will be evaluated for consistency with the San Francisco General Plan and the Final sidio General Management Plan Amendment (GMPA). San Francisco County Transportation Authority (SFCTA) is the lead agency for California ironmental Quality Act (CEQA) compliance for the Doyle Drive Project. The SFCTA has n this role pursuant to an Interagency Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the TA and Caltrans executed in April 1998. Major tasks of the SFCTA pursuant to the MOU de preparing a CEQA Environmental Impact Report (EIR) jointly with a National ironmental Policy Act (NEPA) Environmental Impact Statement (EIS); developing a final ing strategy; and creating a preliminary engineering design for the project. The Federal way Administration (FHWA) is the Lead Agency for the NEPA EIS. The combined document meet the requirements of the both environmental regulations and will be referred to as the /EIR. Doyle Drive Environmental and Design Study initial Environmental Study Introduction The San Francisco County Transportation Authority (SFCTA) is proposing to replace Doyle Drive located in the Presidio of San Francisco (the Presidio), within the Golden Gate Recreation Area, in San Francisco County, California. The Presidio has been part of the National Park system since 1994 and a National Historic Landmark since 1962. The Doyle Drive roadway has been determined to be a contributing structure to the landmark. Doyle Drive is maintained and managed by Caltrans within a right-of-way originally granted by the Army and is now under the jurisdiction of the Presidio Trust, a federal corporation that manages Area B of the Presidio (see Figure 1). The National Park Service manages Area A (see Figure 1). Doyle Drive is 1.5 miles long and is the southern approach of U.S. 101 to the Golden Gate Bridge. It has three San Francisco approach ramps, one beginning at the intersection of Marina Boulevard and Lyon Street and the other at the intersection of Richardson Avenue and Lyon Street. State Route (SR) 1 (Coast Highway) merges into Doyle Drive approximately one mile west of the Marina Boulevard approach (see Figures 1 and 2). Built over 60 years ago, Doyle Drive links the City of San Francisco, the Peninsula, Marin County and points north with the Golden Gate Bridge. As part of the primary north-south freeway link in coastal California, Doyle Drive carries over 144,000 weekday travelers, including public transit passengers. With its narrow lanes and lack of a median or shoulders, Doyle Drive does not meet current Caltrans operational standards for safety. If the structure is not replaced, structural degradation, caused by age and the effects of heavy traffic and exposure to salt air, may cause Caltrans to restrict multi-axle vehicles in the coming years. In addition, the eastern portion of the aging facility's location in a liquefaction zone also presents the potential for the existing structure to fail in an earthquake. Except for ramps at the Golden Gate Bridge toll plaza, no vehicular access into the Presidio is possible from the existing Doyle Drive. The existing structure crosses over several historic buildings in its high viaduct portion, is a visual and audible intrusion on the Main Post and national cemetery in its low viaduct section, and is a physical barrier between Crissy Field and the rest ofthe Presidio {Report ofthe Doyle Drive Task Force to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors [Doyle Drive Task Force Report], 1993). The purposes for replacing Doyle Drive include significantly improving traffic conditions on the roadway and the structural and seismic safety of the roadway. Multimodal transportation alternatives and traffic conditions on local roadways can also be addressed in the project. Alternatives will be evaluated for consistency with the San Francisco General Plan and the Final Presidio General Management Plan Amendment (GMPA). The San Francisco County Transportation Authority (SFCTA) is the lead agency for California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) compliance for the Doyle Drive Project. The SFCTA has taken this role pursuant to an Interagency Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the SFCTA and Caltrans executed in April 1998. Major tasks of the SFCTA pursuant to the MOU include preparing a CEQA Environmental Impact Report (EIR) jointly with a National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Environmental Impact Statement (EIS); developing a final funding strategy; and creating a preliminary engineering design for the project. The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) is the Lead Agency for the NEPA EIS. The combined document will meet the requirements of the both environmental regulations and will be referred to as the EIS/EIR. 1 3 1223 06587 0041 Doyle Drive Environmental and Design Study Initial Environnriental Study These agencies are expected to have a role in the preparation or approval of the Doyle Drive Environmental and Design Study EIS/EIR: • California Departnnent of Transportation (Caltrans) - CEQA Responsible Agency • The Presidio Trust - Land management agency for the Presidio Area B (see Figures 1 and 2), consulting agency under the National Historic Preservation Act. The Presidio Trust has indicated intent to be a NEPA Cooperating Agency for preparation of the EIS/EIR. • United States Department of the Intenor, National Park Service (NPS) - Land management agency for the Presidio Area A (see Figures 1 and 2), consulting agency under the National Historic Preservation Act. The NPS has indicated intent to be a NEPA Cooperating Agency for preparation of the EIS/EIR. • Golden Gate Bridge Highway and Transportation District (GGBHTD) - CEQA Responsible Agency • California Office of Historic Preservation, State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO) - Consultation pursuant to the National Historic Preservation Act (Section 106 review) • United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) - Consultation pursuant Section 7 of the Federal Endangered Species Act. • California Department of Fish and Game (CDFG) - Consultation pursuant to the California Endangered Species Act • United States Army Corps of Engineers (USCOE) - Consultation and permitting pursuant to Section 404 of the Federal Clean Water Act • San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC) - Consultation pursuant to the McAteer-Petris Act • San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB) - Consultation and permitting pursuant to Section 401 of the Federal Clean WaterAct Previous Planning Efforts and Studies In the early 1970s, Caltrans prepared plans to improve Doyle Drive. These plans proposed to rebuild Doyle Drive as an eight-lane road, with six travel lanes and two auxiliary lanes. In response to a 1985 request from the San Francisco Board of Supervisors to recommend an alternative that would not encourage an increase in the number of vehicles using Doyle Drive, Caltrans modified the design in 1988. The modified design removed the auxiliary lanes, but also closed connecting approach ramps at SR 1 , which would have affected traffic and circulation in the Presidio and in the Marina and Richmond neighborhoods. The issues were not resolved and a preferred alternative was not identified. In 1991, Caltrans requested that the San Francisco Board of Supervisors accept one or more design concepts for Doyle Drive; in response, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors established a Doyle Drive Task Force, consisting of representatives from various local governments and public and private organizations, to consider design alternatives and develop a consensus on the preferred alternative. In 1993, the Report ofthe Doyle Drive Task Force to the San Francisco Board ofSupervisors {Doyle Drive Task Force Report) was submitted, which developed a concept of a scenic parkway through the Presidio. This parkway concept envisioned three travel lanes in each direction and an additional east-bound auxiliary lane between the San Francisco exit of the 19^^ Avenue off-ramp and a new direct access point to the Presidio. The Board of Supervisors unanimously approved in principle the recommendations ofthe Task Force and urged Caltrans to expedite inclusion of a rebuilding of Doyle Drive in the next State transportation funding cycle (February 1993 Resolution, Intermodal Study Report p. 4). 4